Discussion The Official Lucy Heartfilia Thread

[Reebi]

Yea that was the other thought I had, especially after reading Hataraku Maori Sama light novels and all the stuff about Leyla saving the demon king when he was a child and a special connection with him, that apparently makes him like Emi's smell (I was reminded of this in the last chapter when Natsu said he liked Anna's smell). Then how Leyla's celestial magic was passed down to her daughter Emi and when she fought the demon king Maou their magic mixed to create Alas=Ramus, their daughter. Emi in her warrior requip also looks just like her mother Leyla. Just like Lucy looks just like Anna/Layla. Cuz in the light novels and Emi is like Lucy. The anime made the character more like a tsundere Erza.

I thought to myself if Layla/Anna passed Lucy on some latent heavenly stuff mix in with the star dressses, she would basically be Emi. Then Natsu would be Maou. Star Dresses requiping would be Emi's half angel requip she does. Then you could have a really big awesome Demon vs Lover battle. Happy would be Alas=Ramus to make them stop fighting. Natsu could regain control seeing Happy and Lucy. Anna could be Leyla, who's watching the outcome to see what happens between Natsu and Lucy to step in if Lucy couldn't handle it.

That would be so awesome.

I should check it out. I always wondered if Natsu could reproduce if he was an etherious.

 

[Raven]

Lucy in Alverz arc is more of Natsu concerned more than any arc, Just reread the arc and see how Lucy was worried about him 24/7 during the whole arc, I always thought that something big is coming from her and she will be really important in saving Natsu. Tbh i loved that she was the one who saved Natsu but the problem is the way. Mashima used a cheap way to make her save Natsu. Mavis getting the book from no where and give it to Lucy and told her to use the power of the friend ship. Even when she finished writing the book, The book vanished and she gave Natsu his life force back without any explanation.

Actually if Lucy fought Natsu and brought him back like the way Elie used from Rave master, It would fit the whole situation better in fairy tail, A place involved with Magic and miracles can actually happen. I'm sure if Mashima even tired he would have made something new and better.

 

[MingMing]

Well I just wanted to get people's opinion about Lucy. I mean what does she have to do with the whole dragon's disappearing, is her mom linked to it because she died the same year the dragons disappeared or was it all just a coincidence. How do you guys think her role will change in the future chapters?

i just really like the whole relationship between Natsu and Lucy. Nalu4LIFE

 

[Otaku-thon]

A bit random but (if this has been asked before, forgive me) I always imagined 2 things Lucy would do after the time skip with star dress (other than get/borrow Libra, Pisces, and Ophiucus, or summon CSK which I had hoped she could've also have done)
People were right about her potentially being low-tier spriggan for me (mid-tier if were nitpicking), if only she trained a little bit longer...

First, I REALLY wanted a final/powerful attack for each star dress, or passive abilities. Lucy gaining a powerup was awesome! But because the abilities were too similar with the spirits, it costed (for me) the spirits' appearance on the last arc. Lucy having a final attack is of course a game-changer, and I hope I get to see other people's opinion on what would've been my dream coming true. Everyone, I want each of your own opinions on what could've been the final attack for each spirit.

Aquarius - with the introduction of Aqua Metria, I guess that's it. Either that or a basic ice-related spell on the water magic Passive: already the water barrier, but again this is Lucy's most powerful spirit, I have fewer complaints.
Leo - I always wanted an offensive attack based on a spiritual roar/lion image "Lion's Roar" and a defensive heat field (basically, the size of half the room with Lucy vs. Jacob), it heals minor, very small wounds (but then we have Lion's Brilliance: The field at least) Passive: Minor burns on contact with lucy/regulus abilities and what we already have, Regulus boosted techniques and skills.
Virgo - either a small-area earthquake or a golem summoning Passive: ???
Taurus: Earthquake or body augmentation. While Lucy does gain some of that on Taurus star dress already, I just want a more powerful version of that. Passive: ???
Scopio - Sand Tornado/Sand Hurricane (3 tornadoes?) Passive: Basic Sand Magic/Sand Control. Sand clones too (too much?)
Sagittarius: Something like Atalanta's (Fate series) Phoebus Catastrophe, a circular area of a rain of arrows. Passive: Enhanced sight/field of vision like Archers in fate series
Cancer: Teleport I guess. Passive: speed mirages, just the lucy illusion kind, not the Flash kind

Capricorn, Aries, and Gemini whose full capabilities weren't completely shown are based on my imagination/thoughts alone
Capricorn: Sixth sense, just a 5-second foresight Passive: Debuff immunity. Disregarding the "glasses alone" immune to eye magic, why not make it something like this? A "Warrior's spirit?"
Aries: Wool Illusion. Creates weapons, inanimate objects on a large area of wool Passive: The wool causes minor debuffs, decrease speed and whatnot
Gemini: Forced copy. Remember when the series kept reminding us that Lucy can only copy people that is equal or weaker than her or has equal or weaker mana? The forced copy skill let's her copy opponent's beyond her capabilities but using their spells which are completely more powerful costs more mana. Passive: Quick mana. Because Gemini costs soooo much mana, Lucy is able to regenerate a small amount of mana enough to keep the form but must wait a while to cast more powerful attacks.

The second, as others have also wanted, spirit fusion. Nothing much there for now.

Thanks for reading!!!

 

[yutu]

Lucy has the most interesting magic.
She’s got a bodyguard with Leo.
a maid with virgo so household see food
a hairdresser with cancer
with aries to keep warm.
Majordome with caprico
with gemini she can send him in appointments that she will not want to go or if she two things planned at the same time.
With auquarius of water has will if aquarius can not make warm water she can ask a natsu to come in the bath with her.

 

[Biri Biri]

Virgo the best hands down.

Who wouldn't like a loyal masochist by their side?

 

[mwarren100]

Lucy deserves massive powerups in the future.

 

[kian]

Lucy deserves massive powerups in the future.

as you’ve said, many, many times.

 

[mwarren100]

Lucy still deserves massive powerups over anyone else right now . hiro and ueda said they were her favorites. Now it's time to show it.

 

[kian]

Lucy still deserves massive powerups over anyone else right now . hiro and ueda said they were her favorites. Now it's time to show it.

being favorite doesn’t mean making her suddenly be able to solo dragon gods lol

 

[One4All]

Am I the only one thinking Celestial Spirits should be fully absorbed by Lucy when doing stradress?or become a weapon or something?That way,she would be more powerful. The spirits would be kinda useless at this point if Hiro doesn’t want to upgrade them.

 

[Kiki]

Am I the only one thinking Celestial Spirits should be fully absorbed by Lucy when doing stradress?or become a weapon or something?That way,she would be more powerful. The spirits would be kinda useless at this point if Hiro doesn’t want to upgrade them.

absorbed like Zoldeo and Capricorn?

 

[strikefreedom]

absorbed like Zoldeo and Capricorn?

No, I'm not thinking of some kind of fusion anymore.

Stardress gives only part of the powers of the mind to lucy.

This' '' fusion "" would make that lucy would retain 100% of the powers of the spirit.

 

[One4All]

absorbed like Zoldeo and Capricorn?

Yeah,something like that. It would mean she will get 100% of their powers/abilities. At least Hiro won’t waste his time drawing spirits and just focus on Lucy and other chars in every battle Luc is involved. This is of course if Hiro won’t give them upgrades in the future.

 

[Cosmicstar]

Am I the only one thinking Celestial Spirits should be fully absorbed by Lucy when doing stradress?or become a weapon or something?That way,she would be more powerful. The spirits would be kinda useless at this point if Hiro doesn’t want to upgrade them.

Why? I mean Stardress already incorporates the spirits powers. It would be redundant to have her absorb the spirits.

We have no idea how powerful her spirits are. The only real fight we had post time skip with spirits is Lucy+Leo vs Elfman+Mirajane and that was 99% off paneled with Leo being tied up off panel. We have no idea who tied him up. What spells if any he performed in battle. etc.

It isn't about Upgrading them but rather showing them off in battle more without comedy factor and performing more then one attack before leaving. Hiro tends to go with the most popular spirits in combat rather than the most useful ones. Like during the battle against the Golems Virgo whose magic is perfectly designed for such a situation wasn't summoned. Hell we don't even know what Capricorn Magic is.

Better writing is what needs to be done and not more powerups. I would rather have Hiro put actual thought into the battles rather than give them random powerups. Why didn't Leo+Virgo perform the combo attack or Lucy summon Gemini to do it? Both of these scenarios would have saved Lucy a bunch of magical power. I am not talking about anything out in left field but logical stuff that should be able to be done.

 

[mwarren100]

Lucy deserves better powerups from hiro. Nobody wants Lucy to get stronger it seems

 

[kian]

Lucy deserves better powerups from hiro. Nobody wants Lucy to get stronger it seems

Lucy literally just got a power up few chapters ago...


No one wants to see Lucy magically jump tiers without proper means.

 

[Cosmicstar]

Lucy deserves better powerups from hiro. Nobody wants Lucy to get stronger it seems

I want Lucy to get to get stronger but at the same time it would be nice to actually see how powerful she is before deciding how more powerful she needs to become.

It would be nice to see how powerful Scorpio and Scorpio form are before seeing something new. I mean a regular Sandbuster is just as big as Dragon force Wendy Tornado. So it would be nice to see how powerful Scorpio is in a full fledge combat scenario before making a clear cut judgment on the character. Overall I would just rather see her current power being properly used before any powerups.

 

[One4All]

Why? I mean Stardress already incorporates the spirits powers. It would be redundant to have her absorb the spirits.

We have no idea how powerful her spirits are. The only real fight we had post time skip with spirits is Lucy+Leo vs Elfman+Mirajane and that was 99% off paneled with Leo being tied up off panel. We have no idea who tied him up. What spells if any he performed in battle. etc.

It isn't about Upgrading them but rather showing them off in battle more without comedy factor and performing more then one attack before leaving. Hiro tends to go with the most popular spirits in combat rather than the most useful ones. Like during the battle against the Golems Virgo whose magic is perfectly designed for such a situation wasn't summoned. Hell we don't even know what Capricorn Magic is.

Better writing is what needs to be done and not more powerups. I would rather have Hiro put actual thought into the battles rather than give them random powerups. Why didn't Leo+Virgo perform the combo attack or Lucy summon Gemini to do it? Both of these scenarios would have saved Lucy a bunch of magical power. I am not talking about anything out in left field but logical stuff that should be able to be done.

Lucy absorbing them 100% is still in line with her principle of “battling alonside the spirits”. It’s just that instead of quantity, her focus would be the quality. I’m losing hope with the spirits at this point. Ever since Lucy got the stardress, her spirits just kinda pushed into the background. Personally,I was looking forward of her stardresses than her spirits in battle. I agree with the bad writing though,we still don’t know the spirits and stardresses full abilities after how many arcs. Even Taurus,Cancer and Aquarius who were present since day 1 were still underutilized.

 

[Cosmicstar]

Lucy absorbing them 100% is still in line with her principle of “battling alonside the spirits”. It’s just that instead of quantity, her focus would be the quality. I’m losing hope with the spirits at this point. Ever since Lucy got the stardress, her spirits just kinda pushed into the background. Personally,I was looking forward of her stardresses than her spirits in battle. I agree with the bad writing though,we still don’t know the spirits and stardresses full abilities after how many arcs. Even Taurus,Cancer and Aquarius who were present since day 1 were still underutilized.

My point is that it is pointless to absorb the spirits when you would get the exact same powers. She would still use Regulas in her Leo stardress, Water in her Aquarius stardress, Diver in her Virgo stardress. You would barely see a difference in the quality of magic because she pretty much uses the exact same power as the spirit in her stardress so you wouldn't really get anything new.