Discussion Straw Hat's Crew Strength (Ranking)

Luckas

MH Senpai
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
3,227
Reaction score
128
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

Moderator Notice:
The threads are meant for discussion, so from now on posts with only the ranking without the reasons you choosed that specific ranking will be deleted.~ Luckas
Moderator Notice:
Quoting myself, from now on if a post will contain only a ranking and nothing else it will be deleted and the poster will be informed.
This a thread for discussing rankings, not for posting rankings.~ Luckas
 

Zoro-kun

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2007
Messages
139
Reaction score
3
Gender
Male
Country
Norway
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

OK here comes the real list. This is how it really is.

Combat
1. Zoro ( just sexy )
2. Luffy ( gear 2/3 was hilarious )
3. Usopp ( i love when he lies."I have a million soldiers i can call for, so just go away!" when he uses his "5 tonn" hammer ^^)
4. Franky ( i love his panties )
5. Sanji ( fire leg, what more? )
6. Chopper ( ur just funny, u cant fight.. )
7. Nico Robin/Nami (grow some manboobs, ur fightingsstyles sucks.. =/ well Robin, i love you though ^^ )

Funny
1. Usopp / Chopper ( best moment: Sanji: dinner is soon ready! usopp and chopper: "Moshii!!! (shaddap)"
2. Luffy (i love his immitations, and his songs..^^)
3. Sanji ( when nami comes back with the weaver... sanji: wtf?! she has put on a t-skirt!!)
4. Franky (FRAAANKYYY!! I love your balls )
5. Zoro ( mendokse..^^)
6. Nami / Nico Robin (can u do anything but laugh? say something funny at least once, no offence Robin, u know i love you <3 )

Sexy
1. Nico Robin (here you go, ur damn sexy^^ )
2. Nami ( 2.place nami, ur girl, thats why, i dont really like u too much, but a pussy is pussy.)
3. Chopper ( ur cute, even though u are a reindeerhuman)
4. Franky (speedo.... <3 )
5. Luffy / Sanji / Zoro / Usopp (yeye.. ur guys, what do u expect? -.- )
 

Raysen_ht

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Messages
1,176
Reaction score
77
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

old thread i know...

But i had to post my ideas on the matter, especially after TB and with such good prospects for SA/FI (admiral fight, Kuma is there, a bunch of strong pirates showed up and Garp might apeear.)

Ranks in fighting

1- Luffi (close/middle range) ---> Super strong (trained by Garp and a lot after Shanks left), great development and use of the powers of his DF (an unbeliveble amount of diferent attacks plus gears 2/3), almost invulnerable to blunt hits!! Besides he never NEVER gives up and is a combat genius!! He finds the best way to attack his opponents, and make up new atacks on the spot (see fight with Crocodile)

2- Zoro (close/middle range) ---> His spirit and willingness to sacrifice anything to win (even his life) really make him a terryble opponent to fight against!! Constant training makes his power increase all the time and his newly aquired aura allow him stronger technics (like Asura)! What can i say... super powerfull guy

3- Sanji (close range) / Robin (middle range) ---> I think its a tie between these 2...

Ill go with him first: Amazing kicks, and many different ways of doing it... His Diablo Jumble (or something) is a DESTROYER shot... i cant think of many people who could take one of those and keep fighting! If he used his hands, he would be tied with Zoro! Downside (in the fighting matter) is he WONT fight women (its great for his caracter though), and can only attack close enemies

Now her: Her DF ability is an overkill, if she get serius she can defeat preety much anyone (exept Logia) very fast (just crack their spine). Plus she has a great control of her power and is really smart!! Only way to defeat her is by surprise (like Moria did when he swiched with his shadow)

5- Franky (close/middle range) ---> A very powerfull body, His coupe the vent attacks are very, very strong. Plus he has many different ways to attack thx to the upgrades he made to his body!

6- Nami (middle range) ---> If u give her enough time to control the weather of the place ur fighting her, its over, she won!! her problem is that if she looses her clime tact, is also over, but she lost!! She can take out massive amouts of enemies with little effort

7- Chopper (close range) ---> his Zoan powers + rumble ball makes him a force to be reckoned. If u underestimate him ur toasted. And what makes him really dangerous is his ability to pinpoint the weackness of an opponent, and his knowlege of anatomy
If he could control monster point, he would be the 3rd one imo

8- Brooke (close/middle range) ---> Incredibly fast (only bones) and a decent swordsman we dont know everything he can do yet. I only placed him over Usopp, cause he can make people sleep (probably stun, paralise and other status changing stuf also) with his music

9- Usopp (middle/long range)---> he is getting more powerfull, and his Kabuto is preety awesome, but still the waekest one of the bunch imo!! Still.... his importance to the crew, on the fighting matter, is that he is the only long range atacker... and that can be VERY important (EL for exemple)
 
Last edited:

The Adamant Dragon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2008
Messages
947
Reaction score
404
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

in Battle:

1. Luffy --- Do I Even have to explain that? I Just enjoy seeing this guy in Battle. He's pure Genius... The fact that he's able to turn such disgusting Ability XD into a work of art and make crazy and powerfull techniques out of it is pure genius.

2. Zoro --- ''SANTORIUU'' !!! nuff said.

3. Robin --- Assassination... Once she gets your neck its Game over.

4. Sanji

5. Brooke --- he's got more in store for us, since he's got his shadow back. We must keep a close Eye on him. We haven't seen his real strengh yet. I think we'll see what he's made of soon. Maybe his rank will go up Later on.

6. Chopper --- When he goes monster point he's just a power house. For me I fell like his strengh when in Monster point mode equals Oz's, without luffy's Devil-Fruit powers of course.

7. Franky --- He could be higher but he's Fighting style Annoy me.

8. Ussop --- When he get serious, his a force to be reconned with. Sogeking lol !

9. Nami
 

Raysen_ht

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Messages
1,176
Reaction score
77
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

@The Adamant Dragon
I agree that Brook still have a lot in store for us, but imo until he shows his true power, he has to be ranked lower than 5
Why do u put nami as the lowest rank??

@Guts
ill just quote Lukas (Global moderator)
Lukas said:
Luckas said:
The threads are meant for discussion, so from now on posts with only the ranking without the reasons you choosed that specific ranking will be deleted. - Luckas
Quoting myself, from now on if a post will contain only a ranking and nothing else it will be deleted and the poster will be informed.
This a thread for discussing rankings, not for posting rankings. - Luckas
__________________
Even if this is an old thread u should at least read the posts on this page... (on the page ure going to post...)
 
Last edited:

The Adamant Dragon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2008
Messages
947
Reaction score
404
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

@Raysen-kun

I Decided to rank them in combat but in accordance of who's fights and Fighting styles were the most entertening to me. Who were the ones I enjoy see fight. Beside the fact that Nami~swan got juicy boobs XD, for me her fighting style just like franky's ( He was high ranked just because he's strong and could not put him on the bottom, Even though Its not on what I Based my ranking ) a certain something, for me... however Luffy with no doubt has Imagination and is Highly entertening top see.

If I Ranked them by who I Thought were the strongests, my rankings of course would I've been complitly different.
 
Last edited:

neomaster121

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2006
Messages
1,294
Reaction score
815
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

Zoro luffy sanji - when it comes to technique
Zoro luffy sanji - when it comes to power
luffy sanji Zoro when it comes to speed
Luffy Zoro sanji when it comes to durablity. Luffy wins just because hes rubber
Sanji Zoro luffy when it comes to brains
 

Tsukisama

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 15, 2007
Messages
6,247
Reaction score
2,771
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

Zoro luffy sanji - when it comes to technique
Zoro luffy sanji - when it comes to power
luffy sanji Zoro when it comes to speed
Luffy Zoro sanji when it comes to durablity. Luffy wins just because hes rubber
Sanji Zoro luffy when it comes to brains
Did you consider any of the other Mugiwara pirates for your assessments? At least in the category of brains, I think that the other pirates have your choices definitely beaten. As the smartest crew member, I would say either Chopper or Robin. Robin is extremely intelligent and knowledgeable on a myriad of subjects. Chopper in his Brain Point is also highly intelligent and has keen analytical ability. As for the others, some of them have also displayed a good deal of intelligence as well. Usopp is a brilliant inventor; Franky is an engineering wizard; and Nami has been shown to be quite savvy too. I would probably rank any of the Strawhats I just named above Sanji, Zoro, and definitely Luffy in terms of brains.
 

goldb

Strongest Under the Sun
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Mar 12, 2008
Messages
27,709
Reaction score
27,506
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

here's my ranks: ( there might be a bit of favouritsm in favour of zoro but that's because he's my favourite character ^^)

strength
-luffy
-zoro
-chopper(monster point)
-sanji
-franky
-chopper(human form)
-brook
-robin
-ussop
-nami
-chopper

intelligence

-robin
-chopper
-ussop
-brook
-sanji
-franky
-nami
-zoro
-luffy

adventurousness

-luffy
-zoro
-ussop
-sanji
-brook
-chopper
-franky
-nami
-robin

that's all i could think of right now, lemme know what you think...
 

Raysen_ht

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Messages
1,176
Reaction score
77
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

@goldb
uuhhnn
Streagth
3)chopper (monster point)
6)chopper (human form)
11) chopper... again?!?!

Well.... how is Robin weaker than Franky, Chopper (human form) (if that wasnt a mistake) and of Brooke?!?! She has a deadly, overkiller DF power.... and we havent even seen Brooke fight properly...

Inteligence
Nami is number 2 imo... she can practically read the ocean... and has almost foresight in knowing the weather!!!


Also, please elaborate a litlle on ur choices...
 

Tsukisama

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 15, 2007
Messages
6,247
Reaction score
2,771
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

here's my ranks: ( there might be a bit of favouritsm in favour of zoro but that's because he's my favourite character ^^)

strength
-luffy
-zoro
-chopper(monster point)
-sanji
-franky
-chopper(human form)
-brook
-robin
-ussop
-nami
-chopper

intelligence

-robin
-chopper
-ussop
-brook
-sanji
-franky
-nami
-zoro
-luffy

adventurousness

-luffy
-zoro
-ussop
-sanji
-brook
-chopper
-franky
-nami
-robin

that's all i could think of right now, lemme know what you think...
Strength: Your list seems pretty good. Chopper with his Monster Point would probably be physically stronger than Zoro, who is a mere human. By Chopper's "human form" I assume you mean his "Heavy Point." In that form, Chopper should also have superhuman strength, stronger than Sanji definitely. Since Brook is just bones, he should have no muscle; so, it is hard to say how strong he is, though I think it is fairly reasonable to leave him above Robin for now wihtout any further evidence. Chopper without anything beside it is supposed to be Chopper's Brain Point, right? If so, then I agree with the rest of the list.

Intelligence: I would also place Robin at the top with Chopper's Brain Point next. Usopp as next is okay, but Franky seems like he would be the next most intelligent to me. His engineering prowess requires a very sharp mind. After that, I would think that Nami is the next smartest. The rest of list looks agreeable.

Adventurousness: This is an interesting category. I am not sure how you defined "adventurous," because you have Usopp as the third most adventurous when he is usually the most afraid to go somewhere dangerous and unknown with Chopper a close second as the least adventurous IMO.

Moderator Notice:
Quoting myself, from now on if a post will contain only a ranking and nothing else it will be deleted and the poster will be informed.
This a thread for discussing rankings, not for posting rankings.~ Luckas
I think Luckas has posted this enough times, and it will no longer be posted again. Posts in this need to contain discussion of your lists and not just lists. Expect lists without any reasons to just be deleted from this post onward.
 

goldb

Strongest Under the Sun
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Mar 12, 2008
Messages
27,709
Reaction score
27,506
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

the way i listed my posts were based on whether or not i thought one could defeat the other in a one on one battle, i have slight favouritism towards zoro in most things but i reckon he is stronger than monster point chopper...not just physical strength, which i think what most people commented on, but also stamina and all other necessary battle attributes...
 

kuriorisu

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Jul 19, 2008
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

intelligence

-robin
-chopper
-ussop
-brook
-sanji
-franky
-nami
-zoro
-luffy
"According to Oda, Nami is the third smartest character in the East Blue Saga/Arc." That is all I have to say.

Ok carrying on. Here's my list...

-luffy
-zoro (will give luffy a good go)
-sanji (i don't think he is on par with zoro, but zoro does think of him as a rival)
-franky
-brooke (seeing his shadow, is good enough for him to be here)
-ussop
-chopper (haven't seen a good fighting scene with him)
-robin
-nami (even though she is last, I still think she is strong, she can withstand Rayliegh's Haki)

I put Ussop at such a place generally because of his stamina, personally I hate him, but I've realised how much damage he can take. He could probably stay in a fight longer than the characters under him. e.g Robin, even though she's got a crazy DF, her body can't keep up with it.
 

Organizized

Pirate King in the North
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Scavenger Hunter Supreme
Joined
Nov 5, 2007
Messages
4,334
Reaction score
22,340
Gender
Male
Country
Sweden
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

You hate Usopp? *gaaaaaaaaaasp* Why? :O

I'd put Robin on par with, if not above him though. Her ability is rather dangerous when it comes to fighting.

And Nami shouldn't be last imo, her clima tact is devastating. She usually takes out whole groups of marines at the same time with her thunder bolt tempo. She should be at least above Chopper when you consider that (even though Chopper is stronger close-range).
 

kuriorisu

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Jul 19, 2008
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

You hate Usopp? *gaaaaaaaaaasp* Why? :O

I'd put Robin on par with, if not above him though. Her ability is rather dangerous when it comes to fighting.

And Nami shouldn't be last imo, her clima tact is devastating. She usually takes out whole groups of marines at the same time with her thunder bolt tempo. She should be at least above Chopper when you consider that (even though Chopper is stronger close-range).
Hm, More like I acknowledge his character.

True about Robin, and also true about Nami. Yeah, thinking about it now Nami probably is stronger than Chopper. But I'm probably still gonna stick with my reasoning.
 

bittman

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2006
Messages
1,746
Reaction score
929
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

Not gonna make my own list, but just wanted to say that too many people have put Nami last for some obscure reason.

In my opinion: Nami > Usopp, Chopper, Brooke (and maybe Franky). I'll also reference kuriorisu's comment on Nami's intelligence and say I would put her only second to Robin. With her weather stick (Climatact), her intelligence and stunning good looks I don't see how the weaker portion of the Strawhats are meant to be better fighters.

And Usopp's intelligence is equal to Franky's. They can build things, sure, but they aren't going to pass any college exams.
 

DutchPhoenix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
651
Reaction score
86
Gender
Hidden
Country
Netherlands
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

lucky for luffy that zoro regained his memory in ep 223.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Organizized

Pirate King in the North
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Scavenger Hunter Supreme
Joined
Nov 5, 2007
Messages
4,334
Reaction score
22,340
Gender
Male
Country
Sweden
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

I'd say going by fighting abilities, Nami > Chopper and Usopp at most. I always look at Usopp as kinda strong because his accuracy is something else and he has some devastating weapons as well (just because he made Nami's clima tact doesn't mean he can't make stronger weopons) and there's never been a doubt in my mind that Brook is stronger. But it's true that Nami's intelligence is on the top 3 of the crew (Robin and Chopper being the two others) and if you go by looks she's #1.

@post above: I don't get it?
 

paradoxe

Banned
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2008
Messages
344
Reaction score
21
Age
35
Gender
Male
Country
Hong Kong
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

1. Luffy - hes the captain. With gear 2nd and gear 3rd, hes both the fastest and the strongest. His willpower is unparalleled, and he has an astute tactical mind, which is surprising.

2. Zoro / Sanji -I'd say Zoro is slightly stronger, but not by much. The pair has always been portrayed as rivals, and this is reflected by their opponents (Mr 2 rivaling Mr 1, Jyabura considering himself stronger then Kaku). In terms of pure power and raw strength, Zoro should be a lot stronger, and his techniques are also deadlier, and his fortitude is greater (being able to take a lot more damage). However, Sanji is much faster, and should be able to dodge or parry many of Zoro's attacks. His intelligence is also very useful in combat.It should be noted that hes the guy who saved the Strawhats asses many times, in Arabasta and in Enies Lobby.

3. Franky - Theres a huge divide between 2 and 3 in terms of power, imo (like the divide in terms of power between the lesser members of the CP9 and the CP9 'monster trio'). Franky has monstrous strength, but his power is lacking. His punches are strong but way too slow, and I can't see his weaponry working too well against higher level opponents. However, I can see him powering up in the future by getting Dr Vegapunk to upgrade his body and give him some better weapons. Laser Franky, anyone?

4. Brook - Opposite of Franky IMO. Whilst Franky is strong and relies on weaponry, Brook
is really fast, and relies on technique. His fighting style is unique, though the difference in skill between him and Zoro is huge.

5. Chopper - Hes taken on several strong opponents. Not much to say really, his physical power isn't that impressive, but hes versatile and intelligent.

6. Robin - I dunno why people always overrate Robin's power. If she was very strong, she would have been able to take on Talarn the Zombie General, and stronger opponents. She has a very useful ability, but it is hindered by the fact that the strength of each limb corresponds with the strength of the limb on her real body, and rendering this ability more or less useless against stronger opponents (in fact I can't even see her winning against Blueno or Fukurou). That said, her speciality is assassination and not combat, and her experience should serve her well.

7. Usopp / Nami - Specialists in different fields. Its been stated that Nami is the weakest member of the Strawhats in a past data book, however that was before she got her climatact. Her physical ability is still the weakest though, and Usopp's fortitude is very strong (probably stronger then Robin or Chopper), and he can take a lot of hits. However, he lacks a 'mass destruction' technique like Nami's thunderstorm, and so may find it hard to take out a large crowd of enemies quickly and effectively. Hes unparallelled in terms of long ranged attacks though, and I do not doubt he would be the world's best sniper by the end of the manga.
 

Raysen_ht

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Messages
1,176
Reaction score
77
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Re: Rank the Strawhats!

Good reasoning @paradox!! I agree with 1, 2, 3 and 7... although i think that 7 should be 6...
About Robin i will not comment because u already gave ur answears to what i would say... we will just have to agree to desagree... i say she is on par with Franky

We havent even seen Brook fight properly yet... so i would have to put him at 7 (but this will probably change soon)...

About chopper i think the you missed the most deadly point of him... he can see the weak spot of any opponent!!!
 
Top