Question Who's Feeding Luffy

[WILDCARD 1 7]

Since this is the big topic right now, just thought I'd throw up a poll and see who everyone thinks is feeding Luffy.

 

[Vanshrimp]

i think, for now, it is caribou, because i don't like the idea of kizaru always carrying that much food with him, or even worst, he wanted to have the food in case he gets hungry during the battle....(Actually, i never liked the idea of a high ranked marine having lot of food in his pockets since we got introduced to vergo). Also, i feel like caribou is relying on luffy to escape, so by solving luffy's food issue, he is actually saving himself.

 

[Yoko75]

i think, for now, it is caribou, because i don't like the idea of kizaru always carrying that much food with him, or even worst, he wanted to have the food in case he gets hungry during the battle....(Actually, i never liked the idea of a high ranked marine having lot of food in his pockets since we got introduced to vergo). Also, i feel like caribou is relying on luffy to escape, so by solving luffy's food issue, he is actually saving himself.

I agree. I believe it's Caribou feeding Luffy. He knows about Luffy's situation when it comes to food and refueling him will recover Luffy so he will be able to fight and give all of them the best chance to survive and escape Egghead successfully. Plus he already fed Luffy before in Wano and in one of the panels from chapter 1103 we see a puddle like substance where Luffy is eating just as when Saturn notices this.

Kizaru I believe doesn't know about Luffy's food situation, but their is a chance that it could be him. Luffy said he needed food so it's a small chance he heard him and was able to sneak him food some how with his light speed ability or clone since we know he can that since he did it in his battle with Luffy. So it could be him. Saturn we know has many people pinned down due his power whether that's Haki related or his DF power he certainly would have no reason to use that on Kizaru unless he felt Kizaru would betray him, but that's all speculation at the moment. That would a neat little twist by Oda if that was the case. Their is a chance it could be a third option like Luffy using his DF to imagine up food to feed himself, but very unlikely due to him shriveling up like an old man from being very low on stamina and tired. As of right now I'm leaning towards Caribou.

 

[TitaniumOxide]

We know a few things:
1.Kizaru shifted positions (aka he can move)
2. We haven't seen Caribou in a while

But the truth is we need to ask a different question. Not who did it but rather, who knows that food will heal Luffy? Sure, Kizaru has this side where he don't wanna hurt his nakamas but we also saw how many attempts he tried to shoot Vegapunk and this is despite his compassion. So yeah his feelings might have gotten stronger but due to his sense of duty he is taking a hit. That being said he also never seen how food healed Luffy. It aint like he was at impel down seeing Luffy eat and miraculously recovering. So I am leaning towards Caribou because Caribou has been spying on Luffy and his crew for a while now not to mention he's an endless storage device.

 

[Fox666]

We know a few things:
1.Kizaru shifted positions (aka he can move)
2. We haven't seen Caribou in a while

But the truth is we need to ask a different question. Not who did it but rather, who knows that food will heal Luffy? Sure, Kizaru has this side where he don't wanna hurt his nakamas but we also saw how many attempts he tried to shoot Vegapunk and this is despite his compassion. So yeah his feelings might have gotten stronger but due to his sense of duty he is taking a hit. That being said he also never seen how food healed Luffy. It aint like he was at impel down seeing Luffy eat and miraculously recovering. So I am leaning towards Caribou because Caribou has been spying on Luffy and his crew for a while now not to mention he's an endless storage device.

Agree. Kizaru feeding Luffy would be a plot-hole, while Caribou makes perfect sense.

 

[wing_gundam]

S-Snake. "Love" over-powers all science.

 

[kkck]

Hmmm, to me the weird part here is that someone could sneak past saturn. He seems able to detect even lower level subordinates who look at him nigh instantly. I suppose caribou is a candidate but would he be able to move around unnoticed? I could buy a seraphine doing that but s-snake doesn't have the right powers for this. I suppose s-bear does.

 

[TitaniumOxide]

I think Saturn can detect people similar to Luffy asking if anyone sense another person (Caribou) back in Fishman island. I think Sanji? Jinbe? Forgot who but they said they felt that presence too. But let's say Caribou was there and is a puddle of mud then it may be hard to figure out that that gunk is actually a logia user. In this case, Caribou can stay a puddle of mud and cannot move like the others but nothing shows that he cannot expel contents from inside his body due to Saturn's powers. Well, this is assuming he is very near in the area (basically next to Luffy which will need to be explained).

 

[Fox666]

Hmmm, to me the weird part here is that someone could sneak past saturn. He seems able to detect even lower level subordinates who look at him nigh instantly. I suppose caribou is a candidate but would he be able to move around unnoticed? I could buy a seraphine doing that but s-snake doesn't have the right powers for this. I suppose s-bear does.

I think Saturn just heard the Marine commenting on it

 

[kkck]

I think Saturn just heard the Marine commenting on it

That is sort of the point. Before saturn could instantly nuke a marine for being of lower rank but now someone sneaks past him and feeds luffy?

 

[wing_gundam]

I don't think Saturn cares about anyone else - insignificant flies to him. He's focused on Boney anyways.

S-Snake. "Love" over-powers all science.

Looks like Kuma's love is over-powering science afterall. I'm doubling down.

 

[M3J]

Probably Nika coming out of Luffy's body

 

[traf]

While Caribou is the usual suspect, I see little point for it to be a mystery if that’s the case. Caribou is almost an unofficial logia Strawhat member at this point.

Kizaru is the next best candidate which I’d like more story wise, but I dunno, never before Kizaru demonstrated ability to act so fast no-one could even see he did something, even though it makes sense for his DF.

 

[WILDCARD 1 7]

Sbs 110 (pew)

Well this answers that question. congrats to all those that said Kizaru.

 

[HereNThere]

Y'all need to start making polls with the votes visible so I can shame those who were wrong so we can see who all got it right.

 

[electricmastro]

Well this answers that question. congrats to all those that said Kizaru.

Why would Kizaru give Luffy food if he was opposed to Luffy the entire time, even killing Vegapunk in the process

 

[XXGenesis]

My vote was correct

 

[Fox666]

Well this answers that question. congrats to all those that said Kizaru.

That's a joke from Oda. Nobody was feeding Luffy.

Luffy was in front of Vegapunk's machine that makes food.

 

[Kuroiyaiba]

Why would Kizaru give Luffy food if he was opposed to Luffy the entire time, even killing Vegapunk in the process

Because Kizaru was in a moral dilemma:
Either fullfilling his duty as an admiral by obeying the elders and murdering his best friend Vegapunk or opposing the elders by not following the orders.
Feeding Luffy secretly and thus helping him protect his best friend was the best course of action for Kizaru to take.
By doing so he could increase the chances of his best friend surviving without being seen.

 

[electricmastro]

By doing so he could increase the chances of his best friend surviving

Kizaru could have increased the chances of his best friend surviving by, well you know, choosing to not actually kill him.

Instead he chose to be this: a killer