Games Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - END GAME

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

He can't be a Doctor. He wouldn't know if his action got blocked or not as a Doctor.



Lol, no. You hosted a ton of games, yet you also still didn't know about it before Kat pointed it out.

Because you mindfucked me yet again.





also as intelligent as you write you are wrong about 99% of the time in this game when townie. DIE!!

 

[Nuno]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 1

No, I'm pretty dumbfounded he got to six votes just moments after Imp said Nana was the safe bet. One vote and then everyone goes, oh, okay. If this turns out to be a mistake, it will be a mistake on us all, lol.

Within 13 minutes 5 people voted for niichan and made a huge bandwagon.
6x naruto-niichan (Tom/wizzard, Katarina/Hardy, Muratcan/Kat, Leonardo/Imperium, Felipe/Farfalla, Mariana-2/Spectrum) per 8.32pm my time.

Later on Kat changed her vote to xi0. That leaves Hardy, Imp, Farfalla and Spec as remaining "bandwagoners".

Imp basically said nana was the safer bet, then says "we can vote niichan to annoy him". When 3 people suddenly do it within no time at all he jumps on an easy bandwagon. That's what it looks like. I'm very suspicious of these 5 last players that voted for niichan. Kat's change doesn't really help as she helped contribute to an easy bandwagon. I'm not yet sure what to think about her "omg what should I do om gom g omg omg posts" and vote change. Maybe it reduces suspicion on her a little.

There isn't a defense to "lurking", anyway. Aside from maybe "I have been busy", which everyone, including me, would be reluctant to buy (and no one did).

Lurking is such a cheap argument, but an argument nonetheless. Basically people that are in fact busy are punished for not turning on 'invisible mode'. None of you would see niichan if he had it on except global+admin level. People getting blamed for trying to be up to date from the phone etc... It's different when you have a guy lurking that is actively posting elsewhere on MH, or you know he/she's not busy. Take notes people.

I suspected niichan myself, but when he gave his reasons for being MIA I found it enough to remove my incentive to vote kill him. Like I said in my post had he not been MIA from the rest of MH but neglected this thread, he would have been a high priority target for lynch IMO, but he was MIA from MH entirely. Anyway pointless now since he's dead and we lost one of the most overpowered late-game townie roles, but people really should think twice before they judge too harshly for lurking, inactiveness etc, which is my general point about this post.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

He cant be a detective either right ?

No, he can be one. Detectives get a PM from the host telling the investigation result. If he got blocked as a Detective, he wouldn't get one and immediately know that he was blocked.
That's as far as my knowledge goes. Correct me DD if I got this wrong, but I remember it this way.

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Hakkun has a point, which turns to be DD accusing someone without reason.

you are not a doctor, detective ... confirm this

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Good, so why do you think we had night without kills ? Prostitute blocked and doctor protected ?

Well the bulletproof is dead, so it has to be a prostitute or a doctor.

It could be a poisoner

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

No, he can be one. Detectives get a PM from the host telling the investigation result. If he got blocked as a Detective, he wouldn't get one and immediately know that he was blocked.
That's as far as my knowledge goes. Correct me DD if I got this wrong, but I remember it this way.

Yeah a detective would definitely know if he was blocked. Is he a detective though?

---------- Post added at 11:58 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:58 AM ----------

It could be a poisoner

Maybe it was....

---------- Post added at 11:58 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:58 AM ----------

One of us might already be dead...

---------- Post added at 11:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:58 AM ----------

Leoat can you tell us who you targeted at night then?

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

No, he can be one. Detectives get a PM from the host telling the investigation result. If he got blocked as a Detective, he wouldn't get one and immediately know that he was blocked.
That's as far as my knowledge goes. Correct me DD if I got this wrong, but I remember it this way.

nah omg it was was true then its stupid ... I thought prostitute could just block when the ppl has killing power ... when the person doesnt then nothing happens no ?

 

[Nuno]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

I also remember haku saying he had a boring role.....mafia would say that. I should wait for the others, they might have info.

He also said he doesn't have a night role.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

also as intelligent as you write you are wrong about 99% of the time in this game when townie. DIE!!

Well, sorry for not being a Sherlock Holmes reincarnate.

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

It could be a poisoner

that could be true

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

that could be true

maybe you got poisoned kat...

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Then we would need doctors and prostitue results which would be too much for just knowing if gnut is lying or not right ?

It's too early for that o.o We still have 16 people playing, revealing that now would help the mafia to eliminate our blocking roles

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 1

Within 13 minutes 5 people voted for niichan and made a huge bandwagon.
6x naruto-niichan (Tom/wizzard, Katarina/Hardy, Muratcan/Kat, Leonardo/Imperium, Felipe/Farfalla, Mariana-2/Spectrum) per 8.32pm my time.

That's why I didn't agree with Hardy's way of "It was your mistake to get lynched". Inactive or not, the bandwagon was huge within moments. Normally, that might only happen when people are absolutely sure of someone's colors. Yet, happened in this game for a clueless lynch. If all those players were Townies, then it's a legendary failure that we got to this conclusion. But I doubt that's the case.

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

maybe you got poisoned kat...

oh well that would suck .. but If I die look who was so bad at me xi0 and Hardy go for them then to take revenge

Spoiler

Im kidding. (Just saying cuz those two would then come and "wtf blab la bla" start bitching again

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 1

That's why I didn't agree with Hardy's way of "It was your mistake to get lynched". Inactive or not, the bandwagon was huge within moments. Normally, that might only happen when people are absolutely sure of someone's colors. Yet, happened in this game for a clueless lynch. If all those players were Townies, then it's a legendary failure that we got to this conclusion. But I doubt that's the case.

Spectrum said, might as well follow you guys and then voted niichan... dumb townie or mafia?

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

i'm not lying....
i read 25pgs yesterday after work and could not post.....
i still feel xi0 is suspect....he did everything to make you guys think i'm of no use...claimed i could be lying or a plan would be fruitless
then,he let niichan die with out trying to say anything but...oh he may be lying too
he had like 60 post on 1st day...i know it was a long phase....but how often we see xi0 post that much....he is mafia
like falla said bout imp influencing the game...i think xi0 is doing this

I didn't think that what I said could apply to Gary xD Hm..

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

It's too early for that o.o We still have 16 people playing, revealing that now would help the mafia to eliminate our blocking roles

thats what I said that its too much just for knowing if gnut is lying

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Wasn't the argument "xi0 is inactive" yesterday or am I recalling it wrong?

That was the argument for some time, but Gary is one of the top posters in this game (5 out of 20 people)

 

[gnut]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 1

Within 13 minutes 5 people voted for niichan and made a huge bandwagon.
6x naruto-niichan (Tom/wizzard, Katarina/Hardy, Muratcan/Kat, Leonardo/Imperium, Felipe/Farfalla, Mariana-2/Spectrum) per 8.32pm my time.

Later on Kat changed her vote to xi0. That leaves Hardy, Imp, Farfalla and Spec as remaining "bandwagoners".

Imp basically said nana was the safer bet, then says "we can vote niichan to annoy him". When 3 people suddenly do it within no time at all he jumps on an easy bandwagon. That's what it looks like. I'm very suspicious of these 5 last players that voted for niichan. Kat's change doesn't really help as she helped contribute to an easy bandwagon. I'm not yet sure what to think about her "omg what should I do om gom g omg omg posts" and vote change. Maybe it reduces suspicion on her a little.



Lurking is such a cheap argument, but an argument nonetheless. Basically people that are in fact busy are punished for not turning on 'invisible mode'. None of you would see niichan if he had it on except global+admin level. People getting blamed for trying to be up to date from the phone etc... It's different when you have a guy lurking that is actively posting elsewhere on MH, or you know he/she's not busy. Take notes people.

I suspected niichan myself, but when he gave his reasons for being MIA I found it enough to remove my incentive to vote kill him. Like I said in my post had he not been MIA from the rest of MH but neglected this thread, he would have been a high priority target for lynch IMO, but he was MIA from MH entirely. Anyway pointless now since he's dead and we lost one of the most overpowered late-game townie roles, but people really should think twice before they judge too harshly for lurking, inactiveness etc, which is my general point about this post.

i'm with you on this...i facepalmed while reading the bandwagon on niichan....

but,don't you think it strang that after he revealed his role...a player like xi0 would be like"wait a minute people"
but he was all....it's him or me....he could be lying....niichan was about to die....why would he have lied at that point...i just dont see why he didnt pick up on this....then he does a safe vote on lala....and says it really doesnt matter if i vote him or not
but,he says my post were filled with "poor me"....

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Regarding Poisoner, doesn't that count as a secondary action for a Mafia? Even if someone got poisoned and will die, it doesn't add anything to why no one died in this night phase.

Yeah a detective would definitely know if he was blocked. Is he a detective though?

He can be one. Too early to say he is one, but he can still be one. We can't deny that possibility.

nah omg it was was true then its stupid ... I thought prostitute could just block when the ppl has killing power ... when the person doesnt then nothing happens no ?

It's not limited to killing roles, yeah.

He also said he doesn't have a night role.

Yeah, I did. I don't have a night role.