Is Ace really Luffy's brother?

[mugen]

I don't even think Shanks was on the island when Ace was still living there.

umm...
he was Ace just left the village three years before Luffy...
but he was there

how else would Shanks know Ace?
I mean Ace was in the village when shanks was there..
Imean Shanks stayed there for a year

 

[Naota]

umm...
he was Ace just left the village three years before Luffy...
but he was there

how else would Shanks know Ace?
I mean Ace was in the village when shanks was there..
Imean Shanks stayed there for a year

I highly doubt Ace was living there at the time Shanks was on the island. And about how Shanks would know about Ace. I mean Ace is one of the strongest captains on WB's crew. Why wouldn't he know about him? =/

 

[mugen]

I give up ..

anyways
Ace has a different name for a reason...
and it's not to sound cool.

 

[OP_overlord]

how is that a spolier moment and ace a nd shanks works
the reason that shanks went to WB first was all about respect even tho it hes his dad WB is still a guy you dont wanna mess with and they like to do things there way, mihawk did the same thing with shanks when he told him about luffy (but we didnt think that luffy was related to mihawk but w/e)

 

[NinjAngel]

I don't know anymore.

All I know, is that Shanks is NOT Ace's father. (actually, I don't KNOW that. It just makes sense)

I honestly don't think Shanks is related to any of them. At the very least, he knew Dragon.

 

[jeffhmwong]

I guess shanks change his name...maybe to follow WB?

 

[OP_overlord]

why would shanks follow WB they are rivials

shanks copuld have the same name as ace that would be cool and unexpected in teh story line ace could join his crew and take him to luffy with the use of that paper

 

[xr3b0rn5inx]

Portgas.D.Ace =.=
Monkey.D.Luffy their names arent even the same

Maybe the parents found one of them frum the roadside,hahaha.

 

[OP_overlord]

they areboth adopted that is funny and if it was true even funnier

 

[Tiger D. Kasthuren]

But just wondering how Ace is related to Luffy. How can he be the brother of Luffy, when he is not named Monkey D. Ace ... Luffy's dad: Monkey D. Dragon ... Luffy's granddad: Monkey D. Gawp ... maybe Portgas is the mother of Luffy and Ace ... somebody who knows?


Moved to the right thread. Luckas

 

[mugen]

aww
whicj is why Ace did not die
cuz we still have to know that..
but Mugen wonders what did Ace trigger?

 

[OP_overlord]

did it have to be ace it could have been luffy attacking teh WG

 

[mugen]

did it have to be ace it could have been luffy attacking teh WG

no it was ace cuz oda said so

 

[OP_overlord]

ok that is all i wanted to know
how did shanks know that ace triggered something while he was talking to WB

 

[NinjAngel]

Ace triggered something? When did that happen? Maybe my mind went crazy or something...

They're related until further notice. How 'bout that? XD

 

[mugen]

did you not read chapter 441?
look here

 

[NinjAngel]

OH YEAH! THAT trigger. I wanna know now, too. I wonder how big it's gonna be?

 

[Efreet]

lol.. no offense but the trigger should be discussed on the other topic...

about Shanks being Ace' father.. i don't know..

Portgas D. Shanks??

 

[OP_overlord]

yeah but it would make to a great twist and not do anything really cause luffy thinks shanks more of a father then dragon

 

[KuraiOfAnagura]

Portgas D. Shanks?
no, that sounds wrong to me.
my opinion is it is all Ods fault. we all know that he hasn't planned the first mangas in a structure. and we all know that Oda lives for this shock moments and he realy didn't plan any further, so he gave the cool, strong elder brother a cool stronger name, than the weaker funny luffy.
and i suppose that odatchi will give us a explanation at the D. reunion, which, i hope so, will be in the new world and very soon.

shanks was on rogers ship (like buggy) and if dragon's realy rogers navigator (which seems obviously to me) dragon could let his sons in shanks care, because he was hunted by WG or marines.
the reason why ace didn't appear in the first chapters was that oda hasn't had him in mind.

anybody against tht?