Opinions About Luffy's Mother

[sushi]

you are sure making fun of yourself...........

 

[mirai]

Ace and Luffy have different fathers, thats why the last names are different.

 

[Liqiud]

Luffy's mother is Robin.. yes it's possible.. no it's not true.

Eheh, not the top of your math class are ya. She was 11 when he was born.

But.. if not Robin, then definately Franky.

WTF are you talking about...Franky has nothing to do with this. And you spelled 'definitely' wrong..

Ace and Luffy have different fathers, thats why the last names are different.

Eh, not so much...If you think in that mentality, Luffy's dad and grandpa have different last names as well. Also read in wiki if the names of OP were americanised, then Ace's name would be D. Portgas Ace.

 

[mirai]

Eh, not so much...If you think in that mentality, Luffy's dad and grandpa have different last names as well. Also read in wiki if the names of OP were americanised, then Ace's name would be Ace Portgas D.

Monkey D. Garp
Monkey D. Dragon
Monkey D. Garp

Portegas D. Ace

Monkey is the same for Garp, Dragon and Luffy, and Portegas for Ace.
So Luffy's grandpa has same last name as his father, the same as Luffy, and Ace has different.

And the wiki, what ground do it have for stating that americanisation will make it Ace Portegas D. ?
Is Portegas D. a single world? dont think so...

 

[Liqiud]

Because the Japanese kanji names usually consist of a family name (D. only as confirmed by Saul), followed by a given name(Luffy), followed by a middle name(Monkey). the middle name is like a given name for future generations, like my middle name is James, as was my father', as is my grandfather's, as was my great grandfather's, etc...

Luffy is most likely the same 'Monkey' is most likely a middle name passed down, while Ace, as with alot of children is named for his mother.

So their names directly translated are.

D. Luffy Monkey
D. Dragon Monkey
D. Garp Monkey
D. Portgas Ace

If D. is not the family name as Saul said it was. Then you might be right.

It's also obvious that they look and act the same..nuff said.

 

[kadodo]

The only thing I wish is that she's still alive. maybe Luffy's mother has to do with Dragon going against the world government. Anybody else think the same?

 

[bebekhappy]

yeah i do...it's nice if we can see his mother.
what if his mother was the store keeper (forgot the name >.<) back in chp 1?

 

[weixiaobao]

yeah i do...it's nice if we can see his mother.
what if his mother was the store keeper (forgot the name >.<) back in chp 1?

we have already decided in this thread that she is not his mother. Right now Liqiud's theory that his mother is Gold Roger's sister or twin sister or even daughter. (I forgot which)

 

[Liqiud]

The only thing I wish is that she's still alive. maybe Luffy's mother has to do with Dragon going against the world government. Anybody else think the same?

OMFGBBQ If one more person posts this I'm going to open up a can of cyber whoopass..

I'll restate this AGAIN:

hmmmm, revised theory: Luffy's mother was the younger sister or daughter of Gol D. Roger. She fell in love, married, did all that good stuff with Dragon. Gol had everything in the world and had lived a long, good, life; the only thing left to obtain/explore was death. Roger and Garp most likely met up and made a deal: Roger would turn himself in; Garp would get the credit for his capture. Luffy's mother was captured by the Navy about 5 or 6 years after Gol's death (long enough to have both Ace and Luffy) for association with the Pirate King. Dragon tried to save her, she was killed during the scuffle. Dragon escaped and/or killed the Naval officers, asked Garp to raise Ace and Luffy, and set out to destroy the WG, having a vendetta, a cause, and a reason to topple the WG.

 

[kadodo]

Well it's just your opinion and that was my opinion up there too. I'll only believe you if you have some good stuff to back up what you say.

 

[jeffhmwong]

What if luffys mom is some old bitch just like avilda? Remmeber, avilda use 2 be old n ugly untill she ate the DF...

 

[Liqiud]

Well it's just your opinion and that was my opinion up there too. I'll only believe you if you have some good stuff to back up what you say.

That theory is my "Good stuff" (It's flawless and perfectly clear; although it is most likely wrong) In which you restated in a very vague form.

What if luffys mom is some old bitch just like avilda? Remmeber, avilda use 2 be old n ugly untill she ate the DF...

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA

 

[weixiaobao]

OMFGBBQ If one more person posts this I'm going to open up a can of cyber whoopass..

I'll restate this AGAIN:

Liqiud, you killing Kadodo (don't kill fellow One Piece's fan) (PS. he may not have read your post since this is like 7 pages long, come on, just inform him, don't kill him)

What if luffys mom is some old bitch just like avilda? Remmeber, avilda use 2 be old n ugly untill she ate the DF...

That's a possibility, LOL LOL LOL. There are quite a few female pirates. Wait, could Luffy's mother a pirate? even though she maybe GR's relative but does that meant she a pirate herself? Hmmmm, I think she most unlikely to be a pirate, maybe she working the circuit or something, a clown perphap.

 

[Liqiud]

WTF would she be a clown for!?! A pirate, now that possible -- Pirate + Association/Daughter or Sister of Gol D. Roger = WG execution

 

[weixiaobao]

I just saying a clown, since that why luffy so mess up. (noting just a guess)

 

[Liqiud]

Eh, all the Ds act like that apparently.

 

[kadodo]

You know that Liqiud just went too far you know, but it's good that he admitted that his theory was wrong (lol)

 

[Liqiud]

You know that Liqiud just went too far you know

Too far? I just said I was going to open up a can of cyber whoopass. There is no too far to me.

but it's good that he admitted that his theory was wrong (lol)

Eh, I said it's probably wrong, and unintentionally or not, you vaguely restated my theory.

 

[kadodo]

Oh well, we'll just have to believe whatever we want.

 

[OP_overlord]

luffys mom is definetaly one of the "mighty seven pirates" and she had better behot and a DF user or it would b weird