This game was bullshit for me.
xnut - only ever posted "is anyone there?" on the piratepad and left. Didn't bother contacting anyone else to discuss if we weren't around. On Night 2 he already PMed Faust saying who to kill without discussing it at all. Was this kid even trying to play? did he not realize he was noob and would be better off discussing stuff with Maz and myself? I know he's gnut's son but it seriously irritated the hell out of me that he says nothing at all at night and even less at day and then wants to decide what we're doing on his own. It didn't even seem like he was following the game, asking who was still alive...even asking who in the mafia was still alive! Don't take this personally, but please never sign-up again. Any other host would have hostkilled him.
Arctigor - came in after Maz and I decided what we would do the first night, insisted on having a role to claim after THE FIRST NIGHT. He mentioned Naive Traitor, I thought it might be funny, but I told him to play it cool. There's no point in declaring a role so early unless you have to. It took all of two posts for him to just spit it out, then he completely fucked it up...seriously, I facepalmed so hard at that.
Mazino - only one who tried and he was off travelling around Germany and wasn't present enough. His investigations were useful to us I guess, but yeah...
I had no Mafia team, and because I held on to my Assassin kill we had no chance. If bene got unlucky with the coinflip this could have turned out differently...but since the game was just cancelled, who knows. This game reminds me of my first game when I was Mafia with digitaldude, Adorien, and BakaHaze, where the latter two were essentially worthless. We still won that one somehow, though.
Well, at least I'm still technically undefeated as Mafia. Thanks DD!
/bitterassholemerryxmas