Mighty Escanor

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
757
Reaction score
2,225
Country
Winterfell
:verily

It's less about wanting perfect female characters and more of an issue that most of the time Nakaba fails to elevate the female cast even to the same level as their male counterparts and that in virtually every aspect of the story - from powerlevels, to combat displays, to character development and ultimately - which is often the focus where this becomes super apparent - romantic themes. Sure you can argue that it's a shounen and thus deliberately caters to male themes but to that I'd counter it is friggin' 2022 and even Japan can fucking afford to go with the times.

The problem is that most of those who criticize Nakaba only talk about trivial and most basic aspects of characters and almost always fail to see the whole structure that makes up a story.


It might be a bold statement from me, and I'm not an expert in manga audience demographics, but the way Nakaba has built the entire NnT on two female characters makes it a very special case of shounen.


When people start to hate a character, they fail to see how important or well written they are. It's not easy to notice what a perfect character Merlin(1) is.


Because Elizabeth(2) doesn't fight that much, you don't see many people talk about how her will is the driving force behind the whole MC.


Derieri(3) is better than 90% male characters both in terms of individual abilities and the structural beauty of her story. If our gut feelings are right, she will continue to be a strong and interesting character under the name of Thetis(4) in MnYK.


Love was more of a driving factor for Ban rather than Elaine(5). Ban could never reach Elaine's level of power or even badassery if it was not for his purgatory experiences, and he couldn't have that experience if it wasn't for Elaine's selfless decision and heroic act. Ban gas always been my 3rd favorite character in NnT, and I will never try to belittle him for the sake of argument.


Jericho(6) and Guila(7) have always had more importance and a more prominent presence compared to the Gil/Howzer/I even forgot his name(!!) TRIO.


Veronica(8) and Matrona(9), do I need to tell how strong they were physically and mentally. They were never damsels in distress and the amount of fanservice associated to them was zero.


Melascula(10) was another fenale character with an impressive set of abilities, a distinct and memorable personality, and an independent and dependable ego. She used to pair up with Galand, but she never depended on him. In fact it was Galan who received useful advices from Mela. Mela later revived him in Galand in MnYK as well.


Galla(11) and Derocchio from the six knight of black had a rather similar dynamics as well. Remember how Derocchio chased by Merlin, ran towards Galla and asked her for help?


Another example is Gelda(12) who was never a weak character, and her character
was not overshadowed by Zeldris.


SD was mistreated by Nakaba Suzuki most probably because of his plans for the sequel. But Lady of the Lake(13) is a prominent character whose importance and relevance is gonna skyrocket in MnYK. She is either FV material or another structurally important character on par with or even higher than Merlin herself.


Arthur is need of a wife not because his sexual desires are getting out of control, but because the wife he was probably talking about has an ability more badass than his own chaos. We all know how important Bartra's role was in NnT. Now an even more accurate and more powerful form of future insight is given to Guinevere(14) who is a female character with a promising future role.


And finally, the female titular character of MnYK, the new Sun to shine even brighter than Mael and Escanor, the absolute fire of the sequel manga, Gawain dono(15) of the four knights of the apocalypse is also a female character. As heir to both the grace and the plot of Sunshine, this lovely character has a future as bright as the Sun ahead of her.


Just how many strong/well written/plot important female characters a story needs to satisfy some fans? If NnT characters could know of these sexist fan expectations, the prevalence of various types of anxiety disorders increase among NnT verse female population lmao.


Dear @Yakkun , this post is in no way aimed at you. I apologize to you if it may look salty or too serious while I'm replying your post. You just provided the opportunity for me to make my own list of wonderful female characters in NnT and MnYK, and the numbers are just there to show how many of these great female characters are there.


Dear @Yakkun , dear @Ann Firestar , and anybody else who has a fair-minded take on the subject, I'd be honored to know about your list of great female characters in Nakaba Suzuki's stories.:verily
 

Mighty Escanor

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
757
Reaction score
2,225
Country
Winterfell
This is an interesting read of my post.

@Yakkun post basically said all that needed to be said, but no one is asking for the women in this series to be "perfect", far from it. More often than not, Nakaba has demonstrated certain weak points when it comes to penning women. #NotAllWomen, obviously, but enough to make the weakness noticeable. And it makes some of us wary of how he'll handle the direction of their character going forward, thus Otaku's post and my response. Even in my post, I acknowledge that it isn't guaranteed that Nakaba will write a woman character badly as I included the word "potentially" in there.

My wanting him to do better with his women does not mean I want them to be perfect or that every man he pens are better than the women.
"Women of all sexualities have the potential to be written poorly here. After all, at the end of the day, they're still women in the NNT universe."

It's a bit hard for me to read your sentence differently. I fully agree with Yakkun's reply, but Yakkun said something very different from yours.

The way you talked about THOSE WHO ARE STILL WOMEN IN NNT UNIVERSE BY THE END OF THE DAY was very different from this toned down #NotAllWomen in newer post of yours. I'm happy to have helped you understand the problem with your post and correct it.

I also invite you to read my second post about female characters in NnT/MnYK verse. Aside from the fact that Merlin is an example of a perfect fictional character, Merlin vs Elizabeth is a stronger force running NnT than anything related to Meliodas and the seven deadly sins. I wonder if some shoujo manga can compete with NnT when it comes to the plot importance of female characters.

It's also perfectly normal for an author to have specific problems with a specific type of character they create. Nakaba has a specific set of problems when it comes to the protagonist, anither very distinct set of problems with secondary characters, he is fully biased towards short characters, young characters, winged characters, ... . Because female characters have their own set of requirements when the author decides to create one of them as supporting characters in a very specific context of a unique story called NnT for example, there might be mistakes shared amongst the majority of them. Although for NnT, it has never been the case as I briefly mentioned in my second longer post.

All that said, let's restate your sentence using a different POV:

Any character regardless of age, color, gender, etc. has the potential to be written poorly here. After all, at the end of the day, they are all made by a human being called Nakaba Suzuki who may make mistakes just like all other members of homo sapiens species.

It's the less sexist form of that sentence which emphasize of the concept of potentials and possibilities more generally and more neutrally.

Nakaba's greatest weak point has always been his unability to create a balanced protagonist vs antagonist opposition. His gender associated weakness is nothing compared to that one. In fact, Elizabeth and Diane weren't treated like this because they are female characters. The sole reason behind it was the fact that Meliodas and King had more protagonistic vibe to them, so they robbed Elizabeth and Diane of their APPARENT share of story.
 

Yakkun

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 20, 2006
Messages
4,418
Reaction score
4,334
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
The problem is that most of those who criticize Nakaba only talk about trivial and most basic aspects of characters and almost always fail to see the whole structure that makes up a story.


It might be a bold statement from me, and I'm not an expert in manga audience demographics, but the way Nakaba has built the entire NnT on two female characters makes it a very special case of shounen.


When people start to hate a character, they fail to see how important or well written they are. It's not easy to notice what a perfect character Merlin(1) is.


Because Elizabeth(2) doesn't fight that much, you don't see many people talk about how her will is the driving force behind the whole MC.


Derieri(3) is better than 90% male characters both in terms of individual abilities and the structural beauty of her story. If our gut feelings are right, she will continue to be a strong and interesting character under the name of Thetis(4) in MnYK.


Love was more of a driving factor for Ban rather than Elaine(5). Ban could never reach Elaine's level of power or even badassery if it was not for his purgatory experiences, and he couldn't have that experience if it wasn't for Elaine's selfless decision and heroic act. Ban gas always been my 3rd favorite character in NnT, and I will never try to belittle him for the sake of argument.


Jericho(6) and Guila(7) have always had more importance and a more prominent presence compared to the Gil/Howzer/I even forgot his name(!!) TRIO.


Veronica(8) and Matrona(9), do I need to tell how strong they were physically and mentally. They were never damsels in distress and the amount of fanservice associated to them was zero.


Melascula(10) was another fenale character with an impressive set of abilities, a distinct and memorable personality, and an independent and dependable ego. She used to pair up with Galand, but she never depended on him. In fact it was Galan who received useful advices from Mela. Mela later revived him in Galand in MnYK as well.


Galla(11) and Derocchio from the six knight of black had a rather similar dynamics as well. Remember how Derocchio chased by Merlin, ran towards Galla and asked her for help?


Another example is Gelda(12) who was never a weak character, and her character
was not overshadowed by Zeldris.


SD was mistreated by Nakaba Suzuki most probably because of his plans for the sequel. But Lady of the Lake(13) is a prominent character whose importance and relevance is gonna skyrocket in MnYK. She is either FV material or another structurally important character on par with or even higher than Merlin herself.


Arthur is need of a wife not because his sexual desires are getting out of control, but because the wife he was probably talking about has an ability more badass than his own chaos. We all know how important Bartra's role was in NnT. Now an even more accurate and more powerful form of future insight is given to Guinevere(14) who is a female character with a promising future role.


And finally, the female titular character of MnYK, the new Sun to shine even brighter than Mael and Escanor, the absolute fire of the sequel manga, Gawain dono(15) of the four knights of the apocalypse is also a female character. As heir to both the grace and the plot of Sunshine, this lovely character has a future as bright as the Sun ahead of her.


Just how many strong/well written/plot important female characters a story needs to satisfy some fans? If NnT characters could know of these sexist fan expectations, the prevalence of various types of anxiety disorders increase among NnT verse female population lmao.


Dear @Yakkun , this post is in no way aimed at you. I apologize to you if it may look salty or too serious while I'm replying your post. You just provided the opportunity for me to make my own list of wonderful female characters in NnT and MnYK, and the numbers are just there to show how many of these great female characters are there.


Dear @Yakkun , dear @Ann Firestar , and anybody else who has a fair-minded take on the subject, I'd be honored to know about your list of great female characters in Nakaba Suzuki's stories.:verily
No offense taken but i will still use this opportunity to comment on your post as I see these things. Warning, this WILL BE LONG.

1) Merlin is not a perfect character, at least not from a writing point of view. Whether or not she is a likeable character bears no weight, but had it not been for a hand full of shortcomings and flaws she would in fact have been too perfect. What sounds like a paradox is in fact the display of what you could call coming close to a Mary Sue. She does not quite fit the description, thankfully. However,, her personal motivation her entire character truly revolved around was seeminly solved in NNT towards the ending by Arthur obtaining the power of Chaos. Her interest in studying said entity and what fruits it bore for her have yet to be seen in 4KOTA and as such she is currently a 'concluded character'. If you want a deeper analysis, you could argue that her motivation was born from the fact that she was brought up with no affection and love, to be a mere tool, a means to an end. Merlin only ever tried to fill up the void in her heart which made her the woman she is. Whether she has changed as a character has yet to be seen. I don't enjoy Merlin and don't think she is very well written because I feel like her entire background seems shoehorned to justify not only her near-flawless powers but also her entire raison d'être because otherwise she would be reduced to a plot device. Nakaba kinda did save her by giving her that background but to me it always felt like it was too little to late. She remains one of the better written women in the manga tho.

2) Elizabeth doesn't fight much but she has shown to actually be capable in several moments. I understand people usually want more from her so she can be Meliodas' counterpart but that's not her role. That does, at the same time, render the given hype towards 'Bloody Ellie' utterly redundant tho, which is an evidence piece of why she is handled poorly as a female character. I like her resolve to solve most matters peacefully but more often than that she is needlessly sexualized and way too often side-lined. She may be the motivating for the MC in Nanatsu no Taizai but see, this is exactly the problem. Because that makes her a means to an end to develop Meliodas' role in the story, not elevate her own. Elizabeth was truly at her best when Meliodas was unconcious because while she experienced pain and sorrow, she still tried to do something on her own. That perioud could have been extended or otherwise handled differently and overall better. Feels like she was robbed of opportunity. During King/Diane training with Glox and Drole, she was handled better in the flashback of the past but overall still felt like she played more of a side role and only got her five minutes when rescuing Derrierie and Monspiet at the end. Even Gowther received better development in that little arc than she did. Lastly, during the Estarossa/Mael reveal she also could have been written into a role where she was way more proactive. In fact she was in the beginning when she protected the nights and temporally held the increasingly crazed Estarossa at bay. But that wasn't seen through; again she was robbed by the combined efforts of several Sins members and two Arch Angels with far less character development than her. In the very few moments where Elizabeth is badass it almost always ends with her ultimately stepping aside instead of being allowed to bring a conclusion by her own hands. That is usually reserved to Meliodas or, literally anyone else.

3) Derrierie sure is a powerhouse in the big picture of things (yet even here several of her male companions among the Commandments outrank her) but ultimately she is just barely even a character. Her character development begins incredibly late in the story and is for the most part reduced to her unspoken affection towards Monspiet, which not only goes nowhere but entirely overshadows the fact that she is sick of the war between angels and demons. She doesn't even kinda pass the Bechdel Test in a sense. She ultimately dies but it seems she gets a second chance as a character in the form of Thetis (4), if the implications turn out true. Maybe I'm expecting a bit much here considering she is really only a third-tier character in terms of story importance.

5) Oof, Elaine. Similar case of a girl that starts out with her own task but is then for the vast majority of the story rendered utterly inactive or acting on the motivation of pursuing her romantic interest with Ban. There is little outside of that what matters, not even her duty to the fairy realm takes on a new definition after the original tree in the human realm burns to the ground in Ban's origin story. Okay, granted, there is the motivation of survival here but again, Elaine even just barely even qualifies to be character. For the most part she is a Macguffin; a plot device that enables Ban's motivation of bringing her back to live and serving as his raison d'être rather than anything else. Post-NNT she gives birth to Lancelot and that's really it. She has her brief moment of glory when fighting and sprouting those wings and lending her power to the war effort but again, this comes so late in the story that it is insubstantial in regards to her overall neglect.

6)/7) Jericho and Guila. Yes and no. Guila is a no-brainer, virtually the only female character in the series who is all in all well-written. She is not perfect by any means nor is she super important but she contines to stay relevant in the context of the story both in NNT and in 4KOTA. She is powerful and capable in her own tier and is only outshadowed in strength and ability by people who obviously occupy a wholly different rank within the knight order or are generally beyond that. She must not hide beind the likes of Gilthunder, Howzer or Griamore and she has worked herself into every position of prestige by effort and recognition of her prowess. Except for the demon blood ritual which granted her powers in the first place but then you could argue that she made it through with sheer willpower while others died. Her love interest existed and albeit it was brief it never dominated her personal motivation or affected her duty. She was initially very protective of her brother but when Zeal grew up, figured he didn't make a good Holy Knight and instead made for Blacksmith she was reliefed that the boy could stand on his own two feet and she didn't get clingy. So yeah, overall good. She continues to work on herself even yet.

Jericho is a different kind of beast and while she initially had her own personal reason to become strong and prove herself that all went out of the window after Gustav died and she inherited his power. Nakaba banked way too hard on her easily falling in love with virtually any dominant male figure or any man that was nice to her, really. What, you thought Ban and Lancelot were the only ones? Nah, there is a small side story where even as a child she easily goes around and confesses to love and attempts at marriage with grown as men. Granted, she was very little there and it was mostly comedic relief but it - SADLY - set the foundation Nakaba build upon later as her main driving force as a character. FACEPALM. When she could have easily come into her own and stepped into her brother's footsteps, surpassing him in ability (she did that at least) but also maturing. The latter part virtually doesn't exist unless Nakaba is going to do more for her in 4KOTA. But so far she, too, is only driven by her love interest and the despair of losing that pipe dream which turned her to Arthur. Jericho deserves better but it remains to be seen whether she can be written out of that poor position.

8) /9) Veronica and Matrona are overall good characters, Veronica is overally not important enough to matter much but she never had a huge role to begin with so I'm kinda fine with where she is. Her role basically is fulfilled and for many 3rd or 4th-tier characters that's absolutely enough. Matrona is in the same boat, actually well-written character with plausible motivation and great strength for the general position she was and is in. No complaints really.

10) Same can be said about Melasculla. She didn't really have any distinctive or discernable personal goal but that's fine. She was basically a soldier and did her job, her relationship with Galland was interesting and hilarious too. Especially if you consider that she is rather young and he is the oldest out of the acting Commandments when they all break the seal. I think that's something that could have theoretically explored in a way, maybe considering Galland as sort of a nice grandpa (not literally) to her or something like that. You know, like that one uncle at the family gathering that is actually cool and that you can chug beers with and talk, that kinda thing. I digress. Again, no complaints about Mela, she good.

11) Galla and... who? Sorry, I honestly don't even know who that is. No comment on my part possible.

12) Gelda, oof, the second. Similar situation to Elaine. Powerful as fuck in a way but everything in her life revolves around her love interest. She has no other motivation. Even only went along with the vampire rebellion and wasn't even an initiator or something like that. Gelda is more a plot device than a character.

13) Lady of the Lake is currently more of an entity and serves to drive one or several plot points but besides that she is not a character. Nothing really constitutes that.

14) Guinevere remains to be seen. Too little to know yet. Is already dangerously close to not passing the Bechdel test if all she does and is motivated by is Lancelot. But again, not passing judgement, way too early.

15) GAWAIN-SAMA THE ONLY TRULY GREAT CHARACTER
cough I jest. Nah, Gawain, whether likeable or not, is currently in a good spot but for her its also a bit early to pass judgement on because we mostly have half-measures and superficial knowledge. Her problem could become similar to Merlin's in that everthing is way too egocentric for her and she doesn't take in any outside influence. That can also be a trap. But I currently don't see it.



This became way longer than I anticipated but it's kinda my stance on most of the women in this manga. It's not gospel tho. If anyone wants to point of blatant flaws or stuff I overlooked or simply doesn't share my view because it may be a bit pessimistic, that's totally fine with me. Would be horrible if everyone only ever just agreed with me.
 

Mighty Escanor

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
757
Reaction score
2,225
Country
Winterfell
Thanks to the mod who moved the posts here. OK let's go.

No offense taken but i will still use this opportunity to comment on your post as I see these things. Warning, this WILL BE LONG.

1) Merlin is not a perfect character, at least not from a writing point of view. Whether or not she is a likeable character bears no weight, but had it not been for a hand full of shortcomings and flaws she would in fact have been too perfect. What sounds like a paradox is in fact the display of what you could call coming close to a Mary Sue. She does not quite fit the description, thankfully. However,, her personal motivation her entire character truly revolved around was seeminly solved in NNT towards the ending by Arthur obtaining the power of Chaos. Her interest in studying said entity and what fruits it bore for her have yet to be seen in 4KOTA and as such she is currently a 'concluded character'. If you want a deeper analysis, you could argue that her motivation was born from the fact that she was brought up with no affection and love, to be a mere tool, a means to an end. Merlin only ever tried to fill up the void in her heart which made her the woman she is. Whether she has changed as a character has yet to be seen. I don't enjoy Merlin and don't think she is very well written because I feel like her entire background seems shoehorned to justify not only her near-flawless powers but also her entire raison d'être because otherwise she would be reduced to a plot device. Nakaba kinda did save her by giving her that background but to me it always felt like it was too little to late. She remains one of the better written women in the manga tho.

2) Elizabeth doesn't fight much but she has shown to actually be capable in several moments. I understand people usually want more from her so she can be Meliodas' counterpart but that's not her role. That does, at the same time, render the given hype towards 'Bloody Ellie' utterly redundant tho, which is an evidence piece of why she is handled poorly as a female character. I like her resolve to solve most matters peacefully but more often than that she is needlessly sexualized and way too often side-lined. She may be the motivating for the MC in Nanatsu no Taizai but see, this is exactly the problem. Because that makes her a means to an end to develop Meliodas' role in the story, not elevate her own. Elizabeth was truly at her best when Meliodas was unconcious because while she experienced pain and sorrow, she still tried to do something on her own. That perioud could have been extended or otherwise handled differently and overall better. Feels like she was robbed of opportunity. During King/Diane training with Glox and Drole, she was handled better in the flashback of the past but overall still felt like she played more of a side role and only got her five minutes when rescuing Derrierie and Monspiet at the end. Even Gowther received better development in that little arc than she did. Lastly, during the Estarossa/Mael reveal she also could have been written into a role where she was way more proactive. In fact she was in the beginning when she protected the nights and temporally held the increasingly crazed Estarossa at bay. But that wasn't seen through; again she was robbed by the combined efforts of several Sins members and two Arch Angels with far less character development than her. In the very few moments where Elizabeth is badass it almost always ends with her ultimately stepping aside instead of being allowed to bring a conclusion by her own hands. That is usually reserved to Meliodas or, literally anyone else.

3) Derrierie sure is a powerhouse in the big picture of things (yet even here several of her male companions among the Commandments outrank her) but ultimately she is just barely even a character. Her character development begins incredibly late in the story and is for the most part reduced to her unspoken affection towards Monspiet, which not only goes nowhere but entirely overshadows the fact that she is sick of the war between angels and demons. She doesn't even kinda pass the Bechdel Test in a sense. She ultimately dies but it seems she gets a second chance as a character in the form of Thetis (4), if the implications turn out true. Maybe I'm expecting a bit much here considering she is really only a third-tier character in terms of story importance.

5) Oof, Elaine. Similar case of a girl that starts out with her own task but is then for the vast majority of the story rendered utterly inactive or acting on the motivation of pursuing her romantic interest with Ban. There is little outside of that what matters, not even her duty to the fairy realm takes on a new definition after the original tree in the human realm burns to the ground in Ban's origin story. Okay, granted, there is the motivation of survival here but again, Elaine even just barely even qualifies to be character. For the most part she is a Macguffin; a plot device that enables Ban's motivation of bringing her back to live and serving as his raison d'être rather than anything else. Post-NNT she gives birth to Lancelot and that's really it. She has her brief moment of glory when fighting and sprouting those wings and lending her power to the war effort but again, this comes so late in the story that it is insubstantial in regards to her overall neglect.

6)/7) Jericho and Guila. Yes and no. Guila is a no-brainer, virtually the only female character in the series who is all in all well-written. She is not perfect by any means nor is she super important but she contines to stay relevant in the context of the story both in NNT and in 4KOTA. She is powerful and capable in her own tier and is only outshadowed in strength and ability by people who obviously occupy a wholly different rank within the knight order or are generally beyond that. She must not hide beind the likes of Gilthunder, Howzer or Griamore and she has worked herself into every position of prestige by effort and recognition of her prowess. Except for the demon blood ritual which granted her powers in the first place but then you could argue that she made it through with sheer willpower while others died. Her love interest existed and albeit it was brief it never dominated her personal motivation or affected her duty. She was initially very protective of her brother but when Zeal grew up, figured he didn't make a good Holy Knight and instead made for Blacksmith she was reliefed that the boy could stand on his own two feet and she didn't get clingy. So yeah, overall good. She continues to work on herself even yet.

Jericho is a different kind of beast and while she initially had her own personal reason to become strong and prove herself that all went out of the window after Gustav died and she inherited his power. Nakaba banked way too hard on her easily falling in love with virtually any dominant male figure or any man that was nice to her, really. What, you thought Ban and Lancelot were the only ones? Nah, there is a small side story where even as a child she easily goes around and confesses to love and attempts at marriage with grown as men. Granted, she was very little there and it was mostly comedic relief but it - SADLY - set the foundation Nakaba build upon later as her main driving force as a character. FACEPALM. When she could have easily come into her own and stepped into her brother's footsteps, surpassing him in ability (she did that at least) but also maturing. The latter part virtually doesn't exist unless Nakaba is going to do more for her in 4KOTA. But so far she, too, is only driven by her love interest and the despair of losing that pipe dream which turned her to Arthur. Jericho deserves better but it remains to be seen whether she can be written out of that poor position.

8) /9) Veronica and Matrona are overall good characters, Veronica is overally not important enough to matter much but she never had a huge role to begin with so I'm kinda fine with where she is. Her role basically is fulfilled and for many 3rd or 4th-tier characters that's absolutely enough. Matrona is in the same boat, actually well-written character with plausible motivation and great strength for the general position she was and is in. No complaints really.

10) Same can be said about Melasculla. She didn't really have any distinctive or discernable personal goal but that's fine. She was basically a soldier and did her job, her relationship with Galland was interesting and hilarious too. Especially if you consider that she is rather young and he is the oldest out of the acting Commandments when they all break the seal. I think that's something that could have theoretically explored in a way, maybe considering Galland as sort of a nice grandpa (not literally) to her or something like that. You know, like that one uncle at the family gathering that is actually cool and that you can chug beers with and talk, that kinda thing. I digress. Again, no complaints about Mela, she good.

11) Galla and... who? Sorry, I honestly don't even know who that is. No comment on my part possible.

12) Gelda, oof, the second. Similar situation to Elaine. Powerful as fuck in a way but everything in her life revolves around her love interest. She has no other motivation. Even only went along with the vampire rebellion and wasn't even an initiator or something like that. Gelda is more a plot device than a character.

13) Lady of the Lake is currently more of an entity and serves to drive one or several plot points but besides that she is not a character. Nothing really constitutes that.

14) Guinevere remains to be seen. Too little to know yet. Is already dangerously close to not passing the Bechdel test if all she does and is motivated by is Lancelot. But again, not passing judgement, way too early.

15) GAWAIN-SAMA THE ONLY TRULY GREAT CHARACTER
cough I jest. Nah, Gawain, whether likeable or not, is currently in a good spot but for her its also a bit early to pass judgement on because we mostly have half-measures and superficial knowledge. Her problem could become similar to Merlin's in that everthing is way too egocentric for her and she doesn't take in any outside influence. That can also be a trap. But I currently don't see it.



This became way longer than I anticipated but it's kinda my stance on most of the women in this manga. It's not gospel tho. If anyone wants to point of blatant flaws or stuff I overlooked or simply doesn't share my view because it may be a bit pessimistic, that's totally fine with me. Would be horrible if everyone only ever just agreed with me.
1) Merlin of NnT was a perfect character from a writing poit of view imo. The thing is Merlin's story is not a concluded one, and her gaiden is supposed to be included in MnYK. In NnT, she was a static character with a role different to the other sins. Instead of a plot device to justify the events, she was a schemer who moved various pieces throughout the time to reach her 3000+ year old wish. I fully agree her motivation and the little backstory wasn't that great. It was more like a simple copy paste of Diane's, but the final arcs of NnT had an abnormally bad quality, and Merlin's part also looked like shit!

MnYK Merlin may have a complete character arc because every character besides Mel and Escanor had his full backstory revealed after their Gaiden, and conclusion happened only after that. Merlin's Gaiden is gonna be embedded in MnYK according to Nakaba. We can expect her story to be 'concluded' in MnYK.


2) The problems with a sexualized and sidelined Elizabeth stems from Nakaba's fetish for the protagonist not her problem with female characters. When an author is willing to mistreat an antagonist to show the might of the protagonist, you can expect them to care about the complicated role of side characters most of the time. Still, if she could help define Meliodas better with her presence, it means she was a well written side character of the main plot. That's in fact what side characters do all the time. Side doesn't mean unimportant. It's someone who walks the path alongside the protagonist and their different ideas and actions are used to better define bothe characters or convey more delicate meanings to the audience.

In ancient holy war flashback, Nakaba had to show more of AAs as the newly introduced characters. Elizabeth shone there, but if she were to steal the spotlight from Sariel, Tarmiel, Ludo, and OG Gowther in their 'debut arc', it would be unforgivable!

Aside from being a side character, Elizabeth was also the main force to oppose Merlin's schemes because of her pure kind heart. Something that might be easily maintained if the Bloody Ellie thing would get more serious. Bloody Ellie was so irrelevant and out of place for her that I could never take it seriously. It was probably added to NnT only to satisfy Elizabeth fans. Bloody Ellie could never convince Diane to join them in the first! The story would easily break apart if she wasn't such a gentle soul she always was.


3,4,6,7,8,9) I picked up these less important characters because they were tiers above their male counterparts of the same tier. That's why I compared Guila and Jericho to the male knight youngling trio.

There is also a problem Nakaba himself admitted in an interview. He likes to create so many characters, but he needs to ignore or sideline many of them in favor of the main cast and main plot. That's probably why it is always too late for him to focus on the likes of Der, Mael, Mons, OG Gowther, demon masters, ... .


11) Derocchio is a stupid looking lion man in Prisoners of the sky movie. He was a magician humiliated by Merlin and later killed by Escanor. It's actually hard not to forget about that mavie and the six knights of black. I understand why you don't have any idea who these idiots are.


13,14,15) I know it's still too soon to add female characters from MnYK to the list. However, because they will end up being great characters very soon, I just included them ahead of time lol.
 

Yakkun

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 20, 2006
Messages
4,418
Reaction score
4,334
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Thanks to the mod who moved the posts here. OK let's go.



1) Merlin of NnT was a perfect character from a writing poit of view imo. The thing is Merlin's story is not a concluded one, and her gaiden is supposed to be included in MnYK. In NnT, she was a static character with a role different to the other sins. Instead of a plot device to justify the events, she was a schemer who moved various pieces throughout the time to reach her 3000+ year old wish. I fully agree her motivation and the little backstory wasn't that great. It was more like a simple copy paste of Diane's, but the final arcs of NnT had an abnormally bad quality, and Merlin's part also looked like shit!

MnYK Merlin may have a complete character arc because every character besides Mel and Escanor had his full backstory revealed after their Gaiden, and conclusion happened only after that. Merlin's Gaiden is gonna be embedded in MnYK according to Nakaba. We can expect her story to be 'concluded' in MnYK.


2) The problems with a sexualized and sidelined Elizabeth stems from Nakaba's fetish for the protagonist not her problem with female characters. When an author is willing to mistreat an antagonist to show the might of the protagonist, you can expect them to care about the complicated role of side characters most of the time. Still, if she could help define Meliodas better with her presence, it means she was a well written side character of the main plot. That's in fact what side characters do all the time. Side doesn't mean unimportant. It's someone who walks the path alongside the protagonist and their different ideas and actions are used to better define bothe characters or convey more delicate meanings to the audience.

In ancient holy war flashback, Nakaba had to show more of AAs as the newly introduced characters. Elizabeth shone there, but if she were to steal the spotlight from Sariel, Tarmiel, Ludo, and OG Gowther in their 'debut arc', it would be unforgivable!

Aside from being a side character, Elizabeth was also the main force to oppose Merlin's schemes because of her pure kind heart. Something that might be easily maintained if the Bloody Ellie thing would get more serious. Bloody Ellie was so irrelevant and out of place for her that I could never take it seriously. It was probably added to NnT only to satisfy Elizabeth fans. Bloody Ellie could never convince Diane to join them in the first! The story would easily break apart if she wasn't such a gentle soul she always was.


3,4,6,7,8,9) I picked up these less important characters because they were tiers above their male counterparts of the same tier. That's why I compared Guila and Jericho to the male knight youngling trio.

There is also a problem Nakaba himself admitted in an interview. He likes to create so many characters, but he needs to ignore or sideline many of them in favor of the main cast and main plot. That's probably why it is always too late for him to focus on the likes of Der, Mael, Mons, OG Gowther, demon masters, ... .


11) Derocchio is a stupid looking lion man in Prisoners of the sky movie. He was a magician humiliated by Merlin and later killed by Escanor. It's actually hard not to forget about that mavie and the six knights of black. I understand why you don't have any idea who these idiots are.


13,14,15) I know it's still too soon to add female characters from MnYK to the list. However, because they will end up being great characters very soon, I just included them ahead of time lol.
I don't really have much to add here, nor do I want to challenge any of those points. You have a different view on some aspects and you are obviously entitled to it. Overall we more or less share the same feelings about these characters, it seems. I disagree on some aspects regarding Elizabeth and I also don't think Gilthunder and Howzer are inferior to Guila and Jericho but that's nitpicking on my part.
 

Mighty Escanor

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
757
Reaction score
2,225
Country
Winterfell
I don't really have much to add here, nor do I want to challenge any of those points. You have a different view on some aspects and you are obviously entitled to it. Overall we more or less share the same feelings about these characters, it seems. I disagree on some aspects regarding Elizabeth and I also don't think Gilthunder and Howzer are inferior to Guila and Jericho but that's nitpicking on my part.
Now that it has come to this, let me make another list to make everything more clear lol.

The list of MH members I personally like to have a manga related conversation with them and enjoy their posts most of the times!

Ann Firestar, Vortigern, Demonspeed, Undina, and you dear Yakkun.

I'm sure there are lots of members who are good at reasoning and analysis, but I did not have the chance to have a conversation with them so far.

I surely have the problem of always being too serious when it comes to argumentation, regardless of context lol. It's not because I hate others or want to make them feel bad. I do it because the most well thought ideas show themselves when people are serious about it. And like you said, it's horrible if people simply agree on whatever they read or hear.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

It's because the female characters get a lot less to work with. And the material they have seems to be relationship-focused, rather than something which is just for them. The female characters aren't necessarily badly written in some cases, and sometimes they do get a lot of material to work with, but it's always less than their male counter-part. In fact, tell me what male counter-part has less material than their female counter-part/lover?
Now that's an amazing question you asked. I love it.

1. The most obvious answer is of course Derieri. While his male counterpart was forcefully put into Silent or perhaps Airplane mode! by the king of demons, she was the more proactive person in the duo. She bore the burden of the little story they had in terms of dialogue and expressions, and the fact that she was a physical fighter, helped her stand out more than Monspeet when it was action time.

2. Another one is once again Merlin. Falls in love. Her love interest dates Ellie. Can't do shit about than. Says fuck it and pursues another purpose in her life!

You may argue that all she did was because of emotional trauma or for the sake of love, but then almost every male character in series does whatever he can only for the sake of love. Mel, Gil, Ban, King, Zel, Mons, Escanor, and OG Gowther reduce to ash if you take love and relationship matters aways from their plot or share of the story. Most engines in the series burn love to operate!

Merlin might've done all of this to end up living with a Fake Meliodas in the country Arthur builds for her, but love was not a subject of interest for her. She never talked about love, and when Ellie mistook Arthur for her lover, she didn't respond iirc. I can't call neither Meliodas nor Escanor her male counterpart because her path was always that of her own. However, Escanor as the one who wanted to stand by her side could never shake her will even though Merlin know her love was pure and strong.

3. It's Diane time!!!! Is there anyone who doesn't laugh at me for this? When she first appeared in the series, she was in love with Meliodas. She was a strong fighter and a baddass lady. Then her backstory was revealed. Something shared between her and Merlin. Then she became a pacifist who hated battles, something you'd expect from Ellie more than anyone else. Not to mention that Ellie later becomes a bloody killer.

Diane's plot had nothing unique to it even though she had always the potential to be one of the best female characters of NnT, but seriously, what could Nakaba do with such a mess of a storyline for her? Change of plans and aspulling a new trait for someone who never had or was never supposed to have it hurts the character a lot.

For the relationship part, she was on an equal position as King before Mael's awakening. Her decision to take Gowther back from insanity was made independently. The she lost her memories and began a lonely journey to her birthplace.

In ancient HW backstory, she once again decided to stand by OG Gowther's side and she passed the test without King being a part of it. Each time their stories branched like this, I liked Diane's part more than King's.

It was all ruined after Mael's awakening. When Gowther said fairies, giants and humans should stand against Mael, and demons and goddesses can't do shit against him anymore, I thought Nakaba is addressing King/Diane/Ban trio right there. King and Diane were one step away from their final power up, and Ban had become stronger in purgatory. Silly me! Only King's power up was enough. Diane was robbed of her moment by him. Why? I don't know. I started to hate King as a character after that. Unfortunately, there was no other opportunity for her to grow stronger and remain relevant against the FV when the final arc was right behind the door!
 
Last edited:

Mighty Escanor

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
757
Reaction score
2,225
Country
Winterfell
I see @Blazar forgot the OG Sun fan :emocat :emocat
My bad. You are right bro. I was so focused on my time in MnYK threads I completely forgot about NnT time.

The thing is the clan of Sun lovers don't have much to discuss about with each other now that MnYK has become so satisfying for them lol. We all can enjoy the cute Sun of this series as much as we want. :cool:

@Samael Morningstar , you are a fellow Sun lover and an active and influencial member in various MH threads. Sorry I forgot to mention you in my previous post. Again, that's because we didn't have many discussions and conversation in the era of Chaos and MnYK.

Now that I'm thinking about it, there other members who used to be active in NnT threads. So sad they've lost interest in either Nakaba's manga or related threads.

Let me update the list once more:

@Arjuna , @BD_Beno , @Seven777 , @LaserBeam , @Shadowlord123 , and @Gallon .

I also remember that there was someone by the name of bittersweettea irrc, but I can't tag her account name here. Maybe she changed the name. There was also that other member I can't remember their name. They used to make creative posts using emojis and symbols.

Good old days. I'm beginning to feel like I'm an old fart now lol!
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
1. The most obvious answer is of course Derieri. While his male counterpart was forcefully put into Silent or perhaps Airplane mode! by the king of demons, she was the more proactive person in the duo. She bore the burden of the little story they had in terms of dialogue and expressions, and the fact that she was a physical fighter, helped her stand out more than Monspeet when it was action time.
Now that I think about it, you're right. Derieri is probably one of the few (if only) female characters who has better material to work with than Monspiet.

Considering how she's been reincarnated into a role that seems somewhat integral to the sequel's story, she'll probably only get better material.

2. Another one is once again Merlin. Fells in love. Her love interest dates Ellie. Can't do shit about than. Says fuck it and pursues another purpose in her life!

You may argue that all she did was because of emotional trauma or for the sake of love, but then almost every male character in series does whatever he can only for the sake of love. Mel, Gil, Ban, King, Zel, Mons, Escanor, and OG Gowther reduce to ash if you take love and relationship matters aways from their plot or share of the story. Most engines in the series burn love to operate!

Merlin might've done all of this to end up living with a Fake Meliodas in the country Arthur builds for her, but love was not a subject of interest for her. She never talked about love, and when Ellie mistook Arthur for her lover, she didn't respond iirc. I can't call neither Meliodas nor Escanor her male counterpart because her path was always that of her own. However, Escanor as the one who wanted to stand by her side could never shake her will even though Merlin know her love was pure and strong.
Yeah, Merlin's backstory and ambitions are selfish but they were born from Meliodas unknowingly rejecting her romantically. It really doesn't look good to the audience when you have a character who decided to change the world drastically just because her crush didn't like her back.

It's also distasteful to have a literal child lusting for an adult romantically like this. Merlin replicating an adult's body to ''lure'' Meliodas over doesn't help either if you bring that scenario into the real world.

I don't understand why Nakaba went down this route of failed romance with Merlin. It wasn't needed whatsoever. She was a child who wanted her father's love but didn't get it, so she looked elsewhere. But why did it have to be for a male lover? If it was me, I would've had Merlin be rescued by Elizabeth (because evil mel saving a little girl makes no sense) and then develop on that sisterly bond. That bond could've become so strong that it replaced the absent parental love she wanted. But then, because the Gods killed Elizabeth and destroyed the only ''family'' bond she had left, she got bitter & wanted revenge, using knowledge/power to fill that void Elizabeth had been filling in for. Hearing about Chaos origins, she could've believed that it would be capable of saving her ''sister'' whilst also directly screwing over the Gods. But along the way, she lost herself to the gluttony.

To me that would've been much more appreciated then what we got. Her backstory felt soiled by Meliodas involvement and I much would've rather seen a sisterly relationship been the base motivator for Merlin's backstory, not a failed romance that's bordering on pedophilia.

You may argue that all she did was because of emotional trauma or for the sake of love, but then almost every male character in series does whatever he can only for the sake of love. Mel, Gil, Ban, King, Zel, Mons, Escanor, and OG Gowther reduce to ash if you take love and relationship matters aways from their plot or share of the story. Most engines in the series burn love to operate!
The difference is how male characters are given a lot more material to work with, even romantically. Meliodas being the only person capable of breaking the curses is a perfect example of this. It's a problem for both him and Elizabeth, but she isn't allowed of resolving the problem herself, she's entirely dependent on him to fix a problem that's inhibiting their relationship.

Male characters also get a lot more individual material than their female counter-parts. Meliodas has his role with his father & brother fully explored and defined properly. We know that he lead the demon clan and did what his father told him, even if he personally disagreed. But what about Elizabeth? We have no idea whether she served her mother in the same capacity, or if she was a disobedient daughter all along. No indicator or exploration into her childhood & young adulthood as a Goddess before she met Meliodas. And even when her mother becomes a villain to defeat, nothing new is revealed and Elizabeth isn't even the one to defeat her.

Another example is King & Diane. He's the Fairy King and we've seen plenty of content with that status, but what does Diane get as the Giant Queen? Nothing. We haven't seen her in that role AT ALL much like how Elizabeth got nothing as the Supreme Deity's daughter in contrast to Meliodas as the Demon King's son.

I could go on all day, I'm sure you get the idea lol.

It's Diane time!!!! Is there anyone who doesn't laugh at me for this? When she first appeared in the series, she was in love with Meliodas. She was a strong fighter and a baddass lady. Then her backstory was revealed. Something shared between her and Merlin. Then she became a pacifist who hated battles, something you'd expect from Ellie more than anyone else. Not to mention that Ellie later because a bloody killer.

Diane's plot had nothing unique to it even though she had always the potential to be one of the best female characters of NnT, but seriously, what could Nakaba do with such a mess of a storyline for her? Change of plans and aspulling a new trait for someone who never had or was never supposed to have it hurts the character a lot.

For the relationship part, she was on an equal position as King before Mael's awakening. Her decision to take Gowther back from insanity was made independently. The she lost her memories and began a lonely journey to her birthplace.

In ancient HW backstory, she once again decided to stand by OG Gowther's side and she passed the test without King being a part of it. Each time their stories branched like this, I liked Diane's part more than King's.

It was all ruined after Mael's awakening. When Gowther said fairies, giants and humans should stand against Mael, and demons and goddesses can't do shit against him anymore, I thought Nakaba is addressing King/Diane/Ban trio right there. King and Diane were one step away from their final power up, and Ban had become stronger in purgatory. Silly me! Only King's power up was enough. Diane was robbed of her moment by him. Why? I don't know. I started to hate King as a character after that. Unfortunately, there was no other opportunity for her to grow stronger and remain relevant against the FV when the final arc was right behind the door!
I mean you encapsulated it perfectly: Diane was on par with King but after the Mael arc she got overshadowed by her lover. It also doesn't help that her only influence past this arc was during the Demon King's fight where she tainted the scene with a ''I want to marry King!'' moment rather than a ''let's defeat a deity who's causing my friends so much pain!''
 

Mighty Escanor

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
757
Reaction score
2,225
Country
Winterfell
Yeah, Merlin's backstory and ambitions are selfish but they were born from Meliodas unknowingly rejecting her romantically. It really doesn't look good to the audience when you have a character who decided to change the world drastically just because her crush didn't like her back.

It's also distasteful to have a literal child lusting for an adult romantically like this. Merlin replicating an adult's body to ''lure'' Meliodas over doesn't help either if you bring that scenario into the real world.

I don't understand why Nakaba went down this route of failed romance with Merlin. It wasn't needed whatsoever. She was a child who wanted her father's love but didn't get it, so she looked elsewhere. But why did it have to be for a male lover? If it was me, I would've had Merlin be rescued by Elizabeth (because evil mel saving a little girl makes no sense) and then develop on that sisterly bond. That bond could've become so strong that it replaced the absent parental love she wanted. But then, because the Gods killed Elizabeth and destroyed the only ''family'' bond she had left, she got bitter & wanted revenge, using knowledge/power to fill that void Elizabeth had been filling in for. Hearing about Chaos origins, she could've believed that it would be capable of saving her ''sister'' whilst also directly screwing over the Gods. But along the way, she lost herself to the gluttony.

To me that would've been much more appreciated then what we got. Her backstory felt soiled by Meliodas involvement and I much would've rather seen a sisterly relationship been the base motivator for Merlin's backstory, not a failed romance that's bordering on pedophilia.
Wow, I loved your scenario so much. It doesn't have moral problems of the original story, and there is a distinction between Merlin and Diane's backstory. Seriously, why Meliodas shows up right in front of every girl who is running away from her home?

I hated the idea too much at that time. But we are yet to know what Nakaba has in mind gor Merlin. I'm afraid Merlin is living with a fake Meliodas in Camelot in MnYK, and there be Meliodas vs Meliodas battle in it as if we have not seen enough of Meli before!

For a better analysis, we need to wait until Merlin's Gaiden and full backstory is revealed. But your scenario for her backstory is way better than Nakaba's. That's the undeniable fact.

The difference is how male characters are given a lot more material to work with, even romantically. Meliodas being the only person capable of breaking the curses is a perfect example of this. It's a problem for both him and Elizabeth, but she isn't allowed of resolving the problem herself, she's entirely dependent on him to fix a problem that's inhibiting their relationship.

Male characters also get a lot more individual material than their female counter-parts. Meliodas has his role with his father & brother fully explored and defined properly. We know that he lead the demon clan and did what his father told him, even if he personally disagreed. But what about Elizabeth? We have no idea whether she served her mother in the same capacity, or if she was a disobedient daughter all along. No indicator or exploration into her childhood & young adulthood as a Goddess before she met Meliodas. And even when her mother becomes a villain to defeat, nothing new is revealed and Elizabeth isn't even the one to defeat her.

Another example is King & Diane. He's the Fairy King and we've seen plenty of content with that status, but what does Diane get as the Giant Queen? Nothing. We haven't seen her in that role AT ALL much like how Elizabeth got nothing as the Supreme Deity's daughter in contrast to Meliodas as the Demon King's son.

I could go on all day, I'm sure you get the idea lol.
Yeah I get it. That's a serious problem. Part of it is the result of gender inequality, and part of it stems from a messy world build.

For example, King was the fairy king! and fairies were living in a well organized society. But Diane wasn't the giant queen during NnT timeline. Giants were scattered through the land and their race never had a single god tier entity to rule over them. This difference made it impossible to create a balanced fairy giant duo, even if both members were male characters.

In ancient HW backstory, Glox had a variety of challenges to face with, while Dolor, a male giant had nothing to do other than fighting for stigma. Dahlia had a more prominent presence compared to Dubz in the second movie as well. A random giant with an exceptional talent can never compete with the king of an entire clan. A king who is a descendant of the sacred tree, a godly entity in the fictional universe.

I mean you encapsulated it perfectly: Diane was on par with King but after the Mael arc she got overshadowed by her lover. It also doesn't help that her only influence past this arc was during the Demon King's fight where she tainted the scene with a ''I want to marry King!'' moment rather than a ''let's defeat a deity who's causing my friends so much pain!''
Such a waste of potential! Such a shameful decision! It was just as Nakaba foreshadowed way before. When Estarossa wakes up from his slumber, the nightmare begins. The dude told us all about the nightmare his audience is going to experience after Mael's awakening. After all, Nakaba is the master of foreshadowing.
 

FKS

Mangahelper
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
3,481
Reaction score
17,102
Gender
Male
Country
France
Volume 9 extras here.

TL:
Pic 2:
Nothing beats the pudding in this world.
*Ugh* How can she gulp down a barrel worth of something as bad as that...

Pic 4:
Band: 4KoA Character Design V
The genesis of Lancelot
Box: Among the four character in the story, Lancelot is the one I had the most trouble creating. Since he already appeared in the prequel Seven Deadly Sins, I has to think about how to differentiate him from others.
The figures first... I drew A with amusing hairstyle and B with Tristan's long hair, so they ended up being met with a no from me.
By the way, A has golden hair and B has blue hair.

Pic 5:
Band: 4KoA Character Design V
The genesis of Lancelot
Box: Now, they look completely different from A and B and wear clothes that look similar to those of the Fairies.
Both C and D have golden hair (like their mother Elaine), however C looks strongly like a boy, making me feel like he overlaps with Tristan, while D has the hairstyle like his father Ban. In addition, C and D's eyes are like Ban's, so they end up being like a younger Ban on a black and white manuscript.

Pic 6:
Band: 4KoA Character Design V
The genesis of Lancelot
Box: E anf F have blue hair inherited from Ban.
...I somewhat don't think they are bad but let's just say I couldn't make them not look like mobs. And since F is the son of Elaine, while I think he, with his straight long hair, is passable, he comes off as a character that could need some more strength.
E's hairstyle, again, is trickier as the final version Lancelot and Percival make a combination.

Pic 7:
Band: 4KoA Character Design V
The genesis of Lancelot
Box: And finally, the definitive draft is G (I came up with this Lancelot draft before the one-shot "The Rainy Forest that Invites the Beginning").
His eyes are clearer than Ban's and his hair is chestnut like Elaine's. His bangs are a bit longer in the present when he is grown up.
On top of that, H is Lancelot who appeared in my debut work Rising Impact serialized in another magazine. I just couldn't keep it that way, so I discarded the draft. (Laughs)

Pic 8:
Nasiens' prescription

Noooo!!
Outside: My breasts are gone!!
Outside: I'm scraggy all over the place, my neck is bulging and my voice comes out weird!!!
Hey... what is going on with me!!?

You drank my drug on your own, Angharad.
It's the yin and yang reversing drug.

Well, anyway... the effect lasts for one hour or so...
Whoah!!?

...my weiner is gone and I feel something cold passing down there!!!
Outside: Wow, amazing!!
S... so these are a woman's breasts!!!

This form surprisingly suits you w...
There, have it!

SFX: Gulp
SFX: Excited

Huh? Huuuuuh? You didn't change much, Nasiens.

The end

Pic 19:
I am invincible!! I am the strongest!!

And the TL for the drawing gallery:
Pic 1:
Tri: What makes Lancelot great isn't his mindreading or his transformations!
Per: Yep! I think I understand!!

Lan: Speaking of it, did you eventually manage to use Fault Counter a little more?
Tri: It is *Full*, not *Fault*!!

L: This girl is full of mystery.
T: Her enormous strength and her haughty attitude... What kind of parents did she have, I wonder?

Pic 2:
Tri: Percival must have a king of secret going on about him.
Lan: Everybody's got to have a secret or two.

Per: I wonder if we were destined to meet!?
Nas: Destined... That might be so.
An: You sure are romantic, are you.

Per: Yep, yep, the cape and helmet suit you well!
An: Uhm... the helmet is big and heavy...
Per: Uh, already returning it? Is it alright?

Mel: Those parent and child look like they'll have a hard time with us.
Ban: By the way, is Meliodas Tristan's little brother?

Nas: This is a collage.
Lan: He is very agile.
Don: Yeah... I wouldn't be able to do that.
An: We can tell that.

Per: What is this delicious pig?
Lan: Gowther showed Tristan and me, so I know.
An: Again, what is this pig?

Pic 3:
An: Hey, let's go complain about him to his father?
Lan: No point in doing that, because he'd legit feign ignorance in front of him.

An: I want to be a Holy Knight soon!!
Don: Eh, I might actually be one before you.
Nas: Don't try to stir fire...
Per: Then let's all become one!!

Per: Oooh, you know these two for a long time!!
Lan: They appear less friendly at first glance but they actually are like very caring brothers, especially that one.

Per: Whoaaah, I'd love going on an adventure in many more places!!
Nas: I will come with you!!

Nas: I'd like us four to go adventuring again...
Don: But now, that the four Knights of the Apocalypse have gathered, there's no place for us to say or do anything...
An: Sheesh! Stop being so hesitant about it!!

An: He looks like a girl with his hair cut. And his eyelashes are long...
Lan: He started growing his hair a long time ago, I don't think he'll get it cut anytime soon.

Page 4:
Per: I have to get much stronger, else I won't be able to heat Ironside.
Lan: Come on, no need to rush things.

Don: First, once the battle is over, let's go hit the sack!!
Nas: True, we've been battling ever since the Entangled Forest.

Tri: As I am now, I look different to my 6 years and 2 years ago selves!!
Lan: ...uh... are you... sure about that...?
Tri: What!? What's with that cold reaction!?

Nas: Can you take me to Hendrickson's clinic later?
Per: Sure thing! You seem to be getting on well wihth that doctor.

Tri: Are we childhoos friends? Or best friends? Which one do you think it is?
Lan: Either one is fine. Actually, we are neither.

Per: Come to think of it, Tristan is ambidextrous!
Lan: It's nice to be ambidextrous...
An: It's rare for you to be jealous.

Pic 5:
Lan: Pelio received instruction from Gowther when he was an apprentice.
Per: Ooh. Donny had Howzer as an instructor. I wonder who I will have.

Tri: Let's the four of us go beat Camelot ruler Arthur without fail!
Per: Wooooooooh!!!
Lan: There, there...

Don: Who is the stronger one of the two?
Per: Hmmmm... Lancelot?
Nas: But the prince Tristan too is strong, isn't he?
An: Either one is okay.

Nas: I agree with Percival.
Lan: It's actually not that easy but when he's the one saying it, it really seems to be that way.
(The drawing is Percy saying: We may not understand each other's words but as long as we understand each other's hearts, we can get along well!!)

An: I get an enormous feeling that Price Tristan grew up pampered by the ones around him.
Don: You have a sharp tooth, huh...

Mel: Well, well, weeeell... I can't wait to see how they will grow from now on...!

Pic 6:
Per: I like my fellow Knights of the Apocalyose but these four are really the best ever!!
Nas + group: *Silence*

Nas: These four are greatly unbalanced... please don't bully Percival.

An: You're being unfair to be good-looking and strong, aren't you?
Don: Then it means I'm also being unfair?
Per: Bwahahahaha!!
Don: Why're you laughing?

--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

While I'm at it, Nakaba fixed a panel:

 
Last edited:

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,827
Reaction score
61,579
Gender
Male
Country
France
Always bow and arrows or a spear as weapons excepted for D.

All these designs are actually at least decent but F is literally a girl? The one he chose is definitely the best IMO but I really like B and H.

E's hairstyle, again, is trickier as the final version Lancelot and Percival make a combination.
Does it confirm what many thought? That he wants to focus more on Percival-Lancelot and Tristan-Gawain as duos or is he saying that their hair would be too similar?
 

Mighty Escanor

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
757
Reaction score
2,225
Country
Winterfell
Let's continue in hangout thread to avoid off topic discussions in chapter 85 thread.

Yeah I don't see any of the non-human clans becoming antagonists again, both because of who's in charge of them now and also because they're just not strong enough at this point. Chaos and everything related to it are the only faction that could conceivably threaten the entire world. In that sense Arthur as the King of Chaos would fit the bill, but that only really works for the readers that started with the sequel. Anyone that has read NnT knows that Arthur's actual personality is completely different from his current one. This chapter reinforced this idea with Varghese's comment about turning Arthur back to normal, which relates to Meliodas's dialogue about bringing Arthur back to his senses. When the good guys see the antagonist as someone who isn't really evil and that just needs a good spanking to snap him out of it, that really eats away at his credibility. Arthur is more like the Hendy of the story than the DK of the story. That's why Arthur seems like a very unlikely candidate to be the actual main villain.

As for who could take Arthur's place, I think there are three candidates depending on the angle that you want to look at things from.

The most straightforward course of action would be to consider the setting that Nakaba has created and ask what kind of an entity would be both powerful as well as important enough to qualify as the final enemy. The original Chaos is clearly the most fitting option. You can't really go any bigger than fighting a literal god, which is a trope that Japan seems to never get tired of. A potential problem with this idea is that Chaos has been implied to be peaceful since it disliked the giants due to their violent nature, but you could make the case that Chaos didn't appreciate being sealed away and now harbors a grudge towards the other clans as well. In fact that could explain why Arthur became a human supremacist after gaining the power of Chaos.

Alternatively you could look at this series as a story that is heavily inspired by the legends of King Arthur. Not only do we have the man himself as the supposed main antagonist and his most famous knights as the heroes, but there's also this central prophecy about Arthur's downfall. In the legends, that happens largely due to the actions of Mordred, who would be a very appropriate villain for an Arthurian story. It also helps that he would be the Prince of Chaos and thus potential on par with Arthur in terms of strength, at least if Mel and the DK are anything to go by.

Lastly you could focus on all the Biblical elements that have been present throughout the series. The Seven Deadly Sins, the Ten Commandments, the Four Archangels and most importantly the Four Horsemen/Knights of the Apocalypse. The great evil of the Biblical Apocalypse is Satan in the form of a dragon, which may or may not be connected to the Dragon of Chaos that was important enough to have been given the center spot in the Coffin. If the FKotA are going to live up to their name and trigger the Apocalypse, then that dragon would be the logical final threat for them to face at the end of it. I also kinda like the idea that the final villain of the sequel was already a major plot point at the start of NnT, in the form of the dragon handle.

So basically you end up with either Chaos itself or someone using its power, be it the Prince of Chaos or the Dragon of Chaos. You could even combine them, like making Mordred turn into the Dragon or vice versa, or making Mordred use the dragon handle sword to manifest the same dragon that emerged to intimidate Oslo.
There's no disagreement between the two of us regarding the future of king Arthur. The three possible candidates you mentioned can all work fit well with the context of MnYK. It seems you are underestimating poor LoL to much! Or I might be the one to overestimate!! I'll write about her in the due secrion.
As for Satan, the dragon of Chaos, the serpent, the monster from the sea, mark of the beast, etc. I can see how Nakaba can make use of an object he introduced in the first xhapter of NnT and make it the big bad of the collective universe, but since dragon handle being the Chaos fragment feels like an asspull by itself, I can't have high hope of this scenario. Not to mention that Satan is not a greater being than god in at least Abrahamic religions. Consequently, in the presence of Chaos as the creator of everything, FV being satan seems like a demotion of the antagonist.
The other problem is that Nakaba has always been more interested in Arthurian legends than anything else. I don't think he gets too much involved with religion in his epic retelling of Arthur's legend. Mordred has a higher chance of being the FV than Satan.

My point was about how Camelot being something that non-humans can't currently enter isn't really a problem if that's not going to last, so it wouldn't affect the role of King&Diane's kid(s) in the story. Other than that I agree with you about pretty much everything, although I don't believe that the focus being on Chaos will sideline the other clans. The actual problem there is that most of the known issues with the other clans have already been resolved. With the exception of the giants and their looming extinction, the other clans could pretty much just chill in their respective realms without a care in the world, unlike the humans who are dealing with an intra-clan war that eats away at the land itself. The way to involve the other clans in the story is to introduce problems that affect them more directly.
Let's clear things out a bit. By main plot, I mean the one that involves the adventures of the antagonist as they face will various challenges and trials that are directly or indirectly created by the efforts or activities of the final villain or those who directly serve them. You see how everything in NnT was sidelined, overshadowed, or even neglected when Mel vs DK became the focus of the story? MnYK is supposed to have at least 4 main story lines and the most pivotal one of them is that of Percy vs (?) Followed by the other three knights vs their respective NEMESES.
The closer you are to the either MC or FV, you are more relevant to the main plot of the story. That's not an insult or a bad thing, just the reality of characters who are not part of either team. It also works for the antagonists as well. Jelamet, six knoghts of black, or Izraf were antagonist of branching story lines, so they never felt as crucial to the story as the likes of Hendy or the 10C. But they served their purpose and became an inseparable part of NnT verse.

I think the reason why the main characters of the series are all at least partly human isn't because of what the main story is going to focus on, but because of how it's going to end. We know that both NnT and the sequel take place before the realms are separated, which seems to be leading up to an ending that basically turns Britannia into the real world Britain. Magic will disappear and all the non-humans and monsters end up in other realms, leaving behind only the humans and those that look indistinguishable from humans. That's why the FKotA, all of whom are named after the Knights of the Round Table, have to be at least partly human. They will remain in the human world as this legendary band of knights that will inspire vaguely accurate books to be written about them. The non-human clans and characters will most likely have a major role in the 2nd half of the story, but it will be focused on their realms and the conflicts therein rather than on their role in the human world, which they are eventually going to leave anyway.
If the story begins in the realms of humans, get other races involved, and ends as they separate from each other leaving Britannia and the realm of humans as the final place of focus in let say it's final act, all the the main cast consists mostly humans and half humans (Tristan may still be the exception), it in fact means the main focus of story is on humans.

By the way, I seriously think you guys are giving that anime introduction too much credit. I know Nakaba can see that far ahead in the future, but the fact that he never addressed the same concept in manga is a bit suspicious. To me, that line in the introduction is there to create a fake sense of reality for the audience. As if it's something that could have happened in our world when there was other realms mixed with it in a long long time ago. Something like the beginning of Star Wars movie when you know it doesn't mean "the story will be concluded in the current timeline of our universe." It's just to make the alternative reality you are gonna work with more relatable emotionally and mentally.

There are cases of a similar trick in other media. "BASED ON A TRUE STORY" "IN A LAND FAR FROM .... ." So I prefer to think of that line like this instead of a foreshadowing/prophecy about the end of MnYK. I don't have any objection if it turns out to be true though.


Yeah it's not that surprising that the new main characters would be very strong, but it makes sense if they are to surpass the Sins over the course of the story. I get what you mean about the KoA being able to stomp some of their enemies similar to the Sins, but I think the way it's handled is different. The Sins were so far above their enemies in the first act of the story that they pretty much just goofed off half the time and mostly only struggled because they just didn't bother fighting seriously. Later on we learn about things like Hunter Fest and have to wonder if Ban could have just soloed demon-Hendy had he felt like it. The whole first act was like a vacation for them, in contrast to the new main characters who actually have to try if they want to win. Lancelot is the only one who has an easy time due to being so strong, but even he still takes things seriously. He's looking for Dubs presumably to obtain a weapon that can withstand his magic. Compare that to how Meliodas sold his Lostvayne and significantly nerfed himself in the process just to make some money.
Agree with the whole part!


I mentioned most of my thoughts on this topic earlier in this post in my reply to Demonspeed. Mordred seems like the most probable option of the ones you brought up, although Morgan is definitely a solid candidate too. I don't really see the Lady of the Lake as a potential villain at this point though, especially not the main threat. At most she could be a personal enemy for Lancelot to deal with.
It's amazing how LoL is seen as a very unimportant character by the majority of fandom. Among the three entities related to Chaos, she was the only one who actively planned for it's revival. Cath was spending time in a cave for an unknown reason, and only met Arthur by chance! Hawk mama was wandering the land randomly helpeing some people or clans when she felt like it! Helped the sky people seal demons for no reason only to become the walking base of operation for another demon for no reason.

The only intelligent an capable entity who tested the humans in search of a proper vessel and manipulated Merlin for millennia was no one other than LoL.

If we assume Arthur's Chaos is a will without a will, then an intelligent entity is needed to guide thus. Who is better than LoL when Arthur is freed? Uhum, I mean other than Mordred of course.

As I said before, Merlin, Gawain, Percival, and Lancelot all have connections to LoL in various form in the legends. Till now, Lancelot has been the only KoA to come in cantact with LoL, but there is no reason to believe Nakaba doesn't know about the importance of LoL and limits her role to an ally or adversary of Lancelot.

As for the names, I was referring to Meliodas and Ban there since those two are the ones with the famous kids. That doesn't apply to King&Diane and I'd actually prefer if their kid(s) weren't connected to the Knights of the Round Table at all, even if Bors and Lionel would fit the family relation to Lancelot. This relates to the theory I mentioned earlier in this post regarding the role of the KotRT in the ending of the series. My ideal choice for King&Diane's kid(s) would be one daughter named Titania, because it's the name of a fairy queen and also contains the word 'titan' which alludes to the giants of Greek mythology. It just works really well for a fairy/giant hybrid.
I agree. Aside from concepts like main story and side story, we both agree that Kiane kids should better have their independent plot focusing more on their own clans and realms.
 

FKS

Mangahelper
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
3,481
Reaction score
17,102
Gender
Male
Country
France

Samael Morningstar

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
4,556
Reaction score
4,471
Age
25
Gender
Male
Country
India
Top