Mag Talk Weekly Shounen Jump [2009] - Discussion & TOC Talk

[predsfan]

can anyone tell me on which shonen jump appears naruto 230? is it WSJ 2009 6&7?

If you mean 430, then yes, I think it's 6&7 2009.

 

[Sexy Randal 105]

I loved Madhouse's treatment of Death Note until the second arc. I didn't like how they cut out the first assault on Mellow's fortress and how they changed the ending. The anime ending was god awful. I also didn't like the added homosexual undertones...

 

[Digital_Eon]

I kinda liked some Madhouse series. Never watched an anime I liked better than such things as DN and Claymore, although that doesn't say much.

Whatever happens, I hope they keep all future Jump series out of the hands of whoever did DGM. Granted, the second season actually stuck to the manga plot, but the first was so horribly butchered and packed with filler (episode fourteen, god!) that I'd pity the next series that got those producers.

At least Madhouse did a damn good job with Claymore - and Death Note, to a point. Sure, the endings were changed, but the rest of the series were pretty accurate, and actually entertaining. I've grown to be unable to stand anime and I can still watch the series I know by them.

 

[Maxy Barnard]

Claymore was an atrocity of an anime. Madhouse's single good anime was Beck as far as i can remember, and that was animated like a pile of arse mosta the time.

anyway, looking at shaft's back catalogue..... I stand by sunrise as the ideal company to do a Sket anime.

on a more WSJ note............ Psyren # 4 cover = meh
Eyeshield 21 # 33 = kinda inbetween
Shaman King Kangzengbang 21 = FUCKING AMAZING
Shaman King KangZengBang 22 = meh
Love Trouble 12 = alright
Sket Dance #06 = BEST SKET COVER YET
Mago #3 = Best Mago cover yet
Luck Stealer #3 = okay


In fact let me reiterate that:

THIS

That is the best reason for a Sket anime, that tiny arc of absolute wonder, that achieved being awesome despite being less gag based than it's usual tone....

and it's pretty

 

[StrangerAtaru]

Dang, that's a great Sket cover.

On the other hand, I actually like the To-Love cover (then again I think Saki is probably one of the most underrated girls in the series and one of the cutest) and think ES21's is meh (Don't really like Taka and really don't want to ressurect the Teikoku game in my head for the moment) and both Shaman King aren't too bad. (I think with the first Jeanne being "maid form", we sort of needed one of the "Iron Maiden"...I guess)

 

[Crude]

I'm also loving that cover. Makes me think what Sket would be like if it were a music series. The rock festival arc is a favourite of mine.

 

[eni]

Little reminder - Anime talk goes here:
http://mangahelpers.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=279

Just created the two season stickies for winter and spring anime >.>

 

[Maxy Barnard]

I foresee a future for Shinohara Kenta in a music shonen ah but that's just wonderful dreaming

 

[DeidaraGrimmjow]

Where did you get those covers if you don't mind my asking?

 

[eni]

Oh, I totally overlooked this cover. How sweet.
It brings Sket back to my reading list, I guess. Just for the sake of this pretty scene <3

@DeidaraGrimmjow
Noodles did a really bad bad thing and hotlinked the images from Shueisha's website (where it got announced, I assume). Obviously he will upload it on a image-freehost soon and replace the image source, ne? >.>

 

[Houjou]

I wish there was a bigger version anywhere!

By the way, how many chapters are normally needed for a (successful) Jump series to get into an anime? I mean, if it's really popular (like Toriko or Bakuman lately).

 

[Bomber D Rufi]

I wish there was a bigger version anywhere!

By the way, how many chapters are normally needed for a (successful) Jump series to get into an anime? I mean, if it's really popular (like Toriko or Bakuman lately).

The rule of thumb is usually 2 years worth of manga has to go by before an anime is announced...though sometimes it can be more or less.

 

[Sexy Randal 105]

I would say that Toriko is definitely going to get a Jump Festa ova next year.

 

[StrangerAtaru]

I would say that Toriko is definitely going to get a Jump Festa ova next year.

Can't really be said actually: until the Jump Anime Tour (for the 40th), there haven't been any Festa OVAs the last few years. (the last one I remember was around the point Gintama got one three years ago). The only new series this last time was Tegami Bachi...but somehow, if they do come back with Festa OVAs, Toriko is a good choice for it. (though somehow Mago may actually be more ready for an anime by December '09 if it's still going and the anime is to start April '10...I actually wouldn't know if Toriko's would start in April or October)

As it really stands, all I really want is for Sket to thrive and survive until July and then see what Jump & Shueisha says.

 

[Kaiten]

It would make a lot of sense for Mago and Psyren to get anime in the spring of 2010 while Toriko would gets one for the fall of the same year. Assuming all three last that long. Less then two years and you end up with to much filler to soon.

 

[◆ T.D.A ◆]

I'm still waiting for the next big thing...

 

[Maxy Barnard]

it's come, it was toriko. and any of these three that just started could be a hit

 

[◆ T.D.A ◆]

Nah unfortunately Toriko isn't my cup of tea.

 

[Maxy Barnard]

so wait it's not the next big thing unless you like it? or do you just mean you're waiting for the next big thing that caters to your needs :P

 

[GGpX]

I don't know if it'll become Naruto/OP/Bleach big, but it'll probably become ES21 big.