Thank you for the info. That's really good for UU!
Well, this is you making up history, the manga never advocated plagiarism at any time.
The problem is we need to judge it before knowing where it's going.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Even you must have liked some manga that ended up being canceled.
I'm not saying give it 30 chapters or something. I'm saying give it at least 8.
TPGW Vol 1 is out in August.
That's the thing, even waiting 8 chapters can sometimes be too long for WSJ. Here's something a former EiC said a few years ago:
He also that sometimes series start to get more popular by week 7 or 8, but the decision is often made by ch 10, implying that's sometimes too late to start growing (resulting in some possible hits that just had slow build-up being axed).
Friend this material is from 2017, things are not so black and white anymore. If it were that simple, Mitama would have already been canceled.That's the thing, even waiting 8 chapters can sometimes be too long for WSJ. Here's something a former EiC said a few years ago:
Former Shonen Jump Editor-in-Chief: Readers Can Decide Manga's Cancellation in 1st 3 Weeks
Nobuhiko Horie was editor-in-chief of Shueisha's Weekly Shonen Jump magazine during its "golden age." He was the editor in charge of manga such as Buronson...www.animenewsnetwork.com
He also that sometimes series start to get more popular by week 7 or 8, but the decision is often made by ch 10, implying that's sometimes too late to start growing (resulting in some possible hits that just had slow build-up being axed).
Jump's standards for popularity are probably a little different now compared to his era but still, if a manga's not popular by chapter 3 they may already be thinking about cancelling it. It's been a few years since we've had a really early cancellation, but we did get a few series ending at only ch 10-12 in the 2010s, and the U19 club got a new member recently, so they do still judge things very quickly sometimes.
You're using a interview with a editor in chief of the 80's/90's, what he said doesnt really represent Jump today specially when volume sales are slowly being more proeminent in keeping series alive, this volumes that are released when they're over 10 chapters.That's the thing, even waiting 8 chapters can sometimes be too long for WSJ. Here's something a former EiC said a few years ago:
Former Shonen Jump Editor-in-Chief: Readers Can Decide Manga's Cancellation in 1st 3 Weeks
Nobuhiko Horie was editor-in-chief of Shueisha's Weekly Shonen Jump magazine during its "golden age." He was the editor in charge of manga such as Buronson...
He also that sometimes series start to get more popular by week 7 or 8, but the decision is often made by ch 10, implying that's sometimes too late to start growing (resulting in some possible hits that just had slow build-up being axed).
Jump's standards for popular are probably a little different now (it's been a while since we've had a really early cancellation) but still, if a manga's not popular by chapter 3 they may already be thinking about cancelling it.
Jump did not care about Kimetsu and Act Age until volume 4. I still think if the FAT campaign they did for Act Age volume 4 did not work out, it would have go bye byeThat's the thing, even waiting 8 chapters can sometimes be too long for WSJ. Here's something a former EiC said a few years ago:
Former Shonen Jump Editor-in-Chief: Readers Can Decide Manga's Cancellation in 1st 3 Weeks
Nobuhiko Horie was editor-in-chief of Shueisha's Weekly Shonen Jump magazine during its "golden age." He was the editor in charge of manga such as Buronson...
He also that sometimes series start to get more popular by week 7 or 8, but the decision is often made by ch 10, implying that's sometimes too late to start growing (resulting in some possible hits that just had slow build-up being axed).
Jump's standards for popularity are probably a little different now compared to his era but still, if a manga's not popular by chapter 3 they may already be thinking about cancelling it. It's been a few years since we've had a really early cancellation, but we did get a few series ending at only ch 10-12 in the 2010s, and the U19 club got a new member recently, so they do still judge things very quickly sometimes.
I agree, the manga cannot last more than 160 or 200 chapters.
financially, the editors of jump have more reason to cancel Mitama than Agravity boys or any other manga they put in by example.