Fantasy (Human) Selene vs Eileen

Who wins, and with what difficulty?


  • Total voters
    53

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,061
Reaction score
1,112
Age
36
Country
United States
It's handling them though.
not really. basically if enchnace erza is not interested in jellal, then he could handle her

Never said that, also never claimed that I've said that.
then we know you are bais. selective powercreep effect

Acno snores harder than Eileen can attack.

I do and he is.
nope, we saw aconologia trying to resist eileen nuke

I ain't the one claiming EIleen is stronger than a human Acno tier lmao.
i aint the one claiming Suzaku is stronger than human Acno tier lol

Not the same because Erza got up and fucked Eileen. Georg stayed down. If I'm going to say Selene gets oneshot by Suzaku, I'm going to need to see it.
plot. even ROT acnologia cant kill erza.
same for me. if suzaku can one shot dragon eileen, i am going to need to see it.

You don't believe that.
i believe its pof eos erza
pof eos erza>>>>>suzaku

It's fire. It would roast Bloodman alive.
fire is physical
So was Selene lmao.
revealing what, her hand? acnologia was revealing he was dragon magic

Why is Lucy?
lucy and laxus are relevant because they are not fodders now.

%1 is what Wendy was using before Eileen took control. How much she used afterwards is unknown.
i wonder how much it was

Based on his performance and hype, no, not likely.
he doesnt have much hype and perfromance. let see if laxus or erza solo one of them, then we will know dragon eileen is above them by reasonable amount
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
not really. basically if enchnace erza is not interested in jellal, then he could handle her



then we know you are bais. selective powercreep effect



nope, we saw aconologia trying to resist eileen nuke



i aint the one claiming Suzaku is stronger than human Acno tier lol



plot. even ROT acnologia cant kill erza.
same for me. if suzaku can one shot dragon eileen, i am going to need to see it.



i believe its pof eos erza
pof eos erza>>>>>suzaku



fire is physical


revealing what, her hand? acnologia was revealing he was dragon magic



lucy and laxus are relevant because they are not fodders now.



i wonder how much it was



he doesnt have much hype and perfromance. let see if laxus or erza solo one of them, then we will know dragon eileen is above them by reasonable amount
I don't really get what you mean, but sure.

How does that indicate bias? Some powercreep is high, some is low. Alvarez is on the higher end, 100YQ seems to be even greater.

And we saw Acnologia try to dodge Jellal's attacks.

Sure, that was Mashima.

Suzakua has superior feats in defeating Selene.

Ridiculous. Suzaku's feats against Selene are objectively superior to any character bar Natsu. Neither Eileen nor August have accomplished anything even remotely close to what he did.

I disagree.

Revealing her dragon form.

Sure and in the same way Lucy isn't fodder, Brandish isn't fodder. There is use for them.

Who knows. Eileen will prob do something in the near future.

He's hyped as human Acno tier, defeated Selene and oneshot both Erza and Natsu. He has all the hype and performance anyone could ever need.
If Erza or Laxus solo one of them, they're not only beating Eileen because of Slayer advantage, they're just outright more powerful than she is.
 

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,061
Reaction score
1,112
Age
36
Country
United States
How does that indicate bias? Some powercreep is high, some is low. Alvarez is on the higher end, 100YQ seems to be even greater.
it shows your biasness because you literally use whatever to make your argument to your liking. alvarzec was on higher end, then gmg. 100YQ might not have any.
Just like you made your jellal above erza for defeating someone far weaker, you came out of nowwhere to say 100YQ has a huge power jump. that is it

And we saw Acnologia try to dodge Jellal's attacks.
what acnologia couldnt dodge jellal?

Sure, that was Mashima.
nope.

Suzakua has superior feats in defeating Selene.
compared to what

Ridiculous. Suzaku's feats against Selene are objectively superior to any character bar Natsu. Neither Eileen nor August have accomplished anything even remotely close to what he did.
when did other characters have this opportunity. how can we compare fairly
acno vs eileen happened. and we know even human selene to sh!t human acno because of him eating magic

we know nothing of selene.

i know why you disagree. when it comes to the character you wank. you accpet only their their strength, for those who you think are fodder, you need to pull bs out to make them weaker somehow

Revealing her dragon form.
why would she need to block natsu with her hand to turn into a dragon, she could have no sold it then turn into a dragon

Sure and in the same way Lucy isn't fodder, Brandish isn't fodder. There is use for them.
brandish is someone, who can with gajeel help, make dragon gods eat mud.

Who knows. Eileen will prob do something in the near future.
that would mean like we already now, very little magic power is enough for df nebel

He's hyped as human Acno tier, defeated Selene and oneshot both Erza and Natsu. He has all the hype and performance anyone could ever need.
If Erza or Laxus solo one of them, they're not only beating Eileen because of Slayer advantage, they're just outright more powerful than she is.
selene allowed her self to lose. dont know where he was hyped to be acno tier. everyone and their mothers can one shot erza and natsu depending on the context.
how do you make stupid like this, i never understand. if he loses to one of them that just mean him one shotting erza and natsu wasnt anything special and selene was not performing anywhere near human acno level.

if selene lost for real, and dragon weakness is the only thing that put eileen out, then we will see suzaku or his equal one shotting dragon selene
if that does not happen, one is untrue, either selene was pretending or dragon weakness is a thing you invented to dehype the bejesus out of eileen.

while all you need for jellal (a character you apparently dislike) to beat someone far weakrr than erza, to be considered above her.
 
Last edited:

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
it shows your biasness because you literally use whatever to make your argument to your liking. alvarzec was on higher end, then gmg. 100YQ might not have any.
Just like you made your jellal above erza for defeating someone far weaker, you came out of nowwhere to say 100YQ has a huge power jump. that is it



what acnologia couldnt dodge jellal?



nope.



compared to what


when did other characters have this opportunity. how can we compare fairly
acno vs eileen happened. and we know even human selene to sh!t human acno because of him eating magic

we know nothing of selene.

i know why you disagree. when it comes to the character you wank. you accpet only their their strength, for those who you think are fodder, you need to pull bs out to make them weaker somehow



why would she need to block natsu with her hand to turn into a dragon, she could have no sold it then turn into a dragon



brandish is someone, who can with gajeel help, make dragon gods eat mud.



that would mean like we already now, very little magic power is enough for df nebel



selene allowed her self to lose. dont know where he was hyped to be acno tier. everyone and their mothers can one shot erza and natsu depending on the context.
how do you make stupid like this, i never understand. if he loses to one of them that just mean him one shotting erza and natsu wasnt anything special and selene was not performing anywhere near human acno level.

if selene lost for real, and dragon weakness is the only thing that put eileen out, then we will see suzaku or his equal one shotting dragon selene
if that does not happen, one is untrue, either selene was pretending or dragon weakness is a thing you invented to dehype the bejesus out of eileen.

while all you need for jellal (a character you apparently dislike) to beat someone far weakrr than erza, to be considered above her.
Lmao, bias? Are you still going on about that? You have no leg to stand on here. You'll literally ignore what's stated about August and Eileen and claim Eileen is superior. You'll literally call Eileen's durability great for facing PoF Erza and PoF Erza's offense great for hurting Eileen, while simultaneously claiming August's durability is shit for being forced into suicide by PoF Gildarts, and PoF Erza>>>PoF Gildarts because she hurt Eileen. You're the poster child for bias.
And are you telling me you don't think Alvarez was a large jump?

He got hit.

Mashima literally states Dragon Gods are Acno tier. Then goes onto state Suzaku is on their human level. You're arguing with the manga at this point.

Exactly. Compared to what? Eileen has done literally nothing that comes close to this. Best she's done is high diff Erza and Wendy.

Natsu vs nerfed God Seed Aldaron. Suzaku did as well against Selene as Natsu did vs Aldaron.

So could Acno. Why did he dodge Jellal's first attacks? Literally no reason to. Even less than Selene blocking Natsu.

And accomplish literally nothing in the process, despite him being nerfed by his seeds. Lucy was more vital against Acnologia than anyone bar maybe Wendy.

So? Even if she only had enough MP left for one attack, that just means she can oneshot df Nebal. Not especially impressive.

I said human Acno tier.
Selene allowed herself to lose because she didn't go dragon form, per her statement.
I'm literally just restating the manga. Is the manga stupid? Sure. But it is what it is.

Not at all. Dragon Weakness can be what beat Eileen and fail to beat Selene easily. They're not the same character any more than END and Mard Geer are. This isn't something I've invented, Erza is weaker than Eileen, both before and after the fight that's just the way it is. The fact that you're not willing to accept that alone says plenty.
 

grey matter

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Dec 4, 2019
Messages
6,580
Reaction score
10,155
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
India
It's all pointless lmao. I'm 100% sure Sharkrai is smart enough to get it. He's arguing for the sake of arguing.

Lucy was more vital against Acnologia than anyone bar maybe Wendy.
And I guess Meledy.

She connected the MP from all over the continent and multiplied them. Before which, Acno was seemingly breaking apart the fairy sphere
 

Steven

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2020
Messages
2,241
Reaction score
4,008
Age
35
Country
Germany
At some point i need to accept that Irene is outdated

Featwise,Selene stomps
 

Sevently

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2017
Messages
1,316
Reaction score
1,238
Age
27
Country
France
Yep, if human Selene scale to human Acno, then she stomps Irene.
If she scale to Suzaku & BDSK, then she loose.
 

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,061
Reaction score
1,112
Age
36
Country
United States
Lmao, bias? Are you still going on about that? You have no leg to stand on here. You'll literally ignore what's stated about August and Eileen and claim Eileen is superior. You'll literally call Eileen's durability great for facing PoF Erza and PoF Erza's offense great for hurting Eileen, while simultaneously claiming August's durability is shit for being forced into suicide by PoF Gildarts, and PoF Erza>>>PoF Gildarts because she hurt Eileen. You're the poster child for bias.
And are you telling me you don't think Alvarez was a large jump?
lets replace erza with natsu here and gildarts with erza
so if pof natsu can be >> pof erza, why cant pof erza be >> pof gildarts?
did we not see erza over power eileen top tier move? did we not see dragon eileen casual move. did we see gildarts over power august top tier move? did we see august causal moves?
and then talk about poster child of bais.
august and eileen are equal, that is what was stated.

alverzec jump was huge. natsu came in and burned the entire stadium, could hear from across town, and one shot bluenote.
gmg jump was good too. we saw natsu vs max.

we have nothing for current arc, nothing. and you think its even bigger than alverzec arc jump. lol
He got hit.
was he trying to dodge too?

Mashima literally states Dragon Gods are Acno tier. Then goes onto state Suzaku is on their human level. You're arguing with the manga at this point.
mishma also said ajeel > team natsu and jura>mira+erza. i am just not gonna jump on the hype train like you. i will wait. and then even agree power creep. i am just waiting

Exactly. Compared to what? Eileen has done literally nothing that comes close to this. Best she's done is high diff Erza and Wendy.
selene might have been acting. putting suzaku far below you are ranking him

Natsu vs nerfed God Seed Aldaron. Suzaku did as well against Selene as Natsu did vs Aldaron.
again selene might be acting. we will find out by the end of selene arc

So could Acno. Why did he dodge Jellal's first attacks? Literally no reason to. Even less than Selene blocking Natsu.
look acno ate jellal attack o show he is dragon of magic. you think everyone and their mothers can no sell iron fist. i am just saying that is not the case. selene did not no sell it.

So? Even if she only had enough MP left for one attack, that just means she can oneshot df Nebal. Not especially impressive.
extremely small about of magic of eileen man. it means like bluenote causally one shotting gmg juvia or something

I said human Acno tier.
Selene allowed herself to lose because she didn't go dragon form, per her statement.
I'm literally just restating the manga. Is the manga stupid? Sure. But it is what it is.
and i am waiting. i am open to anything, but will wait till the end of the arc atleast

Not at all. Dragon Weakness can be what beat Eileen and fail to beat Selene easily. They're not the same character any more than END and Mard Geer are. This isn't something I've invented, Erza is weaker than Eileen, both before and after the fight that's just the way it is. The fact that you're not willing to accept that alone says plenty.
why? END and mard arent same. one is demon, one is some weird hybrid and not explored at all. bloodman would be a better example
unlike selene and eileen. they are both dragons. and difference is only in power. if someone weaker than human eileen can one shot her dragon form, someone around human selen should definelty one shot dragon selene

tell me how can your hypothesis of dragon eileen can be proven or dis proven

i am willing to accept that pof erza did infact over power deus sema. are you willing to accept that. if erza can over power eileen top tier move she can wreck her too. just like gildarts vs bluenote black hole. or if some attack over powers jura mt fuji, i can see that attack will wreck jura too.

i dont see why dragon weakness need to be here at all. nothing in those panels suggest eileen was weak to ds, she just seems resistance to non ds magic.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

It's all pointless lmao. I'm 100% sure Sharkrai is smart enough to get it. He's arguing for the sake of arguing.
dude you just said there is no consistencey in power scalling in fairy tail. and yet you think mishma is going to sh!t on one of the main, or family members
hell you shouldnt even be shocked if dragon eileen and dragon selene fight for a while

i told you before, search for an excuse for the good guys. any excuse to make them stronger. because mishma has to do something for the good guys to win
 

Loke

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2016
Messages
837
Reaction score
1,508
Age
30
Country
United States
Irene could land blows on Acno but due to magic immunity/resistance or whatever we couldn't really get a good gauge of her AP against god tiers. Leaning towards Selene. If all else fails, BFR gg
 

Jko

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Mar 28, 2016
Messages
7,452
Reaction score
18,778
Country
United States
Human Acno would solo the BDSK lmao.
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
lets replace erza with natsu here and gildarts with erza
so if pof natsu can be >> pof erza, why cant pof erza be >> pof gildarts?
did we not see erza over power eileen top tier move? did we not see dragon eileen casual move. did we see gildarts over power august top tier move? did we see august causal moves?
and then talk about poster child of bais.
august and eileen are equal, that is what was stated.

alverzec jump was huge. natsu came in and burned the entire stadium, could hear from across town, and one shot bluenote.
gmg jump was good too. we saw natsu vs max.

we have nothing for current arc, nothing. and you think its even bigger than alverzec arc jump. lol


was he trying to dodge too?



mishma also said ajeel > team natsu and jura>mira+erza. i am just not gonna jump on the hype train like you. i will wait. and then even agree power creep. i am just waiting



selene might have been acting. putting suzaku far below you are ranking him



again selene might be acting. we will find out by the end of selene arc



look acno ate jellal attack o show he is dragon of magic. you think everyone and their mothers can no sell iron fist. i am just saying that is not the case. selene did not no sell it.



extremely small about of magic of eileen man. it means like bluenote causally one shotting gmg juvia or something



and i am waiting. i am open to anything, but will wait till the end of the arc atleast



why? END and mard arent same. one is demon, one is some weird hybrid and not explored at all. bloodman would be a better example
unlike selene and eileen. they are both dragons. and difference is only in power. if someone weaker than human eileen can one shot her dragon form, someone around human selen should definelty one shot dragon selene

tell me how can your hypothesis of dragon eileen can be proven or dis proven

i am willing to accept that pof erza did infact over power deus sema. are you willing to accept that. if erza can over power eileen top tier move she can wreck her too. just like gildarts vs bluenote black hole. or if some attack over powers jura mt fuji, i can see that attack will wreck jura too.

i dont see why dragon weakness need to be here at all. nothing in those panels suggest eileen was weak to ds, she just seems resistance to non ds magic.
For one, Erza isn't Natsu. She doesn't have the Flame of Emotion.
Secondly, because theres nothing suggesting she is. You arbitrarily rank August's durability low because Gildarts forced him to suicide, instead of ranking Gildarts offense high like you do with Erza for what she did to Eileen. Instead you use a double standard to claim "oh, PoF Erza is just>>>Gildarts because August's durability is trash, so forcing him to suicide isn't as good a feat as cutting Eileen". No reason for it, just bias. Gildarts literally blitzed and shredded August, it's a better feat than smashing Deus Sema.

Nothing he says, after seeing Suzaku solo a human Acno tier. The disingenuousness is astounding.

Yes?

True. And if that's the case the power creep isn't as big. If she wasn't though, it is.

And why did he dodge?

Who knows.

END and Mard Geer are as similar as Selene and Eileen are. Eileen is a "hybrid" as you claim that became a dragon. END is a "hybrid" that became a demon.
Huh?
No, it's closer to Wendy stopping Dimaria's full powered attack. Eileen was clearly portrayed as superior. This is obvious.

Literally everything suggests she is weak to DS. The entire function of slayer magic for one. Eileen laughing at Erza before Slayer magic and then being shocked when Wendy gave it to her. The very fact that it was used in the first place. All suggest she's weak to DS. This claim right here, is as dumb as claiming that nothing suggests Mard Geer is weak to Slayer magic. It's literally the same.
 

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,061
Reaction score
1,112
Age
36
Country
United States
For one, Erza isn't Natsu. She doesn't have the Flame of Emotion.
Secondly, because theres nothing suggesting she is. You arbitrarily rank August's durability low because Gildarts forced him to suicide, instead of ranking Gildarts offense high like you do with Erza for what she did to Eileen. Instead you use a double standard to claim "oh, PoF Erza is just>>>Gildarts because August's durability is trash, so forcing him to suicide isn't as good a feat as cutting Eileen". No reason for it, just bias. Gildarts literally blitzed and shredded August, it's a better feat than smashing Deus Sema.
and gildarts isnt erza.
which is it, can erza do everything natsu can, or can erza can do things that gildarts cant.
you seems to be going dumber as you go forward. i can rank erza offense based on deus sema, i can base, dragon eileen offense based on her claw strike. what can you do other other than make arbitrary nonsense. oh, jellal farted, that is above smashing deus sema :XD


Nothing he says, after seeing Suzaku solo a human Acno tier. The disingenuousness is astounding.

Yes?

True. And if that's the case the power creep isn't as big. If she wasn't though, it is.
i will wait, you can wank

END and Mard Geer are as similar as Selene and Eileen are. Eileen is a "hybrid" as you claim that became a dragon. END is a "hybrid" that became a demon.
Huh?
No, it's closer to Wendy stopping Dimaria's full powered attack. Eileen was clearly portrayed as superior. This is obvious.
so basically eilene is less weak to ds than selene?

not when erza was smashing deus sema.

Literally everything suggests she is weak to DS. The entire function of slayer magic for one. Eileen laughing at Erza before Slayer magic and then being shocked when Wendy gave it to her. The very fact that it was used in the first place. All suggest she's weak to DS. This claim right here, is as dumb as claiming that nothing suggests Mard Geer is weak to Slayer magic. It's literally the same.
what.
your claim are going more into retardation
eileen story was that to fight dragons, they needed dragon magic. otherwise they cant hurt them. eileen destroyed her life for it.
nothing in this suggests, that eileen is weak to ds. she is not resistant to it, unlike normal magic, just like dragons. that is all.
 

grey matter

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Dec 4, 2019
Messages
6,580
Reaction score
10,155
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
India
Irene could land blows on Acno but due to magic immunity/resistance or whatever we couldn't really get a good gauge of her AP against god tiers. Leaning towards Selene. If all else fails, BFR gg
Acno (human or dragon) would one shot her within a second if he's serious. Immunity won't even come into play here, when the gap is several tiers
 

Loke

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2016
Messages
837
Reaction score
1,508
Age
30
Country
United States
Acno (human or dragon) would one shot her within a second if he's serious. Immunity won't even come into play here, when the gap is several tiers
And what proof do you have of this? Irene isn't GS.
 

grey matter

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Dec 4, 2019
Messages
6,580
Reaction score
10,155
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
India
And what proof do you have of this? Irene isn't GS.
Proof is August being unable to register what had transpired until Acno one shotted GS and reached far behind him. And shitting his pants subsequently

Serious Acno one shots Eileen.

Acno one shots every character in x792. Like that was the entire narrative, you see the dude, you have no choice but to somehow get away.
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
and gildarts isnt erza.
which is it, can erza do everything natsu can, or can erza can do things that gildarts cant.
you seems to be going dumber as you go forward. i can rank erza offense based on deus sema, i can base, dragon eileen offense based on her claw strike. what can you do other other than make arbitrary nonsense. oh, jellal farted, that is above smashing deus sema :XD




i will wait, you can wank



so basically eilene is less weak to ds than selene?

not when erza was smashing deus sema.



what.
your claim are going more into retardation
eileen story was that to fight dragons, they needed dragon magic. otherwise they cant hurt them. eileen destroyed her life for it.
nothing in this suggests, that eileen is weak to ds. she is not resistant to it, unlike normal magic, just like dragons. that is all.
Sure, Erza can do things that Gildarts can't. She can requip for example, that's her magic. Just like Natsu's magic is flame of emotion.
Except Deus Sema is literally featless as is Eileen's durability. You rank her tough because you want to rank Erza tough. You rank August weak because you don't want Gildarts to be as powerful. In short, you're a hypocrite.

Literally just restating the manga.

Dunno, depends what Selene tanks in the future. Can't imagine she can do much worse though lmao.

No, her story was that Dragons were too powerful, not that they couldn't hurt them without DS. The gap between them and humans was enormous, just like the gap between Mard and Tartaros Gray was enormous. Just like the gap between Eileen and Erza is enormous, Mashima makes this plainly obvious and we both know it.
 

Vex_Haid

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2021
Messages
1,091
Reaction score
240
Country
Canada
Human Acno would solo the BDSK lmao.
so true

the delusional fanboys are to scared to face the truth that BDSK are fodder

OT: irene one shot the fake acno tier
 
Top