Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Scruffy8642]

I see HxH, OP and maybe Boruto remaining from the current line-up. Heroaca and BC might stick around but I don't think Horikoshi and Tabata want, nor need to, needlessly drag out their stories. The same for the rest as they will simply wear out their premises if they run for more than 5 years.

Yeah this. Nothing else in the lineup can realistically be ongoing in five years time just based off story content, let alone avoiding cancellation that long. BC is still relatively young, but the story has progressed quite far, and unless they pull the whole “He’s not the real villan, here’s a new one” thing, I can’t see it doubling it’s current length. MHA and Kimetsu are in similar positions. Can’t really see HQ lasting more than 2-3 years considering how few matches are left in the nationals. Reckon everything else will be cancelled in another 5 years. I mean, we only have 5 series over 5 years old currently anyway.

 

[shoyoboyo]

BC is still relatively young, but the story has progressed quite far, and unless they pull the whole “He’s not the real villan, here’s a new one” thing, I can’t see it doubling it’s current length

Nah, get ready for the Naruto inspired scenario where aliens are the final boss.

 

[Scruffy8642]

Nah, get ready for the Naruto inspired scenario where aliens are the final boss.

True, but I imagine it’ll get cancelled before getting very far into post-Licht plotlines.

 

[shoyoboyo]

I can see it ending about a year after the anime only if 1) a continuation of the anime isn't greenlit, and 2) Jump decides that the boost the anime brought to the manga isn't worthwhile, which is possible given how underwhelming the sales are.

 

[DyanSon]

Dude Digital sale lmoa

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Outta these current series in Jump how many do y'all think will still be serialized 5 years from now?

Haikyuu will still be in the national tournament, that's for sure.
Hero Academia I have my doubts. Can be ending previous year or still lasting.
Same with Black Clover, Dr.Stone and Kimetsu no Yaiba.
Hinomaru I see it still lasting perfectly.
World Trigger will still be in hiatus.
Yuuna-san, RxL and Promised Neverland would have ended. I think BokuBen would have also already ending.

Yep, 5 years would be like beginning of new cycle, with only One Piece and Haikyuu standing, and maybe Hero Academia, Black Clover, Dr.Stone and Kimetsu no Yaiba.

PD: Black Clover still have Diamond Kingdom trolling the main characters, and then Heart and Spades Kingdoms.

 

[Franz]

Nah, get ready for the Naruto inspired scenario where aliens are the final boss.

Please.

Did you read the manga?

--- Double Post Merged, May 20, 2018, Original Post Date: May 20, 2018 ---

I can see it ending about a year after the anime only

Are you serious ?
Toriko is lasted three years after the end of the anime...

--- Double Post Merged, May 20, 2018 ---

Yeah this. Nothing else in the lineup can realistically be ongoing in five years time just based off story content, let alone avoiding cancellation that long. BC is still relatively young, but the story has progressed quite far, and unless they pull the whole “He’s not the real villan, here’s a new one” thing, I can’t see it doubling it’s current length. MHA and Kimetsu are in similar positions. Can’t really see HQ lasting more than 2-3 years considering how few matches are left in the nationals. Reckon everything else will be cancelled in another 5 years. I mean, we only have 5 series over 5 years old currently anyway.

HQ will last until the next Oympiads.

BC and MHA will arrive at 300-400 chapters

 

[susanoo13]

In 5 years the ones that will be remaining is only One piece, BnHA and Black clover and those two will be nearing their end. HQ will finish in 2 years, no need to drag it beyond the finals at nationals. Dr. Stone and Kimetsu though...They could possibly stay for the next 5 years.

 

[James Rye]

I always forget that this is on hiatus and not ended. I never followed it, but what are the odds that it'll come back within the next year?

At this rate I think it would be a miracle if it returns this year. I wanted it to be back last year already.

 

[Franz]

Both Black Clover and My Hero will last another two to three years at a minimum.

The first I think will stop before the 400 chapters, My Hero even at 500 if the success will last, but also 400 would be very probable .....

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Didn't Horikoshi said in one interview last year that the manga was like at 60% of the planned history?

 

[ChocoBar9]

Didn't Horikoshi said in one interview last year that the manga was like at 60% of the planned history?

It was 20% and it was around the time AssClass ended

 

[Heiji]

Didn't Horikoshi said in one interview last year that the manga was like at 60% of the planned history?

http://www.mangamag.fr/actualite/actualite-manga/bataille-finale-my-hero-academia/

 

[Franz]

Percentages leave the time they find.

Having said that according to Horikoshi has already started to plant the seeds for the final ..

 

[Newkerzy]

Regarding the discussion on MHA's longevity, my two cents: I think MHA is going all the way to at least 8-9 years. Ending around 500-510ish is pushing it, but should be doable if done right.

 

[Franz]

Given the success is very likely, but even 8 would be acceptable.

Hokuto no Ken lasted "only" 5 years and Kinnikuman classic 8 precisely.

The "original" story of Jojo (understood as a conflict between the Joestar and DIO) ends with the third series, then 5 years.

 

[SharkBait]

I dont think HQ would end so. It can go to 2nd year and so on. key characters are like first and 2nd years still and he could really build upon the story with new first years and maturing 2nd years. Some powerhouses still havent been shown and we need our rematches.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

I did it, Jump grandpa has now its own thread. Now to wait for Hokuto no Gun to scanlate chapter 4 in any moment of June https://mangahelpers.com/forum/threads/otoko-ippiki-gaki-daisho-by-hiroshi-motomiya.3010711/

 

[Inumaru]

If you guys could choose, do you prefer World Trigger to never come back or for it come back with a different artist? Ashihara's art style is relatively simple, I imagine it isn't so hard to emulate.

 

[Heiji]