Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Jovan]

How much is this selling?I read around 16 chapters,it looks decent.

Mato Seihei no Slave does not appear in Top 50 Oricon, but for Jump+ standards decent. Per Book-rank, last volume sold:
│**7310 (4)│**10501│**11317│-------│-------┃*,*11,317 (*18)┃2019/07｜魔都精兵のスレイブ ２

 

[Nemesis]

Third? I bought the second cover one so I would remember

Oh, about author comments, I meant where can you find them without being given the link on manga plus? I couldn't find it on the featured page.

What third?

About author comments, they appear on the site or app about one day after the chapters are out. It's pretty easy to find them lol It's a banner written comments from the author

MANGA Plus by SHUEISHA

mangaplus.shueisha.co.jp

 

[TxxT]

Another issue where no series ends, they've kept some of these series long enough imo

 

[Nemesis]

Another issue where no series ends, they've kept some of these series long enough imo

True. Really out of the characteristic for them, even for the reign of Nakano

 

[TxxT]

The preview page for 49 issue says

Haikyu!! should've gotten Cover/LCP over Stone 100% imo since they're announcing the final arc

 

[ShenGao]

Once HQ!! ends BNHA will be the second oldest on going manga in the magazine. Pretty weird if you think about it.

 

[NeeNeen]

Haikyu!! should've gotten Cover/LCP over Stone 100% imo since they're announcing the final arc

Dr Stone is starting a new (spin-off) series. That's a lot more special than a final arc that'll probably take years anyway.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Dr Stone is starting a new (spin-off) series. That's a lot more special than a final arc that'll probably take years anyway.

The start of the final arc of one of the biggest seller and most acclaimed manga of the decade VS the start of a 9 chapters spinoff of a manga that doesnt even reach 100k in the top 50.

Are you really sure about what is more special or impactful for Jump?

 

[TxxT]

Dr Stone is starting a new (spin-off) series. That's a lot more special than a final arc that'll probably take years anyway.

How is a spinoff for a series that can barely break 100k fm more special than the final arc announcement of the 2nd oldest ongoing series in the magazine?

 

[Franz]

Haikyuu's final arc could easily last another year

 

[Jovan]

Another issue where no series ends, they've kept some of these series long enough imo

I wonder if the fact it takes this long for something to end means that Jump is planning a bigger newbie batch? Even then, it would still be 4 new series max unless Neverland suddenly ends out of nowhere.

 

[Neala897]

The start of the final arc of one of the biggest seller and most acclaimed manga of the decade VS the start of a 9 chapters spinoff of a manga that doesnt even reach 100k in the top 50.

Are you really sure about what is more special or impactful for Jump?

Furidate has made ( assuming there werent any editorial meddling ) very dangerous decision that might costs him a lot. I dont sure Jump wants to promote this arc until they know readers reaction

 

[TxxT]

Furidate has made ( assuming there werent any editorial meddling ) very dangerous decision that might costs him a lot. I dont sure Jump wants to promote this arc until they know readers reaction

...but its literally being promoted with a color page and this "new arc" has been mentioned on 2 consecutive issue previews now

 

[Jovan]

The Miitama 6th place has me confused since after the David-Japan stuff I don't know if gag manga rank or not lol

Based Jujutsu being 4th, and Yozakura 3rd chapter ranked fine. Also, Double Taisei over Samurai 8. Again.

Even Isobe Isobee had to go through a regular period before they moved it permanently to the bottom slot only during the Black Clover batch. It did pull some great TOC placements.

Volume 35 (28-7-2014)
1. One Piece
2. Hinomaru Zumou
3. Isobe Isobee Monogatari
4. Assassination Classroom
5. Shokugeki no Soma
6. PSI Kusuo Saiki
7. Toriko
8. Kuroko no Basuke
9. Haikyuu!!
10. World Trigger
11. HunterXHunter
12. Illegal Rare
13. Gintama
14. Kochikame
15. Bleach

Cover & Lead Color Page: Naruto
Color Page: Yoakemono
Color Page: Nejiyama-san (Oneshot by Kouki Ishikawa - Golden Future Cup Entry Number 1)
Color Page: Nisekoi
Unranked: Mitsukubi Condor and My Hero Academia

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

I think we got like 50 tweets of the people top-5 10s WSJ manga. Maybe I'll try to do later a results ranking. Kek, I'm starting now.

Meanwhile, if anyone else wants to leave their 5 favorite Jump manga of this decade, please do so

 

[Teennitro]

I have a question this decade is almost over I was wondering what manga blew up in popularity in their first volume the only thing that's come to the top of my mind is assassination classroom, promised Neverland, my hero, Spy X Family even though it's a Jump+ manga

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Shonen Jump 10s manga popularity polls results, by 39 users

I would have loved redon top-5 ;_; If you read it please submit it

I think I've recopilled it well. If anyone wants to check, is free to do so.

1. Kimetsu no Yaiba - 20 votes
2. Haikyuu - 19 votes
3. My Hero Academia, Chainsawman and World Trigger - 18 votes
4. Assassination Classroom - 16 votes
5. Act-age 15 votes
6. The Promised Neverland, Hinomaru Sumo, and Saiki Kusuo - 10 votes
7. Jujutsu Kaisen - 9 votes
8. Black Clover - 8 votes
9. Dr.STONE - 7 votes
10. Golem Hearts - 2 votes
11. Yuuna-san, We Never Learn, Samurai 8, Samon, Illegal Rare, ST&RS, Higuma, Hungry Joker, Magico, Shuudan, Shimai Fukei Kill-co-san - 1 vote

Shokugeki no Soma - 0 votes
Nisekoi - 0 votes

-Didn't expect Kimetsu 1st at all. I was expecting MHA or Haikyuu
-Chainsawman, Act-age and World Trigger got a lot of votes. Really surprised me.
-Neverland and Dr.Stone got less votes than I expected.
-lol Shokugeki

 

[Konja9]

Seems Mato Seihei no Slave is getting a special chapter next issue??

Act-Age cover, yay!!

Mitama and Yozakura are holding up well, not bad.

Samurai 8....not especially surprised I guess.

I'm surprised about Samurai 8.

I mean, the sales of Samurai 8 are still a lot better than Double Taisei and Yui Kamio.

So, I guess readers of the magazine really feel disinterest for Samurai 8.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Shonen Jump 10s manga popularity polls results, by 35 users

I would have loved redon top-5 ;_; If you read it please submit it

I think I've recopilled it well. If anyone wants to check, is free to do so.

1. Kimetsu no Yaiba - 18 votes
2. My Hero Academia and Haikyuu - 17 votes
3. Chainsawman and World Trigger - 15 votes
4. Act-age and Assassination Classroom - 13 votes
5. Hinomaru Sumo - 10 votes
6. Saiki Kusuo - 9 votes
7. The Promised Neverland -8 votes
8. Black Clover and Jujutsu Kaisen - 7 votes
9. Dr.STONE - 6 votes
10. Golem Hearts - 2 votes
11. Yuuna-san, We Never Learn, Samon, Illegal Rare, ST&RS, Hungry Joker, Magico, Shuudan, Shimai Fukei Kill-co-san - 1 vote

Shokugeki no Soma - 0 votes

-Didn't expect Kimetsu 1st at all. I was expecting MHA or Haikyuu
-Chainsawman, Act-age and World Trigger got a lot of votes. Really surprised me.
-Neverland and Dr.Stone got less votes than I expected.
-lol Shokugeki

Requoting it in new page for people to see it, give their picks if they haven't done them, or comment it.

I've updated it with Raf votes who is later posting.

 

[NeeNeen]

Not in order:

World Trigger
Act-age
Dr. Stone
The Promised Neverland
Hell Warden Higuma

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 24, 2019, Original Post Date: Oct 24, 2019 ---

The start of the final arc of one of the biggest seller and most acclaimed manga of the decade VS the start of a 9 chapters spinoff of a manga that doesnt even reach 100k in the top 50.

Are you really sure about what is more special or impactful for Jump?

If we're talking about what's more rare (2 series in the same magazine) or what has a more immediate impact, then yes.

As many people have mentioned, this last arc could take years. They have plenty of time to do something with it once the ending draws closer.

A new series has a much more direct impact on the volume it appears in, so it makes sense to me to put something like that on the cover.