Discussion Magellan Discussion Thread

[kkck]

We don't know if Magellan is a paramecia or a logia. I have to say that the fact that Luffy managed to punch Magellan and his fists did not go through him does not mean the warden is a paramecia : he could be a solid poisonman - as Ao Kiji is a solid iceman - while his poison attacks can be gaseous and liquid.

And it's right that what has done the anime is very confusing. When I watched the episodes you guys are talking about, I was sure he was a paramecia and yet I could not understand what happened with his DF, which was suggesting he was a logia.
There is also the moment when Luffy talked about his poison cloud, and Magellan answered that it was not a simple poison gas but actually a living thing and a part of him - I don't know if it's only in the anime or not. Anyway, it's a characteristic peculiar to the logias

In the manga itself, at this page his legs clearly disappeared, as if he turned a part of his body into poison to produce his Hell's Judgement. Not to say that he needed to make some movements to make the monster move in the same way.
There is also the time when Magellan tooks several cannonballs at the same time at full shot and did not get injured at all. Oda did not let us see what truly happened in this moment because Magellan was hidden by the explosions around him.

A simple question, have we ever seen Magellan blooding ?

Aokiji does break down to ice when punched though. Magellan has never shown any form of intangibility nor he has even imply he has such a thing. He is about as much of a logia as Mr 3 IMHO (who is more than obviously a paramecia). If magellan was really a logia then every scene in which we saw him being hit in some way would have been impossible, he would have just either break down or dissolved and not take the hit.

 

[Poneglyph420]

Doesn't Magellan use Venom road to travel through his poison...
It's like a poison slide right.?
If he's logia wouldn't he just become poison and travel that way??

I'm so confused...

 

[Zatono]

I'm not really sure what Venom Road was exactly. http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/545/13/

To me, it looked like he hardened his poison in order to crash through that wall of stone, and just called it Venom Road...since he basically made a road of poison doing it. It's hard to say though.

 

[Lord Rayleigh]

On that image you posted, I can see both Magellan's legs. He is moving, and has tiny legs, but if you looks closely, you can see his shoe behind his butt.

I've looked closely and we still can't see his two legs nor his two shoes.

Spoiler

I think it's very likely Magellan is a paramecia with the ability to turn a part of him into poison and to produce poison. That would explain some strange things of his DF.
It means he can still be injured.

Don't worry, I do not create a new kind of paramecia. Actually, there's been one character in the whole manga that has been confirmed to have this kind of ability and this person was present in the MHQ war.
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/558/07/
Colonel Hina can produce steal rings and to turn into steal rings.

PS : in the anime the captain of the largo pirate could produce nets and also turn his body into nets.

 

[kkck]

I would assume the reason we can't see magellans legs in that image is that their are immersed in poison and poison is hardly transparent. His body never liquidizes or gasifies into poison.

I never really understood why there is so much confusion regarding logias... I mean, there are two requirements. One is to be able to generate a lot of your element and the other is to be able to turn into said element to get intangibility. I don't see why the confusion with such simple rules at this point (I remember people thought luffy was a logia even though he lacked a shred of intangibility)

 

[Fox666]

I've looked closely and we still can't see his two legs nor his two shoes.

Spoiler

Here:

 

[Uriel]

I hope this gets in the next databook or the next SBS. :S

 

[kkck]

Here:

Spoiler

I still think his legs are there covered by poison. Thing is, his poison is hardly transparent.

 

[LnDRash]

The origin of Magellan's appearance ?

Somehow just remembered this Beastman guy from the original He-Man Cartoon Series...

I think the symmetry is quite impressive.

http://www.ddsite.com/heman_beastman.htm

There's also this snake guy which reminds me of Hannyabal:

http://www.behindthevoiceactors.com/_img/chars/char_6018.jpg

[tmod=Akainu]Removed image tags, please don't hotlink[/tmod]

 

[Bugzee]

I so want to see how “the f**k’d up Magellan” looks like LOL! He must of got one hell of a beating from the escaped prisoners. Imagine how many of them were dying to get a chance to inflict some kind of pain and torture on Magellan himself!?

It kinda sucked that we didn’t get to see a few panels showing the current state of Impel Down after BB & co left.

 

[Ashura_Ichibugin]

I'm not really sure what Venom Road was exactly. http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/545/13/

To me, it looked like he hardened his poison in order to crash through that wall of stone, and just called it Venom Road...since he basically made a road of poison doing it. It's hard to say though.

No, it is a form of travel. He produces something like hydra and moves forward in it. Look here: http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/534/13/

Doesn't Magellan use Venom road to travel through his poison...
It's like a poison slide right.?
If he's logia wouldn't he just become poison and travel that way??

I'm so confused...

It is the strongest evidence of him being paramecia together with his lack of intangibility in spite of his venom being liquid and gas.

 

[chess4]

i hope magellan becomes a VA.

 

[undertoe]

How is this even a question? He is a Paramecia. Poison is not elemental.

 

[zerocooldx]

All i have to say is that its a shame that Magellan is a prison warden, meaning that he really won't step away from ID unless specifically ordered to. Which means that we probably won't see him much from now on, and that sucks because hes got an insanely cool and powerful DF.

 

[chess4]

All i have to say is that its a shame that Magellan is a prison warden, meaning that he really won't step away from ID unless specifically ordered to. Which means that we probably won't see him much from now on, and that sucks because hes got an insanely cool and powerful DF.

i hope he gets relieved of his duty and gets special pemission to go after the level 6 prisoners. i think(well more like hoping) he becomes a normal a rear admiral or vice admiral. he is strong and it would be a waste to leave him out of the story from here on out.

the marines have lost a lot of man power, so i think they will need magellan

 

[frontaLobotomy]

If Magellan were to leave Impel Down, Luffy would be in serious trouble. One drop of that poison and it's gg for him. Given his serious demeanour, and his apparent desire to take full responsibility for the events at the prison, there is a chance he could be assigned to dealing with the escaped convicts from Level 6, specifically Shiryuu. I would say the best place for him is warden of the prison though, once it has been rebuilt, and has some actual prisoners in it, as his DF power is god mode in that place.
I do hope we'll get to see some sort of action regarding the battle between Magellan, and presumably Teach and the other Blackbeard Pirates. As he won't have gone down without a fight. Though I think we'll be left imagining what it was like, in the same way we'll never get to see the fight between Roger and Whitebeard.

 

[kkck]

Magellan can't leave the prison though, there would be no one who could replace him. Magellan is way to power and is basically the force that keeps ID in check. Without him, even a minor incident could escalate in a matter of minutes.

 

[ScratchmenApoo]

But there ISN'T a prison left any more. Everyone escaped. Most of the gaolers/guards got beaten or killed. Both Magellan and Hannyabal got destroyed. Most of Impel Down's interior got ripped up as well. Impel Down is over, it's not gonna come back to the current storyline as a prison, maybe only in a few panels.
But I do agree with Magellan wanting to hunt down Luffy. Right now in the anime his sheer willpower to stop Luffy is resonated more than in manga. Then again, Luffy needs to beat him.
It's like with Crocodile, 1st battle Luffy got defeated very easily but survived (same as the fight with Magellan). 2nd battle Luffy learned how to damage him (in case of Magellan, it was Mr 3.'s wax). 3rd battle Luffy kicked the crap out of Crocodile and I think the next time he meets Magellan, Luffy probably won't have wax to help him out, but something else to bring the poison-guy down.

 

[bittman]

But there ISN'T a prison left any more. Everyone escaped. Most of the gaolers/guards got beaten or killed. Both Magellan and Hannyabal got destroyed. Most of Impel Down's interior got ripped up as well. Impel Down is over, it's not gonna come back to the current storyline as a prison, maybe only in a few panels.

Uhh? At most, what, 200-300 or so prisoners escaped? Pretty sure they've got thousands going on there. Hardly "everyone" escaped.

Ok, tonnes of marines got beaten or killed at Marineford. Should Sengoku just go "gg" and pack up the entire marine headquarters? Besides, Magellans current state has only been shown in text, for all we know he just had enormous cramps from all the battling and was well overdue for a bathroom break.

Most of the interior ripped up: hardly. The Sphinx destroyed a bit, level 6 probably got trashed a bit, Inazume ruined one set of stairs and Iva ripped the door off it's hinges. The damage to ID's physical structure pales in comparison to the damage done to Marineford or Enies Lobby.

Of course it will come back in the current storyline as a prison. If the marines closed this prison down they might as well just free every pirate everywhere and shut up shop. Impel Down is still a very functioning prison that just got hit badly by some unfortunate events, it will recover and will be seen again. That said, most likely we'll get most of Impel Down's recovery in a cover story arc.

And I think Magellan should be staying in ID. I mean, if ID shuts up and Magellan becomes all marine vice-admiral or something, then One Piece just took an enormously dark turn of tone because we're basically saying that the marines only want to kill people now rather than capture them.

 

[Zatono]

How is this even a question? He is a Paramecia. Poison is not elemental.

I agree that he's paramecia, but it's not because poison isn't elemental. Light and Darkness aren't elemental, are they? Even Magma really isn't elemental, since magma is composed of more then fire <.<