Mag Talk Weekly Shounen Jump [2009] - Discussion & TOC Talk

[Teeba]

Wouldn't Neuro have a cover for its ending though? That's at least something. XD

But I agree, other series need the cover hype other than Bakuman.

 

[[Cross]]

Yeah, Neuro should have its own cover for its end and Bakuman already had a recent cover. Giving those series that haven't had one in months would be refreshing, but probably won't happen.

 

[StrangerAtaru]

Highly doubt it about a Neuro cover even for the end: compared to POT which was a major force, Neuro was never really like that and probably will just end and get a cp and the ending in the center of the magazine. Besides, usually the last cover comes within the final weeks, not the final chapter itself.

 

[Sexy Randal 105]

So it's really gonna end in the next few weeks?

 

[Rejuvenation]

I'd be fine with a Neuro cover but with Jump's current way of doing things it probably won't get one. >.>

But oh well, I'm just happy Psyren and Mago aren't at the bottom.

 

[Cassius]

TOC of this week. ¿Dofla or Heiji is fake? it's too early for the toc, i think.

◆jDGJcYE7Bg [sage] Date:2009/03/24(火) 22:42:45 ID:EVQcXX10P Be:
18号掲載順
ワンピ(表紙&巻頭)
ナルト
トリコ
リボン
銀玉
黒子(センター)
鰤
バクマン
サイレン
フー
いぬっ
こち亀
ぬらり
バブ
スケット(センター）
ネウロ
２１
Dグレ
ぼっけ
とらぶる
ジャガー

Traslate.

One Piece(Cover+Pc)
Naruto
Toriko
Reborn
Gintama
Kuroko(Pc)
Bleach
Baku-Man
Psyren
Hoop-Men
Inumaru
Kochikame
Mago
Beelzebaby
Sket Dance (Pc)
Neuro
ES21
D.Gray-Man
Bokke-san
To Love
Jaguar

 

[Sexy Randal 105]

Wow Psyren is really high this week.

 

[Koen]

Last week we had tuesday too, so this might be a correct one

well - I am going to do the noodles (sorry for stealing your usual post )

1. One Piece(Cover+Pc) -> always first, counting it in
2. Naruto
3. Toriko
4. Reborn
5. Gintama
6. Bleach
7. Baku-Man
8. Psyren
9. Inumaru
10. Kochikame
11. Mago
12. Neuro
13. ES21
14. D.Gray-Man
15. Bokke-san
16. To Love

 

[fxu]

I don't think DGM is being ranked yet... is it?

Anyway, yay for Psyren

Let's hope it can keep this up.

 

[StrangerAtaru]

Pretty interesting if this is correct: good week for Gintama and Psyren (heck even Reborn, regardless of..things), pretty good as well for Bakuman...and somehow Bokke and To-Love are the ones in trouble.

 

[Maxy Barnard]

it's a pretty good ranking this time around. except for reborn obviously.

glad to see psyren get what it truly deserves for it's more recent chapters

 

[◆ T.D.A ◆]

BTW when does that show reviewing WSJ on TV Tokyo start?

 

[Kaiten]

Not really happy with Mago's rating. I would be happier if it were above Kochikame, but as long as it's out of the bottom five I shouldn't complain. At least Gintama is in the top five.

The Jump talk show starts on April 3.

 

[Rejuvenation]

1. One Piece(Cover+Pc) -> always first, counting it in
2. Naruto
3. Toriko
4. Reborn
5. Gintama
6. Bleach
7. Baku-Man
8. Psyren
9. Inumaru
10. Kochikame
11. Mago
12. Neuro
13. ES21
14. D.Gray-Man
15. Bokke-san
16. To Love

Toriko @ the 3rd position again. [noparse][/noparse]

Reborn at 4th is somewhat surprising. I'll have to check back and see what chapter that was.

Bleach beaten out of the top 3 again is fuck win.

Psyren and Bakuman in the mid-tier pleases me.

Mago just barely out of the bottom 5 but its safe for now so I won't complain.

Now if only Bokke could get up.

 

[◆ T.D.A ◆]

Hmm though I think with recent chapters with Ichigo back in the limelight, Bleach may return to the top 3.

 

[[Cross]]

Its rank reflects the boring tone of the beginning of the Ichigo/Ulquiorra fight, it'll pick up in time. However, would D.GM count as being ranked? I mean, don't they have the results of the votes from before the hiatus?

 

[Digital_Eon]

They probably would have the results of previous votes for DGM. It's consistent with previous results for an action arc, after all. I don't think it'd be shoved to the bottom again without some reason, even though it got a MIDDLE colour page with its cover.

Wow, Bleach out of the top 5, even? Ouch. (Yeah, that includes OP's cover, but it'd have been up there anyway.)

Nooo, Bokke-san! Hold on a little longer and maybe some series will end quickly and save you for... a little longer...

 

[Hayashida]

mago sitting pretty is nice; as long as it isnt in the depth its all good.

i don't think dgm is being ranked yet, i know alot of people dont like the current arc or little tim,

Spoiler

though its doing well as a post-death-of-cross-arc,

and more innocence users are going to come in all of the time anyway(a long way to go to 107 or 109? i know its around suikoden's 108 anyway), so some are bound to not be liked.
eh, after all that, i'd say itll be ranked soon ^^

 

[Sexy Randal 105]

mago sitting pretty is nice; as long as it isnt in the depth its all good.

i don't think dgm is being ranked yet, i know alot of people dont like the current arc or little tim,

Spoiler

though its doing well as a post-death-of-cross-arc,

and more innocence users are going to come in all of the time anyway(a long way to go to 107 or 109? i know its around suikoden's 108 anyway), so some are bound to not be liked.
eh, after all that, i'd say itll be ranked soon ^^

*cough* Spoilers....Thanks jerk. I read the Viz translations...

 

[Kaiten]

I like the current arc. Just me though. But as Digital_Eon said, action arcs tend to rank very low, sometimes in the bottom five. Even the Cross's introduction at the end of the Ark were this low. That's assuming these chapters are ranked, which I'm being wishy washy about mostly due to denial.