I like some things about her
Below are some of them, and other opinions. TL;DR warning
How well she is written into the story?
Her introduction was awesome. Brandish gave the 12 hype after Hyberion mentioned them, and she did it well with that casual island removal. If she had remained a villain I think she would have worked out to be one of the better ones (she can't possibly be any more trolled than she has!) . But she was to be associated with Lucy. Now while I like this a lot, it could have been written in much better. Like maybe just one glance at Lucy in particular, since she did recognise her. It felt completely random when Brandish all of a sudden referred to Lucy as Layla's daughter. This was a forced development.
Brandish' backstory...
This started quite suspect with the return of Aquarius. From my knowledge she was gone from FT, yet without a key she still appeared out of nowhere. Essentially, Brandish' backstory ushered in Layla's role with the Dragon Slayers, and why Layla died. I felt this fit in well despite my gripes with Eclipse itself, and the aforementioned forced development. Seeing Grammi and a young Brandish was a nice panel. Grammi's final words to protect Brandish were also important for her emotionally. So it was a bit of a goo-lash in terms of writing, but a real tasty one for me (I enjoyed these chapters).
Her characterisation...
Brandish started carefree about her duties, and had some kind of relationship/rivalry with DiMaria. My first impressions were that Brandish might be a bit of a psycho, mixed in with some weird and/or cute quirks. After Star memories, we got to see more of her personality, and her change. This was understandable to me, since she's vulnerable at this time. She came to realise that there isn't a point in the war (what is the point? Follow Lord Zeref to genocide?) and had enough courage to negotiate with August, who himself would have heard out FT (until Mest). Brandish' ambivalence is probably best illustrated when she hugged DiMaria, and of course when she actually spoke of it. Along with Irene, Brandish has more development and complexity as a character than the other shields (not a big feat), and is up there relative to other well developed villains in the series.
Her role as a FT healer...
It's pretty convenient that she can shrink wounds and the like. With a glass half empty Brandish is used to keep FT alive, or in the case of END, detonate him when the time is write. However these are her abilities, she just helps with the healing no different to Wendy. So even with the convenience in mind, it's what she wants and chooses to do. It fits, imo.
Joining FT?
They need to make Brandish GM and build a statue for her
(it's the end of the series so it's irrelevant imo)
Interactions with other characters
- Lucy - as a big fan of Lucy, I really like their friendship. Lucy's alluring personality is hard for Brandish to deny. A lot of Lucy's best moments this arc have been with Brandish as well.
- Natsu/Happy - Brandish likes both of them, especially Happy's furriness They've got good chemistry.
- Aquarius - this was so funny to me, can't wait for it to be animated.
- DiMaria - from Mari's POV, Brandish betrayed her. If they are to mend their relationship, it would probably have to come from Brandish. DiMaria might come to the table if Brandish makes the first move (it's the only way I see it happening if it has to).
- August - They have a seemingly good relationship. As expected of grandfather and granddaughter.
- Marin - her treatment of Marin resembles what Aquarius did to her. However I still think Brandish needs to apologise (and Marin too for attempted murder).
- Evergreen - brotp!
Future role in this arc and beyond...
Personally, I prefer her to stay in her current role of a wounded person who is treating the wounded. I hope she doesn't participate in the war other than that (still it's a treasonous act). I just hope August doesn't catch on, or Zeref. After the war, I hope she can be friends with Lucy and DiMaria.
Romance?