Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[pamuchi]

Top franchises
KnY, op, spy x family, tpn, haikyuu bnha, bc are in the list

 

[Halloween]

Everyone, it's okay to post color pages early, however, if the content in them contains spoilers, they absolutely need to be wrapped with spoiler tags.

This includes quoting. If you quote a post that has a non-spoiler tagged color page, I ask that you manually add spoiler tags in yourself.

Furthermore, this rule also applies to not safe for work (NSFW) material. It's okay to post color pages that may be NSFW (like some Yuuna color pages), but you need to spoiler tag it while also indicating that it's NSFW. Thanks.

 

[SharkBait]

Top franchises
KnY and Op are in the list

BLack Clover and HQ too.

 

[Ryuusei]

Top franchises
KnY and Op are in the list

#1 Kimetsu no Yaiba
#3 One Piece
#7 The Promised Neverland
#13 Spy x Family
#17 Haikyuu!!
#18 Boku no Hero Academia
#19 Black Clover

 

[SharkBait]

What happened to HeroAca to be within a margin of error of being under BC.

 

[Ryuusei]

What happened to HeroAca to be within a margin of error of being under BC.

It's only revenue coming from comic sales and during October only, what's being reflected here is MHA's backlog sales.

 

[Ctkk]

It's only revenue coming from comic sales and during October only, what's being reflected here is MHA's backlog sales.

Do they really count only comics for franchise sales? Not Light novles, anime BDs, etc?

 

[Ottes]

Spoiler: Yuuna-san Color Page (NSFW)

 

[Ryuusei]

Do they really count only comics for franchise sales? Not Light novles, anime BDs, etc?

I don't know if they have monthly charts for general franchise sales, but they do have yealy post general franchise sales.

 

[RafGL]

Top franchises
KnY, op, spy x family, tpn, haikyuu bnha, bc are in the list

Oricon Top 20 Franchises - October 2019
1. Kimetsu no Yaiba
2. Love live!
3. One Piece
4. Aladdin (Disney)
5. Juni Kokuki
6. Detective Conan
7. The Promised Neverland
8. Toy Story
9. City Hunter
10. Hypnosis Mic: Division Rap Battle
11. Black School Rules
12. Fate Series
13. SPY x FAMILY
14. Touken Ranbu
15. Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai
16. Listen to the Universe
17. Haikyu!!
18. Boku no Hero Academia
19. Black Clover
20. Kamen Rider Series

 

[ShenGao]

Spoiler: Yuuna-san Color Page (NSFW)

Will this chapter include another "hold this page under the right light to see some nipples" controversy?

 

[RafGL]

Dr. Stone break on Issue #52. Will resume on Issue #1

 

[Ctkk]

They didn't know how to have Boichi take a break so they made him do two series at once. (In be4 this is Inagaki getting sick and there's gonna be a spinoff chapter anyways.)

 

[Jovan]

Dr. Stone break on Issue #52. Will resume on Issue #1

Hence the oneshot appearing. Also it matches now with MangaPlus IDs. The pattern is the same ever since Dr. Stone Reboot debuted

#48 Neverland absent, Tokyo Grind Horror Channel appeared
#49 BHA absent, Shirosugi! Akunososhiki appeared
#50 One Piece absent, Seiyaku no Oga appeared
#51 Nothing is absent, nothing extra appears
#52 Dr. Stone is absent, Seiken no Yuusha no Goei appears

 

[RafGL]

Hence the oneshot appearing. Also it matches now with MangaPlus IDs. The pattern is the same ever since Dr. Stone Reboot debuted

#48 Neverland absent, Tokyo Grind Horror Channel appeared
#49 BHA absent, Shirosugi! Akunososhiki appeared
#50 One Piece absent, Seiyaku no Oga appeared
#51 Nothing is absent, nothing extra appears
#52 Dr. Stone is absent, Seiken no Yuusha no Goei appears

Every spot filled in the magazine, hence serialization round starting whenever something gets axed or after Byakuya ends (they still could fill with One-Shot or extra chapters, but that would be way too much already, wouldn't it?).

 

[Halloween]

New poll is up.

 

[Jovan]

New poll is up.

So to get to the first anniversary, it has to survive until #15? Hmm.

The lack of any Shueisha support for the manga ever since the first two chapters make me think it's not (with Vol 5 as the final one).
Depends on what are their plans among Neverland/Stone Reboot ending and the Beasei Squad mess, but it would be very undeserving to see something like this survive for that long. Never had the good TOC placements after the early start, sucks in the volume sales...

In worst (or best?) case, this should move to Jump+, where it could outperform some of the manga serialized there. It would also give Shiibashi less pressure.

 

[Radagast92]

It seems that with Nak is a problem to have 20 series + oneshots in the magazine like old days.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Hence the oneshot appearing. Also it matches now with MangaPlus IDs. The pattern is the same ever since Dr. Stone Reboot debuted

#48 Neverland absent, Tokyo Grind Horror Channel appeared
#49 BHA absent, Shirosugi! Akunososhiki appeared
#50 One Piece absent, Seiyaku no Oga appeared
#51 Nothing is absent, nothing extra appears
#52 Dr. Stone is absent, Seiken no Yuusha no Goei appears

I wonder if we'll see Black Clover or Kimetsu getting a break soon.

 

[CrimsonEpitaph]

What happened to HeroAca to be within a margin of error of being under BC.

BC had a new volume, MHA had only backlog.