- Joined
- Jul 3, 2016
- Messages
- 2,061
- Reaction score
- 1,112
- Age
- 36
- Country
-
i meant, with such a small response from your side, it kinda shows your lack of interest in this topic. so no motivation for me focus on this compared laxus vs erza. that is allMystogan had so much potential
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
This makes no sense. I gave you my answer to a question you asked.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
yes. laxus > erza@sharkai so ur agree that Laxus>erza so what’s the point of this debate? is cuz ppl beleive that there is a gap?
imo The confirmation is when mystogan floored every1 except makarov and laxus
the point is to find what is going through people mind to make laxus>>erza
using hax as a point is just horrible. laxus might have slept, but as usual was boosting about himself. both marakrov and laxus knew about mystogan, which might have also helped. hell, laxus might have had runes from freed. or even a weak heart.
also mystogan wanted to hide form erza the most.
this is point is just horrible. hax works, when plot demands it. weaker enemies hax will work fine on good guys. but for god sake mira cant macro anyone of worth
--- Double Post Merged, ---
i seeAt the beginning of the Manga, I think Erza was very "weak" because of her trauma. Her mind was far weakened her. This is why she was thinking that Natsu was at her level. He was not. She saw herself far weaker than she was just like Jose told her in Phantom Lord.
She was beginning her resilience during Paradise Tour vs Ikaruga. Before this period, her trauma should put Laxus "far" above her. This is why Laxus was thinking that Erza was too weak to compete with him. At this time, he only knew Erza like that. He wasn't aware about the beginning of her resilience who putted her "far" above a foe too strong for her (Ikaruga) and managed to surprise Jellal who didn't expected that power up.
So, in Fantasia, we don't know who would have won. Erza had hidden power (hakama without armor) and Laxus also had hidden power (Dragon Slayer). For me, they were around the same level.
With time, by analogy, I see them as even as "Natsu vs Gajeel" (don't count post Tartaros for the Dragon's Slayers's rivalry) : barely on the same level, but one can tap into far more power level in PoF (natural Dragon Force and Erza's Heart for example).
For now, in my opinion :
- In a scenario where they are challenging to strength contest, they are even. They will both hold back to not doing fatal blow and their staminas will be higher than their strike. Mismatch...
* Erza was only in that condition in her last fight vs Laxus : Handicap.
- In a scenario where they are both losing there mind, I think Erza can win, even without PoF. Laxus barely collapsed for a second when Erza used a hold back enchanted strike. With full strength, enhance with full anger, I don't know if Laxus can tank this. Erza could also manage to cut him as he couldn't even react in counterstrike. Both full anger, no restriction, I give Erza high to extreme diff.
* Laxus was only in that condition in his last fight vs Erza : Average.
- In a scenario, the same as Fantasia, where people's life are in Balance, Erza might fall before full Laxus's strength and then, will tap into PoF to bypass him the same way she did with Azuma. In PoF mode, Erza for the win, mid-diff, like Azuma.
I know people won't agree. I respect these idea and I will stop to debate. It is only my opinion. If you think Laxus is "far" stronger, I respect your point of view.
well i dont try to extrapolate myself much.
only reason i compare laxus and erza because they werent compared much in the manga, and yet people had a strong opinion about it.
but this might be incorrect
after all jellal didnt know who would win, him or erza
marakrov thought erza or df natsu could take laxus
(there was another theory going around that laxus respected mystogan only because he was taking out trash guild in phantom arc, while fairy guild barely survived phantom main guild)
soo, who knows. i just try to stick with things shown.
for example wahl dying from lightening weakness. wahl weakness is cannon. he not being able to detect red lightening, might have caused his redirecting machine to not work, thus wahl being hit by his weakness at such a level killed him.
even here, i am not hundred percent sure.
laxus fans love to do this (making connection or inferences from literally thin air)
hades example
tempster example
are brought up for this reason
i wanted to ask you, what do you think is stronger
pre ts jellal GC or pre ts laxus Roar
and why


.

