Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[G_I_A]

Do you guys believe Fairy Tail could have been a million per volume seller in japan(because it is worldwide) if it was in Jump?

Canceled with less than 24 chapters.

 

[Kadir0]

Today is the day We Can't Study will get ranked, place your bets guys, which position will it get? Mine is 6

 

[Koi Kage]

Today is the day We Can't Study will get ranked, place your bets guys, which position will it get? Mine is 6

I'm guessing 6/7 th

 

[G_I_A]

Today is the day We Can't Study will get ranked, place your bets guys, which position will it get? Mine is 6

dead bottom.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

dead bottom.

Hopefully. Mangaka belongs in Jump Plus, and should stay there.

 

[tirakai]

how many series will be ranked next issue anyway? 11?

 

[Nakura]

how many series will be ranked next issue anyway? 11?

Yup. I predict We Never Learn will be 7th.

 

[Leoat12]

Dr.Stone was much better without the badly written scientific things. Just pure good action and a strong guy appearing. It is a great evolution a cool (meaning serious) guy when we had a brat who thinks know everything and a jester so far.

 

[TyVip]

Rank 4,

Spoiler: Reason

I'm the Editor in Chief in disguise. I chose each series's ranking based on number generator between 1-20. Except One Piece, its number generator is between 1-4, And Isobe.

 

[shoyoboyo]

I hope We Never Learn gets ranked above black clover just to trigger you two. even better if it ends up being more successful despite black clovers constant pushing
In all honesty though, i've been enjoying we never learn and i wouldn't mind it surviving. it's a fun series with cute girls that don't suffer from the same face syndrome of nisekoi.

 

[SkerllyFC]

For me, if a manga ranks 3 consecutive weeks in the bottom, there is when I think it should be cancelled. Just because the first week ranked in the bottom doesn´t mean it will be auto-cancelled. Although Spring Weapon has had some good rankings despite being at the bottom mostly

 

[tirakai]

I'd be happy with any of this round surviving which is pretty rare for me, there's always at least one I don't want to see in the magazine.

I wouldn't even mind a U19 run, it might be terrible but I'm kind of interested in seeing what the creator's intentions for the series are (plus I find the terrible-ness weirdly endearing). Maybe not as a proper long runner but something around 40-50 chapters would be nice where there's enough time for it to do a couple arcs to show off some of its potential if it has any (and to give the writer a little experience).

 

[G_I_A]

We Can't Study, U19 and Hungry Marie will be canceled.

 

[ChocoBar9]

Do you guys believe Fairy Tail could have been a million per volume seller in japan(because it is worldwide) if it was in Jump?

No especially since Fairy Tail premiered in what was Jump's most prosperous time period since the Golden age of the mid to late 80's where pretty much everything on the lineup was a top seller even Jaguar. Mashima's "talent" can only prosper in a company that doesn't have much in terms of expectations for its mangaka and who's sales quota isn't as high. Quite frankly I still think FT's sales are too high despite the fact that its dropped considerably since it got its boost 8 years ago and despite the anime getting cannned and the movie bombing it still has a lucrative income coming from somewhere whether it be manga sales or figures, its a franchise in which I'll never understand its appeal or maybe the fanbase just love the abuse hence why they keep coming back.

 

[Kadir0]

We Can't Study, U19 and Hungry Marie will be canceled.

Dr.Stone, Hungry Marie, Robot x Laserbeam will survive, everything else will get cancelled.

 

[TyVip]

^ your signature disagrees with you.

 

[Nakura]

All of them will be cancelled and they'll bring back Yagi again

 

[Tamil]

No especially since Fairy Tail premiered in what was Jump's most prosperous time period since the Golden age of the mid to late 80's where pretty much everything on the lineup was a top seller even Jaguar. Mashima's "talent" can only prosper in a company that doesn't have much in terms of expectations for its mangaka and who's sales quota isn't as high. Quite frankly I still think FT's sales are too high despite the fact that its dropped considerably since it got its boost 8 years ago and despite the anime getting cannned and the movie bombing it still has a lucrative income coming from somewhere whether it be manga sales or figures, its a franchise in which I'll never understand its appeal or maybe the fanbase just love the abuse hence why they keep coming back.

If I had to guess maybe it's the shipping fandom that's pushing the sales but even then it's questionable why it got so high.

 

[xAsum0x]

All of them will be cancelled and they'll bring back Yagi again

Who

 

[G_I_A]

Dr.Stone, Hungry Marie, Robot x Laserbeam will survive, everything else will get cancelled.

So you're venerating veterans?

All of them will be cancelled and they'll bring back Yagi again

No, they'll bring back Bleach and it will sell more than One Piece.