Games Mafia Game 144 - Pan the Diver - Day 5

[Copy Panda]

D5 VOTES

Voting 6/8

5x Kako - Sam #1377, Arrow #1378, Lumi #1394, Nash #1432 #1448, Tatsu #1479
1x Nash - Kakoha #1447

DAY DURATION

Spoiler: Event Rules

0-50m - [Surface] - Pantis Shrimp respects the power of love! One random mafia and one random townie turn into Lovers!

51-100m - [Shallows] - Pantis Shrimp can't let it rest! All passive roles at [Shallows] height are replaced with Restless Spirit!

101-150m - [Depths] - Pantis Shrimp is overruled! All defused Bombs receive a Sea-Urchin (one-time NVD)! Starting from the following Day Phase: all Bomb Defusers who have successfully dismantled a bomb (at any point during the game, including different depths) become a Noble.

151-200m - [Abyss] - Pantis Shrimp has been parried! A random plain townie's [Abyss] role is replaced with Prostitute! A random mafia's passive [Abyss] role is replaced with Escort!

Beware of the poll closing time.​

 

[SirSamuel016]

I'm almost certain that dego is scum- can only prove it at 51-100m depth though

 

[Natasha]

DD claims spy/det in deeper levels yet has stayed voting ascend 40m the whole day.

Keel

Votelock DD

 

[Stylether]

Do you dissagree that people claiming solid patterns pre post 20 have high chance to be town for quickfiring before they've scoped the mech out?

High chance? Not at all, to borrow the words of someone else:

I'm torn whether it's more useful for everyone to claim which of their depth roles are active or passive, or whether its more harmful.

Useful because - mafia has to lie/fake a lot of stuff on a relatively short notice, while town can be honest in whether they are active-passive-passive-active etc. Could make mid-lategame easier for finding liars.

Harmful because - gives mafia good targets for their kills to snipe good active roles

I personally felt like not coming out with patterns might have been the better shout in the first place (not that I will stand in the way of the tide once formed (diving pun)) since knowing who has passive abilities when will not only make it easier to target exclusively useful actives, but also dismantles the chances that a useful passive could get a meaningful impact. In this case, I find the certainty at which some people took towards claiming their exact active/passive pattern at the start without having such worries or concerns to be significantly less town-indicative than you, it seems.

 

[SirSamuel016]

DD claims spy/det in deeper levels yet has stayed voting ascend 40m the whole day.

Keel

Votelock DD

cyka blayt because you're russian (rushing)

 

[arrowofsky]

Oh Lumi gets included in the batch of "people who ended up on DD's case for his vote", along arrow, Gry

When I am involved in this list ?

 

[Stylether]

cyka blayt because you're russian (rushing)

If you wanna get used to the underground rap scene you'll have to get used to some russians

 

[Natasha]

cyka blayt because you're russian (rushing)

Dego was about to leave and I'd rather he not float his vote on Gry.

 

[Degojaru]

Beyond that, Degojaru's posts have felt very safe. Despite having posted a lot, a lot of what had been posted feels like recap posts where they will simply reiterate or reframe something without adding their own two cents or attempting to shift the convo.

I share a few ideas that others said, tried saying a bit more this time but I'll try being more original

Wait

Lock DD

I don't see killing DD a good option at least in D1. Maybe I'm wrong but don't gonna vote him, also in his bday

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 10:31 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 10:29 AM ---

I'm almost certain that dego is scum- can only prove it at 51-100m depth though

You're welcome, it will prove that u was wrong

 

[Natasha]

So we are basically cool with being in the first depth level

Since im dying anyway I have townie spy townie detective

Spy/det being cool with being vanilla townie is basically a fatal slip. @Degojaru

I don't see killing DD a good option at least in D1. Maybe I'm wrong but don't gonna vote him, also in his bday

Happy birthday @digitaldude hope you're partying hard enough for all of us

 

[arrowofsky]

I share a few ideas that others said, tried saying a bit more this time but I'll try being more original



I don't see killing DD a good option at least in D1. Maybe I'm wrong but don't gonna vote him, also in his bday

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 10:31 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 10:29 AM ---

You're welcome, it will prove that u was wrong

I think you are just a bit vengeful on @GrySun from the last game

 

[Degojaru]

Spy/det being cool with being vanilla townie is basically a fatal slip.

Maybe he doesn't want to reveal it so early? But did anyways so idk

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 10:34 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 10:34 AM ---

I think you are just a bit vengeful on @GrySun from the last game

Yes I'm

 

[Lady pompom]

@Lady pompom could you elaborate why you trust shino? You said its because you agree regarding the mechanic but her aims would directly place you into your less preferred role. And her point was less "every non diver is town" but more "it helps town more to alternate which layer is active which day" which I dont agree with.

I didn’t read it like that, but anyways, I feel shino is a sharp observer and she’s been paying attention to altercations among players, she both said concise information and pointed out her dislike for people saying things like certain depths are more town/mafia-like, which I agreed to. I trust her guts actually.

DD claims spy/det in deeper levels yet has stayed voting ascend 40m the whole day.

Keel

Votelock DD

It’s not a good idea to keel him, he just revealed his roles too, I’d give him the benefit of the doubt for today at least. But you’re being very pushy against DD even after reveal, which gives me scum alerts.

Very busy atm, will elaborate on other quotes later if I have time. Still thinking on who to vote for.

 

[Stylether]

When I am involved in this list ?

Your early posts, 23, 28 and 33. For the record, I'm not saying everyone on the list is suspect, I'm just saying that DD making a joke vote leading into a lynch feels like something that a scum might fan the flames of, so I'm tempted to say at least one scum in between the lot of you.

That being said, I like this post from Natasha, so...

DD claims spy/det in deeper levels yet has stayed voting ascend 40m the whole day.

Maybe we're after the right person for the wrong initial reasons.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 10:36 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 10:36 AM ---

bday

Happy birthday our most digital of dudes~

 

[Natasha]

Maybe he doesn't want to reveal it so early? But did anyways so idk

As you wish
See ya tomorrow hopefully~

 

[arrowofsky]

Yes I'm

That is sad, but MG143 is independent from this game. The only thing we can use from previous games is vibe check, and that also fails with these experienced smooth players.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 10:39 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 10:38 AM ---

Your early posts, 23, 28 and 33. For the record, I'm not saying everyone on the list is suspect, I'm just saying that DD making a joke vote leading into a lynch feels like something that a scum might fan the flames of, so I'm tempted to say at least one scum in between the lot of you.

That being said, I like this post from Natasha, so...



Maybe we're after the right person for the wrong initial reasons.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 10:36 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 10:36 AM ---

Happy birthday our most digital of dudes~

The problem is not his joke vote, he did exactly the same thing in D1 of MG143 while he was townie, so that alone does not make him sus. The rest ambigous posts and overall silence makes it bad. But for me on that accord, Holt is still more sus than DD.

 

[Marmalade]

~ 2 hours and 20 minutes left for today
8 players still have to vote


This cute host is dying for sushi, hosting this game isn't easy on an empty stomach. Please catch some good fish and chef up something yummy



​

 

[Degojaru]

That is sad, but MG143 is independent from this game. The only thing we can use from previous games is vibe check, and that also fails with these experienced smooth players.

Don't worries, it's hard for me having a good lynching option in D1 so I'm fine with a placeholder vote, I will leave prev game tomorrow it just was for today lol

 

[Natasha]

It’s not a good idea to keel him, he just revealed his roles too, I’d give him the benefit of the doubt for today at least.

I would too if he had been voting to delve to reach his role. As is he's claiming spy/det who's content sitting in the shallows and also claiming lol.

 

[Stylether]

Spy/det being cool with being vanilla townie is basically a fatal slip.

Yeah this is pretty damning, no matter how you twist it.

Vote: DigitalDude (aka Birthdayboy)

 

[Degojaru]

Lynching DD now will left us without Spy if he was saying the truth, and if he isn't the real spy can't reveal it without being the next night killing objetive imo, there are other sus peoples so I not share targeting him in D1, maybe I'm too dumb to figure it lol but seems he'll be lynched anyway without my vote

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 10:50 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 10:46 AM ---

I'll try to be back before day ends, catch u later