Games Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - END GAME

[James Rye]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

The day ends in 15 minutes.

Alright.

I gonna votekill zasz.

Lawl, you better do something with your spy action that can fucking PROOVE that you are the sane spy and not a mafia faking to be spy and Panda is the only one who has an active night role left we know of. Just stop accusating innocent townies already because they piss you off. I didn't saved on the first day so that you can get us all troll-killed!

---------- Post added at 03:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:46 PM ----------

Isn't zasz sicky townie

Impossible, sickly townie gives sicknesses, sickly townie does not automatically get sick at the very first day, else it would be easy to guess who is sickly townie for everyone in each game where a sickly townie is in it.

 

[Copy Panda]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

well no voters disease is independent from your role (I think)

honestly most of my mistakes came from just not knowing how to handle the rules and such, so feel free to ask someone else for confirmation :/

 

[Demonspeed]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

What if we spare lawl today? What happens tonight? I am Plain Townie now, if you truly stole my role and someone else will die? lawl is the only one besides me to have claimed active role. Maybe tata(if she truly is kamikaze) should blow up tonight depending on the result?

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

You guys are excusing a troll that got Jorp and Frosty killed to go for uncertain things

 

[g01]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

I see then there is a sicky townie

 

[James Rye]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

What if we spare lawl today? What happens tonight? I am Plain Townie now, if you truly stole my role and someone else will die? lawl is the only one besides me to have claimed active role. Maybe tata(if she truly is kamikaze) should blow up tonight depending on the result?

And on who should Tata blow up tonight?

Lawl can check on Panda if Panda really stole your role that is. Maybe Panda just bluffs and you still got your role. WHich is why you might wanna try out to still send a "I protect x" pm to hardy for the night phase in case of Panda just bluffing to be pirate or actually have stolen another role and not yours.

 

[Hardy]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

Spoiler

[highlight]Day 2 ends in 16 hs.[/highlight]​

Haha so you are Mafia! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAH

I went for Holt!

votekill lawl

lock vote Lawl

Votelock Jorped

---------- Post added at 04:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:27 PM ----------

fellow townies lets not waste any more time and kill this mafia jorp

So both of you have alibis. Gotta say seems Jorp is telling the truth.
votekill Lawl. Imo, the story of you targeting Jorp as he perform a kill seems too fantastic especially considering that you promised to deliver a mafia today.

Wow jorpie is trying hard to survive! Tryhard Mafia is the best. Go to holt coming out suddenly as well . Ggwp boysvotelock jorped going to sleep. If I get lynched plz for the love of god lynch him next day

Misho gets nothing by killing the "hider" today and getting himself killed the day after. Townies are a bigger majority so far. You're just going down with Jorp like that, with no reasoning at all to pick a side.

Votekill Jorp

---------- Post added at 07:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:05 PM ----------



Nice way to try to deviate focus when clearly either you or Misho is lying '-' Fuck the rest right now.

Agree with farfosh, this is the same as first day

FOR NOW votekill jorped

First of all, calm down guys!

And let's recap:

Demon - why did Aonori die? Weren't you supposed to protect him? Are you naive or insane after all? If so I hope the sane doc stays hidden. Hell, we need the inactive ones to be more active!

Panda - who did you rob tonight? That is really important to know from which person you stole a role if your pirate claim role is real after all.

Jorped - calm down. And think logically. We lost two detectives and we might, MIGHT, have a third one who hopefully keeps his mouth shut till he finds out his sanity and with luck finds a Mafia member. And yet you tell us to kill the only spy guy who might be of help to find actions?

Lawl - I think we need to start having proof that you are really spy after all. Like you targeting Demon without Demon saying who he targeted and you writing first who demon targeted and demon either sayingtthat is correct or not. Because THIS is why claiming spy is freaking hard if not IMPOSSIBLE for Mafias, because unlike with detective and doctor they do not know which townie REALLY has a night role with an action and even IF they do know that they cannot know for sure WHICH one those townies targeted at night!
Also according to your result, Jorped CANNOT be escort because he targeted Aonori and Demon protected Aonori that night. So the only explanation for the last night is that Demon got blocked by Mafia Escort who oviously cannot be Jorped since according to your result he didn't targeted demon! The only reason a "hider" would target a detective is that he knows said detective is protected by a doc and Demon declared to protect Aonori so he was obvious to die this nigth first. HOWEVER! Aonori DIED this night and Jorped didn't!
Which means given that Aonori found both gnut and jorped "guilty" in the past two nights adn that demon failed to protect Aonori and Jorped targeted Aonori given Lawl's result:

Jorped is Mafia Boss thus the "guilty" result of Aonori which is also why Jorped tried his best not to get lynched the past days as else we would already know Aonori's sanity. And somebody else if Mafia. Probably Panda or somebody else who voted for gnut to die and who isn't a fully confirmed townie like me.

I votekill Jorped for now.

Even if I am wrong I rather kill a now useless hider as the mafia will never ever target jorped as they KNOW they cannot kill him than a possible spy after the lose of two detectives!

And I suggest again that we mob up on Jorped and get him duel killed on the two duel chances we have today!

WHO'S WITH ME?!?!

Votekill Misho troll o/

OK... This is interesting....

Vote Kill lawl for now

wow that was unexpected!!!!

---------- Post added at 01:26 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:19 AM ----------

truly lets not jump on the townie straight away and look at the big picture. I clearly made a mistake in my spying activities but hey we are all humans.votekill panda for now.

votelock lawl I knew your story was too good to be true. Now you're claiming to be blocked? Why didn't you just say that the first time so we investigate rather than implicated Jorp?

Votekill Panda

I need to go right now

Votekill Lawl

I lev you master but...but...

If Law is just trolling, it's better to keep him around regardless. At the moment we need all the townies we can get.

Zasz has been afk like, the whole game right? Wouldn't it be kinda unfair if he turned out to be mafia anyway? Like, there's no chance for us to interact and figure out if he is or isn't.

Holt hasn't really elaborated on his role, nor has Gol as far as I know.

I think Farf isn't that much of a suspect at the moment, especially since I agree with things she says (I mean, that could be a ploy but w/e).

Haku I think isn't just a regular townie, but we'll leave that for what it is at the moment.

Of Demon and James I guess we can say they're innocent.

Ah well, lets not lock in votes till we have certainty.

For the moment I'll go with vote kill Holt however. I can still change it, but I think it's best we eliminate actual mafia contenders over professional trolls.

---------- Post added at 01:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:48 PM ----------



hum you missed mouse

I need to go to work now or I'll get terribly late. So for now I gonna vote for lawl. If I have time and internet maybe I change after the duel.
Votekill Lawl

Yeah, hence, besides lawlett, I said. The only way to make that happen would be to kill lawlett, I assume.

Anyways, I Vote Kill Zasz

I honestly stand by that executing a troll is not as favourable as killing someone who doesn't reveal anything to the group.

At this point my main suspects are Hardy and Zasz. Since Haku voted Zasz, I'm going to change my vote to Zasz as well. We can always interrogate Law who's active, we cannot interrogate Zasz.

I hope this argument is clear, feel free to argue back. But at least consider it. We have the potential to finish this up tomorrow if we play it right

votekill Zasz

The day ends in 15 minutes.

Alright.

I gonna votekill zasz.

Lawl, you better do something with your spy action that can fucking PROOVE that you are the sane spy and not a mafia faking to be spy and Panda is the only one who has an active night role left we know of. Just stop accusating innocent townies already because they piss you off. I didn't saved on the first day so that you can get us all troll-killed!

---------- Post added at 03:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:46 PM ----------



Impossible, sickly townie gives sicknesses, sickly townie does not automatically get sick at the very first day, else it would be easy to guess who is sickly townie for everyone in each game where a sickly townie is in it.

10 of 10 votes

lawlett-kun 5x (Katie/Holt;Cho/Farfalla;Ernie/Demonspeed;Neville/g01;Ron/Tatasugoi)

Zasz 3x (Seamus/Hakuteiken;Fred/James;Crabbe/TSPanda)

TSPanda 1x (Dean/lawlett-kun)

Unable to vote, Not Voter Disease 1x (Luna/Zasz)

[highlight]Day 4 ends in 10 minutes[/highlight]

If I missed a post or a vote please let me know.​

 

[g01]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

Why do you trust lawl so much?

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

Rules state that he could have passed that disease around at night phases, but he didn't and hence, didn't get to use a single vote whole the game.
Does not reveal his role, does not join discussions, does not vote.
That's Zasz' identity for this game.

Well, Demon should probably still "protect" someone this night, since we can't be sure if Panda stole your role or not. No point in declaring a target whatsoever. There aren't any roles that Townies would surely want to protect at this stage, anyway (unless the ones that are yet to be revealed go in this group).

 

[Demonspeed]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

So today it's either Zasz or lawl, Panda escaped death again somehow.

If lawl/Zasz dies and he is Spy/Townie: What does it mean? What do we do?

If lawl/Zasz dies and he is Mafia: What do we do?

 

[James Rye]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

You guys are excusing a troll that got Jorp and Frosty killed to go for uncertain things

If you don't like that, we can still kill you Miss "I am passive and nothing else".

Lawl was about to get close lynched on day 1. Day 1 lynches are usually two categories, either it is a huge bandwagon on one player who mostly ends up as townie but sometimes as mafia and the other is a close voting race where the mafia tries to kill by 1 vote and them usually being the deciding one. Which is why I made that tie to prevent Lawl's death and it turning out to get GrySun in the end killed.
Also lawl claiming spy which is a worse move than claiming detective or doctor both roles which are much easier to fake for Mafia than a spy.
That and knowing that Lawl is an asshole troll who likes playing dirty and getting innocent people killed for giggles. If he really is spy then let's hope he had enough bloodshed for today and tells the truth about his night action tomorrow. If not we can still lynch him tomorrow and give up on this game.

 

[Copy Panda]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

What if we spare lawl today? What happens tonight? I am Plain Townie now, if you truly stole my role and someone else will die? lawl is the only one besides me to have claimed active role. Maybe tata(if she truly is kamikaze) should blow up tonight depending on the result?

I honestly think we lose if law dies now

You guys are excusing a troll that got Jorp and Frosty killed to go for uncertain things

get mad at him later

And on who should Tata blow up tonight?

Lawl can check on Panda if Panda really stole your role that is. Maybe Panda just bluffs and you still got your role. WHich is why you might wanna try out to still send a "I protect x" pm to hardy for the night phase in case of Panda just bluffing to be pirate or actually have stolen another role and not yours.

so suspicious

 

[Demonspeed]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

If you don't like that, we can still kill you Miss "I am passive and nothing else".

Lawl was about to get close lynched on day 1. Day 1 lynches are usually two categories, either it is a huge bandwagon on one player who mostly ends up as townie but sometimes as mafia and the other is a close voting race where the mafia tries to kill by 1 vote and them usually being the deciding one. Which is why I made that tie to prevent Lawl's death and it turning out to get GrySun in the end killed.
Also lawl claiming spy which is a worse move than claiming detective or doctor both roles which are much easier to fake for Mafia than a spy.
That and knowing that Lawl is an asshole troll who likes playing dirty and getting innocent people killed for giggles. If he really is spy then let's hope he had enough bloodshed for today and tells the truth about his night action tomorrow. If not we can still lynch him tomorrow and give up on this game.

Lala is not dying today, three votes are locked on lawl already, you, Haku and me are the ones who can change votes, Panda vote is locked on Zasz.

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

Rules state that he could have passed that disease around at night phases, but he didn't and hence, didn't get to use a single vote whole the game.
Does not reveal his role, does not join discussions, does not vote.
That's Zasz' identity for this game.

Well, Demon should probably still "protect" someone this night, since we can't be sure if Panda stole your role or not. No point in declaring a target whatsoever. There aren't any roles that Townies would surely want to protect at this stage, anyway (unless the ones that are yet to be revealed go in this group).

Agreed, but what makes him a better option over Misho if we compare them? The no voting says he's highly inactive.

 

[Copy Panda]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

So today it's either Zasz or lawl, Panda escaped death again somehow.

If lawl/Zasz dies and he is Spy/Townie: What does it mean? What do we do?

If lawl/Zasz dies and he is Mafia: What do we do?

-edit, disregard this-

Why do you trust lawl so much?

because we have evidence of troll not treachery, for the sake of our mumbers we cant kill him

Spoiler

[highlight]Day 2 ends in 16 hs.[/highlight]​

10 of 10 votes

lawlett-kun 5x (Katie/Holt;Cho/Farfalla;Ernie/Demonspeed;Neville/g01;Ron/Tatasugoi)

Zasz 3x (Seamus/Hakuteiken;Fred/James;Crabbe/TSPanda)

TSPanda 1x (Dean/lawlett-kun)

Unable to vote, Not Voter Disease 1x (Luna/Zasz)

[highlight]Day 4 ends in 10 minutes[/highlight]

If I missed a post or a vote please let me know.​

law voted zasz

 

[James Rye]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

So today it's either Zasz or lawl, Panda escaped death again somehow.

If lawl/Zasz dies and he is Spy/Townie: What does it mean? What do we do?

If lawl/Zasz dies and he is Mafia: What do we do?

If Lawl's spy we made a big mistake. if he is mafia, well, maybe we kill Panda next, I dunno. Doesn't really tells us much.

If zasz was townie then a useless because not active enough one and also hardly voting one.

If zasz was mafia then agood one because survived so far and nobody really bothered to look at him/her.

---------- Post added at 03:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:56 PM ----------

We got 3 mintues left.

People.

Vote!

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

If you don't like that, we can still kill you Miss "I am passive and nothing else".

Empty words so far '-'

 

[Copy Panda]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

So today it's either Zasz or lawl, Panda escaped death again somehow.

If lawl/Zasz dies and he is Spy/Townie: What does it mean? What do we do?

If lawl/Zasz dies and he is Mafia: What do we do?

panda will die shortly no worries

If zasz dies its not our fault for suspectinb him, if lawl dies we were too quick to jump the gun (... I think:/)

my remaining suspect is holt anyway

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

Agreed, but what makes him a better option over Misho if we compare them? The no voting says he's highly inactive.

One is feeding us information (false and/or correct), the other does not.
I personally prioritize having bad information over none.

 

[g01]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - DAY 4

Agree...