Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Mammo]

Shoseki ranking :

5/2
1-One Piece 85
2-Haikyuu!! 26
3-Shokugeki no Soma 24
4-Boruto 03
6-Black Clover 11
9-Kimetsu no Yaiba 06
13-Karadasagashi 13
16-Samon-kun wa Summoner 09
78-Ibitsu no Amalgam 03
90-The Promised Neverland 03
106- Tenjin 07
158-The Promised Neverland 01
165-The Promised Neverland 02
254-Ole Golazo 02
272-Kimetsu no Yaiba 05
293-Kimetsu no Yaiba 01
304-Kimetsu no Yaiba 03
317-Kimetsu no Yaiba 02
357-Kimetsu no Yaiba 04

5/3
1-One Piece 85
2-Haikyuu!! 26
3-Shokugeki no Soma 24
4-Boruto 03
6-Black Clover 11
8-Kimetsu no Yaiba 06
16-Karadasagashi 13
20-Samon-kun wa Summoner 09
77-The Promised Neverland 03
128-The Promised Neverland 01
143-The Promised Neverland 02
146-Tenjin 07
237-Kimetsu no Yaiba 05
297-Kimetsu no Yaiba 01
319-Kimetsu no Yaiba 04
338-Kimetsu no Yaiba 02
396-Kimetsu no Yaiba 03

Dragon Ball heroes is doing way better than I expected

OP previous volume jumped 40 place up and BnHA 13 jumped 20 place up, they are closely behind Samon now
at this rate both will appear on next week oricon
I wonder what happened that made them jump

 

[Tamil]

Shinobu pushing KnY vol. 6 to the 80k mark

 

[Mammo]

if it Shinbou-sama, then crossing 100k mark isn't just a dream

also the reactions for Kanao's origin story in Japanese social media is very positive, hoping that will also help increasing the volumes sales

I think I just figured out the reason for old volumes jumps, OP jump is because the filler is over and Big Mom made her anime debut and heroaca jump must be because how big Deku was on the all star cover?

anyway, if this a silly childish DBZ spinoff is selling well I'm really curious about how DB Super volume 3 will sell next month, it's the volume with Zamasu stuff in it, I think it will sell between 200k and 300k

 

[iceemperor]

if it Shinbou-sama, then crossing 100k mark isn't a just dream

also the reactions for Kanao's origin story in Japanese social media is very positive, hoping that will also help increasing the volumes sales

I think I just figured out the reason for old volumes jumps, OP jump is because the filler is over and Big Mom made her anime debut and heroaca jump must be because how big Deku was on the all star cover?

anyway, if this a silly childish DBZ spinoff is selling well I'm really curious about how DB Super volume 3 will sell next month, it's the volume with Zamasu stuff in it, I think it will sell between 200k and 300k

You can't really say a series, even a silly spin-off that debuts in the 30s and 40s is selling particularly well because most of its sales will be in the first 2~3 days after which it drops out of the top 50. Even Samon right now might not be in the top 50 in the daily Shoseki around this weekend because of how fast series that low drop out of the top 50. Kimetsu however is growing at a nice steady pace.

Also, One Piece's volume 84 coming back up again is actually pretty common for the series. Whenever a new volume came out, the previous volume would again start rising, coming back into the top 50, either because people missed it and bought both to get caught up or other unknown reasons. Heroaca rising up from 45 to 23 is big though. It being Golden week and thus people having time to actually relax and buy the series might be one possible reason.

 

[ElJin]

The OVA is bundled with a special edition of volume 11.

It is? Oh sorry then, my mistake.

Thank you for the information.

 

[Nakura]

Do we know that the sales for MHA volume 13 are counting the OVA limited edition, or are they separate? I remember volume 7's limited edition was separate, but we saw that limited edition in the charts.

 

[iceemperor]

Do we know that the sales for MHA volume 13 are counting the OVA limited edition, or are they separate? I remember volume 7's limited edition was separate, but we saw that limited edition in the charts.

It was treated as a book instead of as a comic so it didn't show up on any ranking chart.

 

[tirakai]

I wonder if Amalgam will sell better than Spring Weapon yet again.

 

[SkerllyFC]

Hello, is this comment section dead?

 

[WyldViolet]

Hello, is this comment section dead?

Yes.
Weekly Shonen jump was cancelled so we all moved on.

 

[Swavey]

Hello, is this comment section dead?

Got any more of those reviews? They're the only thing people in this comment section come for.

 

[Tamil]

Hello, is this comment section dead?

Toei sucks at adapting manga.

 

[TyVip]

Toei sucks at adapting manga.

inb4 they adapt Kimetsu

 

[Support]

I really like the videos that super eyepatch wolf makes, the latest one is on shonen jump and I think is worth a watch:

 

[TyVip]

I really like the videos that super eyepatch wolf makes, the latest one is on shonen jump and I think is worth a watch:

No it's not, the video is poorly research and he is missing a lots of facts.

He says One Piece is on a decline, his facts are the 2010 sales and 2016 sales (this is false), also he compares Nisekoi sale and MHA sale.

He claims Kochikame and Assassination Classroom got cancelled (this is also false)

His ranking is also false.

I didn't bother to watch the last 5 minutes when he talks about the 6 new series, because the other 70% are false facts.

 

[WyldViolet]

No it's not, the video is poorly research and he is missing a lots of facts.

He says One Piece is on a decline, his facts are the 2010 sales and 2016 sales (this is false), also he compares Nisekoi sale and MHA sale.

He claims Kochikame and Assassination Classroom got cancelled (this is also false)

His ranking is also false.

I didn't bother to watch the last 5 minutes when he talks about the 6 new series, because the other 70% are false facts.

Dude only has 6 posts. Probably shilling his own video.

 

[Leoat12]

Hello, is this comment section dead?

Why you had to ask? It was good that way.

 

[Tamil]

inb4 they adapt Kimetsu

Not happening.

I really like the videos that super eyepatch wolf makes, the latest one is on shonen jump and I think is worth a watch:

I really dislike his videos in general he's a tryhard. He left out Kimetsu No Yaiba & Yuragi?

 

[savethecat]

No it's not, the video is poorly research and he is missing a lots of facts.

He says One Piece is on a decline, his facts are the 2010 sales and 2016 sales (this is false), also he compares Nisekoi sale and MHA sale.

He claims Kochikame and Assassination Classroom got cancelled (this is also false)

His ranking is also false.

I didn't bother to watch the last 5 minutes when he talks about the 6 new series, because the other 70% are false facts.

I think his videos are normally pretty be good. But this one wasn't too good.

 

[Nakura]

I actually really like Eyepatch's videos. They're usually quite good for what they are. However, this is probably his worst video. It comes off as a video from an outsider when it comes to following WSJ. His video has a lot of iffy information, and some flat out false information.

Some stuff that bugged me in particular:
Assassination Classroom, Kochikame, and arguably Nisekoi were not cancelled.
He left out Kimetsu in the ranking data for some reason?
He included World Trigger, yet didn't include HxH in that data. Does he not know World Trigger is currently on hiatus? If not, that pretty much sums up his research.