Games Mafia Game 87 - Baccano! - END GAME

[Farfalla]

I don't know... Maybe Mafia wants a Town lynch for today and they poisoned someone before?

Still, how's that tradeoff worth it? We'd lynch Greg, he'd die as BG, we'd lynch Van next. What's to gain here?

 

[Baka Taichou]

I don't know... Maybe Mafia wants a Town lynch for today and they poisoned someone before?

what?

well I think the possibility of a mafia member straight out claiming a townie is lying so early in the game when they have no need to put themselves in the spotlight is farfetched. It's not like there's few of them left and they're desperate to cause chaos just yet.

my two cents.

 

[Hardy]

I don't know... Maybe Mafia wants a Town lynch for today and they poisoned someone before?

...and then what happens with the poison? What does that change?

It's fine just lynch xnut, you think about that tomorrow '-'/

 

[Shad]

I'm just gonna say it

The doctor and hoe claim sound very fishy, what if mafia talked at night and agreed that both roles won't be in the game because of the RT mechanic.

So claimed it today, van claim could have been made without reading the gnut claim, so it backfired.
Demonspeed claim is going unchallenged.

Just a theory a MG theory!

Sorry guys I'm actually slightly sick, I will rest for a while and lurk, may sleep and wake up later to vote still 16h in the day.

 

[Lambu]

Guys we need to chill a bit, just a tiny little bit with the arguments please

 

[Baka Taichou]

I'm just gonna say it

The doctor and hoe claim sound very fishy, what if mafia talked at night and agreed that both roles won't be in the game because of the RT mechanic.

So claimed it today, van claim could have been made without reading the gnut claim, so it backfired.
Demonspeed claim is going unchallenged.

Just a theory a MG theory!

Sorry guys I'm actually slightly sick, I will rest for a while and lurk, may sleep and wake up later to vote still 16h in the day.

what? how could van not read gnut when he actually quoted gnut when gnut claimed he learned bodyguard, that doesn't make sense Shad.
Rest well shad! hope the sickness goes away

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 19, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 19, 2020 ---

Guys we need to chill a bit, just a tiny little bit with the arguments please

we're chill lambu, nice of you to join us XD

 

[Shad]

what? how could van not read gnut when he actually quoted gnut when gnut claimed he learned bodyguard, that doesn't make sense Shad.
Rest well shad! hope the sickness goes away

That how I remember it, the quoting happened after people pointed that raven claim is exposing gnut.
Sorry I can't look it up, please you or someone look at van posts and check.

I may look it up myself later as well.

thanks you @sakura-aneki

 

[Lambu]

Managed to read a bit in my break time without login in so Im not that behind, but I need to read more carefully now either way, waste of time.

From what I got at first glance tho: DD is pretty much scum and he needs to die.

Also to all the people vouching for the Greg vs Van, I find it amusing that not a single person pointed out at the possibility of both being legit towns for a possible RT protection on G.

 

[digitaldude]

Managed to read a bit in my break time without login in so Im not that behind, but I need to read more carefully now either way, waste of time.

From what I got at first glance tho: DD is pretty much scum and he needs to die.

Also to all the people vouching for the Greg vs Van, I find it amusing that not a single person pointed out at the possibility of both being legit towns for a possible RT protection on G.

Sakura is the mafia!! I blocked the rail tracer kill.

 

[Lambu]

Holt flipping as Santa pretty much brings the one big mafia set up, which makes Hardy way less believable. Shad rubs me the wrong way with his responses to him tho and that post about Orgz should have shot a lot more alarms than it did, expected a greater reaction from the likes of Gry. Basically if Gry didn't vouch for that G protection on N1 I would be convinced he's scum this game.

Hll is quite scum too, safest lynch among all the inactives.

 

[Farfalla]

Also to all the people vouching for the Greg vs Van, I find it amusing that not a single person pointed out at the possibility of both being legit towns for a possible RT protection on G.

How would that work?
Greg claimed he targeted Orgz and learned his role for sure.
Van says he used prostitute to block him, so that couldn't have happened.
I don't see what role a RT protection could have had in here.

 

[Gajeel]

Also, @Gajeel @desin24 and @Belserion have been so barely active the whole game :/

A lack of time completely made my morale go down this game. Two for one

Also to all the people vouching for the Greg vs Van, I find it amusing that not a single person pointed out at the possibility of both being legit towns for a possible RT protection on G.

But, how did gnut successfully learn Bodyguard if Vandred blocked him last night? Maybe I'm not grasping things correctly.

 

[Hardy]

Also to all the people vouching for the Greg vs Van, I find it amusing that not a single person pointed out at the possibility of both being legit towns for a possible RT protection on G.

What does that change though? Van blocked greg, so greg cannot be a successful apprentice. Only scenario is Vandred being blocked himself but no one came out to say they used the block rt on him.

 

[Lambu]

Sakura is the mafia!! I blocked the rail tracer kill.

Only thing that doesn't make me lock you tbh

How would that work?
Greg claimed he targeted Orgz and learned his role for sure.
Van says he used prostitute to block him, so that couldn't have happened.
I don't see what role a RT protection could have had in here.

Cause RT protection is P0 and nullifies prostitute action.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 19, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 19, 2020 ---

What does that change though? Van blocked greg, so greg cannot be a successful apprentice. Only scenario is Vandred being blocked himself but no one came out to say they used the block rt on him.

^^^

 

[Baka Taichou]

agree with farf, unless rt was used to block, but that's priority 4 right?

 

[Demonspeed]

Yeah, I do think that HII is Mafia.

 

[Hardy]

Only thing that doesn't make me lock you tbh



Cause RT protection is P0 and nullifies prostitute action.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 19, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 19, 2020 ---

^^^

Then why didn't greg say he got protected?

 

[Farfalla]

Basically if Gry didn't vouch for that G protection on N1 I would be convinced he's scum this game.

Spoiler

I really wanna leave this here... it's food for thought, but still... Been thinking of it since yday, so in case later in the game this could be relevant.
What if mafia got both the RT kill and protection on N1. They wanted the RT kill on a target they protected as well to make a big balls move and exchange a kill for the credibility of possibily two members (as in they intentionally failed the kill to look good, since they generate evidences for those). And even if Greg would eventually go down with his claim later on, their interaction wouldn't incriminate Gry per se, so their integrity could be managed.
I also think Misho's death was extremely convenient. Why they picked him over many others - like Van claiming active - is just too odd. My guess would be they have a detective and checked on him on N1. That also incriminates Hardy, of course, since the main plan people were saying dets should follow was to cross check him with Raven. And with that, maybe even the Hardy vs Gry antics is a part of their strategy as a single group. Woof. Here, for posterity.

 

[digitaldude]

Can you guys claim some more roles? we have doctor and bodyguard.

 

[Farfalla]

Cause RT protection is P0 and nullifies prostitute action.

Ohhh... Ok, had it as a doc only in my head. Very good point.

So far, we had 2 people claiming to try to snatch that one: Hardy to use it on Gry, and Shad to use it on Greg (correct me if I'm mistaken tho), so it would make perfect sense indeed.