I knew Farf will die before me, which is why I spent the time writing this post and updating the vote viewer for D2.
Web site created using create-react-app
shadoow.github.io
-----------
This is based only on
vote analyzes it doesn't include other factors.
Objectively best town ever
Shad
Town, if not I don't mind losing to
Farfalla
GB
Lambu
Gnut
Will explain more later why these guys votes have looks town.
Inconclusive Read
Belserion
Day 1: Placeholder vote on Mazino
Day 2: Says she won't be here for the rest of the phase, votes Pom while giving a good enough reason.
Notes on Belserion
Currently the lowest post count, but her posts didn't trigger any alarm.
Lady pompom
Day 1: Put a placeholder vote on Seraph but said later she didn't know he already had a vote, making seraph the first person with 2 votes.
She then locks Shinobi another unconfirmed player before james reveals to be freeman.
Day 2: Votes Mazino and saves Gry, in her post voting Mazino she doesn't say what she voted him, instead she says she still distrust Shad and GB
Notes on Lady pompom
Unlikely theory: Seraph being cool while james was freaking out believing it will be a death match between him and seraph (both had 2 votes) could be because Seraph had a teammate vote on him and knew it won't stay (Pom's vote), but seraph also had his own vote to use to break the tie.
I just remembered while thinking about Pom that she always distrusts Shad, previous game we were both town and she spent all game trying to kill me every day, and reluctantly let it go after many days, so between her Love for Gry and her 'Hate' for Shad, it can explain saving Gry and Shading shad in the post about Voting Mazino, this is why
Inconclusive.
Minor Scum Read
Asako
Day 1: Early Placeholder vote on Belserion
Day 2: Voted Mazino First because 'in case I don't wake up to vote', then left her vote on him even tho many of us were doubting Mazino was scum in the last hour, only redeemed by showing up in the last hour, a scum may prefer to just lay low as they already sneaked a first placeholder vote on a town.
Notes on Asako
Unlikely theory is that she is possibly scum with Gry, as she expressed doubts about Mazino being scum but still didn't change her vote, can be explained by her teammate Gry having 2 unmovable votes, only way out is to stick on Mazino.
She also voted Mazino after I started mentioning how absent he was, voting somebody absent is a safe move for mafia.
Medium Scum Read
Seraph
D1: Votes Lambu because why not, this can be considered a placeholder vote #345.
D2: Placeholder vote on DD in case he doesn't comeback and spoiler alert he didn't come back.
Notes on Seraph
He sneakly defended Shinobi here #438
And Shinobi defended him here #379
Outside very few posts where he tags player with an irelevent question like: @X @Y @Z what up? And one or two jabs at Lambu, he is only talking about himself.
Shinobi
D1: Placeholder vote on Tatsu, she lied tho in her explanation D2 about what happened #310
She says that she didn't vote marm, james and seraph even tho she was being treatened, looking at the vote replay, at no moment was she less than 2 votes away from the highest lynch, she never had to save herself by voting somebody, if she needed to save her self she would have as she stated that she was online at the end of the day. this post is just pure lie.
D2: She votes Pompom for threatening her the Day before and for defending Gry.
She then write this next voting post, without interacting with anybody after the above post, she just decided on her own without waiting for a reply from pompom.
After all? Care to explain what happened in your head to settle on pompom?
Notes on Shinobi
Seraph sneakly defended Shinobi here #438
And Shinobi defended Seraph here #379
Between Gry and DD one is mafia the other isn't
DigitalDude
Day 1: Votes James, when asked if he was online at the end of the day, his answer was that he was too shocked by the freeman reveal to make a move, in a way it is understandable but shows he wasn't ready to vote somebody else, maybe he felt confortable being the first voter of james and didn't expect to have to move his vote, especially since another town was getting lynched anyway, since he knew marm was town, he didn't want to join the fray on her either.
Day 2: He was the only one that supported publicly my call and voted Gry, the last time DD supported me in anything was in the Civ Game 96, he joined my town madness and won the game as mafia.
GrySun
Day 1: Voted Farfalla and then locked shinobi getting her to 2 locked votes, but he only made this move after everybody else voted and Marm was already at 4 votes, he voted 1 minute before the day end when questioned about it he said that he discussed with pom to switching to a low poster but I coudn't find this post, even if it exists, it still a useless vote, when questioned about this, he said he is not playing at 100% (Busy IRL, just reading from phone).
Day 2: He made weak accusations against Farf and maybe 1 or 2 more people but I dont remember who and he didn't pressure or felt convinced by his own accusations, he then joined the thread in the morning and his only intention was to not die to my lock and DD's vote, his only concern was self preservation while not attacking anybody, his vote on DD was not because of the usual Town Gry Pressure or Tactics or Reading people as mafia, it was a response to DD's vote on him. He is playing passivly, not making moves as Gry would as town.
). Freeman... Died uncovered. And also came out quite early. If they had to die, that was probably the best time. The traitors deployed interesting strategies. Very exotic approach. Mafia overall played pretty decent; the first few nights town mislynched and only towards the mid-to-end did non-towns start perishing.
