Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Franz]

I have read about people complaining about the positions of My Hero and BC in the TOC.

I thought it was well established that if a series is now established the positions are relatively important .......

 

[DoctorNero]

I have read about people complaining about the positions of My Hero and BC in the TOC.

I thought it was well established that if a series is now established the positions are relatively important .......

Yes, but if your series is at the middle, how will you be able to use the TOC as proof that it' the bestest series ever?

 

[Franz]

The position counts only if the series is in its infancy.

Evidently when a series is established the Jump does not feel the need to expose it even more and puts it in the middle.

In a year or two I believe that Stone and Kimetsu will occupy the central band, when with their respective anime will be released.

 

[Xzone]

Probably are mostly BC shitposter crying that they can't laught at other series being in a worst position than them.
I remember them faking a TOC because in one issue MHA was ranked better than BC

 

[Franz]

Probably are mostly BC shitposter crying that they can't laught at other series being in a worst position than them.
I remember them faking a TOC because in one issue MHA was ranked better than BC

Actually this is not the case...

 

[SharkBait]

Believing this week's toc as an accurate assessment of performance is akin to playing the editors mind game. Its doubtful act age would suddenly get more life than BLack Clover though it is certainly possible that Jujutsu has cannabolized the similar academy type school dorm manga that is HeroAca. Horikishi should be worried.

 

[Franz]

And why should he be worried? Before Jujutsu reach the My Hero sales, it will take a few years.

 

[SharkBait]

And why should he be worried? Before Jujutsu reach the My Hero sales, it will take a few years.

Jujutsu's performance is explosive and disruptive. It has the markings and makings of being the next Naruto. People will stop collecting HeroAca once the movies cooled down and the fads over and take note of Jujutsu. It's positions strongly suggest and highly imply its happening. Horikoshi needs to counter this with something game changing like a Kirishima or Ochako death.

 

[DyanSon]

Isn't MHA vol 1 do the number Jujutsu vol 1 do in one month with just 1 week? I think Jujutsu isn't a threat for MHA.

 

[Mammo]

>all of these people being excited about a new serialization round and posting wish list when the hack is still the eic
*sips monster* you prolly gonna get a manga about organizing your socks drawer and you all gonna pretend it's the next big thing

 

[shoyoboyo]

As long as sock puppets are involved and it's a comedy then I'm down.

 

[Caiops]

Jujutsu's performance is explosive and disruptive. It has the markings and makings of being the next Naruto. People will stop collecting HeroAca once the movies cooled down and the fads over and take note of Jujutsu. It's positions strongly suggest and highly imply its happening. Horikoshi needs to counter this with something game changing like a Kirishima or Ochako death.

This is bait in another level.

 

[OtterBrigade]

you prolly gonna get a manga about organizing your socks drawer and you all gonna pretend it's the next big thing

Why are you pretending that wouldn't be the next big thing?

 

[RafaFedKilla]

>all of these people being excited about a new serialization round and posting wish list when the hack is still the eic
*sips monster* you prolly gonna get a manga about organizing your socks drawer and you all gonna pretend it's the next big thing

You are spot on how horrible the EiC has been. Shueisha needs to move his office to the basement he has brought tremendous shame to Jump.

We need sports and we need battle manga. Not castoffs from Giga. We need mangaka that can keep up with the page count.

 

[101nemesis]

Jujutsu's performance is explosive and disruptive. It has the markings and makings of being the next Naruto. People will stop collecting HeroAca once the movies cooled down and the fads over and take note of Jujutsu. It's positions strongly suggest and highly imply its happening. Horikoshi needs to counter this with something game changing like a Kirishima or Ochako death.

Man, if anything, what ticks me off from your bait is your already overly used "strongly suggest and highly imply". Like holy shit, I wanna print out those words and staple it on your head (not literally) but its just how I feel whenever I see you use those 5 words together.

--- Double Post Merged, Aug 31, 2018, Original Post Date: Aug 31, 2018 ---

Yeah there were 2 manga Zombie Powder and Zombie Gun. Zombie Powder was axed in 4 volumes but Zombie Gun was really successful. The main character in Zombie Gun is a zombie.

I dont think Zombie Powder was around zombies tho. It was just the name. I might be wrong, I haven't read much of it.

 

[SharkBait]

Man, if anything, what ticks me off from your bait is your already overly used "strongly suggest and highly imply". Like holy shit, I wanna print out those words and staple it on your head (not literally) but its just how I feel whenever I see you use those 5 words together

I never hardly ever say that phrase. Only whenever there is plenty of evidence to support the conclusion that is being stated is it ever used.

I just wish there were other jujutsu fans here. Its so underrated.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Believing this week's toc as an accurate assessment of performance is akin to playing the editors mind game. Its doubtful act age would suddenly get more life than BLack Clover though it is certainly possible that Jujutsu has cannabolized the similar academy type school dorm manga that is HeroAca. Horikishi should be worried.

Jujutsu's performance is explosive and disruptive. It has the markings and makings of being the next Naruto. People will stop collecting HeroAca once the movies cooled down and the fads over and take note of Jujutsu. It's positions strongly suggest and highly imply its happening. Horikoshi needs to counter this with something game changing like a Kirishima or Ochako death.

I laughed hard.

 

[TyVip]

I dont think Zombie Powder was around zombies tho. It was just the name. I might be wrong, I haven't read much of it.

The powder can raise people from the dead. But yeah the main character is not a zombie like Zombie Gun.

 

[Caiops]

I think what Sharbait is trying to say is that Act-Age needs more cute boys, so then it can become a million seller just like Black Clover

 

[Nemesis]

>all of these people being excited about a new serialization round and posting wish list when the hack is still the eic
*sips monster* you prolly gonna get a manga about organizing your socks drawer and you all gonna pretend it's the next big thing

"hack". Ridiculous. lol