Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2011] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[cartofipai]

So Oumagadoki will end, that's sad. I like this series. Then, is that means Horikoshi's one shots going to included on upcoming OD's volumes to fill pages?

Also, how many people think Hokenshitsu going to follow OD? Based on its recent chapters, I have a feeling that Hokenshitsu is heading toward the climax.

never read hokenshitsu but from what i saw od is better... well ... i still got enigma and magico as new series maybe sengoku armors ( that is if someone translates it )

 

[Googlez_kun]

I saw the end coming,but it's still sad to see it go now.I guess i will never understand how japanese readers think,because Oumaga had so much soul compared to other series.Sigh~
I hope Horikoshi will come back with something more suitable for JUMP.

 

[saladesu]

Sala, T said that it's ending before ohana posted her ToC :/

Well, that wasn't posted in this thread, and I didn't have the time to check 2ch myself... And usually, Ohana will put a (終) to indicate the series is over but she didn't (wonder why).

But damn, I was clinging on to some hope for Oumaga but I guess it's the end of the road

Rabbit in Peace indeed! You will be missed, Shiina and gang~~~ It was a good, refreshing series, and I am really sad to see such a promising series go.

Meanwhile, I wonder which series will be next to get the axe I'm guessing Hokenshitsu, as Mago really isn't in a position to have its story end any time soon (though a move may be possible).

 

[Jaymie]

Not very good for Dois Sol or Grimm... Magico's unranked, but it's still very high, so it must have been very well-received.

Sengoku is still a wild card, but I have a feeling that it will stick as well.

 

[SoulEaterFreak]

Not very good for Dois Sol or Grimm... Magico's unranked, but it's still very high, so it must have been very well-received.

Sengoku is still a wild card, but I have a feeling that it will stick as well.

I think magico will do well for now, but I doubt it will last long.

As for Sengoku ARMORS, haven't got the chance to read one of the new chapters, only the one shot (that one was nice) but it's difficult to tell how it'll do at this point. (and I don't know why no Edited Manga-group picked it up yet.)

 

[Negative Syndicate]

I think magico will do well for now, but I doubt it will last long.

Well, Magico will get color page on next issue, so I think it will last for a while.

 

[DeidaraGrimmjow]

Well, Magico will get color page on next issue, so I think it will last for a while.

Not necessarily, Negative. Don't forget about Ane Doki, Lock-On and Double Arts.

 

[Galactic Tomahawk]

It's possible, but I never found things like that worth worrying about unless it actually starts tanking.

And either way, it means Jump wants it to survive. For something that almost totally came out of nowhere that's a pretty good sign.

 

[Nayrael]

...already discussing about survival of new series that are not even on the bottom of the bottom? I don't think even the most narrow-minded capitalist would decide to think of ending a series with results of only 1 chapter...

Unless they end up in the very bottom (aka last position in ToC), I think we don't need to think about survival rates of the new series right now.

 

[Akiyama]

#19

via mangastream / binktopia

 

[Jaiden82]

Am glad Bleach is in the top three since Magico doesn't count for now. But I like how good Magico is doing though, its a pretty good manga. Bakuman is 2nd. Reborn is still in a decent place. But Mago, oh Mago, please don't be the next one to get the axe. Rise my friend rise.

Not necessarily, Negative. Don't forget about Ane Doki, Lock-On and Double Arts.

Am I still the only whose pissed that Ane Doki didn't last that long?

 

[Finestela]

Not necessarily, Negative. Don't forget about Ane Doki, Lock-On and Double Arts.

The only comparable series is probably Double Arts... And Double Arts had good early rankings until it crashed later on If Magico can hold on to the momentum and not repeat that mistake, it should be alright.

Lock-on NEVER had single digit position (other than the CP chapters) in its pre-Ch.9 ToC spots.

Ane Doki's color is probably more of a push by the editors instead of reflecting good rankings, since it was already in the bottom 6 (more like bottom 5, since we had Jaguar back then) at Ch.10. Not to mention the editors were trying to make Ane Doki into a replacement for ToLoveRu...

(I personally liked Hatsukoi Limited more than Ane Doki )

 

[Rejuvenation]

Tough break for OM but its been struggling for a while. Congrats to it living longer than initially expected.

As far as Lock-On! goes, I called it ending based on the content of the series. It was weak sauce from the start so I didn't see it living more than 2 volumes.

(I personally liked Hatsukoi Limited more than Ane Doki )

You aren't the only one. Hatsukoi was superior to Ane Doki imo. I pretty much didn't care for the series anymore once Chiaki came.

 

[Drmke]

Wait so Zoo is ending this week? Or just ending soon?

 

[Negative Syndicate]

284 ：T ◆PecpvbY4/. ：2011/04/14(木) 15:11:35.76 ID:3WqVBa/g
さっき気がついたけど昨日のドべ5盛大な間違いしてましてすいません（笑）

T said s/he made a big mistake on the spoiler for bottom 5. What this means?

 

[Koen]

I read the two first chapters of Sengoku Armors since it is at least scanlated in French. I do not understand that this manga is ignored because the story is very likeable. The art is also great and it sometimes reminds me of one piece. It isn't the same like one piece's art but the char design tends to lean more to it than to Bleach or Naruto. Each time that I see the princess, then she always reminds me of a younger version of Nami. My biggest worry is that it might become a new akaboshi because it is quite generic. But oh well, short term manga or not, imo this manga definitely deserves a Edited Manga

 

[Finestela]

Perhaps it's because Sengoku materials has been done so much already?

I can't comment on it since I have not yet read it (due to both lack of open raws and a general sense of fatigue toward Sengoku themed stories). However, in general, there's a sense/bias toward these types of materials that they are curtail for certain demographic group, and thus a built-in repulsion for certain readers.

 

[Jase]

Am glad Bleach is in the top three since Magico doesn't count for now. But I like how good Magico is doing though, its a pretty good manga. Bakuman is 2nd. Reborn is still in a decent place. But Mago, oh Mago, please don't be the next one to get the axe. Rise my friend rise.



Am I still the only whose pissed that Ane Doki didn't last that long?

You're not. I recall it didn't get much love on these parts when it was coming out, but I enjoyed it.

 

[Finestela]

I was too busy dealing with the heartbreak of TLR ending than to follow Ane Doki actively at the time :/

 

[Asgaroth]

I was too busy dealing with the heartbreak of TLR ending than to follow Ane Doki actively at the time :/

heartbreaking ending? it seems more rushed and opened for my to call it a good ending.

ane doki was fun, its disappointing that nothing romance/echi is in jump currently, ecpecially for the great art.