Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Eru13]

It's not. The mangas that receive color pages cannot be too close to each other.

Not quite, I've seen some issues where they're only separated by one series
Besides, that's not the point, I mean, with BC being the third center color, it's on a way lower position than its usual top 7

 

[G_I_A]

Not quite, I've seen some issues where they're only separated by one series
Besides, that's not the point, I mean, with BC being the third center color, it's on a way lower position than its usual top 7

I just checked the last 5 issues. It's not a rule but there's no way that all the chapters that received color pages are consecutive. Pretty much there's a difference of 2-6 chapters between them.

Even so, next week will be the REAL DEAL. EVERYTHING will be ranked (except My Hero Academia that gets the lead cp and one piece that is absent) It will be ONE HELL of a battle between: Souma, Haikyuu, Black Clover, The Dance Manga and Ansatsu.

I vote for: Ansatsu, Souma, Haikyuu, Black Clover, The Dance Manga.

 

[conankudo]

 

[Heiji]

 

[Gikiseima]

i'm very happy to see souma hit spot no 1

 

[ElJin]

Black Clover CP:

---------- Post added at 11:38 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:45 AM ----------

Can anyone upload here the authors comments, please?

 

[ryozen]

Horikoshi

 

[piau9000]

Ranking - VOL 34

1 - Food Wars
2 - One Piece
3 - My Hero Academia
4 - Haikyuu
5 - Straighten Up
6 - Gintama
7 - Nisekoi
8 - Hinomaru Zumou
9 - Toriko
10 - PSI Kusou Saiki
11 - Kagamigami
12 - Lady Justice
13 - World Trigger
14 - Devily Man
15 - Kochikame
16 - Bleach




Average ranking of 2015 - VOL 34

"+" means that the series ended or moved to another magazine.

One Piece - 1.73
Assassination Classroom - 2
My Hero Academia - 2.37
Haikyuu - 3.82
Food Wars - 3.87
Black Clover - 4.45
Straighten Up - 4.5
Hinomaru Zumou - 6
Toriko - 6.39
Gintama - 6.85
PSI Kusou Saiki - 7.20
Nisekoi - 8.41
World Trigger - 8.71
Kagamigami - 9.07
Devily Man - 11
+Gakkyuu Houtei - 11.15
Kochikame - 11.16
Bleach - 11.32
+Ultra Battle Satellite - 11.9
+Judos - 12
+Takujou no Ageha - 12.33
+Hi-Fi Cluster - 12.71
Lady Justice - 13
+Cyborg Roggy - 13.5
+E-Robot - 13.5
+Sporting Salt - 13.5

 

[Drmke]

It's kinda ironical how Black Clover is lower when it has color pages than when it doesn't

It's generally been excepted in the past here that the editors do that to draw more attention to the back of the magazine and less popular series.

 

[xi0]

They charge more money for advertising the closer in proximity it is to the color pages...so yeah, it makes sense that they would stretch them out through the magazine.

 

[ElJin]

Shoujo Fukkyuu: Recovery-Q CP:

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Golden Future Cup is going to be tough with seven entries this year, much more interesting than last year.

 

[joshua019]

bleach last place. I hope they cancel it soon

 

[Mammo]

seriously I don't even like bleach & i'm embarrassed for Kubo

Japanese people would rather read Lady justice & Devilyman over reading bleach

just end it already

 

[RafaFedKilla]

seriously I don't even like bleach & i'm embarrassed for Kubo

Japanese people would rather read Lady justice & Devilyman over reading bleach

just end it already

That's not true at all. Bleach's latest volume just sold 300k and Lady Justice and Devilyman will be lucky to reach a tenth of those sales for their lifespans. TOC is not hard and fast,I don't know how many times we've been over this....

 

[RubyR91]

I hope Kagamigami pulls a Mago and rises in the ToC.

 

[SharkBait]

i'm very happy to see souma hit spot no 1

The power of SoKuga, its as good as SoTaku. Apart from dull Subaru, the character designer makes some of the most perfect male rivals for his lead character. Still if he makes Soma win, heads are gonna roll.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

seriously I don't even like bleach & i'm embarrassed for Kubo

Japanese people would rather read Lady justice & Devilyman over reading bleach

just end it already

Yeah, because after more than 10 years being a big hit, Kubo will be embarrassed and end Bleach abruptly because Lady Justice and Devilyman are above, even still being one of the 5 most selling mangas (volumes) in the magazine . What a logic.

What surprises me is that after all these years with the manga in the half to bottom, people still thinking that rankings have some real relevance in Bleach, even more now that is already in the final saga.

 

[G_I_A]

Why do you guys even count bleach at the TOC? It's ALREADY cancelled. Ever since this "last arc" was announced, it was already gone. It does not matter how long it will take, the fact is that its not gonna get better. Get over it.

 

[jagman1x3]

Why do you guys even count bleach at the TOC? It's ALREADY cancelled. Ever since this "last arc" was announced, it was already gone. It does not matter how long it will take, the fact is that its not gonna get better. Get over it.

By that definition, there's no point in looking at the rankings because everything except Kochikame is going to end some day. The point is wondering how much longer it'll last before it starts to show in the sales.