Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah, and really he was shady about his role before deciding on doctor (a role that was free until that time).You blocked lambu ?
One of you is surely lying then either you or lambu.
Well... There was no janitor kill..You blocked lambu ?
One of you is surely lying then either you or lambu.
1. Pretty much everyone claimed a role, nobody is lying with a doc. And why do you mention Daws? You only ever investigated Orgz's role. Do you know something about Daws which we don't? Was he the true doc?Hmm...
1. I already offered up a reason as to why a doc might not come out. We're down at least one doc, and we don't know what Daws' role is. Other than 'a card did it' or 'Farf is lying', I don't think that I can come up with something else other than that Daws wanted to protect Gnut and killed him instead. Maybe both card effects activated? It's about as possible as Farf forgetting how to save Kato, though I guess that at least can potentially be confirmed. I honestly don't get how Farf's account makes so much sense compared to how I contributed, but I guess touching on that's no better than beating a dead demon.. This whole thing is so hard to wrap my head around because someone is basically vouching for Farf, and it's either you, Gry, or Erin.
Basically what I've been thinking is, between Farf and me, someone gains an edge by Farf being innocent and whatnot, and it honestly could be you at this point.
2. I don't see why I'd have a problem with Spy duties. I could simply say, 'x targeted y' and talk about a mafia member or so? I could have said, 'Farf targeted X!' and attempted to implicate her. If this is deliberated, why would this be the play? Why didn't I claim det like I previously assumed I was anyway? 'Gry is innocent!' and done, but instead I used my then unknown power on what appeared to be the best target and I'm being punished for it smh
Not to mention, I have participated in the lynching of Demon, Brandish and I would have killed Arjun if not for yesterdays events; why wouldn't I just implicate a new mafia member with my newfound detective powers if I'm killing all of them off anyway? Like, there's a fair bit of randomness in this game, but I'm consistently pro-town at least, no?
3. Why Magi though, when she confirms me? Magi and Lawl have been clowning on the dude since his outburst earlier, and he's been responding madly at them every time. Like you say, she's a convenient target, and the only other viable target would be Lawl, but I'll say this much: on my first mafia game I was mafia with Magi (this is ~2 years ago? I think) and she also bullied me, was sarcastic and mean, both on pad and out. So I have no problems believing him whatsoever. Given the circumstance, it could very well be a play, but I don't see why I have to be the director of the play when Magi is someone known to pull fruity spice.

But that's not possible, the rules say you always get the PM with the tarot effect change once the day ends. Is this something we can ask the hosts about for confirmation?No, I got my role change after I submitted my action for sure. I know because I thought 'omo'
yep i know but no janitor kill doesnt mean necessarly janitor blockedWell... There was no janitor kill..
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Then Monkey would be sacrificing Lambu for nothing though.wouldnt be surprised if lambu and monkey are on the same team faking this no death scenario![]()
If you fullfill the criteria for any card effect, you will be notified at the end of that day phase.But that's not possible, the rules say you always get the PM with the tarot effect change once the day ends. Is this something we can ask the hosts about for confirmation?
I asked him if he's a regular townie and he said yes. I doubt there exist regular townies, so he could be a Sleeper either already recruited or yet to be recruited...I'll just add that I dont recall since when Holt has been saying he's literally nothing (and won't check). If it started ar least on the previous day, leaving it at least replied, he could be a Sleeper that got recruited. It's another possibility for the no kill.

I planned on doing so but thanks for reminding me. Sorry for the inconvenience.hosts-kun pliz could it be possible to link every each end of each day /night on op post it easier to check back, thxs![]()
1. Er, I was saying that we don't know his role. He could have been the remaining doc (because Lambu sure as well isn't), and simply insane doc'd Gnut. I mean, you'll simply find out if you kill Lambu, how hard does it have to be?1. Pretty much everyone claimed a role, nobody is lying with a doc. And why do you mention Daws? You only ever investigated Orgz's role. Do you know something about Daws which we don't? Was he the true doc?
2. Then your target says "I didn't target that person" and gg for you. Not having to bring in other mafias to conspire together with you is better in case you're found out. Sure there's a lot of other things you could've pointed out but this one is honestly safer considering the other claims.
Yes you helping with the lynches confuses me, but I can't explain how greg died otherwise, and I don't think Farf is lying.
3. Exactly, Magi is known to do that and you know it. And I also wouldn't be surprised at all if Magi did that, but so far I will assume she is a legit det.
Also Panda, the inconsistencies about your tarot effects and role powers is too huge.
See? Host says so himself.If you fullfill the criteria for any card effect, you will be notified at the end of that day phase.
Host basically confirms you‘re lying. Can you not see the big problem with your claim? Retell everything you did, you‘ll probably notice it.1. Er, I was saying that we don't know his role. He could have been the remaining doc (because Lambu sure as well isn't), and simply insane doc'd Gnut. I mean, you'll simply find out if you kill Lambu, how hard does it have to be?
2. So I can arrange for Arjun to indicate Magi, but I can't arrange for a mafia member to confirm my Spy claim? And also, what you don't seem to get, I've had plenty of opportunities to claim safer roles, and instead claimed spicy stuff, all while hunting mafia.
3. Yeah sure, but you know, you and Farf know that much as well. With you quite simply saying 'I don't think Farf is lying' all the time, that makes me question just how valid your reasoning can be, if you don't actually have a basis. Like, you simply don't. There's cards, unknown roles and a mafia team of unknown size, and my claims are beaten out by Farf claiming something that can't be verified and her forgetting to be miller??
See? Host says so himself.
Town would believe monkey is a slut tho, I wouldn't call it nothing. But if lambu is mafia isn't panda def not mafia? Wasn't lambu on his ass whole day throughout yesterday?Then Monkey would be sacrificing Lambu for nothing though.