Discussion Boycotting the Summer Olympics in China?

Digital_Eon

Proofreader
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2007
Messages
1,140
Reaction score
70
Age
36
Gender
Female
Country
Canada
Dalai Lama doesn't support independence for Tibet but an authonomy (I think).
Yup. Which makes me wonder why Chinese government officials are calling him a devil and saying he's behind all this. Apparently, the Tibetans want something completely different from him.

I don't think that boycotting the Olympics is the solution. As mentioned before, it isn't fair to the athletes, who have trained for this and honestly don't have a choice in where the Olympics is held. There are other ways to express disapproval at a nation's doings, after all.

That said, here's an interesting article from Maclean's on the subject of China and Tibet. I think the writer makes a very interesting point when he says that China's afraid of small groups because they could disrupt the government and even take over China - because in the past, they have.
 

roku-sky

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2007
Messages
216
Reaction score
60
Gender
Hidden
Country
Canada
You know, the first post does make an interesting point - there are a host of issues that needs to be addressed in China. I personally think Tibet is the least of those issues... and that it is rather bad they are hijacking the entire centre stage and spotlight. Environmental issues will eventually put billions of people in danger - has that been covered much? Nope. All everyone talks about is Tibet :/

I mean, I do agree that Olympics should not be politicized and all, but at the same time those issues are still present in the country regardless of the Olympics. When the spotlight is on them, it offers a great way to raise awareness. But I can't help but feel false awareness is being fostered, on an issue that isn't the business of other countries, and that really - nothing constructive comes from Tibet protests. Only results I see is just more hate :(
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I personally think Tibet is the least of those issues...
The least of issues?? i personally do not agree. Especially when it come down to the issue of independence..

Environmental issues will eventually put billions of people in danger - has that been covered much?
is this always been the main topic and also a problem for every single country.. Though you got a point, but can you show some proffs that China do not cover environmental issues... though this may not be the right thread to discuss this..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environment_of_China
anyway, here is some of the things that China did do to cover environmental issues... why single out only china.. while the rest of the world have pretty much the same problem..

But I can't help but feel false awareness is being fostered, on an issue that isn't the business of other countries, and that really - nothing constructive comes from Tibet protests. Only results I see is just more hate :(
This last statement i agree, and it already is a reality..
 
Last edited:

roku-sky

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2007
Messages
216
Reaction score
60
Gender
Hidden
Country
Canada
nonono... For the environment, I meant if it was covered by the news media - and there's little attention focused on this growing problem in China in comparison to what we hear nowadays about Tibet. I find these environmental issues much more important than Tibet, which I'm so sick of hearing about on the news.

I don't really see why Tibet is an issue - its just a part of China. Britain invaded there in 1900s when China was falling apart, convinced them to declare independence in 1913, which they did. And eventually China reclaimed it in 1950s. What issue? Brits and other colonial forces were causing a whole bunch of disruptions in Asia during that time (including shipping opium into China, burning Beijing... read Asian history for more info) - I find that to be a bigger injustice. Hong Kong only came back to Chinese control in 1997 if y'all recall. Tibet has been a part of China since before the Americas were discovered. China ain't gonna let it go anytime, same as America ain't gonna give all their land back to the native Indians, or give Texas and Hawaii independence and whatnot. People don't seem to understand that its never been an "occupation" in Tibet, the area is a part of the country. They just got it back after it was taken from them in an ultimately failed coup to break China apart.

Like I said before, I think its ultimately the Western media that has been raising these false awareness of what Tibet really is. This whole pro-Tibet debate is just a waste of time in my eyes - nothing is going to change, except more hate mongering. Unless that was the initial goal in the first place. :/
 

link777

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
90
Reaction score
1
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
Costa Rica
Nothing good comes with violence, Gandhi style rules!!!
 

miyi

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Tibet has been a part of China since before the Americas were discovered. China ain't gonna let it go anytime, same as America ain't gonna give all their land back to the native Indians, or give Texas and Hawaii independence and whatnot. People don't seem to understand that its never been an "occupation" in Tibet, the area is a part of the country. They just got it back after it was taken from them in an ultimately failed coup to break China apart.
Tibet wants autonomy, and you can argue it's almost nearly as if to say they want to be "apart" from Chinese identity.

In America, you have legal, as well as illegal immigrants flowing into America, to become part of America. You don't see them protesting for autonomy nor independence. Your example does not match with reality, and the point I want to illustrate here is that perhaps, just perhaps, the Tibetans have a legitimate argument for wanting autonomy. Perhaps it's due to their resentment over unfair Chinese rule. Why else would they protest in the first place? If the Chinese government were fair to them, perhaps it would be a different story.
 

roku-sky

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2007
Messages
216
Reaction score
60
Gender
Hidden
Country
Canada
Well, part of the problem is the whole Western world is encouraging them to protest, really. Throw the word "freedom" around and everyone gets riled up, no matter how inappropriate (or foolish). Its become a vicious circle.

So you may ask why did they start protesting in the first place? I didn't really want to bring that whole debate here, but if you read back to the events leading up to 1959, you clearly see CIA involvement in the revolts. If you recall, when China reclaimed Tibet it was at the height of the Cold War. Any power gain by Communists countries were seen as a threat - naturally CIA would try to intervene. So for evidence - I actually found some on the internet, surprisingly: http://www.state.gov/www/about_state/history/vol_xxx/337_343.html

These documents (from your own government website, by the way) show CIA incited propaganda and revolts during that time. I suspect there is still CIA involvement seeing as all these Free-Tibet groups seem to have bottomless wallets (read some of the protesters were paid 300 euros a day to just be there). That is the reason for China's hate for the Dalai Lama, they see him as still part of the CIA plot to disrupt their country and he is probably still getting money from them nowadays to travel around making speeches. Bottomline? Resistance and hate has been constructed, fanned, encouraged. And now, continually fueled by the western media.
 
Last edited:

miyi

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Well, part of the problem is the whole Western world is encouraging them to protest, really. Throw the word "freedom" around and everyone gets riled up, no matter how inappropriate (or foolish). Its become a vicious circle.

So you may ask why did they start protesting in the first place? I didn't really want to bring that whole debate here, but if you read back to the events leading up to 1959, you clearly see CIA involvement in the revolts. If you recall, when China reclaimed Tibet it was at the height of the Cold War. Any power gain by Communists countries were seen as a threat - naturally CIA would try to intervene. So for evidence - I actually found some on the internet, surprisingly: http://www.state.gov/www/about_state/history/vol_xxx/337_343.html

These documents (from your own government website, by the way) show CIA incited propaganda and revolts during that time. I suspect there is still CIA involvement seeing as all these Free-Tibet groups seem to have bottomless wallets (read some of the protesters were paid 300 euros a day to just be there). That is the reason for China's hate for the Dalai Lama, they see him as still part of the CIA plot to disrupt their country and he is probably still getting money from them nowadays to travel around making speeches. Bottomline? Resistance and hate has been constructed, fanned, encouraged. And now, continually fueled by the western media.
Yes, it is no secret of the CIA's role backing the Free Tibet Movement and the Dalai Lama during the Cold War, but that program was shut down years ago. It was a failed US policy, and the Chinese were able to reclaim Tibet and rule it since. Recently, the Chinese built railways between 2001 to 2007 in Tibet making troop deployment far easier, as a means to clamp down Tibetan resistance in a swift manner. This railway construction, of course, is portrayed by the Chinese media as part of it's modernizing policies in Tibet. The fact remains that their domestic policy towards Tibet is that of repression and some would say, tyrannical.

In the first half of the 20th Century, Tibet was a de facto independent nation, but as soon as the Chiang Kai Shek nationalist were replaced by Communism, Tibet was subservient to Chinese rule, and still to this day. No doubt, the CIA played a role in assisting Tibetan resistance movements as part of US policy to undermine Chinese Communism, and I would argue that politically, the US was right in supporting Tibet on this issue, since it served to the best interest of US strategically during the Cold War against Chinese Communist threat, as you said.

The moral side of the argument is China's repressive domestic policies towards Tibetans. But I'm not arguing about the politics, I'm arguing about the moral issues, specifically the human rights abuse. If China is to host the Olympics, then it serves their interest to revamp their world image by improving their human rights record, not the other way around.

Personally I would like to see China make some compromises with the Tibetan people. Give them some sense of autonomy, encourage the preservation of Tibetan culture, allow them to self-govern to a certain extent. In return -- and perhaps the only possible solution to this conflict -- is for Tibetans to still accept Chinese rule. I would hate for the violence to further escalate, knowing that the international community will be able to do so little to assist Tibetans without engaing in full scale war against China. A lot is at stake here, and it's important that both sides work out their differences under a workable solution without resorting to violence, but both sides must make compromises.

I recommend this comprehensive case study on this issue:
http://cc.purdue.edu/~wtv/tibet/article/art4.html


And while the Western media is as expected very critical of China in how they've handled this issue, you can argue the same point with the Chinese media, which apparently seeks to demonize the protesting Tibetans.

Lastly, while the CIA may very well have a hand in this (although I doubt they did), even the Dalai Lama himself have publicly denied any involvement in the Tibetan protests. It is quite possible that the Chinese government have attempted to sell that argument to justify their decisive clamping down of these protests, as yet another anti-Chinese Dalai Lama-backed revolt.
 
Last edited:

BoXs

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Dec 31, 2007
Messages
19
Reaction score
1
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
I hear all these human right abuse in Tibets ... but I really don't know what kind of abuse they are @@' ...

and the railroad was made partly for military use, but it is also for transporting goods ... I mean which big/medium sized cities doesn't have a rail road? ... no goods can come in and out means no export and imports means less jobs means people would be poorer means ... you get the rest XD
 
Last edited:

miyi

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I hear all these human right abuse in Tibets ... but I really don't know what kind of abuse they are @@' ...

From Human Rights Watch:
(New York, August 2, 2007) – China’s dire human rights record and a renewed crackdown on media freedom may spoil the government’s hopes of a successful “coming out party” at the Beijing Olympics, which begin in a year, Human Rights Watch said today.

A year before the August 8, 2008 opening ceremonies for the Beijing Olympics, the Chinese government shows no substantive progress in addressing long-standing human rights concerns. Instead, apparently more worried about political stability, Beijing is tightening its grip on domestic human rights defenders, grassroots activists and media to choke off any possible expressions of dissent ahead of the Games.

“Instead of a pre-Olympic ‘Beijing spring’ of greater freedom and tolerance of dissent, we are seeing the gagging of dissidents, a crackdown on activists, and attempts to block independent media coverage,” said Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “The government seems afraid that its own citizens will embarrass it by speaking out about political and social problems, but China’s leaders apparently don’t realize authoritarian crackdowns are even more embarrassing.”

China has a well-documented history of serious human rights abuses, including widespread torture, censorship of the media and internet, controls on religious freedom, and repression of ethnic minorities in Tibet and Xinjiang.

China continues to lead the world in executions. The government classifies the number of people executed as a state secret, but it is believed that China executes many more people than the rest of the world combined each year. Most trials are deeply flawed, as the accused often do not have access to adequate defense counsel, trials are usually closed to the public, evidence is often obtained through torture, and the appellate process lacks needed safeguards. China’s courts lack independence, as they remain controlled by the government and ruling Chinese Communist Party.

But the staging of the Olympics is exacerbating problems of forced evictions, migrant labor rights abuses, and the use of house arrests to silence political opponents. The government is continuing its crackdown on lawyers, human rights defenders and activists who dedicate themselves to rule of law and the exposure of rights abuses. Fear of citizen activism has led to government obstruction of local activists and grassroots organizations working to stem China’s HIV/AIDS epidemic.

Fears of harm to China’s national image have even led Chinese officials to stop prominent activists from leaving the country. Among them, Hu Jia and Zeng Jinyan, a husband-and-wife team of human rights activists, have been clamped under house arrest and travel restrictions since May on unsubstantiated suspicions of “harming state security.” Dr. Jiang Yanyong, a courageous surgeon who exposed the government’s cover-up of the 2003 SARS outbreak, has been denied permission to travel to the US in December to receive a New York Academy of Sciences human rights award.

The victims of government retribution against perceived “troublemakers” often include those who devote themselves to defending some of China’s most marginalized and vulnerable citizens. Chen Guangcheng, a blind, self-educated lawyer who documented abuses of China’s family planning law, was convicted in August 2006 of instigating an attack on government offices in a sham trial in which his lawyers were physically attacked and then detained by police to prevent them from attending. Gao Zhisheng, an outspoken advocate of the rights of human rights abusers said in April 2007 that he agreed to write a confession to charges of sedition leveled at him in December 2006 only after he had been tortured and security officials had threatened his wife and children.

“Political repression is not in keeping with the behavior of a responsible power and Olympic host,” said Adams. “The Chinese government shouldn’t waste this unique opportunity to use the 2008 Games to demonstrate to the world it is serious about improving the rights situation in China.”

Human Rights Watch said that China’s close relationship with dictatorships and rights- abusing governments in places like Sudan, Burma, Cambodia and Zimbabwe will also come under close scrutiny in the coming year.

With one year to go before the Olympics launch, “The starting gun has been fired on the assessment of China’s commitment to rights at home and abroad,” said Adams. “Just as Chinese citizens will be rooting for their athletes to win medals, we are rooting for the Chinese government to move up in the league tables on rights protection.”

More background on major areas for human rights reform in the Olympic run-up:

# Forced evictions and school closures. The construction of facilities for the 2008 Olympic Games in Beijing has involved forced evictions of thousands of citizens in and around Beijing, often without adequate compensation or access to new housing. The pre-Olympic “clean-up” of Beijing has resulted in the closure of dozens of officially unregistered schools for the children of migrant workers.

# Labor rights abuses. Thousands of migrant workers employed on Olympic and other construction sites across Beijing do not receive legally mandated pay and benefits including labor insurance and days off, and are often compelled to do dangerous work without adequate safeguards.

# Repression of ethnic minorities. China continues to use the “war on terrorism” to justify policies to eradicate the “three evil forces” – terrorism, separatism, and religious extremism – allegedly prevalent among Uighurs, a Turkic-speaking Muslim population in China’s Xinjiang Uighur Autonomous Region. Uighurs who express “separatist” tendencies are routinely sentenced to quick, secret and summary trials, sometimes accompanied by mass sentencing rallies. The death penalty is common. In Tibet, Chinese authorities still view the Dalai Lama, in exile in India since 1959, as central to the effort to separate Tibet from China and view Tibetan Buddhist belief as supportive of these efforts. Suspected “separatists,” many of whom come from monasteries and nunneries, are routinely imprisoned.

# Controls on religious freedom. China does not recognize freedom of religion outside the state-controlled system in which all congregations, mosques, temples, churches and monasteries must register. The government also curtails religious freedom by designating and repressing some groups as “cults,” such as the Falungong.

# The death penalty and executions. The government does not publicize figures for the death penalty, but it is mandated for no fewer than 68 crimes. Though the exact number is a state secret, it is estimated that as many as 10,000 executions are carried out each year.

# HIV/AIDS rights advocacy obstruction. Measures to address China’s HIV/AIDS crisis are hampered as local officials and security forces continue to obstruct efforts by activists and grassroots organizations to contribute to prevention and education efforts and to organize care-giving.

# Use of house arrest system. Numerous human rights defenders and government critics have been harassed, detained and subject to house arrest. If today’s pattern holds, a pre-Olympic clampdown in the weeks and months before the Games is likely.

# Ties with rights violators. China’s close relations with countries linked to severe, ongoing human rights violations are also a serious source of concern. China maintains relations with and provides aid to regimes including Sudan, the site of egregious human rights violations in Darfur, and Burma, whose military junta violently suppresses civilians. China has also not ratified the International Covenant on Political and Civil Rights, which it signed in 1998.


Here's another report ---> from Amnesty International USA


I'm wondering, how many people actually read all the articles I hyperlink? These are educational stuff, I urge everyone to at least skim through it, they are top-notch articles. :D


China's very own human rights NGO, the China Society for Human Rights Studies, predictably refuted Amnesty International's report on the issue of the Tibetan protests last March at Lhasa, and claims that the analysis were distorted and flawed, and fails to recognize that the protesters were actually "criminals" who were in fact, the abusers of human rights.

Hmm....go figure.


and the railroad was made partly for military use, but it is also for transporting goods ... I mean which big/medium sized cities doesn't have a rail road? ... no goods can come in and out means no export and imports means less jobs means people would be poorer means ... you get the rest XD
I understand that. Indeed the Chinese government would argue that the railroad was built for beneficial purposes, like you said. I accept that.

But at the same time, it can also be argued that the construction of this railway was politically calculated to ensure rapid deployment of Chinese troops so they can effectively monitor future potential unrest.
 

BoXs

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Dec 31, 2007
Messages
19
Reaction score
1
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
I read the first one briefly ... and read a few pages for the other one ... finish it after exam ... but the first one doesn't really address my question ... I was asking about human right abuse just in Tibet and not in other parts of China since he protesters were always talking about human right abuse in Tibet only :/ Maybe it is in the other article ... read after exam XD

From the first article ... there are few interesting points that kind of made me question it ... like saying the moved people away for the Olympics and not give them a home ... the thing is ... China recently moved enteir city just to make way for the new dam's water route ... an entire city compare to a few thousands of people ... if China can do that ... I doubt they cannot give those people a home right? ... also about that labour right abuse thingy ... I do not think they are stupid enough to not pay those construction workers well for this Olympic game they are so proud of that they are willing to traing thousands and thousands of people who would only serve in those 14 days ... I am not talking 1 to 3 weeks training ... I am talking more than a year long ... they are willing to spend that much for training itself ... logically there would be no reason to cut budget on the construction workers ... if they are willing to spend millions on training alone ... I think those people who abuse the labour law are normal employers which I am not surprise lol ... but definitly not the Chinese government ... they are not stupid to risk getting bashed by the world when money ... which they have a lot ... can solve the issue before hand ...

I rather have registered religion than a cult like Falungong ... that religion advised people not to go to doctors but instead go to them for like ... spiritual heal ... lol ... donate like mad ... thus now the leader is living in the States ... very well off too ... lol ... if you research that religion ... it is really more like a money digging one than an acutally religion ... even in today's society I think religion and politics never go well together just look back in history ... if a religion have too much power ... it is never good for the country ... at least this is what I learned from some old history ... can't point out a good one now ... but even the communism guy saw that ... thus communism doesn't allow religion

Back to study! XD so won't be responding anytime soon
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
. I was asking about human right abuse just in Tibet and not in other parts of China since he protesters were always talking about human right abuse in Tibet only :/ Maybe it is in the other article ... read after exam XD
Well, the article from Amnesty International does a pretty good job of summing up the violations in Tibet. Arbitrary arrests, shooting protesters, etc... It's not pretty. While not a human rights violation, not letting in foreign news media into the area seems suspect.
From the first article ... there are few interesting points that kind of made me question it ... like saying the moved people away for the Olympics and not give them a home ... the thing is ... China recently moved enteir city just to make way for the new dam's water route ... an entire city compare to a few thousands of people ... if China can do that ... I doubt they cannot give those people a home right? ... also about that labour right abuse thingy ... I do not think they are stupid enough to not pay those construction workers well for this Olympic game they are so proud of that they are willing to traing thousands and thousands of people who would only serve in those 14 days ... I am not talking 1 to 3 weeks training ... I am talking more than a year long ... they are willing to spend that much for training itself ... logically there would be no reason to cut budget on the construction workers ... if they are willing to spend millions on training alone ... I think those people who abuse the labour law are normal employers which I am not surprise lol ... but definitly not the Chinese government ... they are not stupid to risk getting bashed by the world when money ... which they have a lot ... can solve the issue before hand ...
You see, it's not so much a belief thing.... It's a fact. While I usually don't ally myself with Amnesty International or the Human Rights Watch, (they spend more time collecting violations by the US and Israel then they do for countries like Iran.... I don't refute the accuracy of these reports, I just dislike that they aren't going after countries that line up and kill homosexuals or deny that the Holocaust didn't happen), the facts are the facts. It's not unprecedented for governments to not pay up.... there was the US's "40 Acres and a Mule", Germany after WWI, etc... (To be fair, the US never officially said it would give each slave 40 acres and a mule, and Germany got a raw deal in the Treaty, but the main point is: governments are known for nonpayment.) And the PRC is doing plenty of stupid things right before the Olympics...shooting protesters for example.

Seriously, how did Beijing get the Olympics? What was the Committee thinking? "There hasn't been enough violent protests during the Olympics... let's give it to China!"

@ Miyi

I usually read the articles you post. They are always incredibly informative, but way too long! And I agree, the CIA's involvement in the "Free Tibet" movement is pretty much common knowledge.

The interesting thing about that HRW article is that it's from last August. Months before the latest Tibet debacle, it was apparent that China had issues with human rights still.
 

miyi

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
United States
@ Miyi

I usually read the articles you post. They are always incredibly informative, but way too long!
Yeah, I don't really read everything myself, otherwise I'd be reading all day.


here's another good article from Newsweek:

http://www.newsweek.com/id/129619


@BoXs:

I didn't have time to read the Michael Parenti piece in full, but it's a religious argument that I don't necessarily want to get into. That's another argument entirely.

[edit]

@BoXs:
btw, I finally read the pbs forum debate you posted (all 7 pages! geez, those guys write so much!)....the discussion specifically between M.A. Jones and David Meanwell from the Tibet Urgent Response Network is very rich and informative as well as entertaining.

M.A.Jones initially, I think, had the upper hand of the debate, but towards the end he resorted to ad hominem tactics that diminished his position. David Meanwell imo won the debate.

Nevertheless, both sides presented point of views to the issue that I haven't earlier considered. It appears to be the case, that there is certainly Western media bias that is largely pro-Tibetan cause, and on the other side of the specturm, there is also a pro-Chinese bias.

I think any honest researcher concerning China and Tibet have a responsibility to uphold paying attention to both sides, sticking to facts and steering away from bias and misinformation. That said, that does not take away from the fact that human rights continue to persist to this day, and measures to address these issues is urgent.

In regards to the Michael Parenti piece, he touched on the Tibetan Buddhism pre-Communism rule, and their feudalism practices, citing atrocities of Tibetan religious elites towards their own people.

While this is true, I would argue, which David Meanwell does likewise, that the atrocities under Chinese repression after their take-over up to the present, is comparitively more intense.

But that isn't the issue, this isn't about comparing the two systems. The issue here is about how to address human rights at present, and what the Chinese government is doing to address the situation.

By continuing to repress basic human rights, such as freedom of expression, press, fair trial, religious expression, and so on, in addition to the fact that they continue to be non-transparent (withholding evidence of their practices from public), in my view perpetuates human rights abuse. By denying these rights not only for Tibet, but as well as to the Chinese people, further diminishes China's credibility in the eyes of Western countries, in regards to human rights.

The goal should not be to demonize either side, but to find ways to solve the conflict and to find a common ground. I think it will be to China's best interest to make concessions in the plight of Tibetans, while at the same time still maintain sovereign control of the region, which would make both sides happy. I am sure that all Tibetans are desperately in want of, is simply more freedom and autonomy. I'm also aware that Chinese policies have, in some aspects, actually benefitted Tibetans, such as the building of the railway which allows food, goods, etc., to be transported. This is progress. But let's not understate the Tibetan plight, nor should we exagerrate them (as M.A.Jones argues). I don't think Tibet should necessarily secede from China, unless that is what they want. From my understanding, they merely want autonomy, so why shouldn't China give that to them? They have more to gain than to lose from this. A healthier Tibet probably translates into an overall healthier China.
 
Last edited:

Windmillblade

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
9
Age
41
Gender
Male
Country
United States
likewise. there wrong dude
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
likewise. there wrong dude

huh?? sorry i didn't understand you, do you meant "they're most likely at fault??"

If that what you meant, I am agree, but do you ever have a "speech" class where they teach you saying "I feel that you are wrong" than "you are wrong, so dang wrong"

that what the west is doing to china, and doesn't matter who is right or wrong the chinese gov.. will get defensive and the matter will not progress in a way that benefit both..

EDIT:
http://sports.yahoo.com/olympics/news?slug=jo-olyboycott041508&prov=yhoo&type=lgns
this article has some good points..
 
Last edited:

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
we need for the games to go on, china has great influence over us, which could be a big problem if we piss um' off
 

lordHokage

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
4,697
Reaction score
421
Gender
Female
Country
Bahamas
Well, since China wants to have their cake and eat it too, I fully support a boycott of the Chinese Olympics by all nations, but unfortunately, I don’t see that happening in my life time. :blink
 
Top