Discussion Series All Time Relationship Rate [VOTING OPEN!]

[Hermit]

As promised, here we are to present the ever divisive shipping rate, or relationship rate, or friendship rate, whatever you want to call it. Here is the list of the 37 relationships that made the final cut:

Spoiler: Spoiler

Natsu Dragneel and Lucy Heartfilia
Gray Fullbuster and Juvia Lockser
Jellal Fernandes and Erza Scarlet
Gajeel Redfox and Levy McGarden
Zeref Dragneel and Mavis Vermillion
Mirajane Strauss and Laxus Dreyar
Alzack Connell and Bisca Connell
Elfman Strauss and Evergreen
Scorpio and Aquarius
Hibiki Lates and Jenny Realight
Ren Akatsuki and Sherry Blendy
Erik and Kinana
Sherria Blendy and Wendy Marvell
Rogue Cheney and Minerva Orland
Sting Eucliffe and Yukino Agria
Ichiya Vandalay Kotobuki and Anna Heartfilia
Lucy Heartfilia and Loke
Lucy Heartfilia and Gray Fullbuster
Natsu Dragneel and Lisanna Strauss
Natsu Dragneel and Erza Scarlet
Natsu Dragneel and Gray Fullbuster
Laxus Dreyar and Freed Justine
Gray Fullbuster and Mirajane Strauss
Gray Fullbuster and Ultear Milkovich
Laxus Dreyar and Cana Alberona
Lyon Vastia and Meredy
Makarov Dreyar and Porlyusica
Kagura Mikazuchi and Millianna
Jellal Fernandes and Ultear Milkovich
Jellal Fernandes and Hisui E. Fiore
Sting Eucliffe and Rogue Cheney
Brandish µ and DiMaria Yesta
Brandish µ and Laxus Dreyar
Kyoka and Seilah
Hibiki Lates and Cana Alberona
Erza Scarlet and Gray Fullbuster
Erza Scarlet and Kagura Mikazuchi

What You Have to Do:
-Rate each ship with a score of 1-10 with half-scores such as 1.5 , 4.5, etc. allowed. You may give ONE 11 to the relationship you see as superior to all. No 10.5's allowed.
-All scores will be sent to @Gryffindor
-Scores will be sent till November 10th, and eliminations will begin on the 11th. The poll will also close on 10th.
-Just for fun, any comments you make on certain ships we will add to the post when it is time for their elimination!
-No trolling scores please.
-It is up to you to decide on how you want to rate some relationships. Meaning it's your choice if you want to rate something as being OTP or BROTP.

Bonus:
-We will once again introduce a poll where you can vote on relationships that didn't make the cut, the winner will get their own special elimination post similar to the same occurrence during the Battle Rate.
-We might also have one other surprise elimination for you guys(maybe).

IMPORTANT:
This is just for fun. We repeat, this is just for fun. This isn't an event for you guys to argue over the legitimacy or non-legitimacy of your favorite relationships. That is not what this is about. You are free to have your opinion on certain relationships but keep in mind that this is a touchy subject and not everyone will share the same opinion. It's fine to be salty, but please keep in mind Forum Rules. Mods will get involved if need be and it'd be pretty silly if things get out of control for an already completed manga. Thanks for your understanding and have fun voting and enjoying the rate!
​

 

[Crescent Jinx]

All I can say is...

Don't make me start tagging you guys according to your ships.

This is going to be fun!

 

[Takuan]

I'm voting for Carla x Happy, the only legit or relevant ship on the list.

- Mystogan x Erza Knightwalker:
I don't think they even had any interaction, from what we've seen. Would we ship Edolas Romeo with Grandeeney, just because Earthland Romeo and Wendy are being shipped?

- Jude x Layla
That's a legit ship, but not relevant enough for me. If we knew the name of Natsu's parents from the flashback, i wouldn't make them my honorary ship; that's the same here.

- Silver x Mika
See above.

- Dimaria x Larcade
I don't want bae Dimaria to end up with such a lame human being.
Oh wait, he's not even human.

- Bacchus x Cana
Now we're talking. This ship is legit, but i remember a pretty good post, with solid arguments, explaining why Cana should not be with Bacchus. This post was from the person whose profile picture is Cana. I don't remember her name. Anyway, that convinced me about this ship.

- Natsu x Anna
Natsu belongs to Lucy, not to her ancestor.

- Lucy x Jellal
I don't even know where this is coming from...
It almost feels like we're randomly taking 2 characters and shipping them. Why not Bixlow x Ultear, or Gray x Cana. That makes no sense.

- Laxus x Lisanna
The only scene they interacted with each other was during Tenrou, when Laxus was tapping her head. That's not enough to make a ship, not even a crack ship.

- Erza x Simon
Alright why not.

- Jellal x Kagura
That CPR gave wrong ideas to people i guess.
@Vici, show us who Kagura should be shipped with

- Gildarts x Cornelia
See Jude x Layla above.

- Ichiya x Erza
Mehh. I was under the asumption that erza was disgusted by Ichiya.
Wouldn't Ichiya x Elfman be a better ship? They had pretty intimate interactions

- Mirajane x Freed
Why? The only interaction they had was their fight. And we all know Mira belongs to Laxus just like Freed

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 4, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 4, 2017 ---

Jellal Fernandes and Hisui E. Fiore

That's the most random thing i've ever seen.

 

[Hermit]

That's the most random thing i've ever seen.

Blame @Valhalla777 and @Gryffindor

 

[FemShep]

Lucy Heartfilia x Jellal Fernandes

I do not recall even one of their interactions because there are none..

 

[GL_Nova]

Y’all really put Laxus and Freed on here...

 

[Invel > Zeref]

Y’all really put Laxus and Freed on here...

Why wouldn't they? Freed is the only one that is confirmed to harbor some sort of attraction to Laxus.

I wonder why certain seemingly random crack ships (Brandish x Laxus for example) beat out pairings with actual one-sided feelings involved like Erza x Simon and Carla x Happy. I am glad that Ichiya x Anna made it to the list. Anna recognizing Ichiya's handsomeness was my favorite part of the last arc

 

[Jko]

Carla x Happy should be been on OG list imo. Tho this list is a pretty good selection.

Lol I'm glad no has voted for Laxus x Lisanna. Hated that ship bcs their "ship" moments was Laxus treating Lis as younger sister.

Wendy and Sherria are basically sisters shipping them is weird. They brotp not otp.

That brings up the question that do we base off the romantic tension of the relationship or can we judge the platonic relations with no romantic undertones?

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 4, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 4, 2017 ---

Also wth no Sting x Rogue, no Sting x Minerva, no Rogue x Yukino, no Yukino x Minerva? Y'all drop the ball on the Saber Foursome. I'm surprised Jellal x Hisui, Jellal x Lucy, and Ichiya x Anna are over them...

 

[Reebi]

Lucy Heartfilia x Jellal Fernandes

I do not recall even one of their interactions because there are none..

He was #1 on her perfect boyfriend list

 

[Raven]

-Where is Gildarts and Irene? They would make very hot wild couple.

-Cana and Bacchus would be awesome.

-I don't really get from where ppl get the cana x laxus thing, Never saw it anywhere to be hinted in the manga compared to Mirlaxus

-Natsu x edo Lucy and Lucy x edo Natsu

 

[Reebi]

-Where is Gildarts and Irene? They would make very hot wild couple.

-Cana and Bacchus would be awesome.

-I don't really get from where ppl get the cana x laxus thing, Never saw it anywhere to be hinted in the manga compared to Mirlaxus

-Natsu x edo Lucy and Lucy x edo Natsu

But Natsu's a switch and edoLucy is a top so that wouldn't work.

The real man in Cana's life is alcohol. I mean, a wild girl who could have any man is a virgin. Clearly, it's by choice. Although, in her bio she did date Macao for some time.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

I find Charla x Happy funny because since Mashima gave Charla a human form after the time skipped and moments between her and Happy pretty much stopped. They weren’t even mentioned in the last chapter.

Now the true ship......
Charla x Lily can rise! +.+

Spoiler

 

[Reebi]

I find Charla x Happy funny because since Mashima gave Charla a human form after the time skipped and moments between her and Happy pretty much stopped. They weren’t even mentioned in the last chapter.

Now the true ship......
Charla x Lily can rise! +.+

Spoiler

The last one looks like they are making kittens

 

[Stormsfury]

What is this new found fuckery?

 

[Hermit]

What is this new found fuckery?

Shipping rate. Join in to give NaLu your 1 and MiraXus your 11

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Hey @Unnamed Namesake, want to help support Laxus x Cana?

Shipping rate. Join in to give NaLu your 1 and MiraXus your 11

This means war.

 

[Takuan]

Hey @Unnamed Namesake, want to help support Laxus x Cana?



This means war.

THATS HER! She's the one i remember talking about Cana and Bacchus, i didn't remember her name.

 

[Reebi]

Guys, Cana is in a relationship with alcohol. They have had a loving relationship for eight years and have lasted longer than most couples in FT. Laxus hasn't really talked to Cana and Bacchus is another alcoholic so those wouldn't work.

Calcohol 4 the win!

 

[Reebi]

I think we can all agree that Cana's boyfriend is alcohol. Well everyone but Crescent_jinxgrace since she ships Cana/Laxus because of Julia/Let.

Let was more structured and rule based. He was a jacked up version of Freed.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

I think we can all agree that Cana's boyfriend is alcohol. Well everyone but Crescent_jinxgrace since she ships Cana/Laxus because of Julia/Let.

I love me some Let and Julia now.