Games Mafia Game 144 - Pan the Diver - Night 3

[Copy Panda]

D4 VOTES

Voting 0/11

.

DAY DURATION

Beware of the poll closing time. ​

 

[GrySun]

Why did nash lock, Im the fcking townie aaah

You did yourself no favors with your playstyle nor with your lie.. The only thing giving me doubts rn is, would you as mafia when claiming some roles to survive with, not immediately list Spy/Det as your first role? Seems so sloppy..

But who else can we lynch? Instead of AAing, how about finding a good alternative lynch?

 

[arrowofsky]

yes

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 12:42 PM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 12:41 PM ---

??????????????????????????????

Just listen to me for once, remember what I have said before.

 

[SirSamuel016]

dego is P-P-A-P but surely it's just the 51-100m P where I can cuck him and we don't need to worry about the other two

 

[GrySun]

Oh come on, does anyone not ever pick it up? It’s always the faux oh look he’s sus that’s actually sus but I digress

Fwiw I dont actually distrust you so far

 

[SirSamuel016]

Just listen to me for once, remember what I have said before.

said what? all I remember is you having jojo's bazaar adventures

 

[Lady pompom]

Regarding DD I'd like to believe he's lying and lynch him still.

That said if he's town, I fail to see why some like shino, Pompom etc were defending him before he cleared up the depth issue, because with that he was mafia 100%. Only mafia would still know to trust him as town, while towns would naturally assume he slipped. He then gave an excuse -> at this point getting doubts about lynching him would be more organic.

Nah, I’m riding my instincts, I hard saw DD slip up so bad as mafia. Shame on me if he is and well played, though. ( I lynched wojak once and I was wrong about him being mafia okay, so tunneling is always a bad thing for me)

 

[shinobi]

ok

Votelock Nash

 

[GrySun]

Did I even defend him? check my post again. I said he could be lying, but we don't need to lynch him on d1.

Anything thats not an instant "i vote you you mafia" is defending there. The optics were so terrible, that without his excuse of lying about the role order I see no way anyone would not think he is mafia. There is being protective of spy/det claim, and there is somehow swallowing that he wants to stay on vanilla townie role instead lol.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 12:50 PM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 12:49 PM ---

sus

Not at all, I like my shallow waters. I take it you wanna defuse his behind? What post of his sounded like bomb?

 

[arrowofsky]

I interpret his posts as his usual play, he’s most games like this which does make for a hard read at times, what put that raised brow on me was the pushy lynch, which os often times not a good sign. Like Holt say, mafia does pull stunts like this to survive Dd also did in the past, but to me his extra info sounded worth checking out, it could be his doom if he is lying, so there’s that.

Anyways, I never said I’m not suspicious, this is a game of distrust, think what you may. I will keep watching DD voters and the results, in case I am really that rusty to discern fake Dd from honest Dd

I dont take being sussed emotionally, just expected more info that is all
I directly saw that playstyle from DD last game, as I said multiple times in other posts, he not only did those, low posted and almost always evasively answered or fully ignored questions asked to him. I still did not get a reply from him on what I said even though I stated I was ready to change my vote, too.
You are convenient with defending him.

 

[Holt]

Not fond of those lynching such claims right away. He could be investigated or something.

But you are ignoring the context of said lynch? if there was a (seemingly) clear slip-up, what investigation should be done when those roles can fake results and even coordinate better after night discussions if they happen to be scum?

 

[GrySun]

I dont want a Nash lynch, at least not yet. Feels too much of a random shot to try her today.

What are even the last min DD alternatives? Lynch Dego while he isn't a Bomb and trust Sam's instincts, or some newbie that underperformed..

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 12:52 PM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 12:52 PM ---

Or just keep it on DD, which is my current preference perhaps.

 

[SirSamuel016]

Not at all, I like my shallow waters. I take it you wanna defuse his behind? What post of his sounded like bomb?

Ah you did pick up what I was throwing down.

More time in the shallows lets me evaluate but I'm certain the puzzle pieces fit. The role pattern is a match for interactability between me and him so I'm thinking he's the one I need to nerf. If I'm successful then thats a safe lynch we get; if not, then I know I need to look elsewhere and I have back-up names too.

 

[GrySun]

But without updated votes we can't make a good guess on how to vote anyway.

I think DD has 4 votes maybe, Nash has 2? Others are at 1 or so.

 

[arrowofsky]

But you are ignoring the context of said lynch? if there was a (seemingly) clear slip-up, what investigation should be done when those roles can fake results and even coordinate better after night discussions if they happen to be scum?

Your first post that I agree with you, it really looks like buying time when orchestrated that way.

 

[SirSamuel016]

I know what you are @Degojaru

 

[shinobi]

Anything thats not an instant "i vote you you mafia" is defending there. The optics were so terrible, that without his excuse of lying about the role order I see no way anyone would not think he is mafia. There is being protective of spy/det claim, and there is somehow swallowing that he wants to stay on vanilla townie role instead lol.

But you are ignoring the context of said lynch? if there was a (seemingly) clear slip-up, what investigation should be done when those roles can fake results and even coordinate better after night discussions if they happen to be scum?

I know all he said and did, but I still don't want to vote for him now. And anyway he's dying without my help.

 

[Holt]

Lynching Nash given the circumstances is baffling. I’m not onboard with that. Regarding DD, considering his subsequent replies I’m also not onboard with it for now at least

 

[GrySun]

So main question is if DD is mafia, or if not then shino/Pom has at least 1 mafia, as only mafia would still not distrust DD at that point in time surely..

 

[Lumii?!]

You did yourself no favors with your playstyle nor with your lie.. The only thing giving me doubts rn is, would you as mafia when claiming some roles to survive with, not immediately list Spy/Det as your first role? Seems so sloppy..

But who else can we lynch? Instead of AAing, how about finding a good alternative lynch?

who would be your top 5 most sus persons ?

 

[SirSamuel016]

@Copy Panda @Marmalade can you give us overtime so you can get the votes in order???