Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Nemesis]

Wow, Yuragi and Hinomaru in the bottom.

Pretty happy for WNL position and the Color Page for next week.

 

[XtrnlArdent]

Yuragi has been in the bottom 5 for a lot of weeks, it has an anime inc but that is not an assurance for survival, hoping it climbs back to the middle pack.

Act-age in a decent position, I see it lasting more than Bozebeats, maybe 40-50 chapters if doesn't drops in the next weeks.

 

[ruggia]

Jump giving Robo the infamous color page of death?

 

[puppeto4]

Look like their plan to turn Jump to Weekly Shonen Exorcist failing

 

[MangAniMY]

https://tieba.baidu.com/p/560847910...0&bdid=138136D65451DB9FB87289F8789E0DF4&pn=0&

Act-Age holding on... the dream is still alive...

 

[Nemesis]

Someone needs to translate act-age. Damn, I want to read the rest.

 

[Heiji]

Jump giving Robo the infamous color page of death?

No, its for anniversary.

 

[MangAniMY]

OP 900 cover hype!

SnS will certainly be anime related.

Robo is its anniversary? (Chanting axe quietly)

WnL should be polls results?

 

[TheEnhancedExe]

Jump giving Robo the infamous color page of death?

Isn't Robo selling more than Hinomaru? I remember Robo selling around 60-70k and Hinomaru around 30k. Unless I'm remembering wrong, I don't think Jump will cancel Robo just because of bottom ranks if it sells way better than a series that managed to survive for nearly 200 chapters.

Especially since recently there haven't been any manga that managed to survive and Jump is in dire need of new manga. HxH will probably go on hiatus again, Gintama is close to ending.

Souma might be close to ending unless it becomes a second Bleach and pulls out its own Fullbring Arc after Azami is gone. I seriously doubt that though.

If the situation was different, I wouldn't be surprised if they cancelled Robo. But in the current situation, I honestly can't see that happening. Especially considering that Robo just started a new Arc that's probably gonna take a while. So I think it's safe for now despite its low rankings.

 

[Franz]

Ju Jutsu and Ziga are not yet classified, right?

 

[MangAniMY]

Jujutsu is at Ch.4 and Ziga is Ch.2,

If you are talking about the "8 chapters thing" then yes.

 

[Franz]

Jujutsu is at Ch.4 and Ziga is Ch.2,

If you are talking about the "8 chapters thing" then yes.

Ok

 

[cody]

The sales have some room to grow IMO. It had an incredible growth but getting an anime when you're only doing ~120k a month is early.

If it is an anime announcement then that means me and cody can have wall text posts discussing studios and if we want to be a dick then break it down to staff members.

I like you, that's a great idea! Whether it will be a positive or negative breakdown remains to be seen... xD

https://tieba.baidu.com/p/560847910...0&bdid=138136D65451DB9FB87289F8789E0DF4&pn=0&

Can Act-age please survive? At least it isn't instantly dead like Bozebeats...(I think). Some translations would be nice as well.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Act-tage for the moment continues in the very middle of ToC

If it stays 3 more chapters in that position, it will be time to ask for Edited Mangas.

 

[SharkBait]

Yesterday after of the chapter of Black clover #24

People love their yuno episodes

 

[Leoat12]

I want Act-Age to survive and although it is too early to say "I want them to survive", Noah's Notes and Ziga had very good starts. Some sacrifices will have to be made among older series. Honestly, RxL has been a entertaining reading so I hope Yuragi is in the chop block.
Hunter x Hunter going back to its normal status and Gintama finally ending would be awesome as well. XD

 

[TheEnhancedExe]

I want Act-Age to survive and although it is too early to say "I want them to survive", Noah's Notes and Ziga had very good starts. Some sacrifices will have to be made among older series. Honestly, RxL has been a entertaining reading so I hope Yuragi is in the chop block.
Hunter x Hunter going back to its normal status and Gintama finally ending would be awesome as well. XD

That would already make enough place for three new manga as there's one place open right now. There's usually 20 series running and we only have 19 right now. I don't think Boruto counts as it's monthly. Although I think Boze probably gets cancelled before Gintama ends. I'm not up to date with Gintama, but from what I've heard the end might still be a few months away.

 

[SharkBait]

Bozebeats will rise i feel it and jujutsu will have an awesome debut same for ziga.

BLack Clover fans where you at, why the drop

 

[Leoat12]

Gintama is a few months away from ending like in the last 2-3 years. I am aware of the standard procedure.
If his aim is to finish everything to perfection, he will serialize forever, just move on, man.

 

[TheEnhancedExe]

Bozebeats will rise i feel it and jujutsu will have an awesome debut same for ziga.

BLack Clover fans where you at, why the drop

Tbh, Boze needs a miracle to survive. Although imo it deserves the axe as most people don't seem to like it, neither in Japan nor in the west. I think 6.66 on MAL is a good indicator for that, even if it's just 350 people that rated it. Usually all manga with less than 7 rating apart from Boruto and Spring Weapon got axed really quick.

Btw, I've never been wrong about stuff like that. Every new manga I dropped since I started reading all new WSJ releases last year ended up getting cancelled. Everything I didn't drop ended up surviving.

I didn't drop Act-Age yet, just can't continue reading as noone is Editing it.