Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[SharkBait]

That Dorksta, so cool.

 

[jagman1x3]

It just occurred to me that Tonari no Young Jump has OPM, which is being published under JC and now Jump+ has Toumei Ningen, which is being published under YJC. Makes you think.

 

[De La Croissant]

Why Boku no Hero and OPM have not yet made a crossover?
DB and OP had one. Ore and Nisekoi had one. NnT and Fairy Tail had one.
It would be cool.

 

[tirakai]

Crossovers aren't exactly the most common thing in the world. Also it wouldn't work anyway, Their settings wouldn't work together at all due to MHA just being in the future/another timeline of our world instead of having it's own fantasy land. Black Clover would fit together with One Piece a lot more.

 

[Ninjaz]

It just occurred to me that Tonari no Young Jump has OPM, which is being published under JC and now Jump+ has Toumei Ningen, which is being published under YJC. Makes you think.

Damn, that's really weird actually.

 

[De La Croissant]

Crossovers aren't exactly the most common thing in the world. Also it wouldn't work anyway, Their settings wouldn't work together at all due to MHA just being in the future/another timeline of our world instead of having it's own fantasy land. Black Clover would fit together with One Piece a lot more.

It doesn't have to be a serious story. More for the sake of fun.

 

[Mammo]

most crossovers are actually fun rather than serious
Heroaca had a crossover with Isobee
Isobee had multiple crossovers with Food Wars
Food Wars had a crossover with Jump heroines
Black Clover had a crossover with Beelzebub and Kagamigami
Kuroko had a crossover with Hinomaru
Nisekoi had a crossover with Haikyuu

 

[De La Croissant]

Kuroko had a crossover with Hinomaru

I know what they tried to do here.

 

[Caiops]

Going by the Shoseki ranking, Neverland #5 is selling as much as Black Clover #1
82 9784088804163 Black Clover 1 Shueisha Yuki Tanaka 2015.6.4
84 9784088812052 Promised Neverland 5 Shueisha Fountain Poisaka 2017.9.4

 

[Leoat12]

most crossovers are actually fun rather than serious
Heroaca had a crossover with Isobee
Isobee had multiple crossovers with Food Wars
Food Wars had a crossover with Jump heroines
Black Clover had a crossover with Beelzebub and Kagamigami
Kuroko had a crossover with Hinomaru
Nisekoi had a crossover with Haikyuu

Glad that those dark times has ended.
I VOTE FOR A "WE NEVER LEARN" CROSSOVER WITH "NISEKOI".
Tsugumi and Chitoge are grade A students and Shu embarrassing the girls would be awesome as well.

 

[Mammo]

Komi did a tribute for WNL the same Monday it started publishing

Can you imagine if Oda or Kishimoto did something like this for Toriko or BnHA first chapters? the internet would never shut up about it, and they will always say stuff like "it's only successful because X pushed it!"

funny how no one says anything about WNL being pushed

 

[Leoat12]

The fact that Tsuitsui Taishi drew Nisekoi spin-off should have helped a little bit people who liked the spin-off and Nisekoi and give the series a chance. I, personally, didn't like the spin-off because it was too ecchi, but I liked the art style, so I went right into it.

Oda and Kishimoto are much more famous, Oda mentioning "Your Lie in April" once gave it a push, so...

 

[De La Croissant]

I remember that. Oda has more power than an anime of 22 episodes.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 2, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 2, 2017 ---

About BnHA, I was reading Blue Flag, from the creator of Cross Manage, and I saw this page:

Very comfy romance. Better than Nisekoi and WNL, btw.

Spoiler

I'm just playing with you guys. But it's really a nice read.

 

[Tamil]

Komi did a tribute for WNL the same Monday it started publishing

Can you imagine if Oda or Kishimoto did something like this for Toriko or BnHA first chapters? the internet would never shut up about it, and they will always say stuff like "it's only successful because X pushed it!"

funny how no one says anything about WNL being pushed

I wouldn't be too surprised if some people think Toriko only got popular because of Oda. I remember people thought Shimabu was pig backing off of Oda and that Toriko only sold well because of it's crossovers.

Luckily MHA never really got that to the extent of Toriko. I don't get how people draw these conclusions sometimes.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 2, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 2, 2017 ---

most crossovers are actually fun rather than serious

Kuroko had a crossover with Hinomaru

When? I think I forgot

 

[Mammo]

When? I think I forgot

http://manga.fascans.com/manga/hinomaru-zumou/72.5/1

When I listed some crossovers that happened in recent years I can't believe I forgot to include the most important crossover ever
PSI x AssClass

 

[shoyoboyo]

Haven't seen that PSI x AssClass one, didn't even know it existed. Gonna have to check that one out.

 

[savethecat]

I would like to see MHA do a crossover comic with Marvel, where the Marvel heroes are the American heroes in MHA's universe, and MHA characters are the Japanese heroes in the Marvel universe.

Obviously would be just for fun, and non canon. but the crazy thing is, this could probably actually make sense in the canon story of both franchises.


Edit: well it wouldn't make sense in Marvel universe because they don't live in a world where everyone has superpowers. So forget that. But it would still be a extremely fun crossover.

Would also be a great idea for a MHA animated film(if BONES ever does one). I know there's a lot of licenses involved, but I feel like Shuiesha and Disney could really make a crossover film happen if someone on either side brought the idea to the table.

 

[Doughboy]

Wonder if MHA will get the Naruto/OP treatment getting a movie announced in 3 years or the Bleach treatment in 5. 2 months left to find out

 

[Tamil]

Studio Bones isn't as big as Toei/Pierrot so its unfair to compare...it could still happen tho

Bones is doing an Eureka 7 film trilogy, releasing a movie each year so you have to consider that too. Bungo Stray Dogs is getting a film in 2018 as well.

 

[iceemperor]

Shudan's chance of survival continues to be dangerously low as Volume 1 was ranked at #46 on honto's daily ranking, it was not in Tsutaya's top 20 for 11/2 and it was in the low 30s on Bunkyodo's real-time ranking in the evening Japan time and ranged from 30 to 40 during the day. Tsutaya, honto, etc are some of the biggest suppliers of Jump comics and their individual daily and weekly rankings have been really close with Shoseki and Oricon rankings. If these are the first day results, there is little chance that it will suddenly shoot up unless there is some sudden TV/radio promotion. The chance that it might show up in the top 50 on the weekly chart is also rather low at this point.