Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread

[Evil3ye]

Is there a reason why a certain someon is waiting with the PM?

 

[Imperium]

Yea hurry up bugzee.

 

[digitaldude]

Hurry up....farfalla!!!

 

[Xadyu]

It was me idiots.

 

[digitaldude]

Shut upt you lowly whore.

 

[Freid]

Am I the only one that thinks the bulletproof townie is too powerful?

Btw, I apologise to scav and Farfalla if I came across a little rude when defending myself.

 

[Imperium]

Rude? There is no need to apologise i woul think. Rude is more like the guy above you.

I agree...Personally I think its better to ditch the bulletproof townie and insane detective. One is overpowered, while the other defeats the purpose of the detective i.e. A player who can cause trouble for the mafia in the night phase. Insane detective just confuses everything and gives the townies one less weapon in a already limited arsenal.

 

[Farfalla]

That's ok, Freid, it's only a game^^ You did what u had to do^^

 

[scav]

bah bulletproof ain't overpowered. u can still be killed by the insane doc, by the townie ( the day) and by the whore.
@Freid don't worry

 

[digitaldude]

I want free thanks too freid.

 

[Evil3ye]

Am I the only one that thinks the bulletproof townie is too powerful?

Btw, I apologise to scav and Farfalla if I came across a little rude when defending myself.

Rude? There is no need to apologise i woul think. Rude is more like the guy above you.

I agree...Personally I think its better to ditch the bulletproof townie and insane detective. One is overpowered, while the other defeats the purpose of the detective i.e. A player who can cause trouble for the mafia in the night phase. Insane detective just confuses everything and gives the townies one less weapon in a already limited arsenal.

bah bulletproof ain't overpowered. u can still be killed by the insane doc, by the townie ( the day) and by the whore.
@Freid don't worry

yeah well, that is to discuss now.

About Insane Detective, I definitely will leave him out in Game 7, as well as the Freeman again.

Bulletproof it now to discuss. I personally believe it only becomes a powerful role to the end of the game, when like now like everyone already can guess their roles, as not many people are left. I wanted to see the Mafia attacking him in the beginning, and how then the game would flow, that's why I'd like to keep it in next game as well. Plus, as we're having three parties and like 2 kills each night, not counting Mad Doc, mostly Townies, a further Blocker might not be that wrong. my two cents.

Other suggestions? Feedback for new roles...
Prostitite, Naive Doc, (Sickly Townie, Mason - not much actions from those this time though)

 

[digitaldude]

woah woah woah........if you leave out insane detective townies would have it easy!

Naive doc is most useless... I mean it's just a title.

 

[Evil3ye]

I know, I will compensate it otherwise

He is useless, but he I think still got an affect on the game, namely that the probability that one is the normal Doctor now is at 33% only lol

 

[Farfalla]

I agree with DD that the insane detective is important to confuse the townies a lil bit, otherwise it would make it more easy. I would agree with leaving the insane one out if the mason guy haven't been added, but with him, things are alrdy a lil better for the townies.

 

[Evil3ye]

Ok, thanks, Your thoughts on the Role Blocker, aka Prostitite?

 

[digitaldude]

Well, it proved very useful and it can screw up both townies and mafia!

 

[Farfalla]

Well, at least I liked that role xD I think we wouldn't win in the end if wasn't for the help of the tramp. I don't think it's overpowered, since he could block an important townie like Detective, Doc or Mason dude in the beginning too.

 

[digitaldude]

I wish I had a role this game...

 

[Evil3ye]

so Prostitute stays

 

[digitaldude]

MASON STAY!