Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Aeneas]

Matsui's author comment:

Spoiler

And in addition to Horikoshi's comment last week, both Gege and Tsutsui gave congrats/farewell to Hinomaru.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Like, I get that arc wasn't for everyone. Hell, Fornever even insulted Toriko fans about it when they dared to suggest that Toriko was better than Fairy Tail.

He should be banned from earth for actually think that Fairy Tail is better than Toriko kkkkk

 

[Halloween]

He should be banned from earth for actually think that Fairy Tail is better than Toriko kkkkk

IIRC, on Twitter he responded to someone who said Toriko is better than FT with "Yeah, well at least people in FT don't drink monkey jizz and turn into trannies."

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

IIRC, on Twitter he responded to someone who said Toriko is better than FT with "Yeah, well at least people in FT don't drink monkey jizz and turn into trannies."

The answer i expect from someone like him, since he would obviously not have an actual argument to defend FT kkkkk i don't even know how this guy has any popularity, i just discovered him because Yonkou and couldn't even watch a entire video.

 

[Halloween]

The answer i expect from someone like him, since he would obviously not have an actual argument to defend FT kkkkk i don't even know how this guy has any popularity, i just discovered him because Yonkou and couldn't even watch a entire video.

Yeah, he's definitely an oddity, for sure. Yonkou has an account here, but I guess he decided to stop posting in this thread?

 

[TJQ15]

The answer i expect from someone like him, since he would obviously not have an actual argument to defend FT kkkkk i don't even know how this guy has any popularity, i just discovered him because Yonkou and couldn't even watch a entire video.

Fornever is such a toxic entity, back in the early YouTube anime/manga community was filled with drama started by him until he declined in popularity. Dude could say so little in a 15 minute chapter review.

--- Double Post Merged, Aug 4, 2019, Original Post Date: Aug 4, 2019 ---

Don't know about D. Gray Man but World Trigger is universe in the near future with twists. You can travel around planets and each one has different climate, architecture, vocation, orbit and proximity to 'earth'. We have even errand planets, which don't follow any orbit.
It's a pity we probably won't see these planets due to publication circumstances and pacing, but the world is there.

D. Gray-man takes place in the 18th Century but they have modern technology so it’s pretty wonky.

 

[tirakai]

I had forgotten D.Gray-man was a twisted historic Earth like Gintama. World Trigger I guess is more of an apocalyptic series too. At any rate that means even less series with their own world. Take away World Trigger and that's just two from this decade, or 3 as long as Samurai 8 doesn't flop (Chainsawman I think is another twisted Earth story?).

regarding Yonkou, he still reads this topic at least, since he sometimes makes a comment when I remind people he just gets scans early and doesn't have an inside source telling anime details (people keep getting surprised when he gets things wrong even though he usually gets anime stuff wrong).

Why are we talking about youtubers though? I thought we got over fornever world's lies.

I guess it's coming up for a break week soon and discussion always gets a bit off track when there's a week without news.

 

[Halloween]

I had forgotten D.Gray-man was a twisted historic Earth like Gintama. World Trigger I guess is more of an apocalyptic series too. At any rate that means even less series with their own world.

regarding Yonkou, he still reads this topic at least, since he sometimes makes a comment when I remind people he just gets scans early and doesn't have an inside source telling anime details (people keep getting surprised when he gets things wrong even though he usually gets anime stuff wrong).

Why are we talking about youtubers though? I thought we got over fornever world's lies.

I guess it's coming up for a break week soon and discussion always gets a bit off track when there's a week without news.

It's a spin-off discussion from Fornever's comments about Toriko in the past. Yonkou kinda just got added to the mix.

Anyway, you're right that we'll have a dead week to deal with. I'll think up some discussion ideas tomorrow.

 

[Jovan]

Shoseki Day 1 sales.
#1 My Hero Academia Vol 24
#2 The Promised Neverland Vol 15
#4 Gintama Vol 77
#7 Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san Vol 17
#9 Chainsaw Man Vol 3
#116 Gokutei Higuma Vol 3

#6 World's End Harem Vol 9
#10 World's End Harem Fantasia Vol 3
#22 My Hero Academia Vigilantes Vol 7
#23 Aharen-san wa Hakarenai Vol 7
#54 Bokuyaku Battery Vol 5
#57 Summer Time Rendering Vol 7
#70 Akuma no Memumemu-chan Vol 8
#107 Gunjou ni Siren Vol 10
#109 Tokedase Mizore-chan Vol 3
#144 TENJIN Vol 12
#156 Kao ga Konoyo ni Muitenai Vol 1
#258 Fuchuu-san Okuenjiken o Keikaku Jikkou Shita no wa Watashidesu Vol 1

Out of Top 500 Moon Land Vol 3
Out of Top 500 Spotless Love Vol 2

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Shoseki Day 1 sales.
#1 My Hero Academia Vol 24
#2 The Promised Neverland Vol 15
#4 Gintama Vol 77
#7 Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san Vol 17
#9 Chainsaw Man Vol 3
#116 Gokutei Higuma Vol 3

#6 World's End Harem Vol 9
#10 World's End Harem Fantasia Vol 3
#22 My Hero Academia Vigilantes Vol 7
#23 Aharen-san wa Hakarenai Vol 7
#54 Bokuyaku Battery Vol 5
#57 Summer Time Rendering Vol 7
#70 Akuma no Memumemu-chan Vol 8
#107 Gunjou ni Siren Vol 10
#109 Tokedase Mizore-chan Vol 3
#144 TENJIN Vol 12
#156 Kao ga Konoyo ni Muitenai Vol 1
#258 Fuchuu-san Okuenjiken o Keikaku Jikkou Shita no wa Watashidesu Vol 1

Out of Top 500 Moon Land Vol 3
Out of Top 500 Spotless Love Vol 2

To complete the top-10:

#3 Kenshin Hokkaido Vol 3
#5 Dragon Ball Super Vol 10
#8 The Gintama character guidebook
#11 New Prince of Tennis Vol 27

 

[Halloween]

#9 Chainsaw Man Vol 3

 

[BaNChiGay]

Shoseki Day 1 sales.
#1 My Hero Academia Vol 24
#2 The Promised Neverland Vol 15
#4 Gintama Vol 77
#7 Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san Vol 17
#9 Chainsaw Man Vol 3
#116 Gokutei Higuma Vol 3

#6 World's End Harem Vol 9
#10 World's End Harem Fantasia Vol 3
#22 My Hero Academia Vigilantes Vol 7
#23 Aharen-san wa Hakarenai Vol 7
#54 Bokuyaku Battery Vol 5
#57 Summer Time Rendering Vol 7
#70 Akuma no Memumemu-chan Vol 8
#107 Gunjou ni Siren Vol 10
#109 Tokedase Mizore-chan Vol 3
#144 TENJIN Vol 12
#156 Kao ga Konoyo ni Muitenai Vol 1
#258 Fuchuu-san Okuenjiken o Keikaku Jikkou Shita no wa Watashidesu Vol 1

Out of Top 500 Moon Land Vol 3
Out of Top 500 Spotless Love Vol 2

Aug 2..... This means only 3 or 2 days. Also though it's 1st day it's pretty surprising that MHA beat TpN.

 

[Aeneas]

Heh.

What do you guys think CSM's ceiling is (4-week sales)?

 

[Tamil]

Go Gintama!

 

[Ctkk]

Aug 2..... This means only 3 or 2 days. Also though it's 1st day it's pretty surprising that MHA beat TpN.

Either TPN is losing steam or people are buying MHA by the dozen so they can spam votes in the popularity poll.

 

[BaNChiGay]

Either TPN is losing steam or people are buying MHA by the dozen so they can spam votes in the popularity poll.

Fujo shit is scary.

 

[LuckyJim]

I thought votes for the popularity poll came from buying copies of the magazine.

 

[Jovan]

Looking at Shoseki, not surprised about Spotless Love crashing and burning. Pulling a seinen with such a concept was always going to be very niche and limited in appeal. Though it recently started being lighter in tone (probably as a way to try and save the manga) .Oh well.

Surprised that Moon Land collapsed from already low rankings (#200ish 1st day for Vol 1) to being completely out. Sad because it covers a topic not often seen in recent shonen manga. Guess the Chainsaw Man and Spy x Family editor can't have it all.

 

[ShenGao]

I thought votes for the popularity poll came from buying copies of the magazine.

There are also voting cards in volume 24. If I remember right people get 1 vote by buying the WSJ copy where it announces the new popularity poll, and 2 votes by buying volume 24.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Ok lads. In 50 years of Shonen Jump animation, which has been your favorite opening and your favorite ending? Try to put videos if you can.

My favorite opening: Fist of North Star opening 1 (the v2 because it has Jagi, Toki, and Raoh).

My favorite ending: City Hunter 1 (GET WILD AND TOUGH!)