I know I'm late but I just watched Scott Pilgrim last night.
hahahahahaha. Satisfaction guaranteed. This being from a fan of the comic. I couldn't really say if non-readers would enjoy it.
That's funny, when I watched it I got this distinct feeling that it would be one of my new favorite movies had I
not read the comic first.
I guess my main problem with the movie was Michael Cera. I'm sorry, but that's how it is. Everyone apart from him (and Alison Pill who played Kim Pine) felt pretty well cast, but man... when the main character is so very little like the one you've grown to love when reading the comics, you can't help but feel disappointed. He put such awkwardness into the character which wasn't there in the comics, and really didn't give off the outgoing, quirky expression Scott does in the comic. Still, I knew it was going to be this way because I pointed out before I saw the movie that Michael Cera can only play one role, and it's
not Scott Pilgrim. I was just disappointed to find out I was right.
Naturally, you're not gonna be able to squeeze 6 volumes into one movie either, so leaving stuff out of the story was expected, but I really couldn't sit by and say I truly liked what they did with the second half of the story in the movie. It just... I don't know, as soon as the screenwriters started adding their own stuff to the story, the genuineness of the entire story felt kind of shattered.
With that said, the movie is perfect when it comes to visual effects and style and the movie really captures the quirky and comic-y atmosphere of the comic. The music was pretty darn good as well, very much like the kind of music I imagined in my head when reading the comic. And though I realize I sounded overly negative in this post so far, I did laugh, I was amazed at its effects, and the original story is just so good it's impossible to turn it into something unenjoyable.
In a lot of aspects, I'd even go as far as saying it's one of the best comic-to-film adaptations I have ever seen. And like I said, had I not read the comic first, I most likely would've loved this movie, instead of simply liking it.
This became longer than I intended. Sorry.
