I was rereading some old chapters and noticed an interesting thing.
Nakaba has a certain way of drawing how teleportation spell works. And he didn’t use that when he drew how Talsker (the chaos knight we saw in the last chapter beside Arthur) evacuated Ironside from Sistana. They kind of just disappeared in the shadows that pulled to them.
Maybe he has magic like that one guy from MHA, or maybe that’s some Chaos powers.
Don’t know what to do with that information, but it may be helpful later on.
I was rereading some old chapters and noticed an interesting thing.
Nakaba has a certain way of drawing how teleportation spell works. And he didn’t use that when he drew how Talsker (the chaos knight we saw in the last chapter beside Arthur) evacuated Ironside from Sistana. They kind of just disappeared in the shadows that pulled to them.
Maybe he has magic like that one guy from MHA, or maybe that’s some Chaos powers.
Don’t know what to do with that information, but it may be helpful later on.
Haven't checked this forum in a long time. I did leave this series at chapter 23 or so, but I recall finding it pretty good (early NNT vibes IMO). Does it still maintain its quality? I'm asking to see if it's worth getting up to date or not.
Haven't checked this forum in a long time. I did leave this series at chapter 23 or so, but I recall finding it pretty good (early NNT vibes IMO). Does it still maintain its quality? I'm asking to see if it's worth getting up to date or not.
I think it's pretty good overall but the arc you completed hasn't been topped yet IMO. Still, depending on what happens the current arc could surpass it.
From my own observations on this forum, the overall reception is better as well. Plenty of things to get excited about.
In the discussion thread for chapter 67 I mentioned that I believe Gawain as well as the other members of the main squad will eventually get new weapons, and I figured I'd elaborate on that a little. Here are some reasons why I think that's the case, primarily focusing on Gawain:
1. Nakaba's usual treatment of special weapons
This is something that applies to more than just Gawain, but in NnT, a lot of importance was placed on the Sacred Treasures of the Sins and how they could amplify the existing powers of each member. This is why the reveal of one of the STs was almost always such a big moment, think Mel destroying the Albion or Ban wiping out all the mini-Indura. The way we've been introduced to the weapons of the new main characters has been a lot less impactful, which is why I'm skeptical that the ones they're currently using are supposed to be their main weapons. It is possible that the actual reveals of what they can do will happen later like how Escanor and Diane first used their weapons' abilities long after first wielding them, but even in those cases the weapons stood out in the first fights they were used in. Diane used Gideon to launch a Mother Catasrophe which almost killed everyone present and Rhitta was shown to be so heavy that not even Galand could lift it. Gawain summoning her Rhitta to her wasn't particularly memorable, especially considering we've already seen Escanor do that before, which leads me to my next point.
2. Gawain's Rhitta seems to just be a piece of Escanor's Rhitta.
Maybe I'm alone in thinking this, but the fact that Gawain appears to be using a weapon made from the broken remains of another weapon is just kind of underwhelming. Gawain might have the same magic as Escanor, but that doesn't mean that even her weapon has to be a hand-me-down from her predecessor. She deserves to have a weapon made specifically for her, preferably one with a different ability from that of Rhitta that makes her stand out more as a unique character. It's been said many times on this forum, but Gawain shouldn't just be an Escanor 2.0.
3. It's a notable powerup
This is another point that is not unique to Gawain, but it's probably the most relevant in her case given the nature of her abilities. Nakaba likes to give his characters these big powerups that suddenly allow them to match or defeat enemies that were previously way out of their reach, think Mel humiliating Galand after regaining his powers or King briefly awakening Chastiefol against an Albion. Gawain is in a bit of a difficult situation in this regard because both Sunshine and magic spells are somewhat static. You can become better at utilizing Sunshine on a technical level and maybe also learn to cast spells faster, but those improvements aren't going to suddenly give her a massive boost in power, let alone significantly alter her fighting style. Unless Gawain is hiding her own individual magic ability that she could learn to better utilize later down the line, the only way I can think of for her to get a noticeable powerup is through a special weapon gimmick.
4. Gawain is known for wielding the sword Galatine in the legends
This is a minor point but I think it's worth mentioning given Nakaba's track record of including all kinds of elements from the legends.
5. Weapon variety
I saved this point for last but it's probably the most important one. Demonspeed brought up the issue of how so many characters in the main group use swords, which I agree with, but I think a bigger problem has to do with the general types of weapons. When it came to the Sins, Mel and Ban had relatively small and agile weapons designed for speed based fighting styles, while Escanor and Diane had these massive hunks of iron that were slower but also packed a heavy punch. King was somewhere in the middle since Chastiefol could transform into different forms, Gowther was the only one with a proper ranged weapon and Merlin had a spellcasting tool. In contrast, the main group in the sequel has Lancelot with a ranged weapon, and then everyone else wields small agile weapons designed for quick hits. No heavy weapons or anything clearly magical like a shapeshifting spear, a bow made of energy or a floating crystal ball in sight. Pretty much anyone could receive some kind of a special magic weapon, but I think Gawain is the only one whose fighting style could incorporate a heavy weapon. The tiny Percival isn't going to be swinging around a massive axe and Tristan isn't going to be flying around with 2 giant hammers. In fact, Gawain's tendency to just tank hits is something you usually see with slower fighters wielding heavy weapons, and her ability to teleport both herself and her weapon allow her to bypass some of the downsides of a slower weapon. Ideally I would like to see Nakaba bring back the sword that he initially planned to have Meliodas use, based on the one-shot that eventually became NnT. That's a holy sword fit for Gawain right there.
That's all I have for Gawain, but I think there's room for upgrades for the other characters as well. Lancelot getting a spear seems fairly obvious given that Nakaba portrayed him with a spear in the one-shot, in his silhouetted form and even in Rising Impact. He doesn't even seem to be able to use his Shining Road with his bow, since he had to borrow Donny's dagger to launch the attack. He could also keep the bow, which would fit the idea of Lancelot being able to master pretty much any weapon, but I think his main weapon is almost certainly going to be a spear. If we need a replacement bow user, then Donny would probably be a good candidate since he should be able to control the arrows with his mind. Maybe Donny could even inherit Lancelot's bow eventually since it looks quite nice. As a third option for a ranged fighter, the Tristan of legend is also known for wielding a bow.
Another detail that sticks out to me is that both Tristan and Nasiens are dual-wielders, which is a bit redundant. I expect one of them to switch to something else, most likely Tristan since he's supposed to be a fusion of light and darkness, which would come across much better if he didn't have to channel those powers through two separate weapons. One singular weapon that combines both elements would really highlight his mastery over his two sides. I know that people don't put a lot of stock in the silhouettes of the FKOTA, but I think they're an indicator of what kind of things Nakaba has considered for these characters. People probably remember the energy sword that Tristan was shown carrying, but what's interesting about that sword is that only the blade is made of energy while the handle is a physical object. It could be that Nakaba was planning to give him a kind of lightsaber type weapon that could manifest either a blade or light or a blade of darkness, or possibly one from each side of the handle to form a twinblade. That idea could be taken even further if we assume that the energy doesn't have to be in the shape of a sword. Maces, axes, whips, bows and even shields all have a short handle, making the weapon into a kind of Swiss army knife similar to the shape-changing Chastiefol.
As a final note, I will say that I would really like to see someone in the main squad use a shield. Shields were very useful in medieval melee combat and fantasy knights in particular are often portrayed with shields that denote their allegiance or beliefs, like a cross for paladins for example. It's outright weird how few characters in the series have used shields. I think Zaratras, the Original Demon and Pellegarde are the only notable examples. The fact that they were smart enough to bring a shield to a sword fight might explain why they were some of the best their respective factions have/had to offer. As for who in the main squad should be the one with a shield, I think Percival in particular would look cute with one.
Haven't checked this forum in a long time. I did leave this series at chapter 23 or so, but I recall finding it pretty good (early NNT vibes IMO). Does it still maintain its quality? I'm asking to see if it's worth getting up to date or not.
Thanks for the inputs guys, I think I'm gonna start everything again from 0 up to the current point. Might pop out in the chapter discussion threads one of these days.
In the discussion thread for chapter 67 I mentioned that I believe Gawain as well as the other members of the main squad will eventually get new weapons, and I figured I'd elaborate on that a little. Here are some reasons why I think that's the case, primarily focusing on Gawain:
1. Nakaba's usual treatment of special weapons
This is something that applies to more than just Gawain, but in NnT, a lot of importance was placed on the Sacred Treasures of the Sins and how they could amplify the existing powers of each member. This is why the reveal of one of the STs was almost always such a big moment, think Mel destroying the Albion or Ban wiping out all the mini-Indura. The way we've been introduced to the weapons of the new main characters has been a lot less impactful, which is why I'm skeptical that the ones they're currently using are supposed to be their main weapons. It is possible that the actual reveals of what they can do will happen later like how Escanor and Diane first used their weapons' abilities long after first wielding them, but even in those cases the weapons stood out in the first fights they were used in. Diane used Gideon to launch a Mother Catasrophe which almost killed everyone present and Rhitta was shown to be so heavy that not even Galand could lift it. Gawain summoning her Rhitta to her wasn't particularly memorable, especially considering we've already seen Escanor do that before, which leads me to my next point.
2. Gawain's Rhitta seems to just be a piece of Escanor's Rhitta.
Maybe I'm alone in thinking this, but the fact that Gawain appears to be using a weapon made from the broken remains of another weapon is just kind of underwhelming. Gawain might have the same magic as Escanor, but that doesn't mean that even her weapon has to be a hand-me-down from her predecessor. She deserves to have a weapon made specifically for her, preferably one with a different ability from that of Rhitta that makes her stand out more as a unique character. It's been said many times on this forum, but Gawain shouldn't just be an Escanor 2.0.
3. It's a notable powerup
This is another point that is not unique to Gawain, but it's probably the most relevant in her case given the nature of her abilities. Nakaba likes to give his characters these big powerups that suddenly allow them to match or defeat enemies that were previously way out of their reach, think Mel humiliating Galand after regaining his powers or King briefly awakening Chastiefol against an Albion. Gawain is in a bit of a difficult situation in this regard because both Sunshine and magic spells are somewhat static. You can become better at utilizing Sunshine on a technical level and maybe also learn to cast spells faster, but those improvements aren't going to suddenly give her a massive boost in power, let alone significantly alter her fighting style. Unless Gawain is hiding her own individual magic ability that she could learn to better utilize later down the line, the only way I can think of for her to get a noticeable powerup is through a special weapon gimmick.
4. Gawain is known for wielding the sword Galatine in the legends
This is a minor point but I think it's worth mentioning given Nakaba's track record of including all kinds of elements from the legends.
5. Weapon variety
I saved this point for last but it's probably the most important one. Demonspeed brought up the issue of how so many characters in the main group use swords, which I agree with, but I think a bigger problem has to do with the general types of weapons. When it came to the Sins, Mel and Ban had relatively small and agile weapons designed for speed based fighting styles, while Escanor and Diane had these massive hunks of iron that were slower but also packed a heavy punch. King was somewhere in the middle since Chastiefol could transform into different forms, Gowther was the only one with a proper ranged weapon and Merlin had a spellcasting tool. In contrast, the main group in the sequel has Lancelot with a ranged weapon, and then everyone else wields small agile weapons designed for quick hits. No heavy weapons or anything clearly magical like a shapeshifting spear, a bow made of energy or a floating crystal ball in sight. Pretty much anyone could receive some kind of a special magic weapon, but I think Gawain is the only one whose fighting style could incorporate a heavy weapon. The tiny Percival isn't going to be swinging around a massive axe and Tristan isn't going to be flying around with 2 giant hammers. In fact, Gawain's tendency to just tank hits is something you usually see with slower fighters wielding heavy weapons, and her ability to teleport both herself and her weapon allow her to bypass some of the downsides of a slower weapon. Ideally I would like to see Nakaba bring back the sword that he initially planned to have Meliodas use, based on the one-shot that eventually became NnT. That's a holy sword fit for Gawain right there.
That's all I have for Gawain, but I think there's room for upgrades for the other characters as well. Lancelot getting a spear seems fairly obvious given that Nakaba portrayed him with a spear in the one-shot, in his silhouetted form and even in Rising Impact. He doesn't even seem to be able to use his Shining Road with his bow, since he had to borrow Donny's dagger to launch the attack. He could also keep the bow, which would fit the idea of Lancelot being able to master pretty much any weapon, but I think his main weapon is almost certainly going to be a spear. If we need a replacement bow user, then Donny would probably be a good candidate since he should be able to control the arrows with his mind. Maybe Donny could even inherit Lancelot's bow eventually since it looks quite nice. As a third option for a ranged fighter, the Tristan of legend is also known for wielding a bow.
Another detail that sticks out to me is that both Tristan and Nasiens are dual-wielders, which is a bit redundant. I expect one of them to switch to something else, most likely Tristan since he's supposed to be a fusion of light and darkness, which would come across much better if he didn't have to channel those powers through two separate weapons. One singular weapon that combines both elements would really highlight his mastery over his two sides. I know that people don't put a lot of stock in the silhouettes of the FKOTA, but I think they're an indicator of what kind of things Nakaba has considered for these characters. People probably remember the energy sword that Tristan was shown carrying, but what's interesting about that sword is that only the blade is made of energy while the handle is a physical object. It could be that Nakaba was planning to give him a kind of lightsaber type weapon that could manifest either a blade or light or a blade of darkness, or possibly one from each side of the handle to form a twinblade. That idea could be taken even further if we assume that the energy doesn't have to be in the shape of a sword. Maces, axes, whips, bows and even shields all have a short handle, making the weapon into a kind of Swiss army knife similar to the shape-changing Chastiefol.
As a final note, I will say that I would really like to see someone in the main squad use a shield. Shields were very useful in medieval melee combat and fantasy knights in particular are often portrayed with shields that denote their allegiance or beliefs, like a cross for paladins for example. It's outright weird how few characters in the series have used shields. I think Zaratras, the Original Demon and Pellegarde are the only notable examples. The fact that they were smart enough to bring a shield to a sword fight might explain why they were some of the best their respective factions have/had to offer. As for who in the main squad should be the one with a shield, I think Percival in particular would look cute with one.
There is always some hype when someone gets a new weapon. Even Percival receiving a normal sword was considered big, but in NNT there was nothing of the sort for the Sins who hadn't lost their STs (Gowther, Merlin, Escanor).
Personally I wouldn't have been bothered if Gawain had Rhitta as an ax because her Magic is supposedly the same. While she currently has it as a sword, it is still a proper weapon to channel her power. Would she really get a significant boost with a new weapon? I am not sure.
Nakaba uses names from the Arthurian Legends but I doubt they will get all the weapons they have in these stories. I can see techniques named after them though or maybe he'll change the type of weapon. For example we have Tristan who is an archer and has Failnaught in the AL but it is pretty obvious that this one is going to stay a dual wielder. Lancelot is an archer here, it is hinted that he wants a new weapon because of his Magic but I don't see him getting something like Arondight as a sword.
For weapon variety I didn't really consider the people from Team Percival because they are not the main group and I doubt we'll see them fight often as equals in a team since Percival outclasses them and is going widen the gap even more as time goes on. If Nakaba is bothered by weapon variety he'll change Gawain's weapon somehow because Percival and Tristan will stay swordsmen for sure. I can see it turned into a new ax or Gawain putting it on Escanor's grave because it is already a great weapon. It's not something which can be thrown away like Percival's sword quickly made by Howzer.
There is always some hype when someone gets a new weapon. Even Percival receiving a normal sword was considered big, but in NNT there was nothing of the sort for the Sins who hadn't lost their STs (Gowther, Merlin, Escanor).
Personally I wouldn't have been bothered if Gawain had Rhitta as an ax because her Magic is supposedly the same. While she currently has it as a sword, it is still a proper weapon to channel her power. Would she really get a significant boost with a new weapon? I am not sure.
Nakaba uses names from the Arthurian Legends but I doubt they will get all the weapons they have in these stories. I can see techniques named after them though or maybe he'll change the type of weapon. For example we have Tristan who is an archer and has Failnaught in the AL but it is pretty obvious that this one is going to stay a dual wielder. Lancelot is an archer here, it is hinted that he wants a new weapon because of his Magic but I don't see him getting something like Arondight as a sword.
For weapon variety I didn't really consider the people from Team Percival because they are not the main group and I doubt we'll see them fight often as equals in a team since Percival outclasses them and is going widen the gap even more as time goes on. If Nakaba is bothered by weapon variety he'll change Gawain's weapon somehow because Percival and Tristan will stay swordsmen for sure. I can see it turned into a new ax or Gawain putting it on Escanor's grave because it is already a great weapon. It's not something which can be thrown away like Percival's sword quickly made by Howzer.
I don't think Percival receiving a sword was the same type of situation as the Sins' STs. It was cool because it was an homage to Meliodas' weapon in NnT, but the sword itself hasn't done anything of note. I'd wager that people who hadn't read NnT and didn't understand the significance of the handle would have been even less impressed. I also disagree about the Sins who hadn't lost their STs, since the first times they either revealed their STs themselves or their special abilities were all notable. Rhitta was so heavy that Galand couldn't even lift it, but then Escanor picked it up with ease and cleaved him in two. When Escanor first revealed Rhitta's ability he used it to interrupt the tournament by nuking Drole and Gloxinia. Herritt was introduced when Gowther used it to alter the memories of the large group of holy knights that intercepted him, Ban and Mel when they infiltrated Liones. The debut of Merlin's ST was her using it to check up on Camelot from afar which wasn't that interesting, but we did see her use it to cast some spells in the fight against Galand soon after and then house her soul inside the weapon after her body had been petrified. These moments highlighted either the unique features of the STs themselves or at least the synergy between them and their wielders in a way that pretty much none of the weapons in the sequel have done so far.
Giving Gawain the exact same weapon as Escanor along with Sunshine would have made her even more similar to her predecessor, but I suppose whether that's a negative or not is subjective. As for Rhitta's power, I think there very well could be a better weapon for Gawain. Consider the fact that Rhitta's abilities synergized really well not with Escanor's strengths, but with his weaknesses. Rhitta stored his excess power that he couldn't control during the day and could then release that at night when he would have otherwise been helpless. The ability to call the axe to him was only necessary because he physically couldn't carry it with him most of the time like the other Sins. Gawain on the other hand was out and about in the crowd in Liones around noon, and not only was she not melting everything around her, but Tristan's group didn't even notice her walk by them. That didn't seem to be the result of her wearing something similar to Escanor's glasses either, because we saw her use her magic without taking off any clothing just a little while later. It appears as though she's just significantly better at controlling Sunshine's output, similar to Mael. The fact that she can use spells also means that she's not helpless at night like Escanor was and could easily teleport herself away or perhaps even shield herself with a Perfect Cube. Even summoning Rhitta to her, while certainly convenient to get her weapon back after teleporting it away, isn't actually necessary because she could also teleport herself to the sword. What this all means is that Escanor's Rhitta was something pretty much perfectly suited for him, whereas Gawain's Rhitta is something that's merely useful for her. I think a weapon tailored specifically for her abilities should be a better match for her than a piece of Escanor's former weapon.
I don't expect the weapons of the characters to be taken straight from the legends, because that's not how Nakaba usually does things. Instead he seems to like naming characters, places and objects after concepts in the legends, so a more likely scenario would be that the characters with named weapons in the legends will receive weapons with the same names, but which are not necessarily the same type of weapon. I disagree that Tristan staying a dual-wielder is obvious, since as I mentioned before, there are currently two dual-wielders in the main cast. In NnT, Nakaba made very sure to give all the members of the main cast completely different weapons and fighting styles, so it would be uncharacteristic of him to give the two such a similar arsenal. They also share the same gimmick with the way their magic interacts with their weapons, since Nasiens can coat the two swords with different poisons and Tristan has color coded swords for the two halves of his powers. I expect one of them to retain the dual-wield approach, while the other one eventually switches to a different type of fighting style. The one doing the switch could be either one, but personally I lean towards Tristan since him being the unification of light and darkness seems like an important plot point, which doesn't really come across very well if he has to channel each power through a different sword. I believe his unique nature could be better emphasized by giving him a singular weapon that combines both sides of his powers. In theory this could be achieved just by giving him the ability to fuse his swords together somehow, either to form a weapon similar to Arthur's incomplete Excalibur or a twinblade that has the two blades share the same hilt. As for Lancelot, I don't see him being a dedicated archer, but he very well could use it as a sidearm. Nakaba has portrayed him with a spear all the way back in Rising Impact, in the Lancelot one-shot and in the silhouettes of the FKOTA. Even the vague armored silhouettes in chapter 1 had a spearman in the group. In the fight against the Dark Talismans Lancelot seemed to favor close range combat, and he was apparently unable to use his bow or even his arrows to launch his Shining Road attack. If the attack is so powerful that it breaks the weapon used to launch it, then logically he would have broken his main weapon back when he used the attack in Sistana, hence why he's now using a backup weapon that's not compatible with his magic.
While I agree that Team Percival will probably not be able to keep up with the FKOTA, I don't believe that's as big of a deal as you think. The same thing happened with the Sins in NnT, where Escanor and Meliodas were vastly stronger than the rest. Even when King, Diane and Gowther finally caught up to TC level, Meliodas and Escanor immediately eclipsed them again with assault mode and The One. Ban spent most of the story as a punching bag and Merlin was largely there for utility and rarely even fought anyone. The only times the Sins were roughly equal were before the TC showed up and after the Holy War had mostly wrapped up. Despite the massive power gap, the weaker Sins still managed to contribute in fights throughout the story, which is most likely going to be the case for Team Percival as well. If anything it might be somewhat easier for them to stay relevant because Percival seems to need other people nearby to power his Hope, and he's also demonstrated the ability to share his power with those around him. Team Percival might end up tagging along in Percival's fights for large parts of the story. As for what I expect the endgame weapons to be, I agree that Percival and Tristan will remain swordsmen, although I could see Tristan switching to a singular sword. Gawain is the only one in the party who could wield a heavy weapon, so I expect her to get something like that. An axe would probably be too similar to Escanor, so I'm leaning more towards a zweihänder, although a war hammer would be a cool option as well and could maybe allow for Gawain to use an attack that resembles golfing. Lancelot gets a spear and might keep the bow, Anne keeps the rapier, Nasiens either keeps the swords or switches to a weapon with a large amount of separate blades to buff and Donny can do pretty much whatever. As for Rhitta's fate, I'd expect it to be returned to whatever memorial they have for Escanor along with the rest of the axe. Frankly, taking a decoration like that and turning it into a weapon is pretty rude in the first place.
Page 2:
...you still call them Daddy and Mommy?
I... I'm doing it out of habit...
Page 4:
Title: In Liones castle (1)
Awesome!! There's actually a bath in the castle!!!
I'd love Anne and Nasiens to join us here too!
Idiot, don't expect Anne to join us!!
Hop!!
Yahooooo!!!!
Bwahahah!
It's so fun!♬
Take thaaat!!!
Ukyaaaaah!!
You can come on inside.
I will... do that... later...
Page 5:
Aaaaah, I'm beat.
Why do I feel sleepy after a nice bath?
I chose this room to sleep in!
Outside: Really?
Oh come on, it's fine, I mean, there's a load of bedrooms besides this one...
Just get out!!
Where is Nasiens?
You're drooling on the sheet!!
Aaah.
I'm tired today.
SFX: Blob blob
Page 6:
Bwaaaaah!!!
Hyaaaaaaaah!!!
Fwafuh.♬ Hey, I surprised you!!
Di-di... di... di...
Di?
Did you see it? Did you see it!? Did you!? You didn't, did you!?
S-see what!? Huh? I just snuck in here to surprise you, that's all...
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
This isn't the time to be sleeping here!!!