Games Mafia Game 58 - Umineko: How to play 13 - END GAME

[gnut]

No, that leaves 3 people.
Me, Marmalade, and you.

Desin is innocent

 

[Gryffindor]

It means that I would have to reduce the number of players to two instead of four. We are currently 6 players with three of them being confirmed, which you agree too.



Which means that it is basically impossible to bring the number of players down to two people unless we start killing confirmed townies (I don't consider myself confirmed). Since Zasz is not here I'd rate that possibility as very low. Plus @gnut has another result to present which means that we will have 4 confirmed townies or maybe even one confirmed mafia if he targeted the right person. Unless he got blocked of course. Even if you lynch me there is no real chance for the mafia to win IMO.

I was going to reply to this but gnut confirmed you innocent, so.......

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 23, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 23, 2017 ---

And you are right, there is no feasible way for the mafia to win. That much is obvious because at the earliest they will get lynched the next day since the NP is skipped since Arjuna was burden. I wouldn't waste my time just to delay the inevitable.

 

[gnut]

Votekill Gryffindor

 

[Gryffindor]

Because?

 

[gnut]

Because?

Everybody else is confirmed

 

[Gryffindor]

No one confirmed Marmalade. Bel is insane, unless you want me to believe that EVERYONE"S results in this game have been 100% accurate.

 

[gnut]

No one confirmed Marmalade. Bel is insane, unless you want me to believe that EVERYONE"S results in this game have been 100% accurate.

Yes marmalade was confirmed by bel....
Why fight it....you should've killed me long time ago xD

 

[Gryffindor]

Exactly, I could've. You don't think if I was mafia I would've gone after you? That is such an obvious move even for a rookie, and yet two days in a row you survived, good for you, but aren't you even the least bit suspicious on why that happened?

 

[Belserion]

No one confirmed Marmalade. Bel is insane, unless you want me to believe that EVERYONE"S results in this game have been 100% accurate.

So every other result was right except the one that incriminates you?

 

[gnut]

Exactly, I could've. You don't think if I was mafia I would've gone after you? That is such an obvious move even for a rookie, and yet two days in a row you survived, good for you, but aren't you even the least bit suspicious on why that happened?

No....just die so we can end this.

 

[Gryffindor]

So every other result was right except the one that incriminates you?

Didn't say they were. In fact I proposed the opposite, I said its convenient how EVERY result presented by a player is accurate.

No....just die so we can end this.

It's not over though. You want to know something....you guys over the past few day phases have been so fixated on finding mafias you have ignored the chapters and colored truths. There is a 4th DN that I passed to a player last night. Each mafia got a DN and so did a townie to start the game. Do you remember this line from chapter 3.... there's only one truth , do you know what it means? You were close with your assumption of only one DN having a 100% effectiveness rate, a theory that was debunked by desin having a successful kill last night when he himself proposed his note would fail and the names of the note having a 50% success rate, the 4th DN is written completely in purple letters. It's called the Witches DN, fitting for the theme of the game no? You still have one more mafia out there with that note, that note can only be held by a mafia member. That's what they refer to in Chapter 4 where they say they could conduct 4 investigations, the 4 investigations refer to the 4 holders of the DN.

 

[Belserion]

It's not over though. You want to know something....you guys over the past few day phases have been so fixated on finding mafias you have ignored the chapters and colored truths. There is a 4th DN that I passed to a player last night. Each mafia got a DN and so did a townie to start the game. Do you remember this line from chapter 3.... there's only one truth , do you know what it means? You were close with your assumption of only one DN having a 100% effectiveness rate, a theory that was debunked by desin having a successful kill last night when he himself proposed his note would fail and the names of the note having a 50% success rate, the 4th DN is written completely in purple letters. It's called the Witches DN, fitting for the theme of the game no? You still have one more mafia out there with that note, that note can only be held by a mafia member. That's what they refer to in Chapter 4 where they say they could conduct 4 investigations, the 4 investigations refer to the 4 holders of the DN.

So basically you're admitting to being mafia. That's what I was waiting for.

Votekill Gryffindor

 

[Gryffindor]

So basically you're admitting to being mafia. That's what I was waiting for.

Votekill Gryffindor

I didn't. Read the chapters "a cute guest turns into a bad guest", I was mafia because I had the Witches DN, but I don't have it anymore. That person is mafia now.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 23, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 23, 2017 ---

And you still wont' address the convenience of results in this game, not only by you but by every other player.

 

[Belserion]

I didn't. Read the chapters "a cute guest turns into a bad guest", I was mafia because I had the Witches DN, but I don't have it anymore. That person is mafia now.

That sounds interesting. We'll cross that bridge after you get lynched. Thanks for the info.

And you still wont' address the convenience of results in this game, not only by you but by every other player.

What convenient results? Can you list them? We have a few hours until....well..... you know.

 

[Gryffindor]

That sounds interesting. We'll cross that bridge after you get lynched. Thanks for the info.

What convenient results? Can you list them? We have a few hours until....well..... you know.

You having guilty on innocent people and innocent on guilty people. Insane detective with 100% success rate, go figure.
Or how Desin always targeted the right people to spy, ironically enough they were mafia.
100% accuracy from everyone.

So you're ok with lynching someone who isn't mafia then. I guess. Tag everyone to get their vote in, I do wonder if I will get lynched even if I do have the most votes.

 

[Belserion]

You having guilty on innocent people and innocent on guilty people. Insane detective with 100% success rate, go figure.

Well yes that is the definition of insane. But first you have to figure out your sanity which it took me three nights to do. If I had taken Demonspeed's guilty verdict as fact then it would have made me look ridiculous considering he wasn't Mafia. Then once you figure it out it's pretty easy. I guess that's why sprit said I was acting weird all game and it's also why when I was asked about my role I said I said I could be helpful after I solved my crisis. My crisis being my sanity.

So you're ok with lynching someone who isn't mafia then. I guess. Tag everyone to get their vote in, I do wonder if I will get lynched even if I do have the most votes.

I'm not ok with lynching someone who isn't Mafia. That's why I was annoyed at the zasz lynch and why I'm glad Empty turned out to be Jesus since I was suspicious of her at first. I somehow doubt I'll regret lynching you.

I won't tag everyone. It's not that urgent. They can read and see for themselves. And I guess we'll see if you do. Just so you know the more you lash out the more you sound like the Mafia you are. I mean I have no problem with it since I've already votekilled you, but just in case you were looking to convince others, maybe you should pull it back a bit. Don't lose your composure like the others did.

 

[Gryffindor]

Well yes that is the definition of insane. But first you have to figure out your sanity which it took me three nights to do. If I had taken Demonspeed's guilty verdict as fact then it would have made me look ridiculous considering he wasn't Mafia. Then once you figure it out it's pretty easy. I guess that's why sprit said I was acting weird all game and it's also why when I was asked about my role I said I said I could be helpful after I solved my crisis. My crisis being my sanity.

I'm not ok with lynching someone who isn't Mafia. That's why I was annoyed at the zasz lynch and why I'm glad Empty turned out to be Jesus since I was suspicious of her at first. I somehow doubt I'll regret lynching you.

I won't tag everyone. It's not that urgent. They can read and see for themselves. And I guess we'll see if you do. Just so you know the more you lash out the more you sound like the Mafia you are. I mean I have no problem with it since I've already votekilled you, but just in case you were looking to convince others, maybe you should pull it back a bit. Don't lose your composure like the others did.

I'm not lashing out. If my persistence to prove my innocence is annoying (regardless of whether you believe it or not) you can just ignore me since you've made your vote. I haven't attacked anyone personally nor have I made any sarcastic replies belittling someone's opinion.

I have not lost my composure, I've responded to everyone who's quoted me and have tried defending myself. If you think my vague remarks have some different meaning, then I assure you they don't. When I say I doubt I'll get lynched, its because I'll be back the next DP to cast a vote. If you think some of my claims are exaggerated and unbelievable, then that just means I haven't done a good job convincing you or people who have casted their vote. The others quit and let themselves get lynched, so I don't see the comparison.

 

[gnut]

I'm not lashing out. If my persistence to prove my innocence is annoying (regardless of whether you believe it or not) you can just ignore me since you've made your vote. I haven't attacked anyone personally nor have I made any sarcastic replies belittling someone's opinion.

I have not lost my composure, I've responded to everyone who's quoted me and have tried defending myself. If you think my vague remarks have some different meaning, then I assure you they don't. When I say I doubt I'll get lynched, its because I'll be back the next DP to cast a vote. If you think some of my claims are exaggerated and unbelievable, then that just means I haven't done a good job convincing you or people who have casted their vote. The others quit and let themselves get lynched, so I don't see the comparison.

Between me and bel....we confirmed everyone but you.
You are the last mafia.

 

[Gryffindor]

Between me and bel....we confirmed everyone but you.
You are the last mafia.

That's not what I was trying to tell her. She said I was lashing out, when I haven't made a single comment attacking someone else.
There's still one more mafia, and its not me. I'll be back tmrw

 

[EmptySoul]

So Desin is innocent
& Marmaladesky is innocent according to Bel which ill believe since her results are pretty accurate
& Gnut,me & Bel are ady confirmed
That only leaves you gryff

Didn't say they were. In fact I proposed the opposite, I said its convenient how EVERY result presented by a player is accurate.



It's not over though. You want to know something....you guys over the past few day phases have been so fixated on finding mafias you have ignored the chapters and colored truths. There is a 4th DN that I passed to a player last night. Each mafia got a DN and so did a townie to start the game. Do you remember this line from chapter 3.... there's only one truth , do you know what it means? You were close with your assumption of only one DN having a 100% effectiveness rate, a theory that was debunked by desin having a successful kill last night when he himself proposed his note would fail and the names of the note having a 50% success rate, the 4th DN is written completely in purple letters. It's called the Witches DN, fitting for the theme of the game no? You still have one more mafia out there with that note, that note can only be held by a mafia member. That's what they refer to in Chapter 4 where they say they could conduct 4 investigations, the 4 investigations refer to the 4 holders of the DN.

My dude,you're telling us this rn?
Sounds far fetched but ill give you the benefit of doubt
So if only a mafia can hold it how could you hold it if you're townie? Or are you saying the person who holds it becomes mafia?
Clarify pls

For now though VoteKill Gryffindor