Initially, was just Lambu and Hardy acting like it was so weird to question Hardy using DD's avy and acting like I was referring to the blue color thing. However, I read back and realized that even though it was apparent from the quote chain, I didn't specifically mention yet. I haven't really built thoughts yet, I don't have anyone I trust or don't trust as is. Besides my other head of course
For the seeming dream-pair Lambred are both playing not like enthusiastic townies whatsoever. TP? Mafia? You name it, but I‘m kinda losing faith in their townieness with each post.
Now if we were talking about them separately, Lambu seems townie with my read (He lurks a lot more when he’s mafia). Van hasn’t been present or contributed enough for me to gage him on D1 but he’s more active right now.
But part of the fun of the game is speculating what happened? It also helps to talk about what people think happened because some people know more because of their roles and it leads to clues in the later part of the game as we get more information. Scav seems to be leading a convo on things also not about you which is something you later
I think that James and DD are shady folks. Them as a pair raises the shadyness over 9000. James behaviour is not Town like,DD is random as usual which has never been a good thing for me and most of the times the gut feeling turned out right on him.
I agree with the shade being high with them but James also goes MIA when he’s town a lot because he’s bored at the beginning or busy. DD also hasn’t used a gif yet. Or been funny. Usually he cracks me up so much when he’s town. They are in my top3 suspects.
Would be funny if Panda is fucking with our minds by putting in no mafia at all and only TP roles like mentor and SS and SK or Santa. XD
Ah yeah, anyone got a present last night? Then again I supposed 16 players ain't enough time for Santa to get rid of all his presents.
Seems really weak for a game like this. Having had a couple game (ofc it was no hydra format), lovers seems to be a better route and threesome candidate >> sub teacher - which implies a mafia team. Also mentor would be bad for a small game with multiple scum. I wouldn’t make a game like that but this is a Panda game. Going by his games and upping the exponent to a level of Farfalla..... probably means half the role list is scum tho.
Ohh, I see, but did you guys ever have that role before (the two of you combined) or no?
Yeah, we never had this role before. That's about what I can say for now. I feel like it's already a pretty big hint. We plan on hinting more tomorrow though.
Oh, and I'm still sleeping on the couch. Still didn't forgive him for his remark about Fairy Tail
Rereading D1 and really there was too much social distancing. Usually that makes me think that a lot of the top contributors to a game are mafia or there’s a lot of disinterest in a roles.
But you are Gajeel? Doesn’t Gajeel just eat whatever element and power up randomly every arc to become Dark Sea Black Steal Beast Gajeel Shadow God Ackerman?
Some personal thoughts, since Juviii doesn't agree with all my hunches.
GrySun/LP
Good vibes but would like to hear more from LP.
Marmalade/Samuel
I trust Marmalade on Sam but still not a good look to lurk and like posts as opposed to actually commenting.
Gajeel/Beno
Good vibes
Brandish/Crescent
Brandish fumblin' like usual so nothing new there, waiting on Crescent to form better opinion.
Holt/Raven
Pretty much laying low despite almost being lynched, doesn't necessarily paint them as suspicious but still would appreciate some commentary.
Seraph/Bel
Seraph seems the usual, more interested in hearing from Bel but guess that isn't happening soon.
Desin/Daws
Am ok with them at the moment.
Lambu/Vandred
idk
Shinobi/Asako
idk...Asako seems detached
BT/Takuan
I liked the way BT posted, good in my book for now.
Hardy/Erinyes
Feel worse vibes from Erinyes than Hardy
DD/James
No good vibes, guess they are bored?
Scav/riki
idk..Scav seems confident in his posting which is good but would like to hear more from riki too.
Apologies for the missing vote and inactivity on the thread. I'm a bit busy at the moment, but I'm able to keep up with the game's posts fairly well. I've been able to talk more on Discord with Desin than I've been able to on here just because it's more convenient to check and making one too many short posts on there doesn't create a lynch mob. Plus,I just don't like making posts if I don't have time to put some real substance into them.
As for the D1 HardYes sniper issue, he should definitely be on people's list of suspects, but as of right now, he just doesn't strike me as mafia. I think the majority of the mafia is playing it fairly shady right now. @Hardy@Erinyes I am curious to hear more of your thoughts on the players in the game though
Lastly, a blocked kill and nothing else is certainly a possibility, but I would be fairly surprised if that was the case AND no TPs were put into a game like this.
Well, there's not much going on from our side. We haven't been really active yet, and we haven't talked that much in private either. Hopefully we'll get more activity later on.
Personally it's not like i REALLY can't participate more, i'm busy but i could still be talking more. It's just that i don't have anything concrete to say. As i said D1, we have a passive role, i'm pretty much waiting for spicy reveals or spy/det results at this point.
In terms of what intrigued me so far, the first thing worth noting was Hardy's "meme" which i understood nothing about, that Lambu defended, and that Holt seemed surprised nobody mentionned anything about it. I didn't catch what as going on when it happened, apparently there was a mix of meming with pretending to be Blue color, and having worn someone else's avatar - like James once did. Hardy then came out of his silence, explained the reasoning behind the meme, and jumped at you Seraph for pointing fingers.
Sorry if all of this is old news, i haven't been really present so far.
Anyway, i was trusting Hardy more after he came out and became active. He's shadier now for sure, along with Erin, but i mean... Breaking the tie would obviously make him very suspicious, i don't see him making such a move.
I distrusted Brand-X last phase, with no real back up - the usual D1 gut feeling - nothing to make a case on them anyway. Now though, it has been said that Brand-X were the cause of Hardy's NVD - Juviii was the one asking them about it - did i miss the post where they said they were responsible for that?
Something we mentionned in private with BT, was the additional information we got from hosts about the roles being tested. It can only mean that at least one of these roles is currently in the game, right ? I immediately thought the lack of kill tonight was due to Mafia being blocked / victim protected, along with a TP not having a killing ability - at least N1.
Shapeshifter could be it, hopefully if that's the case we'll eliminate that threat soon enough.
But i immediately thought about the Mentor/Mentee pair, that some people also thought about. With the Sub Teacher possibly being tested and all.
Aside from the ST whose presence in the game would be explained by the Mentor Mentee, i don't think anything of the other roles. Mafia Doc is nothing town should dwell too much on anyway since we can't directly try to kill a Mafia at night. I'm assuming the Mafia Doc doesn't protect from a Bomb, since it would render the Mafia Bomb Defuser very useless in comparison...
Then the Mafia Robber, even if there's one in the game, he most likely would manifest himself anytime soon, since it would spell doom for him (since he has to use his own vote and his victim's vote on the same player).
Right now i don't trust anyone, while not having any real suspicious towards anyone in particular.
Even Lawl i'm unsure about, and that's coming from me.
Sorry if you felt ignored babe (), I've been going through the ringer a bit with my health of late. I'll endeavour to be as active as possible but I could easily end up bleeding out at some stage which will require some hospital time.
For my two cents at 2AM, I reckon:
- Haven has been a bit too quiet
- Brand X were a bit 'peculiar' on the crescent side of things Day 1
- Seraph seemed a bit stinky, but he was also playing like Seraph so that might be it
Suspects? you and your other head the Lambred duo. I have my eyes on Hardyes too.
and as I said yesterday, the less suspicious ones to me are Son of Sin, BenoNacho, BelsAph, and now maybe Marma.
Ohh, I see, but did you guys ever have that role before (the two of you combined) or no?
Yeah, we never had this role before. That's about what I can say for now. I feel like it's already a pretty big hint. We plan on hinting more tomorrow though.
Oh, and I'm still sleeping on the couch. Still didn't forgive him for his remark about Fairy Tail