Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[DyanSon]

Come on.

 

[Tanzo]

#29 :
Cross Account (New Serie, Cover, Lead Color)
Black Clover
One Piece
Gintama (Color)
Haikyu
My Hero Academia
Shûdan (Color)
Yakusoku no Neverland
Yuragi
Kinmetsu no Yaiba (Color)
Dr Stone
Psi
Hinomaru Sumo
Food Wars
Benkyô
Seishun
Robot x Laserbeam
Marie
Poro no Ryûgakuki (End)
Isobee

#30 :
Lead Color fo My Hero Academia
Color Page for Hunter x Hunter, Cross Account
Misteria - Kaiki Collection : Oneshot by Kôta Shugyô (Color)
Hinomaru Sumo & Shûdan get extra pages

We don't know yet if Hunter x Hunter will have cover in #30.

Also, Spring Weapon No. 1 has an extra arc (bangai-hen) in Issue 30.

 

[SharkBait]

BLack Clover back to its rightful place. Im glad its still well received.

 

[G_I_A]

Also, Spring Weapon No. 1 has an extra arc (bangai-hen) in Issue 30.

Yeah yeah that too... Back to DESPAIR

BLack Clover back to its rightful place. Im glad its still well received.

Well received... WELL RECEIVED? It's above three other manga that sells freaking much more, have anime and all other hype that you can possibly imagine.

How can MHA lose to it? Just tell me how? I'm soooo lovin' this... Where are MHA/WCS/WTV fans? I demand you here now ;/

 

[Koi Kage]

Oh boy,.. Black Clover in first... Newcomers getting canceled like apples falling from trees, MHA out of the top 3, Dr. Stone above we can't study, Zumou getting extra pages to its INEVITABLE END... Is this the best toc EVER?

Come on, let the DESPAIR begins.

If you've been keeping notice MHA been around the fifth place for a few weeks now so it's not something new. We can't study is the most consistent rankings wise out of the remaining new batch so I'd take where Dr. Stone at face value only until it reaches a state of consistence.

 

[Nakura]

Fingers crossed for Cross Account being good! Looking forward to MHA's lead colour page next week too!

 

[G_I_A]

If you've been keeping notice MHA been around the fifth place for a few weeks now so it's not something new. We can't study is the most consistent rankings wise out of the remaining new batch so I'd take where Dr. Stone at face value only until it reaches a state of consistence.

You know I've been. But Black Clover was never above it. And yes like I said, Dr. Stone was the best new series. I don't know what "consistency" you're talking about. Dr. Stone was above WCS some weeks. Simple as that =)

It's weird about Marie though. I'm following the series and there's no hints about its ending, but well we know it's inevitable. It's okay. But only if WCS follows it.

 

[razerxs]

It's weird about Marie though. I'm following the series and there's no hints about its ending, but well we know it's inevitable. It's okay. But only if WCS follows it.

I think Marie's been spared a couple more months. We probably won't have another cancellation round until well after Hunter x Hunter's next hiatus.

 

[shoyoboyo]

Black Clover in first lol all hope is lost. Also, WNL is slowly dropping, my worry is starting to grow.

Oh boy,.. Black Clover in first... Newcomers getting canceled like apples falling from trees, MHA out of the top 3, Dr. Stone above we can't study, Zumou getting extra pages to its INEVITABLE END... Is this the best toc EVER?

I answer it myself dudes, IT IS.

Come on, let the DESPAIR begins.

Bruh, every time Zumou slips a little in the rankings you mention its "inevitable end". You need to get better at baiting lol

 

[Koi Kage]

And yes like I said, Dr. Stone was the best new series. Simple as that =)

It's weird about Marie though. I'm following the series and there's no hints about its ending, but well we know it's inevitable. It's okay. But only if WCS follows it.

With how well the first Volume of We Can't Study did it's first week and getting a re-print says it's not going anywhere anytime soon Marie will most likely go within a few weeks most likely even though it doesn't com across like it will it's plot has been stagnate for a while so it's inevitable just a matter of when. I don't think Dr. Stone is that good really especially with it's latest few chapters that showed useless back story for literally no reason.

 

[G_I_A]

Black Clover in first lol all hope is lost. Also, WNL is slowly dropping, my worry is starting to grow.

Bruh, every time Zumou slips a little in the rankings you mention its "inevitable end". You need to get better at baiting lol

It's no bait. It's getting extra pages for no reason... What else could it be?

And yes, you should worry about WCS. And yes again, Black Clover is here to cause trouble.

--- Double Post Merged, Jun 14, 2017, Original Post Date: Jun 14, 2017 ---

With how well the first Volume of We Can't Study did it's first week and getting a re-print says it's not going anywhere anytime soon Marie will most likely go within a few weeks most likely even though it doesn't com across like it will it's plot has been stagnate for a while so it's inevitable just a matter of when. I don't think Dr. Stone is that good really especially with it's latest few chapters that showed useless back story for literally no reason.

Well you're using sales to talk about WCS (probably because you like it) and your opinion to talk about Dr. Stone (probably because you dislike it). Let's wait Dr. Stone sales shall we?

I bet they'll be on pair or even above WCS.

--- Double Post Merged, Jun 14, 2017 ---

I think Marie's been spared a couple more months. We probably won't have another cancellation round until well after Hunter x Hunter's next hiatus.

I agree, makes perfect sense.

 

[Koi Kage]

Well you're using sales to talk about WCS (probably because you like it) and your opinion to talk about Dr. Stone (probably because you dislike it). Let's wait Dr. Stone sales shall we?

Is that not what you yourself is doing saying that Dr. Stone is better than this or that because you like Dr. Stone and dislike another?

 

[Heiji]

It's no bait. It's getting extra pages for no reason... What else could it be?

Hinomaru Sumo get extra page for : End of current match & thanks for popularity. (火ノ丸　※VS久世クライマックス＆大好評御礼)

 

[Tamil]

Extra pages are a big deal in most cases. Toriko got it before the timeskip and for the wedding chapter. So HZ is ending very soon? Time to start reading.

 

[G_I_A]

Extra pages don't amount to much just means the chapter story couldn't fit within the usual 19/20 page limit so to make a complete chapter a few extra pages was needed.

Is that not what you yourself is doing saying that Dr. Stone is better than this or that because you like Dr. Stone and dislike another?

Not even you believe in that. No series get extra pages for nothing. You do know they are paid for the number of pages drawn right? Zumou is ending. Everybody knows that.

And yes it is. But I also said, let's wait.

 

[razerxs]

What is going on with Zumou anyway? Wasn't it in the tournament to go pro: the cliche grand finale arc?

 

[G_I_A]

What is going on with Zumou anyway? Wasn't it in the tournament to go pro: the cliche grand finale arc?

Sort of. We already know what will/won't happen unless there's like a HUGE timeskip/plot twist. But yeah it should end very soon. This extra pages could be exactly for the announcement or something related.

I hope I'm not spoiling anything. Please let me know If I did.

 

[Heiji]

Sort of. We already know what will/won't happen unless there's like a HUGE timeskip/plot twist. But yeah it should end very soon. This extra pages could be exactly for the announcement or something related.

Hinomaru Sumo get extra page for : End of current match & thanks for popularity. (火ノ丸　※VS久世クライマックス＆大好評御礼)

 

[Tamil]

Saw some random pages of HZ. Really hope it gets an anime adaptation. Has there been instances where series are in a similar position as HZ (low sales but does relatively well in rankings) and still get an anime?

 

[Heiji]

HZ (low sales but does relatively well in rankings)

A french editor said to me, for Japanese editor, if a serie they are not big succes in sales (for volume) but have success in magazine, she can continue. Its same for Riku in Shônen Champion. Low sales but serie is popular in magazine.