Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[WyldViolet]

On going Favorite
One Piece
Food War
Yuuna
The Promised Neverland
Haikyuu

Ooh, my ongoing favorites would be;

1. The Promised Neverland
2. Hinomaru Sumo/My Hero Academia
3. Gintama/One Piece
4. Haikyuu/Yuragi
5. Kimetsu no Yaiba

 

[Tamil]

For almost every year since 2011 I keep doing those videos and MH forums is always the first place I think of to post in, I may rarely comment here but I do come and read comments everyday and quiet enjoy it. Hope you'll enjoy the video to, I tried to do my best, feel free to fix any mistake I did.

What? Toriko only at 23M?

I was expecting a bit higher...before the timeskip it was doing 20M. So the timeskip gave the series only a 3M boost (TS was 13 volumes so that is like 230k/volume for the TS)?

 

[TyVip]

^ pretty much, you can check it at MAL.

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

1. JoJo
2. Hunter x Hunter
3. Boku no Hero
4. World Trigger
5. Medaka Box

Haven't read a lot Shounen Jump series yet, list might change in the future.

 

[justsomeguy]

For almost every year since 2011 I keep doing those videos and MH forums is always the first place I think of to post in, I may rarely comment here but I do come and read comments everyday and quiet enjoy it. Hope you'll enjoy the video to, I tried to do my best, feel free to fix any mistake I did.

So Slam Dunk sold more per volume than Dragon Ball? :0 Are these worldwide or Japanese sales?

 

[Tamil]

^ pretty much, you can check it at MAL.

Kave told me it was inaccurate though. He posted this

Volumes 31 & 32 could've easily sold near the mid 300k's but they were released near the end of the year so it's hard to find the data on sales. Everything post-TS was selling 300k+ until Toriko's final year (2016). I doubt it averages to the low 200k's?

 

[Kave]

Kave told me it was inaccurate though. He posted this

Volumes 31 & 32 could've easily sold near the mid 300k's but they were released near the end of the year so it's hard to find the data on sales. Everything post-TS was selling 300k+ until Toriko's final year (2016). I doubt it averages to the low 200k's?

They did according to book-rank.net

326,381 (102 days) Toriko volume 31
325,736 (111 days) Toriko volume 32

This site http://www.geocities.jp/jump_manga/ has the most recent numbers from Oricon (really useful site to compare sales btw)

 

[G_I_A]

Finished:

Naruto
Toriko
Babu
Reborn
Bakuman
Dragon Ball

Ongoing:

One Piece
Neverland
BC
Haikyuu
Gintama

 

[WesKR]

Top as in best or favorite? they have different lists.

Best - only on COMPLETED series
One Piece (only exception)
Yu Yu Hakusho
Eyeshield21
Dragonball
Hoishin Engi

On going Favorite
One Piece
Food War
Yuuna
The Promised Neverland
This is not accurate since they are the only one UP TO DATE at the moment . Haikyuu/HZ/Kitmsetsu I haven't catching up.


Completed Favorite
Eyeshield21
Dragonball
Naruto Pre Shippuden
To Love Ru
Sket Dance/Beelzebub/Bakuman

Hoshin Engi was really good, it's surprising to me that it rarely gets mentioned.

As for my top 5 ongoing
1. World Trigger
2. One Piece
3. Toriko The Promise Neverland
4. Kimetsu no Yaiba
5. My Hero Academia
I read everything but Gintama and Food Wars and the rest is pretty meh.

 

[Pietro]

Top 5 series:
Naruto
Dragon ball
One piece
Katekyo hitman reborn
Bleach

Ongoing series:
One piece
Black clover
My hero academia
Food wars
Kimetsu no yaiba

 

[Savi]

So Slam Dunk sold more per volume than Dragon Ball? :0 Are these worldwide or Japanese sales?

Japanese circulation and in some cases fused with sales data. Worldwide One Piece sold 406M, Naruto 220M, Dragon Ball 240M. Can't find any info about Slam Dunk, but it was popular in the east mostly, less in the west.

I'm not sure I can have a list of favorites, there are so much titles I love from this magazine. Jojo is number 1 tho, my other favorites are

Spoiler

- Hadashi no Gen
- Dr. Slump
- Hokuto no Ken
- Dragon Ball
- Bastard!!
- I"s (Favorite romance)
- Slam Dunk (Favorite sports)
- Yu-gi-oh!
- Hunter X Hunter
- Eyeshield 21
- Death Note
- Gintama
- Sket Dance (Favorite slice of life/comedy)
- Bakuman
- Beelzebub (The first manga I read every week back to back when it was published)
- Haikyu!
- AssClass

 

[DyanSon]

1. OP
2. HxH
3. Naruto(especial place on my heart)
4. MHA
5. KnY

 

[Leoat12]

Jump bests series for me

1) Slam Dunk
2) Hikaru no Go
3) Bakuman
4) One Piece
5) SKET DANCE

I don't really follow SAO, but I've heard good things in later materials, which is supposedly an improvement over SAO's 2nd season.

Alicization just started by Yen Press and it has been interesting and intriguing. Kawahara Reki evolved a lot, it is clear in Sword Art Online Progressive and The Isolator. But anyway, if you want to continue, go to LN forum, which, btw, needs some love.

 

[Halloween]

Finished:

1. Toriko
2. YYH
3. Dragon Ball
4. Bleach
5. Bakuman

Ongoing:

1. The Promised Neverland
2. One Piece
3. Kimetsu no Yaiba
4. Hinomaru Zumou
5. HxH (this would rank higher, but the constant hiatuses subtracts from my overall enjoyment.)

 

[Doughboy]

Ongoing/finished Naruto, MHA, YYH, Dragon Ball, Neverland or Yuuna. I'm still catching up with Bleach so it could probably move into that 5th spot when I'm done cause from what I've watched I like it alot. OP I used to be so into like Naruto (trust me) but something about it after the Skypiea arc just got too damn dry and I haven't followed it consciously in like over 8 years. Public opinion would say OP is better than Naruto but Naruto's story never got boring to me, it just dragged at certain times after the timeskip.

 

[G_I_A]

Ongoing/finished Naruto, MHA, YYH, Dragon Ball, Neverland or Yuuna. I'm still catching up with Bleach so it could probably move into that 5th spot when I'm done cause from what I've watched I like it alot. OP I used to be so into like Naruto (trust me) but something about it after the Skypiea arc just got too damn dry and I haven't followed it consciously in like over 8 years. Public opinion would say OP is better than Naruto but Naruto's story never got boring to me, it just dragged at certain times after the timeskip.

The whole war to me was a complete mess...

 

[Doughboy]

The whole war to me was a complete mess...

It was and that was part of the problem, even if Naruto is my favorite series of anything I've ever read or watched. I had no idea why Kishi made like 5 people become the "final villains". Just got way too dumb with power scaling and not to mention with all the coincidences with the Ashura/Indra story. Shuppuden's main problem was just too much focus on Naruto and Sasuke in general but overall still enjoyed it for the most part.

 

[savethecat]

Do you guys think we'll get another Shonen like DB where the MC becomes an adult mid run

 

[Gikiseima]

For almost every year since 2011 I keep doing those videos and MH forums is always the first place I think of to post in, I may rarely comment here but I do come and read comments everyday and quiet enjoy it. Hope you'll enjoy the video to, I tried to do my best, feel free to fix any mistake I did.

seriously no mx0?


Finished
1.Death Note although more prefer the anime ending
2.Slam Dunk
3.Yu-Gi-Oh!
4.Ichigo 100%
5.Naruto (shinobi war arc,dbz route with infinite chakra,which sucks)
Reading
1.Shokugeki no Soma
2.hokuto no ken
3.promised neverland
4.Rookies
5.My hero academia
want to read
1.city hunter
2.cobra
3.isobe
4.medaka box
5.---------

 

[Silverblade]

0. One Piece
1. Gintama
2. Bastard!!
3. Rokudenashi Blues
4. Eyeshield21
5. Sesuji wo Pin!