Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Kadir0]

HD pic of Jump Heroines poster preview

Spoiler

Is Emma in it?

 

[Nakura]

Emma is there. She's beneath Uraraka's legs.

 

[savethecat]

I love the way Emma is drawn

 

[ChocoBar9]

this was the Todoroki vs Inasa stuff right?

yeah, those chapters were not great

I remember I complained about some chapters being only 15 pages in this thread, I wouldn't notice they were so short if they were satisfying

That's in the next volume. This one only covers up until the end of the first round. Seems like most of the negative reviews stem from the exam itself not being very interesting others are probably flaming as usual.

 

[TyVip]

I'm more interested in Isobe Isobe's heroine to be honest, she wasn't in Jump the first time the heroines were drawn.

Also, it's kinda weird that Erina is in the middle and not the front.

He should have draw Robin this time instead of Nami again.

 

[Swavey]

I love the way Emma is drawn

It isn't clearly visible to me but she still looks like a 6 year old Hinata disguised as a girl

Also, it's kinda weird that Erina is in the middle and not the front.

He should have draw Robin this time instead of Nami again.

Who is in the front I can only see Nami. I see Ochako too thankfully she is floating or else she would have been lost between the other 5 heroines with the same design.

 

[Kadir0]

It isn't clearly visible to me but she still looks like a 6 year old Hinata disguised as a girl.

That makes her even the cutest

 

[TyVip]

A Jump universe manga that take place in the school like that would be really fun to read.

I believe this should be the heroine roster exclude We Never Learn (I counted 18 girls from the "HD" picture). 19 if the "doll" on the table is a girl.

Spoiler: Heroine List

Haikyu!!

One Piece

My Hero Academia (CP)

Kimetsu no Yaiba

Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Souma

Black Clover (CP)

Hinomaru Zumou

Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san

Gintama

Spring Weapon No. 1

The Promised Neverland (CP)

Straighten Up! Welcome to Shika High's Competitive Dance Club

Samon the Summoner

Ole Golazo

The Disastrous Life of Saiki K.

Chronicle of Isobe ~Life is Hard~ (CP)

Amalgam of Distortion

Demon's Plan

From the picture, I can clearly see

One Piece, MHA, Kimetsu, Shokugeki, Gintama, Promised Neverland, Yuragi, Haikyuu, Samon, Straighten Up, Ole Golazo.

Not really clear but I spot Teruhashi Kokomi(?) from Saiki and Gojo Reina from Hinomaru Zumou.

 

[Tanzo]

The Promised Neverland - Interview Part 2
https://news.nifty.com/article/entame/showbizd/12176-79456/

Spoiler

- Some of Shirai's influences include Naoki Urasawa, Takeshi Obata, Yusei Matsui (He liked Neuro a lot), Hirohiko Araki in suspense factor, and various others.
- Shirai often watches movies, which are also a big influence. He mentions a movie he loves called The Good Son, a suspense film.
- He likes situations with two-sided characters and excitement.
- Shirai: "Within Jump, while other manga are creating flashy and fierce battles, we only have to make strong pulls with psychological warfare that exceeds that."
- Posuka likes drawing Krone. Shirai also likes seeing her in action.
- Posuka also likes drawing Isabella, and thinks she is the only character currently that should be drawn beautifully.
- Shirai likes to deceive/challenge the readers.
- Shirai's wants to tell the message of "Friendship, Effort, Victory" (the Jump slogan) in the story. Even if the girl is the hero, without any battles, and if the story seems anti-Jump like, he still hopes it will lead in that message.
- He's decided the setting and story of the world where Emma will escape to. The meaning/place is in the title "Promised Neverland".
- The title of the manga was supposed to be "Neverland" only. But, it was supposed to be somewhat better in that "Neverland", so he changed the title.
He's thinking of developing a way where the term "Promise" is linked to the core of the story firmly.
Shirai: "If Emma can jailbreak successfully, I'll know the meaning of "Promised Neverland", so I'd like to do my best to not have the series end by that time (laugh)!
- The jailbreak arc will be finished around volumes 3-4, Shirai doesn't know how it will go but he'd like to proceed to the next arc soon.

 

[Kadir0]

It sounds like TPN will never go to an action route. I was kinda hoping it would maybe around 40% and the rest psychology and stuff. Because if the world is as messed up as we all assuming, then conflict is unavoidable.

 

[savethecat]

Glad to see that Neverland is going to stick with its current route. And looks like they're definitely leaving the farm soon

 

[SoldadoInvernal]

The Promised Neverland - Interview Part 2

Shirai: "If Emma can jailbreak successfully, I'll know the meaning of "Promised Neverland", so I'd like to do my best to not have the series end by that time (laugh)!

[/SPOILER]

It's "i'll know the meaning of Promised Neverland" or you'll?

 

[Mammo]

That's in the next volume. This one only covers up until the end of the first round. Seems like most of the negative reviews stem from the exam itself not being very interesting others are probably flaming as usual.

thanks for the correction
next volume reception is gonna be interesting too it seems

I see Ochako too thankfully she is floating or else she would have been lost between the other 5 heroines with the same design.

it's Tosh, same face abuse is mandatory, at least he put some effort into mimicking Horikoshi

A Jump universe manga that take place in the school like that would be really fun to read.

I want a manga that treat school the way Bully (Rockstar's game) treated school

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

HD pic of Jump Heroines poster preview

Spoiler

 

[Mammo]

I think I figured out why Toteko wasn't serialized, it's because the oneshot that won Jump Plus Golden Future Coin competition had a similar "monsters daycare" premise

https://shonenjumpplus.com/episode/10833497643049550101

 

[Newkerzy]

Well, I certainly hope it won't be that soon. At the very least, I give it about Toriko's length before it ends so it won't suffer the same fate its predecessors did. Most of the mangas that ended on a good note is always around 300-ish.

 

[Koi Kage]

Well, I certainly hope it won't be that soon. At the very least, I give it about Toriko's length before it ends so it won't suffer the same fate its predecessors did. Most of the mangas that ended on a good note is always around 300-ish.

I agree and 300-ish sounds like a perfect length

 

[SharkBait]

We Never Learn was a 80% good start, the thrusting of romance antics and some fanservice felt unnecessary and awkward. It could have been a good manga if it focused more on the questions and answers and tutoring mission rather than trying to get someone clearly uninterested in love with females involved in a plot like that.

BLack Clover felt like it was taking off to new heights. I cant wait to see what new magic arte Dorksta unlocks.

And Food Wars has finally regained its missing touch and is focusing on what we want , more sotaku firing each other up.

 

[savethecat]

Well, I certainly hope it won't be that soon. At the very least, I give it about Toriko's length before it ends so it won't suffer the same fate its predecessors did. Most of the mangas that ended on a good note is always around 300-ish.

I agree and 300-ish sounds like a perfect length

Which series are you guys talking about

 

[Koi Kage]

Which series are you guys talking about

MHA
"I've bulk read MHA to catch up with it and I see that, in my opinion, the series will possible dip in quality. I can see where Horikoshi will most likely go with the series and I can see it going into a route similar to Bleach. I'm a casual fan of this series and I really don't want that sort of thing happen. On a side note I dropped Bleach at the Full bring arc." <- my original post that I accidentally deleted