I thought you said Age Scratch has no limit because it wasn't stated to have one. If it doesn't have a limit then it should work on Acno as well and not just on Laxus. I dunno about you but I find it very hard to believe Dimaria can replicate all the damage Acno received in his life (400 years full of fighting countless Dragon Slayers, Dragons and tanking spells from Irene who is canonically much stronger than Dimaria) with just one casual spell.
Age Scratch isn't even her strongest spell. What did Dimaria accomplish with her full power attack then? Pushing back TO Chelia who was shielded by Base Wendy?
Since Age Scratch is weaker and contains less MP than her full power attack, which didn't really hinder even TO Chelia, I believe it wouldn't even remotely hurt Acno. No matter what it's effect on much weaker characters is.
Also, Irene's spells > Age Scratch. If Acno can laugh off Irene's spells, he'd laugh off Age Scratch as well. Simple as that.
He did. But the war probably wasn't a walk in the park for him. He faced Prime Igneel. He dealt heavy blows and took heavy blows. Blows I have trouble seeing Dimaria replicating with her level of MP. Much less with one casual spell.
Acno coming out of that war unscathed would not only make him look more impressive than he already is, but it would also show just how weak Dimaria is compared to him.
Against Prime Igneel and the foster Dragons at least during the Dragon Civil War I'd imagine he did go all out. He might've held back against half-dead Igneel. But even that Igneel is leaps and bounds above anything Dimaria can do so whether or not he was holding back is irrelevant.
Also, again, claiming Acno wasn't going all out during that war would only make him look even more impressive than he already is.
I brought her in to point out how strong Acno is compared to Dimaria and how ridiculous the idea of Age Scratch affecting him to the extent you think it can, is.
If Irene can't do shit to him as far as physical and/or mental damage goes, Dimaria can't either. It's not rocket science.
Even if August could hurt Acno it wouldn't prove Dimaria could too with her Age Scratch (which, again, isn't even her strongest spell) since August is much stronger than Dimaria.
That's portrayal bro. Zeref is portrayed to have a chance at killing Acno only with "infinite" Magic. Without it, he doesn't. He has an empire and he still goes for Fairy Heart. That just shows how big the gap is between Acno and Dimaria.
We know Acno ruled
the world for years with no trace of Zeref, his empire or FT. That's enough for me.
Only makes him look more impressive.
Fairy Law, like Age Scratch, wasn't stated to have a limit. If Acno
doesn't end up like Jose, than FL
does have a limit. If even Etherion wouldn't put him down why do you think Dimaria would make him feel pain with one casual spell?
You have also yet to prove Age Scratch would work on Acno. All you got is the fact that it wasn't
mentioned to have a limit. How that proves it would hurt him is beyond me tbh.
Never claimed he was.
I brought Acno, Irene and Zeref to prove Age Scratch does in fact have limits. Acno's got the best feats and portrayal in the manga by far. Dimaria making him feel pain with one casual spell while characters much stronger than her couldn't do so doesn't sound right in my head.
Never said Laxus wouldn't be affected by Age Scratch. He would. If it even lands that is. But the way I see it, the amount of pain he'd feel from that shouldn't surpass the amount of pain he'd feel if he's hit by one of Assault Wahl's spells. Which are definitely tankable for someone like him.
By that logic, Laxus can one-shot Acno with FL. Franmalth can absorb his spells, GMG Erza's Nakagami can dispel (and thus overpower) his roars, Seilah can control him and Mard can erase him from existence.
See how wrong the logic of "this spell wasn't mentioned to have a limit, therefore it doesn't have one" sounds?
>Age Scratch not having a limit simply because it wasn't stated to have one.
>Logic.
Personally, I'd go with logic. Yes. Even FT has some kind of logic behind it. Such as Acno being miles ahead of Dimaria in every possible way.
