Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2011] - Discussion and TOC Talk - Part 1

[Zeromcd]

ohana ◆IR7jauNn4E ：2011/08/17(水) 15:48:48.45 ID:FqfYaGymO
ジャンプ表紙 イチゴ
巻頭イチゴ
ワンピ
ナルト
トリコ
バクマン
スターズＣ
スケット
鏡の国
ハングリージョーカーＣ
こちかめ
ぎんたまＣ
めだか
ハンター
いぬまる
ぬらり
べるぜ
くろこ
マジコ
エニグマ
リボン
花咲

Jump Issue 37 Information

Bleach (Lead CP, Cover)
One Piece
Naruto
Toriko
Bakuman
ST&RS (CP)
Sket Dance
Kagami no Kuni no Harisugawa
Hungry Joker (CP, Oneshot,)
Kochi Kame
Gintama (CP)
Medaka Box
Hunter x Hunter
Inumaru Dashi
Nurarihyon no Mago
Beelzebub
Kuroko no Basket
Magico
Enigma
Reborn
Hanasaka Ikkyuu

 

[Samui]

Issue 38:
38 cover will be Toriko
Center color: Reborn, Beelzebub, and the Golden Cup Awards.

From Aohige.

 

[Shinjipl]

Looks like Toriko's Gourmet Temple chapter still ranked in top three, although it wasn't that great. Enigma's climax chapters don't seem to do well at all. Also, it's funny how Reborn is always bouncing from the top to the very bottom, is this series that inconsistent ?

Oh, and I have a question. Is this Hunter x Hunter's rank for chapter 304 or is it not ranked since it was in hiatus for so long ?

 

[Nayrael]

Should we consider HxH ranked or wait for 8 weeks to pass?

Pure rankings (for now considering HxH unranked):

01. One Piece
02. Naruto
03. Toriko
04. Bakuman
05. Sket Dance
06. Medaka Box
07. Inumaru Dashi
08. Nurarihyon no Mago
09. Beelzebub
10. Kuroko no Basket
11. Magico
12. Enigma
13. Reborn
14. Hanasaka Ikkyuu

2 more chapters till ranked: ST&RS
3 more chapters till ranked: Harisugawa in Mirror World
8 more chapters till ranked: HxH

 

[Divinenega]

Glad to see medaka box doing well but Enigma really needs to climb back up. Were readers really that upset about the e-test climax? I thought it was pretty epic. Also weird to see Reborn so low, but it'll climb back up soon.

 

[Kubukurin]

Medaka is high, Mago is out of the bottom, Enigma is in bottom.
Fine week for me.

 

[Jaiden82]

Sucks Magico is in the bottom again this week. Well at least Mago is out of the bottom.

 

[Asgaroth]

i hope enigma will get axed before enigma, because the later got more chapters and a not so typical genre. the chapter thing is that we know (or probably not...) more about it. we know the character betters and so, its set up completely. know begins the first "real" arc. besides magico is already boring and nothing but endless finds.

 

[mrDovydas]

Well, Kurogane also got scanlated. http://lazyassmanga.blogspot.com/2011/08/kurogane-oneshot.html

 

[Drmke]

2 more chapters till ranked: ST&RS
3 more chapters till ranked: Harisugawa in Mirror World
8 more chapters till ranked: HxH

Next week is chapter 8 for Stars so its ranking actually begins then. Also I don't think Hunter x Hunter ever gets ranked anymore since it's so rarely in the magazine, it will never get any votes.

 

[Kaiten]

Exactly. What's the point of ranking a fifteen year old series that never runs for more than twenty chapters a year?

 

[Nayrael]

Next week is chapter 8 for Stars so its ranking actually begins then.

I thought "8 chapters ago" meant that chapter 1 would be ranked in issue in which chapter 9 is published?

Also I don't think Hunter x Hunter ever gets ranked anymore since it's so rarely in the magazine, it will never get any votes.

Yeah, makes sense... not to mention that its chances of cancellation are 0% anyway ^_^;

 

[mrDovydas]

Delivering an average toc table while it's still hot...

 

[Nayrael]

Updated pure Rankings Table:

01. One Piece (c627)
02. Naruto (c543)
03. Toriko (c145)
04. Bakuman (c136)
05. Sket Dance (c189)
06. Medaka Box (c102)
07. Inumaru Dashi (c???)
08. Nurarihyon no Mago (c158)
09. Beelzebub (c112)
10. Kuroko no Basket (c121)
11. Magico (c15)
12. Enigma (c37)
13. Reborn (c341)
14. Hanasaka Ikkyuu (c6)

2 more chapters till ranked: ST&RS
3 more chapters till ranked: Harisugawa in Mirror World

(hope the chapters number are right... please alert if you see a mistake... and tell me on what chapter Inumarudashi is right now...)

 

[Rejuvenation]

A near perfect top 5. I don't give a crap about Naruto but the other 4 are cool with me. Great stuff.

Medaka Box just barely missed the top 5 but I'll take 6th place. This could be shaping up to be the best arc of the manga and I'm enjoying the ride.

Ikkyu is another cushion at this point and no surprise Reborn is so low. Its fully deserved like Bleach has been. If Enigma and Magico want to continue to tank in rankings and sacrifice themselves for everything else I won't have any complaints but we will see if any of the two new manga can save them instead.

I see Kubo decided to start whoring out all of the fan favorite Shinigami. Maybe the Japanese fan base finally got a message through to him after all.

 

[R4n]

Also, it's funny how Reborn is always bouncing from the top to the very bottom, is this series that inconsistent ?

Each chapter is either 'So bad it is awesome' (rank up) or 'So bad it is horrible' (rank down). Once in a blue moon it is genuinely awesome. So yeah...

 

[Galactic Tomahawk]

I think Magico's doomed unless it really picks up soon, the all-fighting-all-the-time thing just isn't working for it.

However I don't think Jump will immediately cancel it either, after all the early promotion it got I could see it reaching the 40-50 mark like Usagi and P2 did.

I think Enigma's established itself well enough to avoid serious danger for a while, still doing better than something like Shinigami did and that stuck around for ages. I think it's just in a slump right now between it's initial hype wearing off and having to establish an actual fanbase.

 

[Nii]

Each chapter is either 'So bad it is awesome' (rank up) or 'So bad it is horrible' (rank down). Once in a blue moon it is genuinely awesome. So yeah...

Lol so true~ I miss the old Reborn, the Varia arc was great and the Future Arc had a lot of good stuff too. One of Amano's strong points was creating an interesting boss villain, Xanxus, (Genkishi) and Byakuran were well thought-out but Deamon was such a failure
well enough of the rant, I hope she comes back with a (way) better arc.

TOC is fine with me, except for Enigma. It's something different and so far, I like were the storie is going. Just cancel Magico and Ikkyu, both have become rather meh :/

 

[ick]

Updated pure Rankings Table:



(hope the chapters number are right... please alert if you see a mistake... and tell me on what chapter Inumarudashi is right now...)

I'm quite sure that both Trinity BAKumA (Sket) and Imanga (Kuroko) aren't up to date with the series, so the chapter of these two series aren't right.

EDIT: Kuroko's chapter should be the 129 (so the 121 is ranked).

Ikkyuu too, this is chapter 14 so the ranked one is the 6.

 

[Nayrael]

I'm quite sure that both Trinity BAKumA (Sket) and Imanga (Kuroko) aren't up to date with the series, so the chapter of these two series aren't right.

EDIT: Kuroko's chapter should be the 129 (so the 121 is ranked).

Ikkyuu too, this is chapter 14 so the ranked one is the 6.

Thanks, those two have been fixed now.