Games MAFIA GAME 19 END!

[shinsengumi]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

benelori, thorn, niichan voted for me ,bene and me had a thing going on for some time but why did the other 2 voted for me without an explanation ?

 

[thornofcarrion]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

How much time left?

 

[digitaldude]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

5 hours left, but like I said in the win thread, I might miss the deadline, and end the day phase late.

 

[Nii]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I highly doubt anyone will change his vote now, why don't you end the day now DD? kkck will be gone starting from thursday and as it is now this place is pretty dead so I think it's best to speed things up a bit

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Unvote

Let me mull over this for a little bit.

 

[Nii]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

fishy

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Not really, it's just these two wagons have built up too fast, imo.

 

[shinsengumi]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

what's the purpose of sicly townie ?i mean ,if a townie keeps another townie from voting ,its a bad thing isnt it ?it will just harm the townies in general . why would you use your ability for that ? am i missing something?

 

[thornofcarrion]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Townies don't know who the other townies are. So, its a risk.

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I took the liberty and edited DD's result posts...if anyone was wondering...changed mazino to Zasz in the brackets of who voted for mazino

 

[Mazino]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

benelori, thorn, niichan voted for me ,bene and me had a thing going on for some time but why did the other 2 voted for me without an explanation ?

what should i say,zasz not even playing,votes everytime for me,only one with real reason was wizz...he just had a feeling though,all other ppl voting me just supported him in the last round
kkck just goes with me cuz i was second in the last voting,u saving ur ass is ok,i would do it the same way...
and what i think about the ppl...
Zasz: not rlly plaing cant say a bit
bene: is suspicous cuz of his replies(cant quote every lil bit sry),only thing supporting him was hardy,but cuz he voted wizz and is also voting against shin can be a sign that he is mafia,cuz he knows they r not mafia(if i read the intro right),which would mean shin is probably a townie,or he just wants to kill a member so he can nullify the suspicion,if im wrong,it means he probably is the prostitute
niichan: toc said he is clean,but toc can be insane which would mean niichan is mafia,but til now the person which i suspect the least
toc: can also be a mafia detective,in that case he also knows who is what and can command the killing ,and he just pretends that he is a townie detective
kkck: hmmm,cant say much about him,though i think he could be the sickly townie,but imo wasnt that suspicious until now,though i dont like his idea of killing 2 ppl at the same time
kdowns: same as kkck,sickly townie maybe even an insane doctor, also not that suspicous so far
shin:at the beginning i thought he was just bluffing being mafia,but after time i thought its a good method to keep the suspicion away cuz everybody thinks he just bluffed,also that he didnt care killing 2 ppl put him on top of my list

so bene and shin on top of my list...followed by toc ...kdowns and kkck ...at least niichan..zasz has no ranking

I took the liberty and edited DD's result posts...if anyone was wondering...changed mazino to Zasz in the brackets of who voted for mazino

what did u do ?

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

what's the purpose of sicly townie ?i mean ,if a townie keeps another townie from voting ,its a bad thing isnt it ?it will just harm the townies in general . why would you use your ability for that ? am i missing something?

u've gotta use that ability to its maximum potential...Not everyone can succeed

 

[kkck]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I fail to see what good the sickly townie can do in general. Situations where such an ability can be used to the benefit of the townies seem rare IMO. Overall the worst case scenario is cancelling a townie vote which increases the weight of mafia votes. In turn it would work if you cancel a mafia vote however in the early game that is a tad complicated given the odds. So basically it is an ability which is far more likely to do bad than good. I guess it can work in the late phase of the game as you could cancel mafia votes but only if the 50-50 odds actually work in your favor. More so, the most likely candidate for this is basically someone everybody already suspects and is likely to get lynched.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

current sickly should of pmed me for tips and advices....I should write a guide 'Sickly Townie 101"

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

vote:Shin

 

[digitaldude]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

END DAY 3​

The townies decided to lynch the most suspicious townie, shin, alas he was just an ordinary man, trying to just make, trying to survive!

Victims: Shin(townie)

BEGIN NIGHT 3​

 

[kkck]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

can you post what the final voting looked like? that is a relevant bit of information at this stage.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Spoiler

vote:Shin

i dont think mazino is a mafia but i have to vote for him or i'll be the one going .but if he turns out to be mafia that will make me the number 1 suspect and i'll die the next day anyway .
my suspect still remains as bene ,he could be faking the prostitute and hardy could be a traitor . i know at least one of the blues is a mafia ,i just cant put my finger on him

to save my hide , votekill mazino

We already remained in 8? That's surprising, anyway.......

Votekill Mazino.

Wow, that's a far stretch I like it though, it might not be totally off. The problem is I am willing to kill any of these guys because I don't have someone who I would deem the most suspicious.

I need to leave soon so I probably should decide on who to vote for now

---------- Post added October 31, 2012 at 12:08 AM ---------- Previous post was October 30, 2012 at 11:26 PM ----------

Need to leave now, I have to give my vote now in case I'm not back in time.

votekill shinsengumi because of reasons bene mentioned and because I'm tired of people not saying anything.

I will try to check the thread tomorrow when I get up and see if there's anything new that would make me change my vote.

I am going votekill mazino. I don't have any clues other than going for the guy who was second last time. Hopefully you guys were right last round.

I am going to have to Vote:Mazino

Interesting analysis in above posts. Well, can't be too detailed *in office*.

Votekill Shin

The only thing I can say for certain, and correct me if I'm wrong is that KD can't be either sane nor insane doctor...or at least the possibility of being insane is really low...the mafia knows whom the target is so they cover it up as well...if the kill is KD's kill as an insane doctor, then it's a huge stretch to say that the janitor picked the same name as well...

So KD is either mafia, or a naive doctor...

What bugs me though is shin's behaviour...not only he forced me to break the tie, although it's funny that only I felt that the tie is wrong(I did expect others to change their votes), but he did so nonchalantly(reading the pages is boring?), without even thinking of the consequences of a double townie kill...because that was the biggest risk...if Mazino is townie as well, then this night would've been a disaster...

If he is a mafia, then this hold shtick gets another meaning entirely, and not to mention that it strengthens the suspicion around me, for being the only to change the vote...

He is inactive and he managed to even be more suspicious than wizzard ever was lol...and it certainly passed over both niichan and mazino who are on the top of my list as well...

votekill shinsengumi

Shin 4x(benelori, thorn, niichan, kdowns)


mazino 3x( kkck, Zasz, shin)



no vote mazino

8/8 voted

---------- Post added November 01, 2012 at 09:19 AM ---------- Previous post was October 31, 2012 at 07:41 PM ----------

END NIGHT 3!​

The townies awoke to find thorn decapitated and his house destroyed!

Victims: Thorn(???)

START DAY 4​

Only 6 players left, let's end this!

 

[thornofcarrion]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

No target of the sickly townie? Or did they target ToC?