- Joined
- Aug 2, 2015
- Messages
- 2,335
- Reaction score
- 3,738
- Gender
- Male
- Country
Well yeah, they're different emotions. I'm not trying to say that Gray's darkness is the same thing as Natsu's feelings for his friends. But what I am saying is that, fundamentally, they are both emotions that make them stronger.
Sure, like I said before, I get that everybody experiences emotions in a battle. In fact, anybody who's even reading the manga should obviously be able to tell that Gray was angry when he fought Invel. Even robots in this manga have emotions when they fight.
Now, here's where we might slightly differ. In my opinion, emotions can take two routes:
1) Emotions --> Stronger --> POF
2) Emotions --> More Effort --> Great Fight
One of the greatest flaws of FT is that many battles tend to go through the first route... In my opinion, good writing follows the second route. Whether you think Gray got stronger or put more effort into his fight against Invel is up to you.
Personally, there's a clear distinction between the two. "Stronger" means you get a random power-up. "More Effort" just means you took the fight more seriously, which is essentially equivalent to an adrenaline rush because you are being pushed to your maximum limit that you started the fight with.
Gray was faking it during Avatar. Levy and Briar didn't say that Gray had a lot of darkness because of his devil slaying marks. Briar said Gray's heart was black because of the speech he gave. He had the markings up the entire time during Avatar. He just took off his shirt. Levy just assumed that since he joined Avatar he went off the deep end. Don't think she even saw Gray.
I don't think Gray's darkness is exclusive to his fight with Invel. But it is reliant on him experiencing negative emotions, which isn't happening right now. Though to be fair, I don't think it even matters when evaluating power levels. Like I said, Mashima's whole shtick is that love is the strongest. When Gray starts tapping into regular POF to fight, he'll probably be stronger than when he's tapping into darkness anyways.
I understand that Gray was faking it during Avatar, but clearly the element of "darkness" was an important concept in that arc because Future Rogue foretold Natsu that Gray would be the one to eventually kill Frosch.
Everybody was genuinely worried and concerned that Gray had actually been overtaken by "darkness" after obtaining DeS Magic, and this includes both his own friends in the FT guild and other allied guilds. In other words, there was an actual reason for people to believe that Gray may have lost control over his mind, other than just his attitude seeming off.
That's why Levy sensed it in Avatar, but not before Gray obtained DeS Magic.
If Gray were to simply pretend to be evil and ask to join the Avatar guild, I highly doubt it would fly by the cult members, especially since they were already suspicious of him after he spent a whole year with them.
It was Gray's DeS Magic masking his kind-heartedness that allowed him to fool both his enemies and his allies, which means that it clearly produces dark energy that can lead to side effects on the user's mind.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Like I said, Invel simply said nothing about Devil Slaying Magic being connected to darkness. He said that the price of using Devil Slaying Magic was losing control of your mind. Which isn't the same thing as darkness. And yes, I am absolutely saying insanity isn't darkness. Invel didn't need to fully control Gray. He just needed Gray to be enraged enough to go after END. I suppose making him angry has the added benefit of making him stronger too, so that he would be better suited to face off against END too.
Mashima didn't create darkness for Gray. The term has showed up throughout the series before the Alvarez Arc. Nor was Gray the first character to use it. Invel literally said that it is a source of power that is available to all humans. Hades was talking about darkness before. Then Makarov gave him a lesson, and told him what we already knew....That it all depends on your feelings.
It should be noted that the following pages has a bit of a mistranslation. Ultear doesn't say "I will seal you into eternal darkness" to Deliora. What Ur actually says here is "I will seal away your darkness" to Gray. This line is then what Gray mirrors to Ultear in their encounter. But anyways, I honestly think that Gray's darkness began with his feelings towards Deliora. When he found closure with Lyon, it got better. Then got worse when he met Silver. Devil Slaying Magic may make it worse by eating away at his mind, but the darkness was always there long before.
Natsu's seed was growing because of his doubt for his humanity. That seed happens to be a seed of darkness. That's the explanation we were given. Was that as bad as thinking Lector was dead? Maybe not. But Sting thought Lector was dead for like maybe all of 5 seconds before Minerva told him he wasn't. Natsu was sitting on his doubt since Zeref revealed he was END. And no doubt thinking Lucy was dead is worse, especially since Natsu didn't know better.
Darkness didn't just pop up during the Alvarez Arc with Gray. Throughout the series. it has been an umbrella term used to describe negative emotions in general. For Ultear, it was her resentment over Ur abandoning her. For Natsu, it was his doubt his humanity (and probably Lucy dying too). For Zeref, it was his anger and sorrow over being cursed. For Gray, it began with what happened with Deliora. Probably got worse in Tartaros with what happened with Silver. To chalk it down to Devil Slaying magic is kind of missing the point of his story tbh. In fact, we miss a huge story beat because "Darkness" is supposedly one of the interpretations for the "One Magic". It's the counterpart to love. I mean, Mashima basically laid it out on the table with Natsu and Zeref's final fight. At the most basic level: Natsu drew upon his love for the guild and Zeref drew upon his darkness. It was quite literally a clash of POF.
I think you're missing the context and implications of the word "Darkness" used throughout the series. The word "darkness" alone has many meanings, and it's different depending on which circumstance in the storyline we're talking about.
Ur was specifically referring to Deliora and his role in Gray's traumatic past when she was talking about "sealing his darkness". Not the "negative emotions" that you're talking about.
If Ur meant "darkness = negative emotions" according to what you're saying, then Ur was clearly proven wrong because Gray continued to experience a lot of negative emotions many times throughout the series after Ur supposedly sealed it. And if that's the case, just what did Ur seal exactly?
This was further exacerbated in the Galuna Island Arc and the Sun Village Arc when Gray was still paralyzed with fear while fighting the demon Doriate, even after a substantial number of years have passed since Ur's sacrifice.
Therefore, the word "darkness" can't just be an umbrella term for every single situation and for every single character.
Last edited: