The problem is that most of those who criticize Nakaba only talk about trivial and most basic aspects of characters and almost always fail to see the whole structure that makes up a story.
It might be a bold statement from me, and I'm not an expert in manga audience demographics, but the way Nakaba has built the entire NnT on two female characters makes it a very special case of shounen.
When people start to hate a character, they fail to see how important or well written they are. It's not easy to notice what a perfect character
Merlin(1) is.
Because
Elizabeth(2) doesn't fight that much, you don't see many people talk about how her will is the driving force behind the whole MC.
Derieri(3) is better than 90% male characters both in terms of individual abilities and the structural beauty of her story. If our gut feelings are right, she will continue to be a strong and interesting character under the name of
Thetis(4) in MnYK.
Love was more of a driving factor for Ban rather than
Elaine(5). Ban could never reach Elaine's level of power or even badassery if it was not for his purgatory experiences, and he couldn't have that experience if it wasn't for Elaine's selfless decision and heroic act. Ban gas always been my 3rd favorite character in NnT, and I will never try to belittle him for the sake of argument.
Jericho(6) and
Guila(7) have always had more importance and a more prominent presence compared to the Gil/Howzer/I even forgot his name(!!) TRIO.
Veronica(8) and
Matrona(9), do I need to tell how strong they were physically and mentally. They were never damsels in distress and the amount of fanservice associated to them was zero.
Melascula(10) was another fenale character with an impressive set of abilities, a distinct and memorable personality, and an independent and dependable ego. She used to pair up with Galand, but she never depended on him. In fact it was Galan who received useful advices from Mela. Mela later revived him in Galand in MnYK as well.
Galla(11) and Derocchio from the six knight of black had a rather similar dynamics as well. Remember how Derocchio chased by Merlin, ran towards Galla and asked her for help?
Another example is
Gelda(12) who was never a weak character, and her character
was not overshadowed by Zeldris.
SD was mistreated by Nakaba Suzuki most probably because of his plans for the sequel. But
Lady of the Lake(13) is a prominent character whose importance and relevance is gonna skyrocket in MnYK. She is either FV material or another structurally important character on par with or even higher than Merlin herself.
Arthur is need of a wife not because his sexual desires are getting out of control, but because the wife he was probably talking about has an ability more badass than his own chaos. We all know how important Bartra's role was in NnT. Now an even more accurate and more powerful form of future insight is given to
Guinevere(14) who is a female character with a promising future role.
And finally, the female titular character of MnYK, the new Sun to shine even brighter than Mael and Escanor, the absolute fire of the sequel manga,
Gawain dono(15) of the four knights of the apocalypse is also a female character. As heir to both the grace and the plot of Sunshine, this lovely character has a future as bright as the Sun ahead of her.
Just how many strong/well written/plot important female characters a story needs to satisfy some fans? If NnT characters could know of these sexist fan expectations, the prevalence of various types of anxiety disorders increase among NnT verse female population lmao.
Dear
@Yakkun , this post is in no way aimed at you. I apologize to you if it may look salty or too serious while I'm replying your post. You just provided the opportunity for me to make my own list of wonderful female characters in NnT and MnYK, and the numbers are just there to show how many of these great female characters are there.
Dear
@Yakkun , dear
@Ann Firestar , and anybody else who has a fair-minded take on the subject, I'd be honored to know about your list of great female characters in Nakaba Suzuki's stories.