Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2011] - Discussion and TOC Talk - Part 1

[Newkerzy]

I don't think so. I think they already know the Deathberry chapters (2) have finally catapulted Bleach back to its rightful spot. So they don't have any worries.

 

[Steffan]

I find it strange that Enigma is ranking so low, yet it just started a new arc like 1 chapter ago.
Maybe Enigma is safe for reasons we don't know?

 

[Divinenega]

I;m really shocked Enigma is ranking so low lately. I get the e-test has gone of for a while but this is ridiculous. It's not like the series has had an actually drop in quality like Bleach or Magico. If anything it;s getting better as it goes along. I just hope the e-test climax revelations and the new arc at least gives it a slight boost. It should at least live long enough to get it;s first year anniversary but...

 

[ruggia]

I find it strange that Enigma is ranking so low, yet it just started a new arc like 1 chapter ago.
Maybe Enigma is safe for reasons we don't know?

well, it must be safe for this round of cuts at least...
but you never know what will happen few months from now.

 

[Jaymie]

Ugh Enigma. Now it just feels like I was punched in the stomach. Chapter 39 was the one ranked, and that was as climatic as climax gets. I suppose the readers are just sick of the arc in general, no matter how amazing the chapters get (so Chapter 40, the best in the series, will probably rank last). Five volumes is fairly long for an introduction arc, I guess. Most introduction arcs are like, a chapter or two long at most.

If anything saves the series, it will be Chapter 44, the start of the new arc. There's also the off-chance that St&rs and/or Harisugawa flop, or Magico ends up below Enigma.

We really need some new series. One to replace Ikkyu, and one to replace the GFC. Usually new series pop up when old ones are canceled, right?

 

[Divinenega]

Ugh Enigma. Now it just feels like I was punched in the stomach. Chapter 39 was the one ranked, and that was as climatic as climax gets. I suppose the readers are just sick of the arc in general, no matter how amazing the chapters get (so Chapter 40, the best in the series, will probably rank last). Five volumes is fairly long for an introduction arc, I guess. Most introduction arcs are like, a chapter or two long at most.

If anything saves the series, it will be Chapter 44, the start of the new arc. There's also the off-chance that St&rs and/or Harisugawa flop, or Magico ends up below Enigma.

We really need some new series. One to replace Ikkyu, and one to replace the GFC. Usually new series pop up when old ones are canceled, right?

Actually I think chapter 38 was the one ranked this week, but it still hurts.

 

[Asclepius]

Full ToC by Ohana

696 ：ohana ◆IR7jauNn4E ：2011/08/24(水) 21:54:25.96 ID:dUbaj3HpP

ジャンプ表紙　リボーン
巻頭　トリコ　人気投票
ワンピ
スケット
ナルト
銀魂
リボーン　C
鏡の国
スターズ
WOLF&RED　C
こち亀
べるぜ　C
バクマン
ハンター
いぬまる
黒子
めだか
ぬらり
ブリーチ
マジコ
エニグマ
花咲


39号　くろがね　巻頭

 

[Googlez_kun]

Wow Sket Dance above Naruto.Congrats!

Wow#2 Even though every saw it coming,i'm still a little surprised that Ikkyu is actually ending this soon.

 

[Zeromcd]

Full ToC by Ohana

696 ：ohana ◆IR7jauNn4E ：2011/08/24(水) 21:54:25.96 ID:dUbaj3HpP

ジャンプ表紙　リボーン
巻頭　トリコ　人気投票
ワンピ
スケット
ナルト
銀魂
リボーン　C
鏡の国
スターズ
WOLF&RED　C
こち亀
べるぜ　C
バクマン
ハンター
いぬまる
黒子
めだか
ぬらり
ブリーチ
マジコ
エニグマ
花咲


39号　くろがね　巻頭

Jump Issue 38 Table of Contents
Cover : Tsuna, Reborn & the Arcobaleno
Toriko (Lead CP) & Character Popularity Results
One Piece
Sket Dance
Naruto
Gintama
Reborn! (Cover, CP)
Kagami no Kuni no Harisugawa
ST&RS
WOLF&RED (CP, Oneshot)
Kochikame
Beelzebub (CP)
Bakuman
Hunter x Hunter
Inumaru Dashi
Kuroko no Basket
Medaka Box
Nurarihyon no Mago
Bleach
Magico
Enigma
Hanasaka Ikkyuu (Cancelled)

Issue 39 Lead CP: Kurogane (most likely a new series)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm hoping that the new series that is starting isn't this

 

[raDar]

More or less that will be it. Coz the One Shot as far as i know is a winner of the Third Manga Carnival of JUMP.

 

[Nayrael]

Pure Rankings for Issue #38:

01. One Piece (c628)
02. Sket Dance (c190)
03. Naruto (c544)
04. Gintama (c358)
05. Bakuman (c137)
06. Inumaru Dashi (c136)
07. Kuroko no Basket (c122)
08. Medaka Box (c103)
09. Nurarihyon no Mago (c159)
10. Bleach (c453)
11. Magico (c16)
12. Enigma (c38)
13. Hanasaka Ikkyuu (Cancelled at c15)

1 more chapter till ranked: ST&RS
2 more chapters till ranked: Harisugawa in Mirror World

 

[The Adamant Dragon]

Wow, I can't believe Kikai Hanasaka Ikkyu is getting cancelled... it was getting really good too. Where the ratings really that bad?

It seems like Jump is getting quite impatient with its newcomers, you either make it big soon or you go home. It had an original concept, but oh well, too bad.

 

[Muddy]

It seems like Jump is getting quite impatient with its newcomers, you either make it big soon or you go home. It had an original concept, but oh well, too bad.

No, it's been like this for years. There was a series that debuted in 2004 (back when I first started following the ToC) called LIVE, which lasted a whopping ten chapters. There've been lots of series in Jump's past that end very early.

 

[Shinjipl]

Good to see Sket Dance up there. And I'm not surprised that Bleach is still at the bottom since this is chapter 453 ranked. It will probably stay there until the latest chapters will be ranked.

Also, it looks like Ikkyu got axed at chapter 15, even faster than Sengoku Armors, Meruhen Ouji Grim or Dois Sol, which means that, out of the Jump series that started in 2011, Ikkyu is the shortest running.

 

[Bomber D Rufi]

Pure Rankings for Issue #38:

Gintama's on chapter 366, not 358.

That said, it's nice to see it pretty high up. If only it had beat out Naruto...if only.

 

[Nayrael]

Gintama's on chapter 366, not 358.

I thought c366 is the newest chapter, not the one ranked?

 

[ZayCon]

When I first saw the TOC I was shocked over how low Bakuman was, but in the pure ranking it's actually pretty high.
I don't think Enigma deserves the place it's in now - it should at least be a little bit higher!

Looking forward to next week. Hope ST&RS will rank well

Liked the cover pretty much. I'm looking forward to this arc, and it will probably be much better than hte last arc.

 

[Nii]

wow, Hanasaku was canceled very fast O__o looks like it really bombed but it got kinda boring so I'm fine with it.

Mago and Enigma are still so low they definitely deserve a higher place, it would be a shame to see Enigma or even Mago go.
I'm actually looking forward to the next KHR arc, the last one was such a disaster that it can only get better. I really hope Amano makes up for the last arc and shows us the good ol' Reborn.

And please let ST&RS have a good ranking next week

 

[Bomber D Rufi]

I thought c366 is the newest chapter, not the one ranked?

Oh. Sorry. :-P I thought you were doing them by chapter out. Yeah you'd be right then.

Huh. That's at the end of the Elizamoto (AKA Renhou) arc. Well...more like the climax. I guess since you know who returned, the Japanese really enjoyed it.

 

[StrangerAtaru]

Interesting rankings, not much more really to say. Sad to see Ikkyu go though but unfortunately we're rather stuffed in the magazine as of late...