Fantasy August vs Irene

[XXEliteXXAceXX]

August use historia calls out god Serena and the other dragons she fought in the past it's game bro

This is assuming that August copied all the Spriggan's magic which has yet to be proven. Therefore, I won't make that assumption. Besides, Irene in her dragon form would utterly destroy Historia Serena, no difficulty.

 

[Natsu Goatneel]

View media item 21462Lol Zeref durability >>>>>> August

It's not even comparable. Come on people. Also, Zeref isn't one bit hurt by Natsu in their current battle. Not ONCE has he screamed in pain or showed signs of being injured. He's laughing and enjoying himself while playing with his littler brother who he's been waiting to kill him for 400 years. He could easily just Timestop Natsu or blast him like he did Larcade but since Natsu is his baby brother and last resort to kill himself(he's obviously still wishing for death) he is still trying to see Natsu's full potential since only he knows what that is as his creator.

As far as August vs Irene goes I'm stuck. August is at this point 100% confirmed strongest Spriggan in story by the author in official Chruchyroll scans. Irene is a dragon thus August should have NOTHING in his arsenal able to deal her damage since he isn't a Dragon Slayer. (And no you CANNOT copy DS magic. It's confirmed you must obtain it through either enchantment from a DS/Dragon, or lacrima)

August is stronger due to his versatility and hax but Dragon Irene is his level due to the fact that her Dragon form is unbeatable if you wield no DS magic.

Historia Serena or Full Powered Serena is complete and utter fodder to Irene. She would EASILY turn Serena into a mouse or extract his lacrima power from his body on sight and oneshot him. Irene's MP is on par with August's(tho he has more) so this is a very plausible assessment.

Conclusion: August cannot damage Irene.

Irene cannot defeat August(who is far to fast to be swiped)

Draw

 

[LaGOAT]

View media item 21462Lol Zeref durability >>>>>> August

It's not even comparable. Come on people. Also, Zeref isn't one bit hurt by Natsu in their current battle. Not ONCE has he screamed in pain or showed signs of being injured. He's laughing and enjoying himself while playing with his littler brother who he's been waiting to kill him for 400 years. He could easily just Timestop Natsu or blast him like he did Larcade but since Natsu is his baby brother and last resort to kill himself(he's obviously still wishing for death) he is still trying to see Natsu's full potential since only he knows what that is as his creator.

As far as August vs Irene goes I'm stuck. August is at this point 100% confirmed strongest Spriggan in story by the author in official Chruchyroll scans. Irene is a dragon thus August should have NOTHING in his arsenal able to deal her damage since he isn't a Dragon Slayer. (And no you CANNOT copy DS magic. It's confirmed you must obtain it through either enchantment from a DS/Dragon, or lacrima)

August is stronger due to his versatility and hax but Dragon Irene is his level due to the fact that her Dragon form is unbeatable if you wield no DS magic.

Historia Serena or Full Powered Serena is complete and utter fodder to Irene. She would EASILY turn Serena into a mouse or extract his lacrima power from his body on sight and oneshot him. Irene's MP is on par with August's(tho he has more) so this is a very plausible assessment.

Conclusion: August cannot damage Irene.

Irene cannot defeat August(who is far to fast to be swiped)

Draw

Funny cuz if that's the case she would have fodderized erza and Wendy but she couldn't Full power god serena plus august will be too much for Irene

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 20, 2017, Original Post Date: Mar 20, 2017 ---

This is assuming that August copied all the Spriggan's magic which has yet to be proven. Therefore, I won't make that assumption. Besides, Irene in her dragon form would utterly destroy Historia Serena, no difficulty.

He saw god serena use his DS magic all he has to do is see their magic and it's instantly copied historia Serena>>Wendy and she couldn't fodderized her him and august together trashes irene

 

[Ilikeyou]

she didn't fodderized wendy cause she is wendy and has plot armor. God serena doesn't. Irene would completely annihilate him. probably just by looking at him just like erza did to her historia opponents.

 

[Seven777]

(And no you CANNOT copy DS magic. It's confirmed you must obtain it through either enchantment from a DS/Dragon, or lacrima)

No it isnt. Neinhart himself technically copied DS magic by creating God Serena

 

[LaGOAT]

she didn't fodderized wendy cause she is wendy and has plot armor. God serena doesn't. Irene would completely annihilate him. probably just by looking at him just like erza did to her historia opponents.

While august is there? Not happening

 

[**Silver**]

she didn't fodderized wendy cause she is wendy and has plot armor. God serena doesn't. Irene would completely annihilate him. probably just by looking at him just like erza did to her historia opponents.

God Serena even has courage to challenge Acnologia so do you think Serena fears Irene? good joke and God Serena is only support hes not in the frontline standing like a idiot, besides August magic power is strong enough to bring back 100% God Serena who in fact is stronger than Erza and Wendy....

 

[Ilikeyou]

God Serena even has courage to challenge Acnologia so do you think Serena fears Irene? good joke and God Serena is only support hes not in the frontline standing like a idiot, besides August magic power is strong enough to bring back 100% God Serena who in fact is stronger than Erza and Wendy....

Doesn't matter if she fears him she will still wreck his ass.

 

[Seven777]

Oneshotting Erza doesnt mean she can oneshot God Serena, people are acting like Eileen could beat him as casually as Acno did despite Eileen<<<<<<<<<<Acnologia.
God Serena tanked the GoI combined attacks with barely a scratch. Erza was getting damaged by the likes of Azuma and even freaking Ikaruga, GoI+Jura>>>>>>>Azuma+Ikaruga. Eileen breaking Erza's bones with a claw swipe doesnt mean anything when God Serena's durability is so much higher than Erza's.

 

[sharkai]

Serena does have high durability
Injured erza couldnt even tank azuma hits
Serena took all goi hits
And of course august cant tank cana hits

So durabilty wise
Serena >>> injured erza> august
Or
Attack wise
Goi >>> azuma > cana

Joke aside
August actually has nice durability, but why did he commit suicide aftwards. Maybe august used huge part of his magic to defend himself.

But august defeat dragon irene with historia. Doesnt seems possible

I think overall they seems equal
Physical all goes the dragon
Mp are equal
Hax all goes to august.

The problem august will really have to put alot of effort to put down dragon irene.
While slight distraction on august part (like if he wants to know why majesty child wasnt loved) will have him wrecked on the floor.

While on the other hand dragon irene can take most of the hits from august because of her immunity to magical hits. Historia power shouldnt suffice. Full power august attack with ds will take irene out of dragon form. But if he wasting that energy making powerful historia, historia attack power wont be equal to august attack power.

Ofcourse can even august use historia.
The guy has yet to use copied magic which is not exactly of his opponent at that cirrent time.
He needed brandish to shrink his wound.
Didnt refract any cana cards
He didnt use slowing magic of racer either. And he couldnt read gildart mind at all

Only thing he managed to retain was meteor. Or something that might be meteor. Since no name was used.

God Serena even has courage to challenge Acnologia so do you think Serena fears Irene? good joke and God Serena is only support hes not in the frontline standing like a idiot, besides August magic power is strong enough to bring back 100% God Serena who in fact is stronger than Erza and Wendy....

Serena stronger than erza. Lol
What's next, gmg rufus stronger than gmg jura

 

[Ebony Maw]

I'm still going with August, possibly in a stomp, though I'll give credit to Irene and say easy-diff.

Admittedly, I am making an assumption here, but I think it's a fair assumption to make; that being, August likely has poison dragon slayer magic. We saw him outright annihilate CS with utter ease, with him copying their magic and using it against them. Since the majority of that fight was off-paneled though, we can only assume that he has copied Cobra's dragon slaying magic, but I don't think it's a baseless assumption because why wouldn't Cobra have used his dragon slaying magic? And even if you dismiss this, August witnessed God Serena stomping the Gods of Ishgar, so he likely has copied that dragon slaying magic. Later we even see him say "God Serena is with me", which could hint that he copied Goddy's magic, because that's the only part of God Serena he could possibly have. If Irene was knocked out of her dragon form by a massively worn out Erza with a sword enchanted by a weakened Wendy, then a full powered dragon slayer spell from someone like August should obliterate her. On the off chance that she doesn't get one-shot and returns to her human mode, she can't do anything to him.

 

[Seven777]

Serena does have high durability
Injured erza couldnt even tank azuma hits
Serena took all goi hits
And of course august cant tank cana hits

So durabilty wise
Serena >>> injured erza> august
Or
Attack wise
Goi >>> azuma > cana

Joke aside
August actually has nice durability, but why did he commit suicide aftwards. Maybe august used huge part of his magic to defend himself.

But august defeat dragon irene with historia. Doesnt seems possible

I think overall they seems equal
Physical all goes the dragon
Mp are equal
Hax all goes to august.

The problem august will really have to put alot of effort to put down dragon irene.
While slight distraction on august part (like if he wants to know why majesty child wasnt loved) will have him wrecked on the floor.

While on the other hand dragon irene can take most of the hits from august because of her immunity to magical hits. Historia power shouldnt suffice. Full power august attack with ds will take irene out of dragon form. But if he wasting that energy making powerful historia, historia attack power wont be equal to august attack power.

Ofcourse can even august use historia.
The guy has yet to use copied magic which is not exactly of his opponent at that cirrent time.
He needed brandish to shrink his wound.
Didnt refract any cana cards
He didnt use slowing magic of racer either. And he couldnt read gildart mind at all

Only thing he managed to retain was meteor. Or something that might be meteor. Since no name was used.


Serena stronger than erza. Lol
What's next, gmg rufus stronger than gmg jura

Nah, Cana is above even Kyoka now, Azuma's nothin' to her.
Besides, even with Gildarts+Kana's attacks August was barely scratched.

August has access to the many hundreds or possibly thousands of Dragon Slayers Eileen's met, summoning a dozen of those should do just fine. In fact considering broken Erza and worn out Wendy could oneshot Eileen out of dragon form, God Serena's offense alone should do the trick. I could see him beating broken Erza and worn out Wendy fairly easily. After all, even the likes of Kyoka, Azuma and Ikaruga dealt with injured Erza pretty well.

 

[sharkai]

Nah, Cana is above even Kyoka now, Azuma's nothin' to her.
Besides, even with Gildarts+Kana's attacks August was barely scratched.

August has access to the many hundreds or possibly thousands of Dragon Slayers Eileen's met, summoning a dozen of those should do just fine. In fact considering broken Erza and worn out Wendy could oneshot Eileen out of dragon form, God Serena's offense alone should do the trick. I could see him beating broken Erza and worn out Wendy fairly easily. After all, even the likes of Kyoka, Azuma and Ikaruga dealt with injured Erza pretty well.

Cana above koyoka. Lol.
But possible
Since we know elfmen plus lissana is above goi by a fair amount.
So it is indeed possible.

That attack made august commit suicide

But august has shown nothing. So i wonder if he keeps any magic at all. The guy couldnt even read gildart mind.

What are talking about broken erza about? We already know how hard she hit. She can over power irene or august top tier move.
God serena is nowhere near that. Let alone erza brute strength plus wendy ds enchant

 

[Seven777]

Cana above koyoka. Lol.
But possible
Since we know elfmen plus lissana is above goi by a fair amount.
So it is indeed possible.

Ha, yeah, pretty sad.

That attack made august commit suicide

As @Laxus chan-yo pointed out, it looks like August was already gonna try that before Gildarts interrupted him. Plus Acno is nearby, August has to save his daddy before its too late.

But august has shown nothing. So i wonder if he keeps any magic at all. The guy couldnt even read gildart mind.

Used Melt without copying anyone...... unless you're saying he actually did copy Natsu and knows DS magic.....

What are talking about broken erza about? We already know how hard she hit. She can over power irene or august top tier move.
God serena is nowhere near that. Let alone erza brute strength plus wendy ds enchant

So you're sayin broken Erza>>>God Serena's lol? The woman who had an extreme diff fight with an Elfman+Lisanna tier opponent? If she was really that much stronger than God Serena she wouldve oneshot Azir the moment the battle started.
Overpower? You saying Erza's offense>Eileens? She didnt overpower Sema, she didnt push back the blast wave Sema creates. She slashed it out of the sky before it landed. Its impressive, but it doesnt put her offense on par with EIleen's or even close to it.
We already know that it was Eileen's incredible weakness to DS magic that caused the oneshot, not Erza's actual offensive ability. Just look at how ineffective her attacks were on human Eileen. She went from barely affecting human Eileen to oneshotting her outa dragon mode. DS advantage is obviously the cause of this colossal difference in performance. So yeah, if broken Erza can oneshot Eileen with DS advantage then any decent fighter with DS advantage can do the same.

 

[Natsu Goatneel]

View media item 21464View media item 21465

No it isnt. Neinhart himself technically copied DS magic by creating God Serena

We know nothing of the basis of Neinhart's magic. Fact is, Neinhart himself didn't use the magic. Historia can be similar to Edo Tensei. That's not copying DS magic.

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 20, 2017, Original Post Date: Mar 20, 2017 ---

Funny cuz if that's the case she would have fodderized erza and Wendy but she couldn't Full power god serena plus august will be too much for Irene

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 20, 2017, Original Post Date: Mar 20, 2017 ---

He saw god serena use his DS magic all he has to do is see their magic and it's instantly copied historia Serena>>Wendy and she couldn't fodderized her him and august together trashes irene

Serena can't fodderize them either lol so I'm missing your point...

The entire fight was PIS. Oh and Irene actually did fodderize them while in HUMAN form right before the flashback of her past. Erza tried an attack and Irene moved so fast that Erza had no time to react to Eileen appearing right in front of her. She could've easily killed Erza right then and there but PLOT of course.

 

[sharkai]

Ha, yeah, pretty sad.

As @Laxus chan-yo pointed out, it looks like August was already gonna try that before Gildarts interrupted him. Plus Acno is nearby, August has to save his daddy before its too late.

Used Melt without copying anyone...... unless you're saying he actually did copy Natsu and knows DS magic.....

So you're sayin broken Erza>>>God Serena's lol? The woman who had an extreme diff fight with an Elfman+Lisanna tier opponent? If she was really that much stronger than God Serena she wouldve oneshot Azir the moment the battle started.
Overpower? You saying Erza's offense>Eileens? She didnt overpower Sema, she didnt push back the blast wave Sema creates. She slashed it out of the sky before it landed. Its impressive, but it doesnt put her offense on par with EIleen's or even close to it.
We already know that it was Eileen's incredible weakness to DS magic that caused the oneshot, not Erza's actual offensive ability. Just look at how ineffective her attacks were on human Eileen. She went from barely affecting human Eileen to oneshotting her outa dragon mode. DS advantage is obviously the cause of this colossal difference in performance. So yeah, if broken Erza can oneshot Eileen with DS advantage then any decent fighter with DS advantage can do the same.

I could use some actual hint in the panel. Something like august saying he doesnt have time for this.
without those hints its look like august actually needed arse magic

Yeah, he seems to have some magic like melt and arse magic. But he hasnt actually copied other people magic who werent near him. People just assumed he used meteor.

Yes, that is mary sue for you, amplified by nakama power. She didnt just knock it out of the sky. You cant knock spell out of the sky. You over power them. That is why irene was shitting herself.
The blast you speak of is the extra energy. The main point is exactly where erza struck. Thats where majority of the power is. Deus sema isnt attack where irene have to miss her target. She actually would prefer it fall on the target head.

Erza was full of pof, no ds other than aconologia and natsu with severe pof can do it.

 

[LaGOAT]

Congratulations they was less than 2 meters away from each other but I let that silde. She blitzes erza who is weaker than god serena. never did I say god serena fodderized them I said Irene couldn't. Irene isn't oneshoting god serena she ain't acnologia tier. Him and august is too much for her

 

[Jko]

Irene pushed back Acno, and dodged his attack, Serena was fodderize. Irene tears Serena a new one. Plot Force >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Serena and August. If you actually think an enemy could beat plot force empowered Erza you're kidding yourself. He couldn't even take down PF Cana and you think he can take the Queen?

 

[Ebony Maw]

Irene pushed back Acno, and dodged his attack, Serena was fodderize

That isn't a fair comparison. When Irene went up against Acno he was just playing, on the other hand God Serena was up against a serious "my objective is to end you" Acno. Had Acno been anywhere near non-casual, Irene would have been fodderized just as badly as Serena.

Irene tears Serena a new one. Plot Force >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Serena and August. If you actually think an enemy could beat plot force empowered Erza you're kidding yourself.

How is Irene tearing Serena a new one when one slash from an enchanted sword knocked her out of dragon mode? Serena can rapidly spam his spells, and the only one that seems to have some sort of build up is his Gale Dragon's roar. I'm not trying to downplay Irene here, she was beat due to crap loads of BS, but how are we supposed to guess what can knock her out of dragon mode if we ignore the only instance of it happening?

He couldn't even take down PF Cana and you think he can take the Queen?

Um, August didn't even try to touch Cana until the end of their fight, and the second he did try he effortlessly blitzed her. On top of this, he was throwing around an enraged Gildarts with sheer ease. Cana is so far below him it's not even funny, you can't even try to use her as an argument when it's clear as daylight that he destroys her. Oh, and this was an August that was basically toying with them, had August been serious he could have just used Melt or any of the other magics he had.

Edit: I actually went back just to check, had Gildarts not been there August would have killed her with an unnamed magical blast from his staff after he blitzed her. And even then, Gildarts was only OK because August's blast hit him in an area Acnologia had taken before,

 

[Ilikeyou]

Actually if the Erza fight never happen. I would not think Irene would get the Serena treatment from a serious acno. She will still lose but it wouldnt be a one shot.