You are remembering right. Just that it would defeat the purpose to list Sleeper, DM or Unskilled mafia in the rolelist no? Just like how there exists no "Doctor" role, but there is a "Sane Doctor", Insane and Naive. Sanity of the Doc wasn't specified so I doubt they'd specify any hidden intricacies either.
Same, was about to say that I liked Tatsu's overall thoughts, just wish she wrote them more often or without being asked.
Sort of, but not completly. Even if we new there is a sleeper, the sleeper wouldn't know he is one. It doesn't completele defeat the purpose, but sort of affects it. Same goes for sane/insane/unskilled status.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
There is lots of benefit in not claiming Pirate under these circumstances, but I am afraid that mafia may claim it to avoid being lynched near the end of the phase and hope the Pirate is afk, like Sam for example if he's the Pirate but isn't coming back anymore.
No sure about that. Since it's the only active role yet because DD is practically dead tomorrow, I'm not sue why not to claim. The suicide-detective route might be the only way the role is useful now. Though we are right at the brink when losing the pirate would mean town win.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Just for curiosity: what about my playstyle is so much different from Sam and Riku? I missed a lot of the dayphase til now, but otherwise?
Saving the Doc role only matters if the Pirate is unknown, else they just kill him right after. The 50% chance does suck and I think Pirates need a buff to be priority 2.5 to better fulfill that niche, but still a valid attempt if the Pirate stays anonymous.
Yeah, I hear you. I'm looking through a different window so it's easy for me to say "why didn't you see it this way?! You're Gry-tan after all
" but you've experienced different things to make you react and think different ways.
Window comment applies here too I guess, but I do know you're able to cut through most things so you can forgive me for having doubts that the mystical reinhardt-simping pigeon could cut through to the truth at the core
Considering all the facts, it was very clearly desperation based on a conclusion created out of nothing. He went out of his way to make a program to track vote changes as things progress which in itself seems like something mafia wouldn't waste their time on, at least publicly, if at all. That's the first point to consider. The second point to consider is that as town I tried to keep a clear head through it all and actually consider other options simply than letting my thinking revolve around the issue, so it was easier for me to put it into perspective of being overblown drama and thus more likely than not harmless. Simple deduction, this game has been a wonder for my MG analysis and thought process, I'll teach you my way next duo-game.
Pirate absolutely should NOT claim, especially if DD's doc claim is legit and not just him baiting mafia as a townie. Showing all our cards is literally a game-over scenario with no coming back unless mafia get decimated today via lynch and lambu bomb.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Likely is an understatement. There is at least one for sure. I told the same thing to DD but the difference between Lala and these two is that Lala is now dead. Besides you she was trusted the most.
Between the Shad and Demon voters (7 votes), is where we will find the mafia imo. Erin who I think is scum voted the Hot Potato hoping it stays on a townie and goes with him if Demon gets lynched; the other two scum can be found amongst the Shad voters. Excluding Farf RIP, that's 2 of Tatsu, James, Gry, Lambu and you.
I will acknowledge when you speak truth, just like I will say your reason to choose me over Tatsu or people with similar profile is extremely weak to say the least.